- 1 - !"! #$ " $$ $% &'(&)*+ & ** , ! " " " #" $ % " """ &'(') #" $ " "% " !*"" + ((* ) " " " )) ) " ((* ) " Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " ' ) )) ) " , " ((* ) " '() " " - $" - % ./ 0/121234/5 6/247 1./ 899:;/< 24 3((* ) 341./=2>/3=1./>/854/<"5249208>/42352?2>:<7/ 84<829.:52;2@0:742471./A:<7@/413=934?291234 84< 35</5 3= ;/41/49/ <81/< )) ) 934?291247 .2@ =351./3==/49/0:42;.86>/:4</5/91234;'84<()3= "84<;/41/49247.2@13:4</573527353:;2@052;34@/41 =3580/523<3=34/B/8584<1308B=24/3=;)))&84< 24</=8:>11308B=24/13:4</573;2@0>/2@052;34@/41=35 ' <8B; =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234 ' 3= "84<;/41/49247.2@13:4</573527353:;2@052;34@/41 =35 8 0/523< 3= 1C3 B/85; 08B =24/ 3= ; )))& 84< 24 - 3 - </=8:>1 13 08B =24/ 13 :4</573 ;2@0>/ 2@052;34@/41 =35 1.5//@341.;=351./3==/49/0:42;.86>/:4</5/91234() 3= "C.29.2;934=25@/<2452@248>00/8>3' ) 34 1./ =2>/ 3= 1./ >/854/< "5249208> 2;15291 84< /;;234 :<7/829.:52;;//D24713;/18;2</631.1./A:<7@/41 84<1389E:21.2@=351./8=35/;82<3==/49/; "& =2>/< 1./ =25;1 24=35@81234 5/785<247 65/8D24730/41./>39D3=.2;.3:;/34) ) <:5247 427.1 .3:5; 84< 93@@211/< 1./=1 C8; 98@/ 13 6/ 5/72;1/5/< 24?/;12781234 C8; :4</518D/4 :5247 24?/;12781234 1./ 899:;/< C8; 8005/./4</< =/C 73>< 3548@/41;C/5/5/93?/5/<=53@.2;03;;/;;234:4</51./ @8.8F85 ./ 24?/;12781234 C8; 93@0>/1/< 84< 9.857/ ;.//1 98@/ 13 6/ =2>/< =35 863?/ ;82< 3==/49/; ./ 899:;/<0>/8</<4317:2>1B84<9>82@/<136/152/< ./ 053;/9:1234 /G8@24/< ";& 13 731 @85D/< G;"& 13 "& 84< 2</412=2/< ; 13 ! 24 ;:003513=21;9341/41234./899:;/<.8;</42/<8>>1./ 24952@2481247 @81/528>; 8?82>86>/ 34 5/935< 24 .2; - 4 - ;181/@/41 :4</5 /91234 3= 5" 6:1 .8; 431 >/< 84B /?2</49/ 24 ;:00351 3= .2; </=/49/ ./ 528>3:51 8=1/5 18D247 2413 934;2</581234 8>> 1./;/ @81/528>; 34 5/935< 98@/ 13 1./ 9349>:;234 1.81 1./ 053;/9:1234 2; ;:99/;;=:>24053?2471./93@@2;;2343=1./3==/49/6B1./ 899:;/< 84< 89935<247>B 08;;/< 1./ 2@0:74/< A:<7@/41 934?29124784<;/41/49247.2@ /247 87752/?/< 6B 1./ ;8@/ 1./ 899:;/< 05/=/55/<52@248>00/8>3' ) ./25;100/>>81/ 3:51345/&8005/92812343=1./@81/528>;345/935<98@/ 13 1./ 9349>:;234 1.81 1./ 053;/9:1234 2; ;:99/;;=:> 24 053?2471./7:2>1B3=1./899:;/<6/B34<5/8;3486>/<3:61 84<1./5/2;432>>/78>21B241./A:<7@/413=934?29123484< 35</53=;/41/49/08;;/<6B1./528>3:519935<247>B 1./800/8>C8;98@/136/<2;@2;;/</24787752/?