Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65524 (KAR)
ROYAL SUNDARAM GEN. INSURANCE CO LTD v. SHITAL
MFA/202136/2025 · 2025-08-18
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65524 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65524 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#! $! % &!$!! % &! ! !$$
'() *
! "
#
$%
Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
$%
'( )&#**
$ (
+
+ !, "&*& + -
)&*
!#
**
+
+
%* *& **
+
+ '
+
. . /
+
/
+
& . /
+
0123 "4 "*$ 143 5602078 1 3091: "; & 31:874;7974<";1=">01??019143198";7903 "*$ ;"2851:143198"5678@1550256"A<6978503;"2"23028
- 3 -
0123"4@02758 # 60B619904<0@1307456781??01978B619904<74< 560 1C123 ?18803 =: 27=A419 "A25 "4 560 <2"A43 ";
971=7975: 18 C099 18 DA145A@ "; B"@?048157"4 1C12303 =:
560 52719 "A25 A274< 560 B"A280 "; 12<A@045 9012403 B"A48091??01274<;"25601??099145C"A938A=@7585615;"2 51E74< "; 74B"@0 78 B"4B02403 56020 78 4" 8027"A8 378?A503 =A5 "49: B"450457"4 217803 =0;"20 5678 "A25 78 5615 560 527=A419 B"@@75503 14 022"2 74 4"5 4"57B74< 560 ;1B55615560>067B90C184"574>"9>03745601BB73045143 ;19809:7@?97B1503560>067B9060@174B"450457"4";560 B"A4809 5615 1BB73045 C18 "BBA2203 15 .$ "4 ***143560:81737E21@619"21"C18?2"B00374< 5"C1238"91?A2;2"@A4074"5"2:B90 ")# ) *,, 604 60 B1@0 "4 A40 )"91?A2 2"13 4012 1" 160= 0861@AE6?052"9?A@?40120@=A247560327>02
";56012=01274< ")')**$ 32">0678>067B9074 218614340<97<045@144023186035"8173@"5"2B:B908
- 4 -
1 208A95 60 613 8A8517403 <270>"A8 74FA2708 143 8ABBA@=035"56074FA2708 & 60 @174 B"450457"4 "; 560 B"A4809 5615 C604 560 1BB73045 C1851E04?91B0 74 560 @7347<65 15 .$ 143 4" "40 C18 ?208045 19"4< C756 560 30B01803 143 ?"97B0 61>0 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 560 >067B90 4 "2302 5" ?2">0B180560B917@14561>0?2"3AB035603"BA@045";
560 B0257;703 B"?: "; ;7285 74;"2@157"4 143 198" 560 B0257;703B"?:";;741920?"2518
G
G143
G#143 198" 560 8?"5 ?14B641@1
G& B0257;703 B"?: "; 74DA085 @161H12 ?14B6141@1 18
G$ B0257;703 B"?: "; ?"85 @"250@ 20?"25 18
G!
143 198" B0257;703 B"?: "; @"5"2 >067B9081BB7304520?"2518
G $ 60 B"A4809 C"A93 >060@0459: B"45043 5615 74B73045C1851E04?91B074560@7347<65143?"97B0 61>0 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 560 B180 4 "2302 5" ?2">0 560 8173 B"450457"4 5615 >067B90 C18 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 560 748A214B0 B"@?14: 0GB0?5 0G1@7474< 560 "49: 14
";;7B719 C754088 4"5674< 78 ?91B03 "4 20B"23 4B0 560
- 5 -
748A214B0 B"@?14: 5""E 560 8?0B7;7B 30;0480 5615 >067B90 C18 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 =A2304 9708 "4 560 748A214B0 B"@?14:5"?2">056081@0A43020B57"4**";
>7304B0 B5 60 ?028"4 C6" 188025 @A85 ?2">0 560 81@0 C604 560 B917@1458 ?2"3AB03 199 3"BA@0458 =0;"20 560 "A25 74B9A374< 74>0857<157"4 ?1?028 143 198" 560 B612<086005 6051E74<";30;04805615>067B90C18;19809:7@?97B150378 4"5 04"A<6 143 560 81@0 618 5" =0 ?2">03 =: 560 748A214B0B"@?14:14361>74<?02A803560@15027190>04 74>0857<157"4
";;7B02 618 4"5 =004 8A@@"403 143 0G1@7403 =0;"20 560 "A25
GB0?5 560 81: "; 560 B"450457"45615560>067B90C18;19809:7@?97B15034"5674< 78?91B03"420B"236048AB6=074<560B180560>02: B"450457"4";560B"A48091??01274<;"25601??0991455615 >067B90 C18 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 B144"5 =0 1BB0?503 74 560 1=804B0";14:@15027196020@A85=01B"<0450>7304B0 =0;"20 560 "A25 5615 >067B90 C18 ;19809: 7@?97B1503 143 560 ;1B5 5615 B612<0 86005 C18 ;7903 143 74>0857<157"4 78
- 6 -
B"@?90503 143 B612<0 86005 78 198" @12E03 18
G# =0;"2056052719"A251434"5B619904<03560B612<086005 , 60 "5602 B"450457"4 "; 560 B"A4809 1??01274< ;"2560748A214B0B"@?14:5615560"C402C18?91B030G) ?125014360C18B"99A303C756560B917@1454"23025" ?2">0 560 ;1B5A@ "; B"99A87"4 198" 4"5674< 78 ?91B03 "4 20B"23143@0209:=0B1A80";560748A203C18?91B030G) ?150 143 560 81@0 B144"5 =0 <2"A43 5" B"@08 5" 1 B"4B9A87"4 5615 60 C18 B"99A303 C756 560 B917@145 =: 321C74<13>028074;0204B0 ! 1>74< B"48730203 560 8A=@7887"4 "; 560 B"A4809 C0 3" 4"5 ;743 14: <2"A43 5" 13@75 143 198" C604 56020 78 4" 378?A50 C756 20<123 5" DA145A@ ";
B"@?048157"4 78 B"4B02403 5615 27<659: 51E04 560 74B"@0 143198"13303;A5A20?2"8?0B58143198"51E74<4"50";199 60138 560 FA85 143 2018"41=90 B"@?048157"4 78 1C12303 6"A<6 B"450435615 DA145A@ 78 198" "4 67<602 8730143 B"A48093A274<560B"A280";13@7887"4B150<"27B199:851503 5615 C756 20<123 5" DA145A@ 78 B"4B02403 4" 022"2 78
- 7 -
B"@@75503 =: 560 527=A419 04B0 C604 8AB6 =074< 560 B180DA0857"4";788A74<5604"57B05"208?"4304583"084I5 12780 "480DA0459: 560 3091: "; & 31:8 78 198" 4"5 ?2"?029:0G?91740304B0C03"4"5;74314:<2"A435" 13@75 143 198" B"43"40 560 3091: "480DA0459: 560 1??01978378@78803
!+, '$!!) &
!+, ') &
785 ".9 ".% .+