Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65558 (KAR)
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR NEKRTC v. PARVATI W/O LATE BASANNA SAKRE
MFA/201661/2022 · 2025-11-05
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65558 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65558 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#! "## !! $ % &
! "# $
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%& '##
(
&$ ))$)
*)$)$
(
( ! (
+(
+( (
# +(
,-. /001/2 -. 34 5,1 62/-7/85 9-21: ;8:1< 165-=8 %& =95,1=5=<1,-621.65 '##9=<.,=<55,165> 31-8? /??<-1@1: 34 5,1 A;:?7185 /8: /B/<: :/51: &$ ))$) 0/..1:345,1 ::218-=<-@-2(;:?1/8: /2/3;</?--8=*)$)$.11C-8?18,/8617185 =96=7018./5-=8
) /65. ?-@-8? <-.1 5= 5,1 9-2-8? =9 5,1 /001/2 3<-1924 .5/51: /<1 5,/5 =8 )' $)$ ' B,18 :161/.1:
- 3 -
71., B/. 0<=611:-8? =8 5,1 =5=<64621 31/<-8? 1?=DE D ))$5=B/<:. ;:,/8-9<=79F/20;</5 /3=;5 E 07 B,18 :161/.1: /00<=/6,1: 81/< ;.D
10=5 =8 9F/20;< 5= ;:,/8- <=/: /5 5,/5 5-71 =81 3;. 31/<-8? 1?=D&)D) E# 6/71 9<=7 =00=.-51 .-:1 9<=7 ;:,/8- .-:1 -8 ,-?, .011: </., /8: 81?2-?1857/881</8::/.,1:5=5,17=5=<64621 ;15= -70/65:161/.1:9122:=B8/8:.;.5/-81:?<-1@=;.-8A;<-1. =8 ,-. ,1/: 7;25-021 9</65;<1 5= 3</-8 /8: 32==: B/. ==F-8?9<=75,18=.1/8:1/</8::-1:=85,1.0=5
& <-=< 5= 5,1 /66-:185 :161/.1: B/. ,/21 /8: ,1/25,4/8:B/.1/<8-8?.)$$$D01<7=85,34:=-8? /-2=<-8? /8: /<7185. 3;.-81.. ,1 015-5-=81< 31-8? 7=5,1< =9 :161/.1: ,/. 2=.5 5,1 1/<8-8? 71731< =9 5,1 9/7-24 :;1 5= ;85-7124 :1/5, =9 :161/.1: 1861 5,1 62/-7/859-21:5,162/-7015-5-=8;8:1<165-=8 **=95,1 65319=<15,12/-7.<-3;8/2.11C-8?6=7018./5-=8
- 4 -
E ;<.;/855=5,1.;77=8.<1.0=8:185/001/<1: /8:9-21:.5/517185=9=3A165-=8.:184-8?5,1185-<162/-7 015-5-=8 /@1<7185. /8: .=;?,5 5= :-.7-.. 5,1 62/-7 015-5-=8
85,13/.-.=95,1021/:-8?.=95,10/<5-1.5,1 2/-7.<-3;8/29</71:5,1-..;1./8:5,1<1/951<<16=<:1: 5,1 1@-:1861 8 =<:1< 5= 0<=@1 5,1 6/.1 62/-7/85 ?=5 1G/7-81: ,1<.129 /. D /8: ?=5 1G,-3-51: :=6;7185. 8/7124 G 5= G%
