Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65583 (KAR)
TUKKAMMA AND ORS v. THE CONSERVATOR OF FOREST AND ORS
WP/202993/2024 · 2025-09-24
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65583 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65583 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#$
%#!&!&"##
'#(
! "
#$%&
"
""
"
Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!'
(& )
&*
$$ $
#
$
& ! ! & $$
"
$$
&
$$
$$
+
$$
- 3 -
'
# (
& )
$+*
&
$ !!' $ $
$
&
$ & ,- &
./01/ &02/3 4567893 :5. 2;9 <92/2/579. 07= ./033/>0.?67
0;6>0. :5. .98<57=9728 25 + ;019 0<<90.9=/7<9.857 ! ;940<2/579= ./2&92/2/57/8:/39=899>/7@:5335A/7@ .93/9:8 0* 5/88690A./25:9.2/5.0./5.0=/.942/5725B608;2;9 5.=9.=029=!' +! !<0889=CD2;9:/.82.98<57=972 1/=9 779E6.9 07= 45789B69723D 25 89208/=9 2;9 5.=9. =029= +!! !! <0889= CD 2;9 2;/.= .98<57=972 1/=9 779E6.9 07= 2;9 5.=9. =029= !! +! !" <0889= CD 2;9 89457= .98<57=972 1/=9 779E6.908/339@0307=0.C/2.0.D
- 4 -
C* 5/88690A./25:07=0F68=/.942/7@.98<57=9728 25+25.9825.92;970F95:2;9<92/2/579.8/7.98<942 5: 307= /7
D5! ! G F9086./7@ " 4.98 8/26029= 020F07>9.//330@9036>007=/82./42/=0. " ;98;5.2:04280.92;989 2 /8 80/= 2;02 2;9 :02;9. 5: <92/2/579. 5 07= @.07=:02;9. 5: <92/2/579.8 ! 25 CD 70F9 08;0.02;
50@0<<0A08/8869=A/2;09.2/:/40295:.0725:
0@6103/ ;/267=9.639!H5:0.7020>007=.0726398/7.98<9425:
307=/7
D5! !F9086./7@ "4.988/26029=020F07>9./ /330@9036>07=/82./42/=0.1/=95.=9.=029= + +H'H2 /8 82029= 2;02 2;9 9<62D 5FF/88/579. /7 $/39 5
=029= !H 'H 40749339= 2;9 9.2/:/4029 5: .072 /8869=/7:015.5:=949089=08;0.02; 50@0<<0;980F9 A08 B6982/579= C9:5.9 2;/8 56.2 /7 &5+'" H 07= 2;980F9A080335A9=2;95.=9.5:2;99<62D5FF/88/579. A0889208/=907=F0229.A08.9F07=9=:5..94578/=9.02/5725 2;9 0;8/3=0. /=0. 1/=9 5.=9. =029= HH ;9.90:29. 2;9<.5499=/7@8A9.9457=6429=CD2;90;8/3=0.0:29.;53=/7@ 0 8<52 /78<942/57 07= <.5499=9= 25 <088 07 5.=9. 57
- 5 -
+!HH 25 .9@.072 2;9 307= F9086./7@ " 4.98 /7 D5! ! 8/26029= 02 0F07>9./ /330@9 &6.86072 25 2;9 5.=9.5:2;90;8/3=0.70F95:=949089=08;0.02;A08=63D .99729.9=/7919769945.=8/7536F78H07=!:29.2;9 =902; 5: 08;0.02; 2;9 70F9 5: ;68C07= 5: <92/2/579. 5 /908010.0?A08=63D.9:39429=/72;9 8 2;/7@8 8255= 2;68 2;9 <92/2/579.8 .949/19= 0 752/49 :.5F 2;9 5::/49 5: 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579. C089= 57 2;9
39229. /8869= CD 2;9 :56.2; .98<57=972 =029= " +! !! 430/F/7@ 2;02 2;9 519.7F972 5: 0.7020>0 1/=9 52/:/402/57 =029= !' +HH =9430.9= 2;9 86C?942 307= 08 $5.982 07= 67=9. 942/575:2;9$5.98242H+"97492;988/82072 5FF/88/579.856@;225/7B6/.90C5622;9@.0725.=9.F0=9/7 :015.5::02;9.<92/2/579.50357@A/2;52;9.@.072998;9 88/820725FF/88/579.1/=95.=9.=029=+!! !!89208/=9 2;9 5.=9. 5: .9@.072 @@./919= CD 5.=9. 5: 88/82072 5FF/88/579. <92/2/579.8 :/39= .91/8/57 C9:5.9 2;9 9<62D 5FF/88/579. ;9 9<62D 5FF/88/579. 1/=9 5.=9. =029= !! +! !".9?9429=2;991/8/57&92/2/57
- 6 -
8 F0229. 8255= 2;68 2;9 :/.82 .98<57=972 /7/2/029= <.5499=/7@8 07= /8869= 752/49 25 2;9 <92/2/579.8 25 0<<90. C9:5.92;962;5./2D57! ! !02"" <F;9;68C07= 5:<92/2/579.50<<90.9=C9:5.92;9062;5./2D07=86CF/229= 0332;9.9391072.945.=8<9.20/7/7@252;9@.072F0=9/7:015.5:
=949089=08;0.02;5A919.2;9:/.82.98<57=9721/=95.=9. =029=!' +! !;93=2;022;9<92/2/579.80.97529720/39=:5. 07D .9@630./I02/57 7=9. 2;989 4/.46F8207498 2;9 <92/2/579.8 0.9C9:5.92;/856.2
567893 :5. 2;9 .98<942/19 <0.2/98 6.@9= 8919.03 4572972/578 .@/7@ 8919.03 4572972/578 4567893 :5. 2;9 <92/2/579. <3049=.93/0749572;9=94/8/57/7& /7 5! !H ! ! =/8<589= 5:57 ! !!
