- 1 - ! "# $ ## #%% &'(&)%*+ & ** , !"! # $ % & ' ' !"! # $ (")!"! **& * + $,& * $ & ,() * $'& * ()"!!"() * !+- !"(+ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * ** ( * * * ' . $# $ .& /0 122033145 60748 5/0 9:;23174145 74 :!+- !"(+:45/0<730:<5/0301=40>7?73@>8014> * @>>067/13 7A 7;2@84748 5/0 B@>8;045 >150> ()"!!"() >7A;7AA748 5/0 9:;231745 14> 19C@755748 5/0 199@A0> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 ( :< 5/008:5716304A5=@;045A95$<:=A/:=5D95E& ! /091A0:<5/09:;23174145746=70<7A5/155/0 199@A0> F/: F1A <1;7371= 5: 5/0 9:;23174145 =0C@0A50> <:= /14> 3:14 :< A!)"""" 99:=>7483G /0 /1> 3045 5/0 1;:@45 5: 5/0 199@A0> :4 !"("!"(- '/04 5/0 9:;23174145 74A7A50> <:= =021G;045 :< 5/0 3:14 1;:@45 5/0 199@A0> 7AA@0> 5/0 9/0C@0H ( :4 !,",!"(+ <:= - 3 - A!)"""" 5:F1=>A =021G;045 :< 5/0 3:14 1;:@45 '/04 5/0 9/0C@0 F1A 2=0A0450> <:= 0491A/;045 5/0 A1;0 F1A >7A/:4:@=0> 1A 5/0=0 F1A 74A@<<797045 <@4> 74 5/0199:@45:<5/0199@A0>14>308134:5790F1A7AA@0>6G 5/09:;231741455:5/0199@A0>74<:=;74816:@5>7A/:4:@= :< 5/0 9/0C@0 14> 9133748 @2:4 /7; 5: =021G 5/0 9/0C@0 1;:@454A2750:<A0=?790:<4:57905/0199@A0>/1>4:5 =0217> 5/0 1;:@45 14> 5/0=06G 9:;;7550> 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630@4>0=0957:4( :<5/095 /0 9:;23174145 <730> 5/0 2=7?150 9:;231745 74 :!! !"(+ /0 =713 :@=5 5::I 9:847J1490 :< 5/0 :<<0490 14> =087A50=0> :!+- !"(+ /0 199@A0> 12201=0> 60<:=0 5/0 =713 :@=5 2301>0> 4:5 8@735G 14> 9317;0>5:605=70>/09:;231741450H1;740>/7;A03<1A '( 14> 8:5 ;1=I0> HA ( 5: , 74 A@22:=5 :< /7A 9:450457:4/0199@A0>>0470>5/0749=7;7415748;150=713A 1?1731630 :4 =09:=> 0H1;740> /7;A03< 1A '( 14> 8:5 ;1=I0>HA(5:(-74A@22:=5:</7A>0<0490/0=713 :@=51<50=51I748745:9:4A7>0=157:41335/0A0;150=713A:4 - 4 - =09:=> 91;0 5: 5/0 9:493@A7:4 5/15 5/0 9:;23174145 /1A 4:5 2=:?0> 5/0 8@735 :< 5/0 199@A0> 60G:4> =01A:41630 >:@65 99:=>7483G 5/0 199@A0> F1A 19C@7550> 0748 188=70?0> 6G 5/0 A1;0 5/0 9:;23174145 7A 60<:=0 5/7A :@=5 , 01=>=7137I 1A/11@J14301=40>9:@4A03 <:=5/01220331450A2:4>0455/:@8/A0=?0>/1A=0;1740> @4=02=0A0450> 0=@A0>5/0;150=713A:4=09:=> 4?70F:<5/0A@6;7AA7:4A;1>06G5/0301=40> 9:@4A03<:=5/01220331455/02:7455/15F:@3>1=7A0<:=;G 9:4A7>0=157:47A G 14AF0= 5:5/0 16:?0 2:745 7A 745/0 .<<7=;157?0E <:=5/0<:33:F748 - 5 7A 5/0 9:450457:4 :< 5/0 9:;23174145 5/15 199@A0>/1>=0C@0A50><:=/14>3:14:<A!)"""" 14> - 5 - 199:=>7483G/0/1>3045A!)"""" :F1=>A>7A9/1=80 :<5/03:141;:@455/0199@A0>/1>7AA@0>9/0C@0H ( :4 !,",!"(+ <:= A!)"""" '/04 5/0 9/0C@0 F1A 2=0A0450> <:= 0491A/;045 5/0 A1;0 F1A >7A/:4:@=0> 4A2750:<A0=?790:<4:57905/0199@A0>/1>4:5=0217>5/0 1;:@45 14> 5/0=06G /0 /1A 9:;;7550> 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630@4>0=0957:4( :<5/095 + : 2=:?0 /7A 9:450457:4 5/0 9:;23174145 0H1;740>/7;A03<1A '(14>8:5;1=I0>5/09/0C@015 H ( H ! 