- 1 - ! "#$%#% && '($) * !"##$% & ' ( !" !"##$% & ) #** ) *+%*%* %%%# * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) $%##%*+ %%%#$# *#! ) ) ) % ) ,% $# -./ 012345 06789 ::043 ./ ;.309 <= 4::03348> 90;08948> 6-433081.81 >-0 ?291@08> 489 906500 94>09 *+%*%* :4//09 .8 7%# * <= >-0 99.>.7843 ./>5.6> 489 0//.78/ 2910 .?4=4:254 A-050.8 >-0 ?291@08> 489 906500 94>09 $%##%*+ :4//09 .8 %%7%#$# *#! <= 99.>.7843 08.75 .B.3 2910 .?4=4:254-4/<0084;;.5@09% % 045930458096728/03;75>-04::03348>% $% -0 4::03348> A4/ 90;08948> 489 >-0 50/:78908> A4/ :34.8>.;; .8 %%7%#$# *#!% -0 50/:78908>:34.8>.;;0453.05-49;.309/2.>;75:45>.>.78489 /0:454>0:7 .787;-05/-450489/2</0C208>3=/-017> - 3 - 4@08909 :34.8> 489 /721-> ;75 9063454>.78 7; >.>30 489 :05@4808>.8?286>.78% -0 /4.9 /2.> 64@0 >7<0 9065009 489 50/:78908> :34.8>.;; 64@0 >7 <0 90634509 4/ 7A805 489 :7 .78 7; /2.> /6-092309 :57:05>.0/% -0 ;7337A.81450/2.>/6-092309:57:05>.0/D + , -./ 0 00.0 01.23 0&0 435/3.6 /3 %/+5/342- $5-40647342 # "" # **%#! E**E*$ **E# **%$* .978. .33410 7; .?4=4:254 432F /%# ****%** """ $ *#E** **% + E97E /% ****%** $ """ $ *#%* **%#$ E97E /%$ ****%** + # # *#%* *$%# 84@E 489-.843 C <.341. ./> 4143F7> /%+ ****%** *#%#+ /%# ****%** -04::03348>90;08948>6-43308109>-0/4.9906500.8 7%# * 489 /4.9 4::043 64@0 >7 <0 9./@.//09 78 @05.>/ 489 4;;.5@09 >-0 ?291@08> 489 906500 :4//09 <= >-0>5.43725>% +% 045809 6728/03 ;75 >-0 4::03348> A7239 678>089 >-4> @>% 4G@.<4. ./ A.;0 7; >-0 4::03348> 90;08948>84@03=0054/.81% -0@>%4G@.<4.17>.>0@ 7/%# >7 $ 7; /2.> /6-092309 E :57:05>.0/ 28905 - 4 - 7%H+H+ 4/ -05 /-450 ;57@ -05 ;4>-05 4/-454>-/.81% 0 /2<@.>/ >-4> /4.9 7%H+H+ 'G%%H( -4/ 87> <008 6-43308109 489 >-050;750 @>% 4G@.<4. A4/ 4</732>0 7A805 7; .>0@ 7/%# >7 $ 7; /2.> /6-092309E :57:05>.0/% -0 /4.9 @>% 4G@.<4. 9.09 78 *!%*"%*#! 489 904>- 605>.;.64>0./4>G%"%0/2<@.>/>-4>4;>05904>-7;>-0 @>% 4G@.<4. -05 -2/<489 .%0% 4::03348> 90;08948> 0054/.81 -4/ .8-05.>09 :57:05>.0/ 7; -./ A.;0 @>% 4G@.<4. 489 -0./ 4</732>0 7A8057;.>0@ 7/%# >7 $7; /2.>/6-092309E:57:05>=%0;25>-05/2<@.>/>-4>@>% 4G@.<4. 489 >-0 4::03348> 90;08948> 0054/.81 -4B0 87 .//20/ 72> 7; >-0.5 @455.410% 0 /2<@.>/ >-4> 4/ :05 06>.78 #+ 7; .892 2660//.78 6> #H " '-050.8 4;>05 50;05509 >7 4/ I% 6>J ;75 <50B.>=( @>% 4G@.<4. ./ 4</732>0 7A805 7; .>0@ 7/%# >7 $ 7; /2.> /6-092309 E :57:05>.0/ 489 4;>05 -05 904>- >-0= 90B73B0 2:78 >-0 4::03348>90;08948><0.81-05-2/<489%0/2<@.>/>-4> @>% -48954<4. 50/:78908> :34.8>.;; <0.81 @7>-05 7; @>%4G@.<4../87>08>.>309>7.8-05.