- 1 - ! "! #$# %$!&&! !!'' (& ) * ! "#$$$%$ & ! " ' ' #$' ( (( ! "#$$$%$ & ! )'* ( " ) ) '%+!'" ) ) ($+($(( +($(' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) ) , $ -.//012312 45627018 .16 .9.:6 6.806 ($+($(( ;.<<06 => 66383?1./ 013?: 3@3/ 5620 .16 ?8?: AA36018 /.37< :3=51./ 36.: !B?: <-?:8 C8:3=51./D" 31 1?+($('8-3<.;;0./3<B3/06 ( :3 .<.@.:.4 .8- /0.:106 A?51<0/ <5=738806 .;;0./9.<=>A/.37.181?'B?:01-.1A07018?BA?7;01<.83?1 8 9.< <5=738806 ?1 $('$($(' 9-01 78.13 E 0:/. .2.<5F. .13 ./?12 938- ?8-0:< 9.< 8:.@0//312 31 .: 1?G '+G(++?1G10.: .:F516.@3//.206:3@0:?B !?:8-0.<80:1 .:1.8.F. ?.6 :.1<;?:8 ?:;?:.83?1" 5< =0.:3121? +(G)('$6:?@03831:.<-.16102/320187.110: .16 6.<-06 .2.31<8 .: A.5<312 .AA36018 1 <.36 .AA36018 78.13 <5<8.3106 B.8./ 3145:30< .16 6306 65:312 8:0.87018 //02312/?<<?B60;01601A>?1.AA?518?B-0:518370/>60.8- -0:-5<=.16.16<?1B3/06A/.37;08383?15160:0A83?1'?B ?8?:0-3A/0<A8.2.31<8 - 3 - + 1A?180<89-0:031A/.37;08383?19.<?;;?<061?8 ?1/>601>312.20?AA5;.83?1.1631A?70?B60A0.<06.<90// .< 60;01601A> ?B A/.37.18< =58 ./<? .//02312 :.<- .16 102/320186:3@312?B.:=>38<6:3@0:8:3=51./B:.7063<<50<.16 :0A?:606 0@3601A0 /.37.18 1?' 0H.73106 -37<0/B .< ' .162?87.:F06H<G'8?G':3@0:?B5<9.<0H.73106 .<'=581?6?A57018<90:07.:F06 1 A?1<360:.83?1 8:3=51./ -0/6 .AA36018 -.6 ?AA5::066508?:.<-.16102/320186:3@312?B5<=>38<6:3@0: /0.63128?60.8-?B78.13.16A/.37.18<90:0-0/601838/06 B?:A?7;01<.83?1.<<0<<06=>38B:?7 .<B?//?9< !+ ,-./ 0123 ' ?<<?B60;01601A> <'''$$G ( ?<<?B0<8.80 <'$$$G + )510:./0H;01<0< <'$$$G ?1<?:8357 <$$$$G 3-+ /" "45 3<<.83<B306 938- I5.1857 A/.37.18 1?' 9.< 31 .;;0./ 8 9.< <5=738806 8-?52- A/.37.18< <8.806 8-.8 60A0.<069.<6?3128.3/?:3129?:F.160.:1312<'$$$G;0: 7?18- 8:3=51./ A?1<360:06 -0: 31A?70 1?83?1.//> .8 <'($$$G <.70 A.//< B?: 3180:B0:01A0 8 9.< B5:8-0: - 4 - <5=7388068-0:09.<1?.66383?1?B0<A./.83?18?.9.:65160: A?1@0183?1./ -0.6< 1 .=?@0 2:?516< <?52-8 B?: .//?9312 .;;0./ 1?8-0:-.16:3-.:.1.=.<.;;. .83//0.:106 A?51<0/B?::0<;?16018?'G ?;;?<06.;;0./ % 0.:6/0.:106A?51<0/0:5<0637;5210645627018 .16.9.:6 ):?7 .=?@0 ?1/> ;?318 8-.8 9?5/6 .:3<0 B?: A?1<360:.83?13< .703<.1<90:06;.:8/>31.BB3:7.83@0B?:B?//?9312 :0.<?1< '$ -?52- A/.37.18< -.6 <8.806 8-.8 60A0.