8 31,/29 =9 <1.0=8:185 5,<11 B-581..1. /<1 1G/7-81: /. . 5= & /8: ?=5 7/<C1:
9=;<:=6;7185/.G. 5=E
* ,12/-7.<-3;8/2345,1-70;?81:A;:?7185 ,12:5,/5 5,1 /66-:185 5==C02/61=8 /66=;85=9 </., /8: 81?2-?185 :<-@-8? =9 5,1 :<-@1< =9 5,1 =9918:-8? ;././<1.;25=9B,-6,:161/.1:.;.5/-81:-8A;<-1./8:
.;66;731:5=5,1-8A;<-1.,1<-3;8/2;0=86=8.-:1<-8? 5,1=</2/8::=6;7185/<41@-:186102/61:319=<1-5,12: 5,/5 5,1 62/-7/85 -. 185-521: 5= 6=7018./5-=8 =9 . #&#$$D/2=8?B-5,-851<1.5/55,1</51=9*H0/
- 5 -
/8: :-<1651: <1.0=8:185 " 9=< .,=<5 I5,1 =<0=</5-=8> 5= :10=.-5 5,1 6=7018./5-=8 1-8? /??<-1@1: 34 5,1 A;:?7185 /8: /B/<: 5,1 /00122/85 " =<0=</5-=8-.-85,-./001/2-70;?8-8?5,12-/3-2-54/8:/. B122/.5,1J;/85;7=96=7018./5-=8
% ,121/<81:6=;8.129=<5,162/-7/85</-.1:5,1 9=22=B-8?6=85185-=8. / ,1 21/<81: 6=;8.12 /001/<-8? 9=< 5,1 =<0=</5-=8,/.6=8518:1:5,/55,1/66-:185,/.=66;<<1:
:;1 5= 81?2-?1861 =9 :161/.1: B,= B/. <-:-8? 5,1 7=5=<64621 =8 5,1 B<=8? .-:1 ,1 <-3;8/2 ,/. 6=77-551:/81<<=<-8,=2:-8?5,/55,1:<-@1<=95,1 ;./2=81-.81?2-?185-86/;.-8?5,1/66-:185
3 ,1<-:1<=95,17=5=<6462131/<-8?1?=D E D ))$6/71-8/</.,/8:81?2-?1857/881<=85,1 1G5<171<-?,5.-:1=95,1<=/:/8::/.,1:5=5,1=9918:-8? ;. ;15=5,1-70/65:161/.1:9122:=B8/8:.;.5/-81: -8A;<-1./8::-1:=85,1.0=5
- 6 -
6 = :-.0<=@1 5,1 6/.1 =9 5,1 62/-7/85 5,1 =<0=</5-=8,/.1G/7-81:5,1:<-@1<=95,1;./. 8 ,-. 1@-:1861 ,1 ,/. 6/51?=<-6/224 .5/51: 5,/5 5,1 /66-:185,/.=66;<<1::;15=</.,/8:81?2-?185<-:-8?=9 7=5=<64621 34 :161/.1: ,14 ,/@1 /2.= 0<=:;61: 5,1 0,=5=?</0,. 7/<C1: /5 G ,1 <-3;8/2 B-5,=;5 6=8.-:1<-8?/225,1.1/.0165=95,17/551<,/.6=77-551: 1<<=< -8 ,=2:-8? 5,/5 5,1 :<-@1< =9 5,1 3;. /2=81 -. 81?2-?185-86/;.-8?5,1/66-:185
: /.524-8<1.0165=9J;/85;7=96=7018./5-=8 -.6=861<81:-5-..;37-551:5,/56=8.-:1<-8?5,1/?1/8: /@=6/5-=8=9:161/.1:5,1=@1</226=7018./5-=8/B/<:1: 34 5,1 <-3;8/2 -.
