Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65565 (KAR)
SMT SUMANGALA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/201138/2025 · 2025-07-21
M I Arun
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65565 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65565 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#"$
%&#!&
'(
!!"#
$% &'% '
(
'%
!)"""
%
!!"
!!"
Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
!!"
! '
*)
!)""! %
'
!!"
$%
&
% ' %
#+ % % '
!(
%
) ,
%
( - %
)""! %%
% '
.))# ' ,", / % %
%
%
' ( %
# %%
'
%
' %% % .!&(
%
%
01
%
2
- 3 -
&%
2 (
34546767894: ;<=7>79? 68 @4 634 8A94:8B ")=;:4C ?D96=C 8B <=9E 79 F8)G! C76D=64E =6 =5988: H7<<=?4=<DI=9E7C6:7;6=<=@D:=?7=55<74EB8:?:=968B 94;4CC=:F54:>7CC789B8:;89H4:C7898B634C=>4B8:989 =?:7;D<6D:=< 5D:58C4C 8A4H4: :4C589E496 8 E7E 986 =;6A76379634C675D<=64E 67>4D9E4: 4;6789 .!&(8B 634 =:9=6=I= =9E 4H49D4 ;6 .)# &34:479=B64: :4B4::4E 68=C0634;61B8:C38:6(D6=B64:=<=5C48B=:8D9E) E=FC :4C589E496 8 3=C 7CCD4E 634 7>5D?94E 49E8:C4>496 E=64E )""! H7E4 994JD:4 68 634 A:76 54676789 89 634 ?:8D9E 63=6 634 C=7E 5:854:6F 7C = A=IB5:854:6F9E8:C4>496:4=EC=CD9E4:
!" !#$%&' !" !#()
*+),- . /0 1*0 2 )203456 7(8 (2396 ,
):$;<<)=0 ,2>0 (?<@())= 0 :$;<<;) A) @$B)
) <C
:)/) )
;<5 D) 1)@'E
) F
- 4 -
??:74H4E @F 634 C=>4 634 5:4C496 A:76 546767897CB7<4E
34 ;=C4 8B 634 546767894: 7C 63=6 C34 7C 634 8A94: 8B 634 5:854:6F =9E 634 :4H49D4 E8;D>496C 54:6=7979? 68 634 C=>4 C6=9EC 79 34: 9=>4 34 3=C 5:8ED;4E = ;85F 8B H7E4 994JD:4 68 634 A:76 54676789A37;3C38AC63=6634546767894:@4;=>46348A94: 8B6345:854:6F@FH7:6D48B=5=:676789E=64E"#"" =9E63479:4<=6789686345:854:6F;89;4:94EC6=9EC 796349=>48B634546767894: # 34 <4=:94E ;8D9C4< =554=:79? B8: :4C589E496 8!E84C986E7C5D64634:4H49D4496:74C8A4H4:34 ;89649EC 63=6 @F H7:6D4 8B :4<4H=96 9867B7;=6789 76 7C 634 A=IB@8=:EA37;37C6348A94:8B6345:854:6F=9E634:4 A=C ;4:6=79 E4<=F 79 ;8>>D97;=679? 634 C=>4 68 634 :4C589E496 8 A37;3 :4CD<64E 79 5=CC79? 8B 634 7>5D?94E 8:E4: @4<=64E<F 4 BD:634: CD@>76C 63=6 634 <7>76=67895:4C;:7@4ED9E4:4;6789.!8B634;6854:=64C 89<F A349 634 546767894: 7C 634 D9E7C5D64E 8A94: 8B 634
- 5 -
5:854:6F=9E9868634:A7C4
9634C=7E?:8D9E345:=FC B8:E7C>7CC=<8B634A:7654676789 ! 4;6789.!&(8B634=:9=6=I= =9E4H49D4 ;6:4=EC=CD9E4:
!"
##$%!&
'!())))(
*'(
&* %$ %
)
+ ,#$'&$ -,)*)&
(,. &)$#*'!( !" % & &*
&
!"