<06 9.< 0.:1312 <'$$$G B:?7 8.3/?:312 9?:F <.70 9.< 1?8 <5=<8.183.806 938- .1> <;0A3B3A 0@3601A0 1 .=<01A0 8:3=51./ :32-8/> .<<0<<06 38 1?83?1.//> 58 1?83?1./ 31A?70 B?: >0.: ($('.<.6?;806=> B?:<088/07018?BA.<0<=0B?:0?FG - 5 - 6./.8 =0312 <'($G <.70 -.< 8? =0 A?1<360:06 .F312 1?80?B.20?B60A0.<06.8>0.:<.161.85:0?B07;/?>7018 .< <0/BG07;/?>06 .16 A/.37.18< =0312 -5<=.16 .16 <?1 8:3=51./:32-8/>.6606'$J8?7?18-/>31A?706065A806'+:6 8?9.:6<;0:<?1./0H;01<0<.16.;;/306A?::0A875/83;/30:?B'' -5<?1:0GA?7;58.83?1/?<<?B60;01601A>9?5/6=0 K!<'($L'$J"G'+:6MH'(H''N<'+%$$G '' 8 3< <001 8-.8 8:3=51./ .9.:606 /?<< ?B <;?5<./ A?1<?:8357 8? A/.37.18 1?' .16 8-?52- :0<;?16018 1?( 9.< <?1?B60A0.<06/?<<?BB3/3./A?1<?:83573<1?8.9.:606<.70 :0I53:0< 8? =0 .9.:606 -5< 8?8./ A?7;01<.83?1 5160: A?1@0183?1./-0.6<9?5/6=0<''$$$$G '( < ;0: 60A3<3?1 31 :0;?:80631 !! A/.37.18< 9?5/6 =0 01838/06 B?: '$J 0<A./.83?1 B?: 0@0:>8-:00>0.:<31A07?:08-.1<3H>0.:<-.@0/.;<06.B80: <.36 60A3<3?1 8-0> 9?5/6 =0 01838/06 8? ($J 0<A./.83?1 30 <(($$$G!<''$$$$GH($J" -5<A/.37.18<9?5/6=0 01838/06 8? 8?8./ A?7;01<.83?1 ?B <'''$$G .<<0<<06 .< B?//?9< - 6 - ,-./607,2/-382 0123 ?<<?B60;01601A> <'+%$$G ?1@0183?1./-0.6< <''$$$$G <A./.83?1!($J" <(($$$G 3-+ /""" 5 '+ 1 @309 ?B 60A3<3?1 ?B 8-3< ?5:8 31 " # $ @< % :0;?:806 31 & '() * && A/.37.18<9?5/6=001838/06B?:3180:0<8.8:.80?BJ31<80.6?B J.9.:606=>8:3=51./?1<0I5018/>B?//?9312 3 ;;0./3<.//?90631;.:845627018.16.9.:6 6.806 ($+($((;.<<06=> 66383?1./ 013?: 3@3/5620.16 ?8?:AA36018/.37< :3=51./ 36.: 31 1?+($(' 3< 7?63B306 A/.37.18< .:0 -0/6 01838/06 B?: 8?8./ A?7;01<.83?1 ?B <'''$$G .< .2.31<8 <'(+'$$G .9.:606 => :3=51./ 938- 3180:0<8 .8 J ;0: .1157 B:?7 6.80 ?B A/.37 ;08383?183//60;?<380HA/563123180:0<8B?:60/.> ;0:3?6 ?B 6.>< .< ;0: <0;.:.80 ?:60: ?B 8-3<?5:86.806('$%($( 33 0<;?16018G 3< 63:0A806 8? 60;?<38 <.70=0B?:08:3=51./938-31032-8900F< - 7 - 333 1 60;?<38 A/.37.18 1?( 3< -0/6 01838/06 B?: <$$$$G 938- ;:?;?:83?1.80 3180:0<8 07.31312 .7?518 3< .;;?:83?106 31 B.@?5: ?B A/.37.181?'$J?B<.70-.<8?=0F0;831 B3H0660;?<3831.1>.83?1./3<06.1F?:?<8./ 60;?<38 0.:1312 -32-0<8 :.80 ?B 3180:0<8 B?: . ;0:3?6?B>0.:<.16:07.31312$J-.<8?=0 :0/0.<0631B.@?5:?BA/.37.181?' !.5 (&&!) $ 3<8?'/?+$ 8F