7A 5/0 04>:=A0;045 7AA@0> 6G 5/0 14I <:= /1?748 >7A/:4:@=0> 5/0 9/0C@0 H 7A 5/0 9:2G :< 5/0 30813 4:5790 H , 7A 5/0 2:A513 19I4:F30>8;045 <:= /1?748A0=?0>5/04:5790:45/0199@A0> @=748 9=:AA0H1;74157:4 :< '( 75 7A A2097<79133G A@880A50> 5: 5/0 F7540AA 6G 5/0 301=40> 9:@4A03 <:= 5/0 199@A0> 5/15 <7?0 6314I 9/0C@0A F0=0 7AA@0> 6G 5/0 199@A0> 5: 5/0 9:;23174145 14> :5/0=A 1A A09@=75G 74 5/0 ;1550= :< <:=;748 >/7 1;61? ::20=157?0 :9705G 14> 5/0 A1;0 F1A ;7A@A0> 6G 5/0 - 6 - 9:;23174145?045/:@8/ '(1>;7550>5/155/0GF0=0 74504>748 5: <:=; >/7 1;61? ::20=157?0 :9705G /0 /1>>0470>5/0<1955/15/0/1>=0907?0>5/06314I9/0C@0 <=:;5/0199@A0>745/15=081=>/@A757A5/09:450457:4 :<5/0199@A0>5/151AA09@=75G/0/1>7AA@0>5/09/0C@0 5:5/09:;23174145F/79/91;05:60;7A@A0>6G/7;6G 2=0A04574875<:=0491A/;045 ) /0 199@A0> /1A A50220> 745: 5/0 F7540AA 6:H 14>0H1;740>/7;A03<1A'(0A5150>5/15<7?06314I 9/0C@0AF0=07AA@0>5:5/09:;2317414514>:5/0=AF/79/ F0=0 ;7A@A0> 6G 5/0; 0 /1A 2=:>@90> A0?0=13 >:9@;045A 74 5/15 =081=> 5: 9:4504> 5/15 121=5 <=:; 9:;23174145 /0=074 :40 1A1?1=1B /131?1>7 14> 141;145/ 1>1= /1?0 13A: <730> A7;731= 9:;231745A 13308748 9:;;7AA7:4 :< 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4( :<5/09557AA5150>5/150?045/:@8/ 1A1?1=1B /131?1>7 <730> 1 A7;731= 9:;231745 18174A5 5/0 199@A0>133087489:;;7AA7:4:<:<<0490@4>0=0957:4( :< 5/0 95 /0 /1A 6004 19C@7550> 74 5/0 A17> 91A0 - 7 - :F0?0= 5/0 9:2G :< 5/0 A17> B@>8;045 7A 4:5 2=:>@90> 6G 5/0199@A0> <:= 5/0 =01A:4A 60A5 I4:F4 5: /7; 0?04 5/:@8//0/1A2=:>@90>5/09:2G:<5/09:;2317459:270A :< 5/0 9/0C@0A 7AA@0> 74 <1?:@= :< 1A1?1=1B /131?1>7 14I 04>:=A0;045 9:2G :< 5/0 30813 4:5790 9:2G :< 5/0 2:A51319I4:F30>8;04514>A5150;045:<5/09:;23174145 745/0A17>2=:900>748A1A20=HA(5: 7;731=3G/0 9:4504>A5/15141;145/1>1=/1><730>A7;731=2=7?150 9:;231745A@6;755748/7AAF:=4A5150;04514>5/15/0F1A A@6B0950> 5: 9=:AA0H1;74157:4 /0 9/0C@0 614I 04>:=A0;045 9:2G :< 5/0 30813 4:5790 2:A513 19I4:F30>8;045F0=01A20=HA)5:(-/0199@A0> A2097<79133GA5150>5/15/040?0=74A575@50>14G9:;231745 18174A55/09:;23174145:=18174A51A1?1=1B/131?1>7:= 141;145/1>1=13308748;7A@A0:<5/09/0C@0A (" 4?70F:<5/0<195A14>97=9@;A51490A5/155/0 199@A0> /1A 1>;7550> 5/15 H (9/0C@0 603:48A 5: /7A 614I 199:@45 14> 75 601=A /7A A78415@=0 4:F /1?0 5: 9:4A7>0=5/02:A757:4:<31F;1G=0<0=5:5/0>097A7:4:< - 8 - 5/0 :4E630 20H :@=5 74 F/0=0 5/0 :4E630 20H :@=5 =0<0==0> 5: 75A ?1=7:@A >097A7:4A :4 5/0 A@6B095 14> /03> 74 21=18=12/ :A,14>-1A@4>0= !" # # $ %&#'( )*# + , + " ,# ,", # $ )', - " + #, # , , , 1 .