&* %$ %
)/ * )*'' )$0,& ! ,(.,& '
!+ -,&* ! %%',#&,
! &
&* %$&"
,)),
! ,! &* !! ) " 0 % )# ,0(!(, &*(,. ),
!,))
$+*&1 , 2* % ,)),
! &* %$&"
,)),
! )*''! &0 3$, (
(,. ),
! '!() ! !+ ,#$'&$ ' %$ %
))/ , )$#* '!() ))))(
*'(
&*%$ %
)
+ ,#$'&$ / ,))% &*'!($)))%#, ,(,!&*4)& 5'!
($'" %$0',)*(/
&* #
!# !( '!( $!( &* %
.,),
!)
&* !& 2
-! !(
$!& "5'!!,!+#&/6 !& #& 1
671 5
.,(( &*&/ &* % )# ,0( $!( )$0)#&,
! 8 )*'' 0 %,( &
&* #
!# !( 2
-! 5'!!,!+
- 6 -
$&*
,&" & &* &,
0&,!,!+ 3$,),& % ,)),
!)
&* $&*
,&" '
!+ -,&* )' (#' &,
!)"0% )# ,0( 5
.,(( $ &* &*&/ ! (,. ),
! '!(
! ! + ,#$'&$ '%$ %
))*''0 3$, (/, + ,#$'&$ ' '!( $%&
1 # ) ,) $)(
)&0',)*,!+ !- ,!($)& ,)/ , )$#* '!() ))))(
*'(
&* %$ %
)
+ ,#$'&$ / ,) ) % &* '!( $) ) )%#, ,( ,! &* 4)& 5'! ($'" %$0',)*(/
&* #
!# !('!($!( &*%
.,),
!)
&* !&
2
-!!(
$!& "5'!!,!+#&/6 !& #& 67-,&*%%
.'
&*9&&:
. !!&1
,, !"
##$%!&
'!())))(
*'( &*%$ %
)
+ ,#$'&$ -,)*)&
(,. &)$#* '!(
!"% &&*
&
!"
&* %$ %
) !( , )$#* '!() '',!+
$&),( &*
#' 5'!!,!+
-*,#*&*4)& 5'!*)! & 0! %$0',)*(/ &* %%',#!& )*'' )$0,& ! ,(.,& '
!+ -,&* ! %%',#&,
! &
&* %$&"
,)),
! ,! )$#* !! ) " 0% )# ,0(1 2*#
!# !($&*
,&,))*'' $ !,)*&*,
%,!,
! -,&*,! , &! (")
&* (&
#,%&
&* %%',#&,
!12*%$&"
,)),
! )*'',))$&* %%
.'
(,. ),
! $))% &*%%',#&,
!/ )$0;#& &
&*
%,!,
! $ !,)*( 0" &* #
!# !(
- 7 -
$&*
,&,) !( )$0;#& &
%"!&
&* ) % )# ,0($!( )$0)#&,
!8 5
.,((&*&/,
%,!,
!,)! & $ !,)*(-,&*,! &* ),( % ,
(
, &! (")/ ,& )*'' 0 (( &*& &* #
!# !( $&*
,&,) *. ! 0;#&,
! & &* ),( (,. ),
! '!(
$) ) % &* %%',#&,
! 5
.,(( $ &* &*&/ ,!
#) &* %$&" ,)),
! ,')&
+,.*,)(#,),
!!(,))$)&* ( $!( &*,))$0)#&,
!-,&*,!&*, &"(") &*(&
#,%&
&*%%',#&,
!/&*%%
.' &*(,. ),
! $))*''0((&
*.0! + !&(0"&*%$&"
,)),
! !(&*) )*''0# &, ,(!(,))$(,!)$#*!! )" 0 % )# ,0( )$0;#& &
%"!&
) % )# ,0($!( )$0)#&,
!81 ,,, !" (,. ),
! ,)
0&,!( -,&* ') -
!+ (#' &,
! ,(.,& $!( &*,) )#&,
!/ ,! ((,&,
! &
&* # ,,!' ',0,',&,)/ &*))*''0!$''!(. ,($%
! ( ,! &*,) + ( 0" &* %$&"
,)),
! 1 2* #
!. ),
! /, ,&&(/)*'')&!(
,&( &
&* :
. !!&1 2* '!( -*
) (,. ),
! ! !+ ,#$'&$ $)-)
0&,!(0" ') ,(.,&/ &* %$&"
,)),
! " ') ,))$! (
,&$
&*),('!(& &*:
. !!&1
- 8 -
,.!#)% &
&*)$ ."!$0 ,))
$+*& &
0 (,. &(
! !+ ,#$'&$ $) &*! % ,
% #
!. ),
! ) &#*/ %%
.( 0" &* 9$ ." 9&&'!& !( !( #
() % &!&/,(!&, ",!+&*&)!(0
$!() &* % & )
$+*& &
0 #
!. &(/ )*'' 0 !(&
,'" ,'( '
!+ -,&* %%',#&,
! (,. ),
! 5
.,(( &*&/ ,! #) &* 9$ ." 9&&'!& !( !( #
() (% &!& ,') &
%%
. ;#& &* % #
!. ),
! ) &#* -,&*,! , &! (") &*(&
#,%&
%%',#&,
! &*) &#* &*%%',#!&/,&)*''0((&
0%%
.( )% % (0"&*%%',#!&!(&*%%
.')*'' 0,))$(,!&*!! )"0% )# ,0(1 . ! #) &* %%',#!& ,! *,) (#' &,
! ,(.,& )&&( &*& &* '!( )
$+*& &
0 (,. &( &
! !+ ,#$'&$ $) ,) + !&( '!(&*!&*%$&"
,)),
! )*'' ;#& &*%%',#&,
!, &*(,. ),
!#
!& .!)!" %
.,),
!)
