Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65522 (KAR)
SHIVANAND v. RAJENDRA KUMAR KATHARI
CCC/200122/2025 · 2025-09-04
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65522 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65522 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
" $#% "
$#% #
""
& ' ( )#"" *
)#""
""
+,
""
""
(
! "
! # ! ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
!! $
%
! &! ! %! ' (
! (
! ) (
! (
! *
! ! (+ ! ! ('*"
(
*(
'','%' ,''') ! (
*(
! #! - 3 -
! ! ! % ! ! &(! ! %&
! "
(
! '
(
) (
! (
(
! ( ! (-)+
('"
(
( (.,
- 4 -
- ' ( ( (
/! ,''')
'',' ( '
0#
(
1
(
% !' %&
! "
(
! '
) (
! (
(
! ( ! (-)+
('"
- 5 -
(
( (.,
- ' ( ( (
/! ,''')
'**., ( '
0#
(
1
+,(
(
! (
! ' (
! (
! )
! ! "
% !* &! %
'
- 6 -
! (+
('"
(
*(
'**.,%' ,''') ! (
(
! "
% !* %&
' (
! (
! - 7 -
) (
! (
! *
! ! (+
! ('*" (
*(
'**.,%' ,''') ! (
(
(
! (
! ' (
! (
! )
! ! "
- 8 -
! # ! ! ! ! %
! &! ! %! '
! (+
('"
(
*(
'','%' ,''') ! (
! (
)''
( 2
(
/
( & & /! 3! (
- 9 -
)%# & 3!
"
45 6'%''789 6'''%'' 7:5 ;<=59 ;6: 868#>6?@=<78>5 6; A45 6:95: @7BB59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 <8 6'','%' >6885>A59 G<A4 6'**.,%' 97A59 ,''') ;6: ><H<= 9<B6C59<58>5 H<95 885IF:5# 789 A45 7@@57=B <5
6'',%''*
6'').%''*
6''*%''* 789 6''*'%''* 7:5 ;<=59 CD:5B@68958A 6BA6*>47==58E<8EA45H5:DB7?56:95:
JF5BA<68<8E A45 6:95: 6; @6BB5BB<68 <8 A45 5H58A 6; 86 7>JF<B<A<68@:6>559<8EB7:5A7K58 ' 45 ;7>AF7= ?7A:<I 6; A45 >7B5 6; A45 >6?@=7<878AB C5;6:5 A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 G4<=5 B55K<8EA45:5=<5;6;G:<A6;?7897?FB789;6:79<:5>A<68 A6 A45 :5B@68958AB A6 <8<A<7A5 A45 7>JF<B<A<68 @:6>559<8EB <8 :5B@5>A 6; A45 @5A<A<685:B @:6@5:A<5B G4<>4 7:5 ?6:5 ;F==D95B>:<C59<8A45B7<9G:<A@5A<A<68BA47AA45@5A<A<685:
- 10 -
<8 6'**.,%'G7BA456G85:<8@6BB5BB<68789 58L6D?58A 6; A45 @:6@5:AD C57:<8E 6'%# '%" 45 >6?@=7<878A%@5A<A<685: >=7<?B <8 A45 G:<A @5A<A<68 A47A 45 479 >68BA:F>A59 A4:55 ;=66: CF<=9<8E E:6F89MAG6B5>689;=66:B"CD<8H5BA<8E=7K4B6;:F@55B 789 B5H5:7= CFB<85BB 5BA7C=<B4?58AB G45:5<8 :F88<8E A45 B7?5 <8 A45 B7<9 CF<=9<8E 789 7=B6 A45 CF<=9<8E ;F:8<B459 G<A4?695:87?58<A<5B5=5>A:68<>E79E5AB789;<IAF:5BB6 7B A6 @:6H<95 @:6@5: 789 >6?@5A<A<H5 B5:H<>5B A6 A45 >FBA6?5:B ) 45 >7B5 6; >6?@=7<878A%@5A<A<685: <8