/<6B 1./;8@/1./899:;/<2;6/=35/1.2;3:51 ' /85< 52 8A/;. 3<<8@842 >/854/< 93:4;/> =351./0/121234/584<@15812"812>>/854/< 27.3:51 - 5 - 3?/54@/41 ">/8</5 =35 1./ 5/;034</41&181/ "/5:;/< 1./@81/528>;345/935< 4 ?2/C 3= 1./ 52?8> 9341/41234; :57/< 6B 1./ >/854/<93:4;/>=35631.1./08512/;1./032411.81C3:>< 852;/=35@B934;2</5812342; !"!# B84;C/5131./863?/032412;24 =351./ =3>>3C247 * 12;1./9341/412343=1./053;/9:12341.811./ 899:;/<.8<653D/30/4/<1./>39D3=1./.3:;/3="& 6B :;247 1./ 2534 53< 84< 93@@211/< 1./=1 3= A/C/>52/; 3 053?/ 1.2; 9341/41234 "& C.3 2; 1./ 24=35@8412;/G8@24/< /.8;=:>>B;:00351/<1./98;/3= 1./ 053;/9:1234 84< 8>;3 ;181/< 1.81 ./ 984 2</412=B 1./ A/C/>52/;6/>34724713.2@"& 2;1./@8.8F85C214/;; 13 ;031 @8.8F85 G"&* ";& ) 84< 85/ 1./ - 6 - 03>29/3==2928>;C.398:7.11./899:;/<34;:;02923484<./ C8; ;:6A/91/< 13 241/553781234 / C8; =3:4< 24 03;;/;;2343=1./73><3548@/41;C.29.C/5/;/2F/<:4</5 1./ ;/2F:5/ @8.8F85 G"&' "&* 2; 1./ 24</0/4</41 C214/;; 13 1./ ;/2F:5/ @8.8F85 C.3 =:>>B ;:00351/< 1./ 98;/3=1./053;/9:1234 3C/?/58=1/593@0>/12343=1./ 953;;&/G8@2481234 ./ C8; 87824 5/98>>/< 13 />2921 1.81 ./ 93:><4312</412=B1./85129>/;1.81C/5/;/2F/<:4</5G"& './41./C214/;;242128>>B ;:00351/<1./98;/3=1./ 053;/9:1234 .2; .3;12>21B 8=1/5 ./ 2; 5/98>>/< 349/ 87824 9844316/18D/42413934;2</5812348;1./5/C8;86;3>:1/>B 43 5/8;34 =35 "&* 13 </03;/ 87824;1 1./ 98;/ 3= 1./ 053;/9:1234 ( 249/ 21 2; 1./ 98;/ 3= 1./=1 6B 65/8D247 30/4 1./ >39D 3= 1./ .3:;/ 3= "& 84< 15/;08;;247 2413 1./ ;8@/ 43 /B/C214/;; 93:>< 6/ /G0/91/< ./4 1./ 24952@2481247@81/528>;2/1./73><3548@/41;6/>347247 13 "& C/5/ =3:4< 24 03;;/;;234 3= 1./ 899:;/< 1./ 899:;/< .8; 431 3==/5/< 84B /G0>8481234 84< 431 18D/4 - 7 - 84B053686>/</=/49/ <3431=24<84B5/8;3413582;/8 5/8;3486>/ <3:61 5/785<247 1./ 98;/ @8</ 3:1 6B 1./ 053;/9:1234 4</5 ;:9. 9259:@;1849/; 8@ 3= 1./ 3024234 1.81 1./ 053;/9:1234 2; ;:99/;;=:> 24 053?247 1./ 7:2>13=1./899:;/<6/B34<5/8;3486>/<3:61 ! .8?/734/1.53:7.1./2@0:74/<A:<7@/413= 934?29123484<35</53=;/41/49/08;;/<6B1./528>3:51 8; C/>> 8; 6B 1./ 25;1 00/>>81/ 3:51 31. 1./3:51; .8?/934;2;1/41>B934;2</5/< 1./ @81/528>; 345/935< 84< .8?/ 8552?/< 81 8 527.1 9349>:;234 <3 431 =24< 84B 5/8;3413241/5=/5/C21.1./;8@/9935<247>B 84;C/5 1./ 863?/ 03241 24 1./ 4/7812?/ 84< 0539//< 13 08;; 1./ =3>>3C247 .//?2;234"/1212342; -+ &$$* " 2;13>3) "