&* !& 9#*($'( )&) !(9#*($'(2 ,0)5
*,0,&,
! 2 !) &,!!()#&/68<
&* !& !( : !&) $')/ 66
!"
&* & ) !( #
!(,&,
!)
&* + !&) ,))$( 0" &* :
.
!!&
&,&
&,1
- 9 -
.,
(
(,. ),
!$!( &*,))#&,
!)*'' 0",&)' '(&
,!# ),!&*+$,(!#.'$ &* (,. &( '!( ) ! &, ,( 0" &* % &!&
9&% !( +,)& &,
! $!')) &*'!(,)%$&&
#&$'! !+ ,#$'&$ '$)) $!( %
.,),
!)
&* !& 2
-! !( $!& "5'!!,!+#&/6 !& #& 67 5
.,(( &*&/ ,! )*,! !!( ,)& ,#&/ )$0;#& &
!" '-
&* &, 0,!+ ,! # + (,!+ #&,
! 0$,'(,!+)
&*#
!)& $#&,
! -'')
&! )/! ##$%!&
( "%$!;'!(/-& '!(
+ (!'!(-*
,)! &1 % )
! +,)& (
',0' &
0 +,)& ( ) ! ##$%!&
)$#* '!( $!( 9#&,
!<
&* !& !( ) #&/ 6 !& #& 6= 0+ !&
)$#*'!($!( 9#&,
!88 &* !& !(
) #&/ 6 !& #&
6/ " -,&*
$& 0&,!,!+ &* % ,)),
! 3$, ( $!( &*,) )$0)#&,
! !( ! &-,&*)&!(,!+ !"&*,!+ #
!&,!( &* ,!/ (,. & )$#* '!(
% & &*
&
!"
&* %$ %
) & )!(,!+
% , ! &,# & &* 2*),'( ,! )$#*
) " 0
- 10 -
% )# ,0( !( )$0;#& &
%"!& % )# ,0($!( )$0)#&,
!81>
) 67C98679E7C5D6463=66347>5D?94E8:E4:3=C @449 5=CC4E @4F89E 634 54:78E 8B <7>76=6789 5:4C;:7@4E D9E4:4;6789.!8B634;69E4:634C=7E;7:;D>C6=9;4C 7B=98;;D5=968B634<=9E=CC4CC4E8:34<EB8:6345D:58C4 8B =?:7;D<6D:4 A7C34C 68 E7H4:6 634 C=>4 B8: 989 =?:7;D<6D:=< 5D:58C4C =9E >=I4C =9 =55<7;=6789 B8: ;89H4:C7898B634C=>4634C=>43=C68@4?:=964EA76379 634 C675D<=64E 67>4 B=7<79? A37;3 76 A8D<E @4 ;89C7E4:4E 63=663454:>7CC7897CE44>4E683=H4@449?:=964E3=6 634=D638:7674C;89;4:94E=:4:4KD7:4E68<88I79687C63=6 A34634:6348;;D574:8B634<=9E3=C>=E4634=55<7;=6789 8:98634F=:4986:4KD7:4E68H4:7BFA34634:347C634 6:D4=9E=@C8<D648A94:8B6345:854:6F8:=9F637:E5=:6F 3=C = :7?36 8H4: 634 C=>4 9E7C5D64E<F 79 634 79C6=96 ;=C4 =<< 634 :4H49D4 :4;8:EC 54:6=7979? 68 634 <=9E ;89;4:94EC6=9E796349=>48B634546767894:A37;3% , #,4C6=@<7C34C63=6634546767894:7C6348;;D5=968B634
- 11 -
