- 1 - ! "#$## # % %&'( %'' ) !"# "$$ #% &' ($'")* "+, !$$ #'"$ ''"'" ""'- $ # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - . ' $ # &' * '$ " '!/ "!+ " ' ! " !"'"*+ "!*+' 0 ! ' " % '$ ' ! !"*+!""$ ' '" ! !!" ' " % % !'" '" !! . ". 1" *'. 1" + 23 4356567839: ;368< =>>?:3@ 7: 57 68 "96A3 7% 7B ?; 9;=8 '7C6>3 5=5678 $=C=;?9=<6 438@68<78523B6C37B523C3=983@#@@65678=C"6D6C?@<3 *98+=8@!"$=C=;?=<6(B79:2795E52396=C"7?95F, 93<6:5393@B795237BB38>3:4?86:2=;C3?8@393>5678: % %93=@G6523>56787B523 - 3 - 8@6=8'38=C"7@3% (B79:2795E523'"F,=93:33H68< 57I?=:2523>96A68=C497>33@68<:68656=53@=<=68:5523A 23 B=>5: 7B 523 >=:3 68 ;963B =93 52=5 93:478@385 7 =: >7A4C=68=85 B6C3@ 523 496D=53 >7A4C=685 68 '" 7 ;3B793 523 96=C "7?95 =<=68:5=>>?:3@7:57=CC3<68<52=55233C@39:68239 B=A6CJ =8@ 523 B=A6CJ 7B =>>?:3@ 7 2=D3 =<933@ 57 =99=8<3 52369 A=996=<3 8 52393 G=: $7;;=96#$?;=:= B?8>5678 23 >7A4C=68=85 =8@ =>>?:3@ 7=C78<G65252369B=A6CJA3A;39:=5538@3@523:=A3 8523D39J:=A3@=J=>>?:3@7577H523>7A4C=68=85 57 523 268@ 4795678 7B 239 27?:3 57?>23@ 239 68=4497496=53CJ =8@ >7AA6553@ B79>6;C3 :3K?=C 68539>7?9:3 =5=97?8@ 4A:5=568<52=5523936:876A43@6A385 57:?>2=>5:=:236:<768<57A=99J23923>7A4C=68=85 =C:7 :5=53@ 52=5 =B539 523 68>6@385 =>>?:3@ 7 =C78< G652=>>?:3@7:57;368<26:B=A6CJA3A;39:=;?:3@ 239 68 B6C52J C=8<?=<3 I?3:56783@ 239 >2=9=>539 =8@ >96A68=CCJ 6856A6@=53@ 875 57 93D3=C 526: B=>5 57 =8J;7@J - 4 - 3C:3=539=>>?:3@793B?:3@57A=99J239852=5 93<=9@523>7A4C=68=85=4497=>23@523?;9;=8'7C6>3 5=5678=8@"27GH'7C6>35=5678$=C=;?9=<62393=B539 :23 3D38 =4497=>23@ 523 "7AA6::67839 7B '7C6>3 $=C=;?9=<678 8:46537B52=587!>=A357 ;3 93<6:5393@ 2393B793 523 496D=53 >7A4C=685 >=A3 57 ;3 B6C3@ 23 C3=983@ =<6:59=53 93B3993@ 523 A=5539 B79 68D3:56<=5678 ?8@39 3>5678 % *+ 7B "9'" 8 523 A3=856A3 523 4356567839: 2=D3 =4497=>23@ 526: "7?95 :33H68<57I?=:2523>96A68=C497>33@68<: 3=9@ 96 $3A4=9=L? C3=983@ >7?8:3C B79 523 4356567839:96 74=CH96:28==@=DC3=983@ 6<2"7?95 7D398A385 'C3=@39 B79 93:478@385 7 =8@ 96 =52 C3=983@ >7?8:3C B79 93:478@385 7 '39?:3@ 523 A=5396=C:7893>79@ 8 D63G 7B 523 96D=C >785385678: ?9<3@ ;J 523 C3=983@>7?8:3CB79;7525234=9563:5234768552=5G7?C@ =96:3B79AJ>78:6@39=56786:. - 5 - !"#$% J=8:G3957523=;7D3476856:68523 B79523B7CC7G68<. >>79@68<57523>7A4C=68=8552368>6@3852=@ 7>>?993@78 23496D=53>7A4C=685>=A357;3 B6C3@ 78 63 =B539 C=4:3 7B A793 52=8 36<25 A7852:2393=93=;:7C?53CJ8793=:78:=::6<83@B79526: 6879@68=53 @3C=J 7B 36<25 A7852: D38 527?<2 523 >7A4C=68=8593B39:5752368>6@385G2393=>>?:3@7:57 :=6@572=D3=;?:3@23968B6C52JC=8<?