%&)*/-$)*( - 9 - 011111 2 3 + # #,, # , $ )* ! " # , , 4 (( /0 :4E630 20H :@=5 18174 74 ! =0750=150> 5/0 A05530> 2:A757:4 :< 31F 14> =0B0950> 5/0 >0<0490 51I04 6G 5/0 199@A0> 5/15 9/0C@0 74 C@0A57:4 F1A 7AA@0> 1A A09@=75G 14> /0 7A 4:5 371630<:=9:4?7957:4@4>0=0957:4( :<5/095 (! /0 :4E630 20H :@=5 74 " # $% =0<0==748 5: 75A 01=370= >097A7:4A 7493@>74875A>097A7:474$A@2=1/=0750=150>5/0 2:A757:4 :< 31F 5/15 7AA@1490 :< 6314I 9/0C@0 ?:3@451=73G 2 "5%&%&$*-0 3 .%&%)/0$%' - 10 - A7480>14>/14>0>:?0=6G5/0199@A0>F/79/7A5:F1=>A A:;0 21G;045 F:@3> 155=195 5/0 2=0A@;257:4 @4>0= 0957:4():<5/095F/79/7493@>0A5/00H7A50490:< 308133G04<:=901630>065 ( '/04 5/0 199@A0> 51I0A 1 613> >0<0490 F/730 1>;755748 5/15 5/0 9/0C@0H ( 603:48A 5: /7A 614I 199:@45 14> 75 601=A /7A A78415@=0 5: 9:4504> 5/15 5/0 A1;0F1A7AA@0>6314I5:F1=>AA09@=75G5/02=0A@;257:4 @4>0= 0957:4A (( 14> () :< 5/0 95 F:@3> 1=7A0 14> 5/0 6@=>04 A/7<5A :4 5/0 199@A0> 5: =06@5 5/0 30813 2=0A@;257:4 ?04 5/:@8/ 5/0 199@A0> /1> 51I04 1 613> >0<0490/07A4:5A@990AA<@3742=:61637A748A@9/>0<0490 14> 74 =06@55748 5/0 30813 2=0A@;257:4 4>0= A@9/ 97=9@;A51490A/07A371630<:=9:4?7957:4 (, /1?08:405/=:@8/5/07;2@840>B@>8;045:< 19C@75513 21AA0> 6G 5/0 =713 :@=5 5 /1A 2=:900>0> 5: 19C@755/0199@A0>:45/08=:@4>5/155/09:;23174145/1A 4:5 2=:?0> /7A <74149713 9121975G 5: 304> 5/0 1;:@45K 195@13 304>748 7A 4:5 2=:?0> 14> 5/0=0<:=0 1>?0=A0 - 11 - 74<0=0490 F733 /1?0 5: 60 >=1F4 18174A5 5/0 9:;23174145 /0 =713 :@=5 9:;;7550> 14 0==:= 74 <:=;748 A@9/ 14 :2747:4 F/04 5/0 2:A757:4 :< 31F 7A ?0=G F033 A05530> '/04 5/0 199@A0> 1>;75A 7AA@1490 :< 5/0 9/0C@0H ( F75//7AA78415@=05/02=0A@;257:41=7A0AF/79/7493@>0A 5/0 0H7A50490 :< 308133G 04<:=901630 >065 4>0= A@9/ 97=9@;A51490 5/0=0 9144:5 60 14G =0C@7=0;045 <:= 5/0 9:;231741455:2=:?0195@13304>748:<5/01;:@45:=/7A <74149713 9121975G /0=0<:=0 4: 1>?0=A0 74<0=0490 9:@3> 60>=1F418174A55/09:;23174145745/15=081=>4?70F :<5/7A5/07;2@840>B@>8;045:<19C@7551321AA0>6G5/0 =713:@=59133A<:=7450=<0=04906G5/7A:@=599:=>7483G 14AF0=5/016:?02:745745/0&&14>2=:900>5: 21AA5/0<:33:F748 $7& /01220137A' $77& /0 7;2@840> B@>8;045 :< 19C@75513 >150> ()"!!"() 21AA0> 74 :!+- !"(+ 6G 5/0 7?73 @>80 14> * @>>067/13 - 12 - 19C@755748 5/0 199@A0> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4 ( :< 5/0 957A/0=06GA051A7>0 $777& :4A0C@0453G 5/0 =0A2:4>045 199@A0> 7A 9:4?7950> <:= 5/0 :<<0490 2@47A/1630 @4>0= 0957:4( :<5/095 $7?& /0 =0A2:4>045 199@A0> 7A A0450490> 5: 21G<740:<A,""""" 4>0<1@355:21G <740/0A/133@4>0=8:A7;2307;2=7A:4;045 <:=120=7:>:<:40G01= $?& @5:<5/0<7401;:@455:60>02:A750>6G 5/0 199@A0> 14 1;:@45 :< A)"""" A/1336021G16305:5/09:;23174145 $?7& 087A5=G 7A >7=0950> 5: A04> 619I 5/0 =713 :@=5 =09:=>A 13:48 F75/ 5/0 9:2G :< 5/0 B@>8;045 <:= 74<:=;157:4 14> 400><@3 1957:4 70 <:= 7AA@1490 :< 5/0 9:4?7957:4 F1==14518174A55/0199@A0> -+ &##* $ 7A5:(3:!