<=9E 34 7C =D638:7L4E 68 >=I4 =9 =55<7;=6789 D9E4: 4;6789.!8B634;6B8:;89H4:C7898B634C=>4B8:989 =?:7;D<6D:=< 5D:58C4C =9E 7B CD;3 =9 =55<7;=6789 7C >=E4 :4C589E49687C@8D9E68=;689634C=>4 , 6 7C =<C8 ;<=:7B74E 63=6 MDC6 @4;=DC4 634 8;;D5=96 8B 634 <=9E =55<74C B8: ;89H4:C789 8B 634 <=9E B:8>=?:7;D<6D:=<68989=?:7;D<6D:=<5D:58C4C=9E8@6=79C 634 :4<4H=96 54:>7CC789 D9E4: 4;6789 .! 8B 634 ;6 76 E84C986>4=963=634@4;8>4C634=@C8<D648A94:8B634 C=>467C=<A=FC8549B8:634637:E5=:6FA387C;<=7>79?
= :7?36 8H4: 634 <=9E 68 E7C5D64 634 8A94:C375 8B 634 54:C89 =55<74E B8: CD;3 ;89H4:C789 9 634 79C6=96 ;=C4 :4C589E496 8! 7C =<A=FC =6 <7@4:6F 68 E7C5D64 634 8A94:C375 8B 634 546767894: 8H4: 634 <=9E A37;3 7C 634 CD@M4;6>=664:8B634A:7654676789@4B8:4634=55:85:7=64 B8:D>8A4H4:=C546767894:3=C4C6=@<7C34E63=6C347C 6348;;D5=968B634<=9E=9EC347C=D638:7C4ED9E4:634 ;668=55<FB8:;89H4:C7898B634<=9EB:8>=?:7;D<6D:=<68 989=?:7;D<6D:=<5D:58C4C:4C589E49687CED6F@8D9E
- 12 -
68 ;89C7E4: 634 =55<7;=6789 A76379 634 67>4 B:=>4 B=7<79? A37;363454:>7CC7897CE44>4E683=H4@449?:=964E9 634 79C6=96 ;=C4 54:78E 3=H79? 4<=5C4E 76 3=C 68 @4 ;89C7E4:4E63=694;4CC=:F54:>7CC7893=C@449?:=964E79 B=H8D:8B634546767894:
49;4634B8<<8A79? 7 >5D?94E 49E8:C4>496 8:E4: E=64E )""! @4=:79? =BB7E=H76 8.))# A763<=9E;89H4:C7898,",5=CC4E@F :4C589E496 8 H7E4 994JD:4 68 634 A:76 546767897C34:4@FC46=C7E4 77 4C589E496 8 7C E7:4;64E 68 7CCD4 634 :4KD7:4E54:>7CC78979B=H8D:8B634546767894: B8:;89H4:C7898B634<=9E=C5:=F4EB8:@F34: @F6:4=679?63=6634<=9E3=C@449E44>4E68 3=H4@449;89H4:64E=C54:6345:8H7C789C8B 4;6789 .! 8B 634 =:9=6=I= =9E 4H49D4
- 13 -
;6.)#A76379B8D:A44ICB:8>634E=648B :4;47568B;4:67B74E;85F8B637C8:E4: 777 34546767894:C3=<<5=F63494;4CC=:FB44B8: 634C=7E;89H4:C78979=;;8:E=9;4A763<=A 7H 37C 8:E4: A7<< 986 ;8>4 79 634 A=F 8B :4C589E4968!;<=7>79?=9F:7?36C8H4:634 <=9E ;89;4:94E @4B8:4 634 =55:85:7=64 =D638:76F ;;8:E79?<FA:76546767897CE7C58C4E8B
!)* '&( #
'
7C68<8,,