Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65585 (KAR)
SUNIL S/O AMEENREDDY DESAI v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/201060/2021 · 2025-11-14
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65585 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $% #
$% !%"! ##
&"' (
! "
##
$$$%
"
&
# # '(! ' #
# ) $'$'% * + ''$'% )
) #
,
($'
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
) +
- )
- ) )
% - )
' ./0 122314 56738 39:/;6 '(!' ;< ;:;8 3./9430 9: '% .383/61<:38 83<38837 :; 10 =:.3 9:> .10 ?336 </437 ?@ :.3 941/A16: 9.14436B/6B :.3 C57BA36: 71:37 $'$'% 210037 ?@ 36/;8 /D/4 )57B3 167 ) # 167 77/:/;614 E.1.1258/6 ;($'
#19:0 B/D/6B 8/03 :; :.3 </4/6B ;< :.3 122314 ?8/3<4@ 0:1:37183:.1:;6$$($'E1:1?;5:E ;617B/8/ :; 56718B/A1/68;17/6<8;6:;<1714/93 /4417B/8/ F.36 :.3 941/A16: 14;6B F/:. ./0 <8/367 F383 28;9337/6B ;6A;:;89@943?318/6B3B;& !!$'$:.378/D38;< :.3 ?50 ?318/6B 3B; $G!$!! 78;D3 :.3 01A3 <8;A :.3 ;22;0/:3 7/839:/;6 /6 810. 167 63B4/B36:
- 3 -
A16638167710.37:;:.3A;:;89@943 0183054:;<:.3 1<;8301/7 199/736: :.3 941/A16: 050:1/637 B8/3D;50 /6C58/30167F10.;02/:14/H37
! .3941/A16:</437123:/:/;65673839:/;6';<:.3 9:033I/6B9;A23601:/;6:F102431737:.1:.30236: 0/B6/</916:1A;56::;F1870A37/9143J2360309;6D3@1693 9.18B30 167 ;:.38 8341:37 9;0:0 : F10 <58:.38 2431737 :.1: :.3 199/736: ;9958837 0;434@ ;6 199;56: ;< 810. 167 63B4/B36:78/D/6B;<:.3;<<367/6BD3./943?@/:078/D38
E 2;6 038D/93 ;< 6;:/93 :.3 8302;6736: 12231837 :.8;5B. 9;56034 167 </437 F8/::36 0:1:3A36: 736@/6B :.3 1D38A36:0A173/6:.3941/A23:/:/;6
6 :.3 ?10/0 ;< :.3 24317/6B0 ;< :.3 218:/30 :.3 41/A08/?5614<81A37:.3/00530167:.3831<:38839;8737 :.3 3D/73693 .3 8/?5614 ?@ /A25B637 C57BA36: 167 1F187.10218:4@144;F37:.3941/A23:/:/;6167.347:.1: :.3 941/A16: /0 36:/:437 :; 1 9;A23601:/;6 ;< 0'' $$14;6BF/:./6:3830:1::.381:3;<K21
- 4 -
1677/839:37:.38302;6736::;732;0/::.39;A23601:/;6 1A;56:14;6BF/:./6:3830:3/6B1BB8/3D37:.3283036: 122314.10?336</437
.3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 941/A16: .10 81/037 :.3 <;44;F/6B9;6:36:/;60 1 #/80:4@ :.3 941/A16: 10038:0 :.1: .3 F10 3186/6B 0%$$$238A;6:.?@F;8I/6B10;A2;56738167140;
05238D/0/6B 1B8/954:5814 41670 167 ./0 <1A/4@ F10 B3::/6B /69;A3 ;< 0$$$$$ 21 <8;A 1B8/954:5814 41670 ;F3D38 :.3 8/?5614 .10 38837 /6 :1I/6B :.3 /69;A3 10 A3834@100%$$$238A;6:. 39;674@:.3941/A16:.103J1A/637:F;7;9:;8010 +167+.38/?561456738D14537:.3941/A16:-0 F.;43?;7@ 7/01?/4/:@ 1: E$K 9;6:817/9:/6B :.3 3D/73693 ;<:.37;9:;8:.1::.3941/A16:05<<3837!K6358;4;B/914 7/01?/4/:@ 167 E$K :; F.;43 ?;7@
53 :; :.3 7/01?/4/:@ :.3 941/A16: /0 6;: /6 1 2;0/:/;6 :; 7/09.18B3 ./0 83B5418 F;8I 167 :.383 /0 4;00 ;< /69;A3 .383 /0 <569:/;614 7/01?/4/:@167941/A16:/036:/:437<;8<5:58328;0239:05:
- 5 -
:.3 8/?5614 .10 <1/437 :; 9;60/738 <5:583 28;0239:0 6 0522;8:;<./09;6:36:/;6.3.10834/3752;6:.3739/0/;6 ;<:.3 23J;58:/6:.39103;<
167 /6 :.3 9103 ;< ! """ 9 10:4@ 753 :; :.3 199/736: :.3 941/A16: .10 050:1/637B8/3D;50/6C58/303F10:831:3710/621:/36:<;8 1 238/;7 ;< $ 71@0 D36 1<:38 7/09.18B3 <8;A :.3 .;02/:14.3F106;:/612;0/:/;6:;7/09.18B3./083B5418 F;8I 3 .10 05<<3837 4;: ;< 21/6 758/6B :831:A36:
;60/738/6B :.3 01A3 :.3 ;D38144 9;A23601:/;6 1F18737 ?@:.38/?5614/0;6:.34;F380/73 +/:.