=8 5,1 ,-?,1< .-:1 1861 =8 5,1.1 ?<=;8:.0</41:5=/22=B5,1/001/2
# 1< 6=85</ 21/<81: 6=;8.12 /001/<-8? 9=< 5,1 62/-7/85<1.0=8:185,/.6=8518:1:5,/55,1/66-:185,/. =66;<<1::;15=</.,/8:81?2-?185:<-@-8?=95,1=9918:-8? 3;. 771:-/5124/951<5,1/66-:1856=702/-85,/.3118
- 7 -
2=:?1: /?/-8.5 5,1 :<-@1< =9 5,1 3;. ,1 =2-61 /951< 5,=<=;?, -8@1.5-?/5-=8 9-21: 6,/<?1D.,115 /?/-8.5 5,1 :<-@1<=95,1;.,1<-3;8/2/951<6=8.-:1<-8?5,1 <10=<5 /5 G* /8: 1@-:1861 =9 5,1 0/<5-1. ,/. <-?,524 ,12:5,/5:<-@1<=95,1;.-./2=8181?2-?185-86/;.-8?5,1 /66-:1851861.;00=<5-8?5,1-70;?81:A;:?7185/8: /B/<:.=;?,55=:-.7-..5,1/001/2
' 1/<:5,121/<81:6=;8.129=<5,1/00122/85/8: 5,1 <1.0=8:185 01<;.1: 5,1 A;:?7185 /8: /B/<: -862;:-8?5,1/001/20/01<. $ 5 -. 5,1 6/.1 =9 5,1 62/-7/85 5,/5 =8 )' $)$ ' :161/.1: 71., B/. 0<=611:-8? 5=B/<:. ;:,/8- 9<=79F/20;<=8 =5=<64621 31/<-8?1?=D E D ))$ /5 /3=;5 E 07 B,18 :161/.1: /00<=/6,1:81/<;.D 10=5=89F/20;<5= ;:,/8-<=/:
/5 5,/5 5-71 =81 3;. 31/<-8? 1?=D&)D ) E#6/719<=7=00=.-51.-:19<=7 ;:,/8-.-:1-8,-?, .011: </., /8: 81?2-?185 7/881< /8: :/.,1: 5= 5,1
- 8 -
7=5=<64621 ;1 5= -70/65 :161/.1: 9122 :=B8 /8:
.;.5/-81: ?<-1@=;. -8A;<-1. =8 ,-. ,1/: 7;25-021 9</65;<1 5=3</-8/8:32==:B/.==F-8?9<=75,18=.1/8:1/</8: :-1:=85,1.0=5
= 0<=@1 5,1 6/.1 5,1 62/-7/85 ,/. 3118 1G/7-81: ,1<.129 /. ,1 ,/. <1-51</51: 185-<1 /@1<7185. 7/:1 -8 5,1 62/-7 015-5-=8 = :-.0<=@1 5,1 6/.1=95,162/-7/85<1.0=8:185,/.1G/7-81:5,1:<-@1< =95,1;./. 8,-.1@-:1861,1,/.6/51?=<-6/224 .5/51: 5,/5 :161/.1: B/. 81?2-?185 -8 6/;.-8? 5,1 /66-:185 951< 5,1 6=702/-85 ,/. 3118 2=:?1: 5,1 6=861<81:=99-6-/2,/.:</B8 <10=<5<=7B,-6,-5-. @1<4 621/< 5,/5 5,1 9<=85 0=<5-=8 =9 5,1 7=5=<64621 ,/. 3118:/7/?1:/8:21950=<5-=8.=95,13;.-.:/7/?1:
) ,1<121@/850=<5-=8.=9 10=<5-.1G5</651: /.;8:1<
- 9 -
<=7B,=7<1J;-.-5-=8<161-@1: 9F/20;< )
/51=9<161-05=9<1J;-.-5-=8 &$ $)$ ' &
/515-71/8:02/61=9-8.0165-=8 &$ $)$ 'K$ $$07K9F/20;< <17-.1. E
/515-71/8:02/61=9/66-:185 =57185-=81:
;731<=901<.=8. -221:
) 8A;<1: =57185-=81: * !'()*+,-'(./01*+-0. $) B=