6'','%' <B A47A @5A<A<685: G7B 7 6#6@5:7A<H5 6><5AD :5E<BA5:59 F895: A45 7:87A7K7 6#@5:7A<H5 6><5A<5B >A .. 58E7E59 <8 A45 CFB<85BB 6; C78K<8E 47H<8E=68EBA789<8E:5@FA7A<687894FE5AF:86H5:AG7B >7A5:<8E A6 A45 ;<878><7= 789 >:59<A :5JF<:5?58AB 6; A45 @56@=5 6; !<L7@F: 789 B7?5 G7B B<AF7A59 <8 A45 @:6@5:AD C57:<8E 6,)%%'45@5A<A<685:47B>68BA:F>A59 A4:55 ;=66: CF<=9<8E :6F89 M AG6 ;=66:B" CD <8H5BA<8E
- 11 -
4FE5 >:6:5B 6; :F@55B 45 CF<=9<8E G7B ;F:8<B459 G<A4 ?695:87?58<A<5B5=5>A:68<>E79E5AB789;<IAF:5BB67BA6 @:6H<95@:6@5:789>6?@5A<A<H5B5:H<>5BA6A45>FBA6?5:B * 8 C6A4 A45 @5A<A<68B <A <B >68A58959 A47A :5B@68958A
6*#6:@6:7A<68 G<A4 78 <8A58A<68 A6 <?@=5?58AA457BA5:@=786;A45D57:'A6G<958A45 ?7<8:679 747A?77894<:679"A6785IA58A6;;55A )?5A5:B"G<A44<E447895985BB95?6=<B459A45=7896; 79L6<8<8E=7896G85:B789<==5E7==DA4:57A5859A695?6=<B4 A45@:6@5:A<5BC5=68E<8EA6A45@5A<A<685:B58>5B6FE4A ;6:A45:5=<5;6;?7897?FB9<:5>A<8EA45:5B@68958AB86A A6 H58AF:5 78D <==5E7= 7>AB G<A46FA 9F5 @:6>5BB 6; =7G ;A5: 95?6=<A<68 A45 @6BB5BB<68 47B C558 A7K58 ;6: A45 ;6:?7A<686;:679G4<>447BC558>6?@=5A59
A <B 7=B6 >68A58959 A47A :5B@68958A 6* 479 <BBF59 86A<>5 A6 A45 @5A<A<685:B >7==<8E F@68 A45? A6 5I@:5BB A45<: G<==<8E85BB A6 7>>5@A A45 >6?@58B7A<68 6;
B, A6 78 5IA58A 6; '.
BJF7:5 ;55A <8
6'**.,%' 789 B**'%# A6 78 5IA58A 6;
- 12 -
))BJF7:5;55A<8 6'','%'6;A45@:6@5:A<5B C5=68E<8E A6 A45 @5A<A<685:B G4<>4 G5:5 :5JF<:59 ;6: G<958<8EA45:679
A<B>68A58959A47A@5A<A<685:B>66@5:7A59G<A4 :5B@68958A 6* 7B A45 @:6@5:A<5B G5:5 :5JF<:59 ;6:
G<958<8E 6; A45 :679 789 A45 B7?5 G7B ;6: 7 @FC=<> @F:@6B5 789 7E:559 ;6: A45 @:6@5:A<5B A6 C5 A7K58 ;6:
G<958<8E 6; A45 :679 CFA A45D 47H5 7E:559 A6 A45 B7?5 BFCL5>AA6A45>689<A<68A47ABF<A7C=5>6?@58B7A<68G6F=9 C5@7<9<8>68B6878>5G<A4A45?7:K5A:7A5@:5H7=58A7B68 A45 97A5 6; A7K<8E#F@ @6BB5BB<68 6; A45 @:6@5:A<5B C5=68E<8EA6A45@5A<A<685:B58>5A457?6F8AG4<>4G7B 6;;5:59 CD :5B@68958A 6* G7B :5>5<H59 F895: @:6A5BA G<A46FA@:5LF9<>5A6A45:<E4AB6;A45@5A<A<685:B , A<B7=B6>68A58959A47AB6?579L6<8<8E6G85:B 789 =789 =6B5:B 7@@:67>459 A4<B 6F:A <8
6'%' >6885>A59 G<A4 B5H5:7= 6A45: G:<A @5A<A<68B 789 A45 B7<9 @5A<A<68B G5:5 9<B@6B59 6;; 789 7
- 13 -
>6?@:6?<B5 G7B 7::<H59 CD A45 @7:A<5B 7G7:9<8E 4<E45: >6?@58B7A<68
A<B7=B6>68A58959CDA45@5A<A<685:B/>6F8B5= A47A<8H<5G6;A456A45: 6'',,%'>6885>A59 G<A46A45:G:<A@5A<A<68BG4<>4>7?5A6C59<B@6B596;;68 ,'') 789 B6FE4A ;6: B<?<=7: :5=<5; 45 >6F8B5= 7@@57:<8E ;6: :5B@68958AB <8 A45 G:<A @5A<A<68 <5 :5B@68958A 6*#6:@6:7A<68G6F=9>68A589A47AA456:95:
@7BB59 <8 6'',,%' >6885>A59 G<A4 6A45:
@5A<A<68B 47H5 C558 A7K58 F@ <8 78 7@@57= G4<>4 <B @589<8E79LF9<>7A<68C5;6:5A45<H<B<68!58>4G6F=97=B6 >68A589 A47A A45 @5A<A<685:B 45:5<8 G6F=9 86A ;7== G<A4<8 A45B7?5>7A5E6:D6;A45=789=6B5:B . 45=57:859 <8E=5F9E547H<8EA7K5886A56;
A45 >68A58A<68B 6; A45 :5B@5>A<H5 @7:A<5B 789 7=B6 >68B<95:<8E A45 ?7A5:<7= 68 :5>6:9 A47A A45 @:6@5:A<5B G5:5 B<?<=7:=D B<AF7A59 789 A45 B7?5 G5:5 7=B6 ;6: G<958<8E6;A45:6797897=B6A7K5886A56;A45;7>AA47A G<A46FA<8<A<7A<8E78D@:6>5BB6;7>JF<B<A<68A45B7?5G7B
- 14 -
9685 789 458>5 A45 @5A<A<685:B 47H5 A6 C5 >6?@58B7A59 68A45C7B<B6;A4586:?BB5A6FACDA45:5B@68958ABG<== 47H5 A6 C5 95><959 CD A45 :5B@68958AB 789 7=B6 78 6CB5:H7A<68?795A47AA45B7?5>7886AC5>68A:7:DA6A45 B5AA=59=7G<8;6:>5 7H<8E >68B<95:59 A45 E:6F89B G4<>4 47H5 C558 F:E59 <8 A45 @5A<A<68B 789 >68B<95:<8E A45 ?7A5:<7= 68:5>6:9 786CB5:H7A<6847B C558 ?795 A47A 79?<AA59=D A45@:6@5:A<5B 6; A45 @5A<A<685:B 7:5 A7K58 7G7D G<A46FA 78D 7>JF<B<A<68 @:6>559<8EB 789 >6?@58B7A<68 A46FE4 @7<9 <A G7B 9<B@FA59 CD A45 @5A<A<685:B 58>5 7==6G59 A45@5A<A<68BG<A4A45;6==6G<8E6CB5:H7A<68&#
! "
! " #$%
& '(#
" "
)
*
- 15 -
(#
"
+ *
" , -
-
*
$. #./ *
01#2#.34#$) * ! -
"
* + *
"
! " !
"#$% - * " (# 5 6G A45 >6F8B5= 7@@57:<8E ;6: A45 >6?@=7<878AB <8 A45 >68A5?@A @5A<A<68B G4<=5 <8H6K<8E - 16 - >68A5?@A LF:<B9<>A<68 47B >68A58959 A47A <8 B@<A5 6; :5@:5B58A7A<68B 97A59 ''* '''* C5<8E E<H587B@5:885IF:5B#!789BFCB5JF58AA6@7BB<8E6; 6:95: CD =57:859 <8E=5 !58>4 7A 885IF:5# A45 :5B@68958AB 47H5 86A >6?@=<59 G<A4 A45 B7?5 6G <A <B >68A58959 A47A <8 B@<A5 6; :5@:5B58A7A<68B 7:5 E<H58 789 7=B6 G458 A45 7@@:6@:<7A5 6:95:B ;6: <BBF78>5 6; 7>JF<B<A<68B @:6>559<8EB <B 6:95:59 :5B@68958AB ;7<=59 A6 >6?@=D A45 B7?5 5H58 7;A5: =7@B5 6; B5H5:7= ?68A4B 85<A45:7>JF<B<A<68@:6>559<8EB<8<A<7A5986:@:6@5:A<5B7:5 :5AF:859 A6 @5A<A<685:B 58>5 <8H6K59 >68A5?@A LF:<B9<>A<68 ' 45 7@@5==78AB <8 G:<A 7@@57=B <5 :5B@68958A 6* 7B G5== 7B :5B@68958A 6B A6 ) <8 A45 7C6H5 G:<A 7@@57=BJF5BA<6859A456:95:6;A45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5 6:95: 97A59 ,''') 68 A45 E:6F89 A47A A45 =57:859 <8E=5F9E5>6??<AA59785::6:<8@7BB<8EBF>4786:95: 789C:6FE4AA6A4586A<>56;A4<B6F:AA45@:7D5:B6FE4A <8A45G:<A@5A<A<68BG4<>4<B7=B6B5A#6FA<8A45E:6F89B6; - 17 - A45 7@@57=B G6F=9 >68A589 A47A <8 7CB58>5 6; 7 @=579<8E 7BG5==7B7:5=<5;;6:@6BB5BB<686;A45@:6@5:A<5B=57:859 <8E=5F9E56FE4A86AA647H59<:5>A59A457@@5==78ABA6 47896H5: A45 @6BB5BB<68 A6 :5B@68958A 6 789 6CB5:H7A<68A47A6:@6:7A<687BG5==7B A7A56H5:8?58A ;6:><C=D 58A5:59 A45 @:6@5:AD 6; :5B@68958A 6 A46FE4 A45 :5B@68958A 6 E:<5H78>5 <B <8 :5E7:9 A6 95A5:?