:.3 1?;D3 9;6:36:/;60 :.3 4318637 9;56034 0;5B.::;144;F:.3122314 ( 6 :.3 ;:.38 .167 :.3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 ;82;81:/;6.1081/037:.3<;44;F/6B9;56:389;6:36:/;60
- 6 -
1 #/80:4@:.310038:/;6;<941/A16::.1:.3F103186/6B 0%$$$ 238 A;6:. 83A1/60 5605?0:16:/1:37 753 :; 419I;<7;95A36:18@3D/736936:.31?03693;<28;;<;< /69;A3 :.3 8/?5614 .10 8/B.:4@ 10030037 :.3 /69;A3 ;< :.3941/A16:6;:/;6144@ ? 39;674@ :.3 941/A16: .10 3J1A/637 :.3 7;9:;8 10 +F.;/016358;058B3;6058B3;6.10732;037:.1::.3 941/A16: .10 05<<3837 6358;4;B/914 7/01?/4/:@ /0 !K .3 ;2.:.14A;4;B/0: .10 10030037 :.1: :.3 ;2.:.14A;4;B/914 7/01?/4/:@ /0 1: !K ;60/738/6B :.3/8 3D/73693 8/?5614 .10 10030037 F.;43 ?;7@ 7/01?/4/:/30 E$K /0 C50: 167 8310;61?43 .3 01/7 7/01?/4/:@ 7;30 6;: 1<<39: <5:583 3186/6B0<;8:.3941/A16:167:.383<;83.3/06;:36:/:437 <;816@<5:58328;0239:0
9 ./874@ 9;60/738/6B :.3 /6C58/30 050:1/637 ?@ :.3 941/A16: 167 9;60/738/6B :.3 1B3 167 1D;91:/;6 ;< :.3 941/A16: :.3 ;D38144 9;A23601:/;6 1F18737 ?@ :.3 8/?5614 /0 C50: 167 8310;61?43 167 /: 7;30 6;: F18816: /6:38<383693
- 7 -
+/:. :.3 1?;D3 9;6:36:/;60 :.3 4318637 9;56034 0;5B.::;7/0A/00:.3122314
3187 :.3 4318637 9;56034 <;8 :.3 218:/30 167 2385037:.3C57BA36:1671F187;<:.38/?5614
% : /0 6;: /6 7/025:3 :.1: :.3 941/A16: .10 050:1/637 /6C58/30/6:.38;17:81<</9199/736:;9958837;6$$($'E 753:;810.16763B4/B36:78/D/6B;<:.3;<<367/6BD3./943 ?@/:078/D38
'$ .3941/A16:941/A0 :.1: .3 F10 3186/6B0%$$$ 238A;6:..38/?56149;60/738/6B:.31B31671D;91:/;6 ;< :.3 941/A16: .10 8/B.:4@ :1I36 :.3 /69;A3 ;< :.3 941/A16:1:0%$$$2A
'' 0238F;567938:/</91:3:.3941/A16:.10050:1/637 95:419381:37F;567;D38:.3<;83.3179;6:50/;6;D38:.3 8/B.: <8;6:; :3A2;814 83B/;6 167 8/B.: <8;6:; ;8?/:;
H@B;A1:/9<819:5833.103J1A/637
816:;0.10+ .3/01358;058B3;66./03D/73693.3.10732;037:.1:
- 8 -
:.3941/A16:.1005<<3837!K6358;4;B/9147/01?/4/:@167 :.3 941/A16: 140; 3J1A/637 :.1: 2.:.14A;4;B/0:
8167161 10 + 6 .38 3D/73693 0.3 .10 732;037 :.1: :.3 941/A16: .10 05<<3837 !K 7/01?/4/:@ :;
2.:.14A;4;B/9 7/01?/4/:@ ;60/738/6B :.3 3D/73693 ;< 7;9:;8 167 /6C58/30 05<<3837 ?@ :.3 941/A16: 167 9;60/738/6B:.31B31671D;91:/;6;<:.3941/A16:F3183 ;< :.3 ;2/6/;6 :.1: F.;43 ?;7@ 7/01?/4/:@ .10 :; ?3 10030037($K
' .3 941/A16: .10 050:1/637 B8/3D;50 /6C58/30 .3 01/77/01?/4/:@.101<<39:37./03186/6B0167:.383/04;00;< /69;A3 167 .3693 .3 /0 36:/:437 <;8 <5:583 28;0239:0 /693:.383/0<569:/;6147/01?/4/:@/6D/3F;<:.341F41/7 7;F6?@:.3;6>?43 23J;58:/6:.39103;< 05281 167
