- 1 - !!"#!$% & "'"(""! ""(( )%* + ! " # $ " % ! " & ' '(" )" & & " &"" "" !!!)" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ " ) )!"!")!)' % & " *$ % & & & & & !" ")!)) & """)()!)!" & & & &+ & '! ,-. /001/2 -. 3-214 56 7,1 /00122/8792/-:/87 ;841< 197-=8 *$ %=3=7=<1,-921.97 (9,/2218>-8>7,1 ?;4>:187/84/@/<44/714!" ")!))0/..147,1<-89-0/2 18-=<-A-2;4>1/841:51</7-?/6/0;</ "" " )()!)! 7= :=4-36 7,1 ./-4 ?;4>:187 /84 18,/891 7,19=:018./7-=8" - 3 - )" &1/<47,1/<>;:187.=37,121/<8149=;8.123=< 7,1 /00122/87 /84 21/<814 9=;8.12 3=< <1.0=84187 =") =7-917=<1.0=84187=" -.4-.018.14" " <-133/97.=37,19/.1-.7,/77,1-8?;<1492/-:/87/>14 61/<. :17 @-7, /8 /99-4187 =8 )"!(")! ( /84 3-214 92/-: 017-7-=892/-:-8>9=:018./7-=8=3." ! !! !!!",17<-5;8/2 9=8.-41<-8> 187-<1 1A-41891 =8 <19=<4 ></8714 :14-9/2 1B018.1. =3 ."' !! /84 >2=5/2 9=:018./7-=8 =3 , -"1" 7=7/2 /:=;87 =3 , - @-7, -871<1.7 </71=3C" '" >><-1A14 56 7,1 ./-4 =<41< ,1 0<131<<14 /8 /001/2 /84:/-8269=87184147,/7,1@/.4=-8>/><-9;27;<1@=<D/84 1/<8-8> .")! !!! 01< :=87," &1 @/. /4:-7714 -8 7,1 ,=.0-7/2 3=< 4/6." &1 .;.7/-814 7,1 3=22=@-8> -8?;<-1. /. 3=22=@. E/91</714 @=;84 =A1< 7,1 1615<=@ 9,-8 <1>-=8 =8 <->,7.-41:1/.;<-8>179"'FF)9:")F F 9:"/91</714 @=;84 =A1< <->,7 1/< FF) 9:" /91</714 @=;84 =A1< 5/9D F)F 9:" /91</714 @=;84 =A1< <->,7 D811 'F)F 9:" 5</.-=8=A1<2137D811)F)9:/84,112)F)9:" </-8= 1A-41891 =3 -87</9</8-/2 52114 =< /2A/<-/2 3</97;<1"G" &1 3-214 - 4 - :14-9/2 5-22. 7= /8 1B7187 =3 ." !! !!!" ;7 7,1 7<-5;8/2 ></8714 =826 ."' !! /84 8= /:=;87. /<1 ></8714 ;841< =7,1<,1/4."871<1.7-.7=51></8714/77,1</71=3(C-8.71/4 =3C" "4:-771426017-7-=81<.;.7/-814.-:021-8?;<-1./848=7 1B/:-8147,14=97=<",1<13=<1 7,1H;1.7-=8=3/..1..-8>7,1 4-./5-2-76 4=1. 8=7 /<-.1" &1 @/. ,=.0-7/2-I14 3=< 4/6." =8.-41<-8>7,18/7;<1=3-8?;<-1. 01<-=4=3,=.0-7/2-I/7-=8 7,-. 9=;<7 3-84. -7 <1/.=8/521 7= ></87 /8 /:=;87 =3 ,- 3=< -8?;<-1. ,- 3=< 0/-8 /84 .;331<-8> /84 2=.. =3 /:18-7-1. ,3=<7</8.0=<7/7-=8/841B7</8=;<-.,-8> /847=@/<4.14-9/21B018.1.,#- "17-7-=81<3-214:14-9/25-22.;841<B"",17<-5;8/2 ></8714 ."' !! 7=@/<4. :14-9/2 1B018.1. /84 -7 -. 9=83-<:14"&1:->,78=7,/A1/7718414/86=7,1<@=<D/721/.7 3=< / 01<-=4 =3 :=87," ,1<13=<1 ,1 -. 187-7214 3=< , 7=@/<4.2=..=3-89=:14;<-8>2/-4;001<-=4" *",;.-8/22 9=:0=8187./@/<414567,-.9=;<7/<1 /.512=@ - 5 - &1891 7,1 /00122/8792/-:/87 -. 187-7214 3=< 7=7/2 9=:018./7-=8=3, ##-/2=8>@-7,-871<1.7/77,1 </71=3C0"/" -8.71/4=3."* !!/.></8714567,1 7<-5;8/2" " 87,1<1.;27 7,13=22=@-8>=<41<-.0/..14 -" 001/2-. -80/<7" --" ,1?;4>:187/84/@/<44/714!" ")!)) 0/..14 7,1 <-89-0/2 18-=< -A-2 ;4>1 /84 1:51< /7 -?/6/0;</ "" " )()!)! -.:=4-3-14" /<7-9;2/<. :=;87-8." 8?;<6 ! !!! 0/-8 /84 .;331<-8> /84 2=.. =3 /:18-7-1. ! !!! </8.0=<7/7-=8 1B7</8=;<-.,:187 /84/77184/879,/<>1. ! !!! 14-9/21B018.1. ' '( =.. =3 -89=:1 4;<-8> 2/-4 ;0 01<-=4 )! ./0 ## - 6 - ---" ,1 92/-:/87 -. 187-7214 7= / .;: =3 , ##- /2=8> @-7, -871<1.7 /7 C 0"/" 3<=:7,14/71=3017-7-=87-227,14/71 =3 <1/2-I/7-=8 -8.71/4 =3 ."* !! ></8714567,17<-5;8/2" -A" 1.0=84187 =")8.;</891 9=:0/86 /2<1/46 410=.-714 /@/<414 /:=;87 56 7,1 7<-5;8/2 /84 -. 4-<19714 7= 410=.-7 7,1 <1:/-8-8> /:=;87 =3 ." )(( /2=8> @-7,-871<1.7/77,1</71=3C0"/" @-7,-8 =81:=87,3<=:7,14/71=37,-.=<41<" A" 8 .;9, 410=.-7 92/-:/87 -. 01<:-7714 7= @-7,4</@ 7,1 187-<1 /:=;87 /2=8> @-7, -871<1.7/99<;14=87,1./:1" ,1- )(""!* '! -.7=" 2="!