=<3=8@>96A68=CCJ 6856A6@=53@2398755793D3=C523B=>57B>7AA6::6787B523 7BB38>3 ;J =>>?:3@ 7 52393 =93 87 @35=6C: :?>2 =: @=53 56A3 =8@ 4C=>3 7B :?>2 68>6@385 @A6553@CJ 523 >7A4C=68=85 2=@ 875 ?8@39<783 A3@6>=C 3K=A68=5678 6AA3@6=53CJ =B539 523 68>6@385 79 =5C3=:5 G65268 = - 6 - 93=:78=;C356A37:>9=47B4=4396:497@?>3@;3B793523 "7?95 57 :27G 52=5 523 >7A4C=68=85 2=@ 497A45CJ =4497=>23@ 365239 ?; 9;=8 '7C6>3 5=5678 79 "27GH '7C6>35=5678793D38523"7AA6::678397B'7C6>3B79523 4?947:37B93<6:53968<523! % 56: 439568385 578753 52=5 93:478@385 7 ) >7A4C=68=85 2=: 875 :G798 =8 =BB6@=D65 G26C3 B6C68< 523 496D=53>7A4C=68523C3=983@>7?8:3CB795234356567839 4C=>3@93C6=8>378523@3>6:6787B52343K"7?9568 G2393 523 43K "7?95 >78:6@3968< 523 96:3 68 B6C68< 7B 496D=53 >7A4C=685: A=H68< :3967?: =CC3<=5678: G6527?5 52393 ;368< =8J =>>7?85=;6C65J =8@ 57 @3539 B=C:3 =8@B96D7C7?:>=:3:A=8@=53@B6C68<7B523=BB6@=D65;J523 >7A4C=68=85 G26>2 G6CC A=H3 26A =>>7?85=;C3 B79 :?>2 =CC3<=5678: 23 43K "7?95 2=: =C:7 93B3993@ 57 = :65?=5678 G2393 523 8?A;39 7B >=:3: 4395=6868< 57 A=596A786=C @6:4?53: B=A6CJ @6:4?53: =93 ;368< B6C3@ G652 &'"&()**+ - 7 - =;879A=C @3C=J =8@ C=>23: =: 93B3993@ 57 68 65: 3=9C639 @3>6:67868 =8@ >=?56783@52396=C"7?95575=H387537B523:=A3;3B793 497>33@68<B?95239 8523493:385>=:3656:57;38756>3@52=5523 >7A4C=68=85 G=: =<3@ J3=9: =8@ :23 6: = 3=>239 ;J 497B3::678 2393B793 :23 A?:5 ;3 2=D68< :?BB6>6385 A=5?965J23852393=938793=:78=;C33K4C=8=5678:B79 523 6879@68=53 @3C=J 68 B6C68< 523 >7A4C=685 =8@ G238 52393 6: 87 93=:78 B79 875 ?8@39<768< 523 A3@6>=C 3K=A68=56786AA3@6=53CJ=B539>7AA6::6787B5237BB38>3 =8@ G238 52393 =93 87 @35=6C: 7B >7AA6::678 7B 523 7BB38>3 ;J =>>?:3@ 7: 57 7B =;?:68< 239 =8@ >96A68=CCJ 6856A6@=568< 239 =8@ B?95239A793 G238 523 >7A4C=685 6: 875 :?447953@ ;J 523 =BB6@=D65 7B 523 >7A4C=68=85 G652 93<=9@ 57 =CC3<=5678: A=@3 =<=68:5 523 =>>?:3@ =A 7B 523 7468678 52=5 93<6:59=5678 7B 523 496D=53 >7A4C=685 =8@ 93B39968< 523 A=5539 B79 ,-."&/ *&+ - 8 - 68D3:56<=56786: 68 =;?:3 7B 497>3:: 7B C=G =8@ 52393B793 523 :=A3 6: C6=;C3 57 ;3 I?=:23@ >>79@68<CJ =8:G39 523 =;7D3 47685 68 523 E=BB69A=56D3F =8@ 497>33@ 57 4=:: 523B7CC7G68<. *6+ 23"96A68=C'35656786:! *66+ '97>33@68<:68656=53@=<=68:55234356567839: *=>>?:3@7:57+68"96A37% 7B?;9;=8'7C6>35=5678$=C=;?9=<678 523 B6C3 7B C3=983@ #@@65678=C "6D6C ?@<3 *98+ M !" $=C=;?9=<6 93<6:5393@ B79 523 7BB38>3: 4?86:2=;C3 ?8@39 3>5678: % % 93=@ G652 3>5678 7B 8@6=8 '38=C "7@3 6: 2393;J" *( %##' $ $ 6:57.C7. ".'$