05281 :.3 941/A16:/036:/:437<;8<5:58328;0239:06D/3F;<:.341F 41/7 7;F6 ?@ :.3 ;6>?43 23J ;58: /6 :.3 9103 ;< =
D > $'( '( 177/:/;6 ;< E$K ;< :.3
- 9 -
/69;A3;<:.3941/A16::;F1870<5:58328;0239:0.10:;?3 9;60/738373693:.3A;6:.4@/69;A3;<:.3941/A16:/0 100300371:0'$$0%$$$LE$K.3941/A16:/0 1B37 1?;5: E @3180 1: :.3 :/A3 ;< :.3 199/736: 167 A54:/24/38 1224/91?43 :; ./0 1B3 B8;52 /0 =' > .50 :.3 941/A16: /0 36:/:437 <;8 9;A23601:/;6 ;< )* + 0'$$M'M' M($K ;6 199;56: ;< -4;00 ;< <5:583 /69;A3-
'!
.3 61:583 ;< /6C58/30 /67/91:30 :.1: :.3 941/A16: A50:.1D3?33656738830:167:831:A36:<;81238/;7;< A;6:.0 ;603N536:4@ :.3 941/A16: /0 36:/:437 <;8 9;A23601:/;6;<)+0%$$$MA;6:.056738 :.3.317=4;00;</69;A3758/6B41/752238/;7>
'E .3 941/A16: F10 .;02/:14/H37 10 16 /621:/36: <;8 A;83 :.16 $ 71@0 /6 :.3 .;02/:14 167 05?03N536:4@ 8393/D37 <58:.38 :831:A36:
53 :; :.3 199/736: :.3 941/A16:.1005<<3837B8/3D;50/6C58/30167140;56738B;63 058B38@;60/738/6B:.328;4;6B3721/6758/6B:831:A36:
- 10 -
10F34410:.3238A1636:7/01?/4/:@938:/</37?@:.37;9:;8 F3183/694/637:;36.1693:.39;A23601:/;61F18737?@ :.3 8/?5614 56738 :.3 .317 ;< -4;00 ;< 1A36/:/30- <8;A 0$$$$:;)+
' ;60/738/6B:.361:583;</6C58/30:.39;A23601:/;6 1F18737 ?@ :.3 8/?5614 56738 ;:.38 .3170 /0 C50: 167 8310;61?43 ' .50 :.3 941/A16: /0 36:/:437 :; :.3 <;44;F/6B 9;A23601:/;6
,-./)012/3/4.5 42.5./1.04) )06054.4
7819. 5273/0: &)' )06054.4 78192) 351 &)' 1/616705<<38/6B0 ($$$ ($$$
37/9143J236030 (($$$ (($$$ #;;76;58/0.A36: 9;6D3@16931671::36716: 9.18B30 $$$ $$$ ;00;</69;A3758/6B41/7 52238/;7 ' $$$ E$$$ ;00;<1A36/:/30 $$$$ $$$$ ;00;<<5:583/69;A3 ((($$ '%$'$ #19/147/0</B583A36: $$$ $$$
188/1B328;0239:0 $$$ $$$ #5:583A37/9143J236030 ($$$ ($$$ 10:
;
- 11 -
'( 6:.383054::.3<;44;F/6B;8738/0210037
1 .3122314/0144;F37/6218:
? .3C57BA36:;<:.341/A08/?5614/0A;7/</37
9 .3 941/A16: /0 36:/:437 :; 1 :;:14 9;A23601:/;6 ;< ) ; +
7 .3 ;82;81:/;6 /0 7/839:37 :; 732;0/: :.3 9;A23601:/;6 1A;56: 14;6B F/:. /6:3830:
O K 21 <8;A :.3 71:3 ;< </4/6B ;< :.3 941/A 23:/:/;6:/44:.371:3;<8314/H1:/;6F/:./61238/;7;< 0/J F33I0 <8;A :.3 71:3 ;< 8393/2: ;< 9;2@ ;< :./0 C57BA36: ;F3D38 :.3 9;A23601:/;6 1F18737 56738:.3.317;<-<5:583A37/9143J236030-0.1446;: 9188@16@/6:3830:
4+ &# ' %
4+ &!%"!' %
/0:;'4;E!