Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65597 (KAR)
M/S SHIVARAJ S BIRADAR v. THE COMMERCIAL TAX OFFICER
WP/203550/2025 · 2025-12-03
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65597 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65597 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#"$ " "
% &
!" #
"
$#%&! '
(
)** ) )**$! *+ ((
, $#%&
* ) * ) #!! -
' ( (
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" * & - * *
$. " * , " ! ! $! $!! $ $# " ! $ ! $!- $ $! ) $
" * * , ! $! $!- $ $! ) $
" * , !- ! # $ ! $ #$&## ) $ / *
*
"
- 3 -
0 (
0 (
12.2.3415 .6 718351 29.6 3:52 611;.4< 83==3>.4< 51=.186
!"#$ %% &'( )*$ $% +$,% - . !"#$%% )*$ / &'( $% +$%
-
. . 01$+ +
!"#$%% )*$ / &'( $% +$% . -
. . 01$
/, . 0.. 2
"#$ %$, +$3,, . -
. . 01$)
% (
452 6
7 -
- 4 -
! 1?541@A3:461=835291B12.2.34156:7C.2629?2 2916:7C.66.346C?@1342911?5=.153AA?6.34>?6@:123 734?8.@1 C.62?;1 1 2?;16 29.6 3:52 2953:<9 291 =?62 B?5?<5?B938291.CB:<41@35@15>9151.4291?BB1?=9?6 7114 @.6C.661@ :B93=@.4< 291 35@15 38 291 66166.4< 88.A15
B?661@ :4@15 1A2.34 - 38 291 ( A2 A2
!- 63=1=D 34 291 B51C.61 29?2 291 B12.2.34159151.49?@4326:7C.221@?4D>5.221437E1A2.34 23291693>A?61432.A16.66:1@7D29166166.4<88.A152 .6 8:52915 37615F1@ 29?2 34 ? F15.8.A?2.34 38 @3A:C142 6:7C.221@ 23 291 388.A1
.2 >?6 432.A1@ 29?2 291 C?.4 A3425?A235 4?C1=D 5. 36?C?4. 9?@ <.F14 6:7$ A3425?A223291?BB1==?42?4@9?@C?@1B?DC1425181551@ 23 29151.4 3>1F15
291 ?BB1==?42 9?@ 432 B53@:A1@ 291 A3CB=12.34 A152.8.A?21 .4 6:BB352 38 9.6 A=?.C 38 6:7$ A3425?A235A?55D.4<3:2291A3425?A2 18155.4<232916?C1 =1?541@ A3:461= 6:7C.26 29?2 6.4A1 291 516B34@142 $ ?BB1==?21 ?:2935.2D 9?6 @.6C.661@ 291 ?BB1?= A348.5C.4< 291 35@15 38 291 66166.4< 88.A15 835 434$6:7C.66.34
- 5 -
>5.2214 37E1A2.34 ?4@ 291 @3A:C1426 ?4@ 29?2 291 @3A:C1426 23 71 51=.1@ :B34 7D 291 B12.2.3415 ?51 291 51<.62151@ @3A:C1426
?4 3BB352:4.2D 71 B53F.@1@ 23 291 B12.2.34157D51C.22.4<291C?221518:529156:7C.2629?2 291 ?C3:42 71.4< @.6B:21@ .6 .4 1GA166 38 6%
!! !!!$ A?:6.4< 61F151 8.4?4A.?= @.88.A:=2.16 23 291 B12.2.3415 14A1
611;6835?==3>.4<38291B12.2.34 ! 1?541@ @@.2.34?= 3F154C142 @F3A?21 ?BB1?5.4<835291516B34@142$?:2935.2D34291329159?4@ 6:7C.26 29?2 291 35@15 @.6C.66.4< 291 ?BB1?= B?661@ 7D 291516B34@142$?:2935.2D.634291C15.2638291A?61?4@ 291 B12.2.3415 9?6 8?.=1@ 23 E:62.8D 9.6 A?61 3>1F15
91 8?.5=D 6:7C.26 29?2 .8 ? 2.C1 .6 8.G1@ B53F.@.4< ?4 3BB352:4.2D 23 291 B12.2.3415 23 6:7C.2 291 @3A:C142 6:7E1A223 ?:29142.A.2D ?4@ B5338
291 6?C1
9.6 A?61 >.== 71A346.@151@.4?AA35@?4A1>.29=?> ! 916?.@6:7C.66.34.62?;143451A35@ !# 1?5@15:61@29151A35@6
- 6 -
!& 91 51=1F?42 B352.34 38 291 .CB:<41@ 35@15 B?661@7D291516B34@1423 .6?6:4@15$
8.
0#9$:)*$ 0 ; )*$ -
. :
..22 6
- 7 <
6
6
: 6
<= #" 4 6
< $
..22
6 . -6
* :/:,:>,$ *3/:>:>/$ ; * ::,:%$
>
)
6
> ?630#4 <:
..22 .6.2
.. 2 6
$
*3/:>:>/$ '2-:/
2
1. &0 0
: -
6 4:2<-
1*%:/:$
"# ; #"# 0
: / 2 ..2 2 ;. 2
--
. :-: .202-:
. @ / A"# 0
"# 0
: / / : 2:.2 *)B* .. 22)6 :
. -6
-
'2-,C
- 7 -
!- =1?5=D
2916?.@35@159?67114B?661@835291 B12.2.3415 432 6:7C.22.4< ?4D >5.2214 37E1A2.346 ?4@ 8:54.69.4<291@3A:C1426 !% 1?541@A3:461=835291B12.2.34156:7C.2629?2 291 B12.2.3415 .6 .4 B366166.34 38 291 51A35@6 ?4@ @:1 23 734?8.@1 51?6346 91 >?6 432 ?7=1 23 B53@:A1 291 51A35@ 516:=2.4<.48.4?4A.?=.CB=.A?2.34349.C ! AA1B2.4< 291 6:7C.66.34 C?@17D291=1?541@ A3:461=835291B12.2.3415?6>1==?6291=1?541@@@.2.34?= 3F154C142 @F3A?21
291 B12.2.34 .6 ?6 :4@15$ . 91.CB:<41@35@15@?21@ !- ! #B53@:A1@ 441G:51$ B?661@ 7D 516B34@142 3 .6 H:?691@ .. 91C?2215.651C.221@23291516B34@1423 ... 91 B12.2.3415 69?== 8:54.69 9.6 >5.2214 6:7C.66.34 ?=34< >.29 291 @3A:C1426
.8 ?4D >.29.4 # @?D6 853C 291 @?21 38 51A1.B2 38 A152.8.1@A3BD3829.635@15
- 8 -
.F91 516B34@142 3 34 F15.8.A?2.34 38 291 51A35@6?4@.26?:29142.A.2D69?==B53A11@23B?66 35@156.4?AA35@?4A1>.29=?>
>.29?43:215=.C.2 38!@?D629151?8215
'( %" "& $
.623=3 (