>-05:57:05>.0/4;>05 >-0 904>- 7; >-0 @>% 4G@.<4.% 8 >-0/0 157289/ -0 - 5 - 6-43308109.@:21809?291@08>/:4//09<=>5.43725>489 ::0334>0725>489:54=/>74337A>-./4::043% % 4B.81 -0459 3045809 6728/03 >-./ 725> -4/ :052/09 .@:21809 ?291@08>/ 489 7>-05 @4>05.43/ :34609 78506759/% "% -0 :34.8>.;; -48954<4. ./ A.;0 7; >-0 5. 4/-54>-/.81489@>%4G@.<4.A4/>-0.59421->05% -0 4::03348> 90;08948> .%0% 0054/.81 ./ -2/<489 7; @>% 4G@.<4.4895034>.78/-.:<0>A008:45>.0/./87>9./:2>09% -0/4.9@>%4G@.<4.9.0978*!%*"%*#!304B.81<0-.89 -05 -2/<489 E0054/.81 4::03348> 90;08948>%> ./ 43/7 87> 9./:2>09 >-4> @>% 4G@.<4. 489 0054/.81 -4B0 87 .//20/% % / :05 :45>.>.78 .>0@ 7/%# >7 $ 7; /2.> /6-092309 :57:05>= A050 4337>>09 >7 /-450 7; @>% 4G@.<4. 489 >-050 ./ @2>4>.78 >7 >-4> 0;;06> .8 7% H+H+ 'G%H(% > ./43/7 87>.8 9./:2>0 >-4> 7%H+H+ -4/ 87> <008 6-43308109% -0 @>% 4G@.<4. <= B.5>207; 7%H+H+<067@04</732>07A8057;.>0@7/%#>7$7; /2.> /6-092309 :57:05>=% >0@ 7/%# >7 $ 7; /2.> - 6 - /6-092309 E :57:05>.0/ <064@0 4</732>0 :57:05>.0/ 7; @>%4G@.<4.<=B.5>207;2<06>.78#7;06>.78#+7; %6>% -0/4.9@>%4G@.<4.9.0978*!%*"%*#!% -0 904>- 605>.;.64>0 7; @>% 4G@.<4. ./ 4> G%"% -0 /4.9 @>% 4G@.<4. A4/ .892 489 78 904>- 7; ;0@430 -.892 10805435230/7;/2660//.7845017B058092890506>.78# 7;>-0%%6>%06>.78# 7;%6>5049/>-2/D ! " # " " # # # $ %& "! " " ! - 7 - "! " # " " " !! & " ! " " " !% ;>-0/4.9@>%4G@.<4.-49/78759421->05 >-0 90;08948> <0.81 -05 -2/<489 A7239 -4B0 .8-05.>>09 .>0@7/%#>7$7;/2.>/6-092309E:57:05>.0/43781A.>- /78759421->054/:052<06>.78#'4(7;06>.78# 7; >-0%6>% -0/4.9@>%4G@.<4.9.09304B.81<0-.89 -05 -2/<489 .%0% 4::03348> 90;08948> 0054/.81% 57:05>.0/A-.6-4504>.>0@7/%#>7$7;/2.>/6-092309E 450 .8-05.>09 <= @>% 4G@.<4. ;57@ -05 ;4>-05 4/-54>-/.81% 8 >-0 4</0860 7; /78 75 9421->05 7; 90604/09 E @>% 4G@.<4. :57:05>.0/ .8-05.>09 ;57@ -05 ;4>-05/-43390B73B092:78-0.5/7;>-0;4>-0548987>2:78 7>-05 -0.5/ 50;05509 .8 2< 06>.78 '#( 7; 06>.78 # 7; - 8 - %6>%8B.0A7;>-04<7B0>-04::03348>90;08948> 0054/.81-4/875.1->7;.8-05.>>-0:57:05>.0/7;-./A.;0 E @>% 4G@.<4.% 57:05>.0/ 7; @>% 4G@.<4. 78 -05 904>- A.33 90B73B0 78 -05 @7>-05 @>% -48954<4. ':34.8>.;;E50/:78908>(% H% 78/.905.81 4<7B0 4/:06>/ >-0 >5.43 725> 489 ::0334>0 725>-4B0 5.1->3=:4//09 .@:21809 ?291@08>/ 906345.81 50/:78908> :34.8>.;; -48954<4. -4/ 4</732>0 7A805.8:7 .787;.>0@7/%#>7$7;/2.>/6-092309E :57:05>.0/% -050 450 87 157289/ @490 72> >7 49@.> >-./ /06789 4::043% 0860 012345 06789 ::043 ./ #*% 8B.0A7;9./@.//437;>-04::0437%# * 970/87>/25B.B0;75678/.9054>.78% 6( '%#%) $ ./>7%#37% >DF