;9 82029F972 5: 5C?942/578 /8 :/39= CD 2;9 519.7F972 .@/7@8919.034572972/5782;9519.7F972<3049=.93/074957 2;9:5335A/7@=94/8/578
- 7 -
* $
J &&'" H'" HH+ !* &
$ J &)* ' HH+ &
$!!HH+
"* &
$ J! ! ' 90.= 2;9 0.@6F9728 07= <9.689= 2;9 ./2 <0<9.8 A/2; 40.9
;9 :0428 0.9 86::/4/9723D 80/= 07= =5 752 .9B6/.9 .9/29.02/57;9/8869.91531980.567=2;99E9.4/895:2;9<5A9. CD2;988/820725FF/88/579./78922/7@08/=92;95.=9.5:.9 @.072 6::/49 /2 25 7529 2;02 2;9 407493302/57 5:
0@6103/ ;/2 A0889208/=9CD2;/856.22/8</152032575292;020:29.2;9 =/8<5803 5: 2;9 ./2 &92/2/57 0 8<52 /78<942/57 A08 457=6429= 07=075.=9.5:.9@.072A08F0=957!HH
2.07@93D 0:29.030<895:03F5822A972D:56.D90.80752/49A08/8869= 07= <.5499=/7@8 A9.9 /7/2/029= 9:5.9 2;9 88/82072
- 8 -
5FF/88/579. 2;9 0;08/3=0.<3049=.93/074957 0752/:/402/57 =029=!' +HH25457297=2;022;986C?942307=/80752/:/9= :5.982 307= 2 /8 0.@69= 57 C9;03: 5: 2;9 @519.7F972 2;02 0 752/:/402/57 67=9. 8942/57 5: 2;9 $5.982 42 A08 /8869= 57 !' +HH @.902=9035:0.@6F972/80==.9889=0C562
942/575: 2;9$5.98242;9>9D08<94285:2;90.@6F9720.99E0F/79= 886F/7@2;9.9/80752/:/402/572;9.9/8752;/7@57.945.=25 8;5A2;022;9.9/845F<3/0749A/2;
942/575:2;90.7020>0 $5.982 42 98</29 2;9 752/:/402/57 75 042/57 A08 20>97 07= 2;9<92/2/579.4572/769825;0192;9<.5<9.2D/7B6982/5708/8 .9:39429=/72;997492;988/820725FF/88/579.4563= 752 ;019 <3049=.93/0749 57 2;9 752/:/402/57 07= 892 08/=9 2;9 .9@.072 5.=9. 0:29. 0 30<89 5: 2A972D:56. D90.8 ;9 30A /8 A933 892239= 2;02 2;9 <5A9. F682 C9 9E9.4/89= A/2;/7 0 .908570C39 2/F9 7 2;9 <.98972 4089 2;9.9 /8 07 /75.=/7029 =930D 7 FD 1/9A 2;9 <.5499=/7@8 0.9 4390.3D C0..9= CD 304;98 ;9.9:5.9 2;9 5.=9. <0889= CD 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579./83/0C3925C989208/=9
- 9 -
9E2392F94578/=9.A;92;9.2;95.=9.5:5789.1025.5:
$5.9828 407 C9 86820/79= ;9 078A9. /8 75 ;9 .90857 /8 8/F<39 7 2;9 <.98972 ./2 &92/2/57 2;9 <92/2/579. ;08 B6982/579=2;9407493302/575:2;9.9@.0725.=9.<0889=CD2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579. 07= 2;/8 56.2 ;08 =943/79= 25 0449<2 2;94572972/575:2;9519.7F97207=;0889208/=92;95.=9. 5:2;988/820725FF/88/579.97492;945789B6972/035.=9. <0889= CD 2;9 5789.1025. 5: $5.9828 /8 0385 3/0C39 25 C9 892 08/=9445.=/7@3D/2/889208/=9 567893:5.2;9.98<942/19<0.2/98<3049=.93/0749572;9 =94/8/578 .9:9..9= 25 86<.0 =5 752 2;/7> 2;02 2;9 30A /8 /7 =56C204;=94/8/5726.7857/285A7:0428;9<.989724089/8 038529829=/72;93/@;25:2;90:5.980/==94/8/578 $5.2;9.90857882029=0C5192;95.=9.5:2;988/82072 5FF/88/579. 9<62D 5FF/88/579. 07= 5789.1025. 5:
$5.9828 0.9 3/0C39 25 C9 892 08/=9 445.=/7@3D 2;9D 0.9 892 08/=9 + ;9 ./2 5: 9.2/5.0./ /8 5.=9.9= ;9 .=9. =029= +!! !! <0889= CD 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579. 1/=9 779E6.92;95.=9.=029=!! +! !"<0889=CD2;99<62D
- 10 -
5FF/88/579. 1/=9 779E6.9 07= 2;9 5.=9. =029= !' +! ! <0889= CD 2;9 5789.1025.
5: $5.9828 1/=9 779E6.90.9B608;9= ' 986320723D2;9 ./2&92/2/57/8 940689 5: 2;9 =/8<5803 5: 2;9 ./2 &92/2/57 <97=/7@ /729.354625.D 0<<3/402/578 /: 07D 0.9 =/8<589= 5: 07= 2;9 /729./F=/.942/57/:07D8207=8=/84;0.@9=
!)* '&"##( &
/825
35"