- 1 - !" #$% %% &"' ( ! " #$ %#$#& ' ( ) * " %#$#& #& * Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - %%#&%& " %#$#& + %#$#& ' ( *, &&# - ) **.()* * && * !.#& * / $ 01230 405 677568 9: 89:45; <1= 6;>9::91? @940 405 A1?:5?41<856=?5;A12?:58<1=B14040576=495:949:46C5? 27<1=<9?68;9:71:68 A1>>1?D2;3>5?4@6:76::5;1?&& 9? 1$.& 6?; 1!.#& BE 405 ;;9491?685?91=9F982;356?;686B2=639(<1= - 3 - :01=4G405=9B2?68H)09:6775689:<985;BE405A869>6?4: 9? 1!.#& ?5 06?=6D 1 1=6> 6401; >54 @940 6? 6AA9;5?4 1? !& 6?; :2:469?5; 3=95F12: 056; 9?D2=95: 6?; :2AA2>B5; 41 405 :6>5 9? 405 01:79468 05=5<1=5 09: 76=5?4: 6?; :9:45=: <985; 6 A869> 7549491? B5<1=5 405 =9B2?68 A869>9?3 A1>75?:6491? 1< :&&&% B24 6: 405 <6405= 1< 405 ;5A56:5; 06: 7=5<5==5;6?1405=A869>7549491?09:?6>59:;58545;<=1> 405 6==6E 1< 76=495: 9? 409: A869> 7549491? 05 =9B2?68 A1?:9;5=9?3 405 5?49=5 5F9;5?A5 1? =5A1=; 3=6?45; A1>75?:6491? 1< :$&!&&&% @940 9?45=5:4 64 I 76 <=1> 405 ;645 1< 7549491? 4988 =5689:6491? 6?; ;9=5A45; =5:71?;5?4 1%?:2=6?A51>76?E41;571:94405:6>5 33=95F5;BE405:69;D2;3>5?46?;6@6=;405 >1405= 6?; :9:45=: 1< 405 ;5A56:5; 06F5 7=5<5==5; 409: 677568 9? @09A0 94 9: A1?45?;5; 4064 405 ;5A56:5; @6: @1=C9?36:>6:1?6?;56=?9?3:$&&&%75=>1?40B24 405=9B2?6806:46C5?09:9?A1>5 1?8E64:.#&%75= - 4 - >1?40 6?; 9?45=5:4 9: 41 B5 5?06?A5; 41 I 76 56:1?6B85 6>12?4: 6=5 ?14 3=6?45; 2?;5= 1405= 056;: 05=5<1=5=5J25:45;<1=5?06?A5>5?41<A1>75?:6491? # 56=;4056=32>5?4:1<B140:9;5: 05 ;5A56:5; @6: 635; E56=: 6?; 405 >28497895=@6:=93048E46C5?6:G$H:4056775886?4:06F5 <6985; 41 7=1;2A5 405 9?A1>5 7=11< 405 9?A1>5 1< 405 ;5A56:5; 9: 41 B5 46C5? 64 :&&&% 75= >1?40 6: 75= 405 329;589?5: 1< 405 6=?646C6 4645 5368 5=F9A5: 2401=94E :9?A5 405 6AA9;5?4 9: 1< 405 E56= & : 75= 405 A946491? 1< 405 1?HB85 75K 12=4 9? A1?:9;5=9?3 405 635 1< 405 ;5A56:5; &I 1< 405 9?A1>5 06: 41 B5 6;;5; 41@6=;: <242=5 7=1:75A4: 9?A5 405 ;5A56:5; @6: B6A0581= 6: 75= 405 329;589?5: 1< 405 1?HB8575K12=49? #&I 1< 405 9?A1>5 9: 41 B5 ;5;2A45; 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 - 5 - 41@6=;: 09: 75=:1?68 5K75?:5: 02: 405 81:: 1< ;575?;5?AEA1>5:41 :&&&L&I%#&IKK$M:!&.&&% . *2=405= 6: 75= 405 329;589?5: 1< 405 1?HB85 75K12=49?405;9A42>1< ! " #$ #% &6?;' " ( ) * ( + 6775886?4 1 B59?3 405 >1405= 1< 405 ;5A56:5; 9: 5?49485;<1=:$&&&%41@6=;:<98968A1?:1=492> $ 05 6775886?4: 6=5 68:1 5?49485; <1= 6? 6>12?4 1< :&&&&% 2?;5= 405 A1?F5?491?68 056;: 95 81:: 1< 5:46456?;<2?5=685K75?:5:6:75=405A946491?9?405A6:5 1<(27=6) ! 5?A5 405 A1>75?:6491? 9: =56::5::5; 6: 2?;5= 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 6 - 1::1<;575?;5?AE :!&.&&% 1::1<A1?:1=492> :$&&&% 1?F5?491?68056;: :&&&&% 1468 5::6@6=;5;BE405=9B2?68 :!$#&&% :&$&!&&&% )*+),-.,/0-)1+23) 1 4 5 02: 405 6775886?4: 6=5 5?49485; <1= 5?06?A5; A1>75?:6491? 1< :.&&% @940 9?45=5:4 64 I 76 <=1>405;6451<7549491?4988=5689N6491?6?;405=5<1=5405 677568;5:5=F5:41B56881@5;9?76=4 & ?405=5:284405<1881@9?31=;5=9:76::5; (9) 056775689:6881@5;9?76=4 (99) 05 6775886?4: 6=5 5?49485; <1= 5?06?A5; A1>75?:6491? 1< :.&&%681?3 @940 9?45=5:4 64I 76<=1>405;6451<7549491?4988=5689N6491?1@5F5=6: 75= 1=;5= ;645; &&# 405 6775886?4: 6=5 ?14 5?49485;<1=9?45=5:4<1=405;586E5;75=91;1<$#;6E:9? <989?3405677568 - 7 - (999) 5:71?;5?4 1%?:2=6?A5 1>76?E 9: ;9=5A45; 41 ;571:94 405 6<1=5:69; A1>75?:6491? 6>12?4 @9409?1?5>1?40<=1>405;6451<409:D2;3>5?4 (9F) 4 9: :4645; 4064 409: 677568 9: <985; BE 405 >1405=6?;:9:45=:1<405;5A56:5;;>9445;8E6775886?4 1: 41 6=5 ?14 ;575?;5?4 1? 405 9?A1>5 1< 405 ;5A56:5; 6?; 405E 6=5 ;575?;5?4 1? 4059= <6405= 05=5<1=5405E6=5?145?49485;<1=6?EA1>75?:6491?6?; 6775886?4 1 9: 5?49485; 41 @940;=6@ 405 5?49=5 6>12?4 681?3@9409?45=5:46AA=25;1?941?405;571:94>6;5BE 405?:2=6?A51>76?E 56=?5;A12?:58<1==5:71?;5?4 19:75=>9445;41 <985F6C68640@9409?4@1@55C: 1.5 &%' $ 9:4 18 1$