/;731<=91,-621.-8@=2@1: 01*+-02 01*+-02
31?-.5</5-=8;731< 3
45 4
62/..=91,-621 ;. 4621B-5,?/<1
:7/C1 -6,1<
1<=/..-=8<=
1=2=;< 1:/8:,-51 1:/8:2/6C
% 16,/8-6/2=8:-5-=8=95,1 1,-621 3
45 <=852195.-:11/:2-?,5/8:-8:-6/5=< :/7/?1: )<=852195.-:13;701</8:6=<81< 918:1<:/7/?1: 4
<=853=5, 8:-6/5=<.,1/:2-?,5 /..17324:/7/?1: )<=852195.-:13;701</8:6=<81< 918:1<:/7/?1: &=5,.;.018.-=89=<C.:/7/?1: E/8:213/</8:011:=7151<;8-5 :/7/?1: =5,@-1B7-<<=</8:015<=25/8C :/7/?1: *1/<2195.-:1 8:-6/5=<:/7/?1: # </C14.517 3
45 1.51:5,1=8=5-=8 =8:-5-=8/8:9=;8:5,/55,13</C1-8 =<:1< 4
1.51:5,1=8 .5/5-=81<46=8:-5-=8/8:9=;8:5,/55,1 3</C1-8=<:1< ' 3.1<@/5-=8.7/:1/55,1.0=5=9 5,1/66-:185 -2 $ <-19/<5-6;2/<.=96/;.1=9 /66-:185=0-8-=8 /7=95,1=0-8-=85,/55,-./66-:185B/. 6/;.1:8=5:;15=/84716,/8-6/2:19165. =93=5,5,1@1,-621. 181</2<17/<C.=95,1-8.0165=< =97=5=<@1,-621 ,1<134<1J;1.51:5=@1<-945,1 @1,-621.:=6;7185./8: =9 <-<@1<. /51&$ $)$ '
/71/8:-?8/5;<1=9 8.0165=<=9=5=<1,-621. - 10 -
& =8.-:1<-8? 5,1 1@-:1861 =9 G ",=5=?</0,./8: <10=<5 /.01<G* -5-. @1<4621/<5,/53=5,<-:1<=97=5=<64621-1:161/.1:/. B122 /. :<-@1< =9 5,1 =9918:-8? ;.
B1<1 81?2-?185 -8 6/;.-8? 5,1 /66-:185 951< ,/@-8? ?=81 5,<=;?, 5,1 6=702/-856,/<?1D.,1151@-:1861/8: <10=<5B1/<1 =9 5,1 =0-8-=8 5,/5 5,1 <-:1< =9 5,1 7=5=<64621 -1 :161/.1:,/.6=85<-3;51:81?2-?18615=5,11G5185=9)$H -86/;.-8?5,1/66-:185=5,/51G51855,1A;:?7185/8: /B/<:0/..1:345,1<-3;8/2-.7=:-9-1:
E 8 <1.0165 =9 J;/85;7 =9 6=7018./5-=8 -. 6=861<81:6=8.-:1<-8?5,1/?1/8:/@=6/5-=8=9:161/.1:
5,1 6=7018./5-=8 /B/<:1: 34 5,1 <-3;8/2 -. A;.5 /8: <1/.=8/321/8:8=-851<91<1861-.B/<</851:
85,1<1.;25B10/..5,19=22=B-8? /,1/001/2-. - 11 -
3 ,1 A;:?7185 /8: /B/<: =9 5,1 2/-7. <-3;8/2-.7=:-9-1:5=5,11G5185L:-<165-8?5,1 <1.0=8:185 " =<0=</5-=8 5= :10=.-5 #$H =9 5,1 6=7018./5-=8 /7=;85 /2=8? B-5, -851<1.5 /55,1</51=9*H01</88;79<=75,1:/51=9 015-5-=85-22<1/2-F/5-=8
6 ,1 /7=;85 :10=.-51: 34 5,1 /00122/85 " =<0=</5-=8 319=<1 5,-. =;<5 .,/22 31 5</8.7-551:5=5,1<-3;8/2
67 $!% #
67 $# % #
-.5= 2=&