<87A<68 6; >6?@58B7A<68 789 A47A 6CB5:H7A<68 <B 5::6856FB789<A>7==B;6:<8A5:;5:58>5 ) A 7=B6 >68A58959 A47A <; =789 <B :595=<H5:59 7B 9<:5>A59 CD A45 6F:A <A G<== 7;;5>A A45 @FC=<> >6??F8<>7A<68 789 >6?@58B7A<68 6;;5:59 A6 :5B@68958A 6G7B86A7>>5@A5958>5<A:5JF<:5B<8A5:;5:58>56; A4<B 6F:A A6 B5A 7B<95 A45 6:95: @7BB59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 !6A4 6:@6:7A<68 7B G5== 7B :5B@68958A 6B A6 ) 47H5 ;<=59 7;6:5B7<9 7@@57=B >68A589<8E A45 H5:DB7?5E:6F89B * 45 >6F8B5= 7@@57:<8E ;6: :5B@68958AB <8 >68A5?@A @5A<A<68B 47H5 ;<=59 >6F8A5: 7;;<97H<A C5;6:5 A45 - 18 - 6F:A 789 >68A589 A47A 9F5 A6 A45 A458 6=9 789 87::6G :679B 6; <L7D7@F: <AD A45 :5B<958AB G5:5 ;7><8E =6A 6; 47:9B4<@ 789 <8>68H58<58>5 G4<>4 @:6?6A59 A45 >68>5:859 7FA46:<A<5B A6 F895:A7K5 A45 G6:K 6; G<958<8E A45?7<85I<BA<8E:679B7897=B6>68A58959<8@7:7E:7@4 6*6;A457;;<97H<AA47A>6?@58B7A<68G7B@7<97897=B6 @:69F>59A4596>F?58AB7A885IF:5B#A6* 99<A<687=7;;<97H<A6;:5B@68958A 6'7=B6;<=59 C5;6:5 A4<B 6F:A 7=68E G<A4 A4:55>6??F8<>7A<68B G4<>4 7:597A59)''*''789'''789B6 7=B6685?6:57;;<97H<A<B;<=59CDA45:<8><@7= 5>:5A7:DA6 A456H5:8?58A5H58F55@7:A?58A97A59'.'' :5E7:9<8E <8<A<7A<8E 7 @:6@5: 789 =5E7= 7>JF<B<A<68 7B @5: A45 @:6H<B<68B F895: <E4A A6 (7<: 6?@58B7A<68 789 :78B@7:58>D <8 =789 >JF<B<A<68 547C<=<A7A<68 789 5B5AA=5?58A >A ') 789 >6@D 6; A45 =5AA5: 97A59 ''' H<95 885IF:5# 789 7=B6 =5AA5: 6; >6??F8<>7A<68 CD 5@FAD 6??<BB<685: H<95 885IF:5# '78986A<;<>7A<687B@5:885IF:5#) - 19 - A <B >68A58959 A47A <8 @F:BF78>5 6; A45 86A<;<>7A<68 5@FAD 6??<BB<685: @7BB59 78 6:95: 68 ''' ;6: <8<A<7A<8E A45 7>JF<B<A<68 @:6>559<8EB 7B @5:885IF:5#*7897=B6<8A457;;<97H<A<A<BBA7A597C6FA <8<A<7A<686;7>A<687E7<8BAA455::<8E6;;<><7=B:5=D<8EF@68 885IF:5B#A6, , 45 >6F8B5= 7@@57:<8E ;6: A45 >68A5?@A @:6>559<8EB <8 4<B 7:EF?58AB G6F=9 H545?58A=D >68A589 A47AA45>6?@=<78>5<B68=D@7:A<7=>6?@=<78>578986AA45 >6?@=<78>5 7B 6:95:59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 <8 58A<:5AD
7H<8E >68B<95:59 A45 >6?@=<78>5 7;;<97H<A 7B G5== 7B A45 E:6F89B G4<>4 47H5 C558 F:E59 <8 A45 >68A5?@A@5A<A<68B7BG5==7BA45G:<A7@@57=BA45@6<8AB A47AG6F=97:<B5;6:>68B<95:7A<686;A4<B6F:A7:5& <" 45A45:A45>6?@=7<878AB47H5?795#6FA7 E:6F89 A6 ;:7?5 >47:E5B 7E7<8BA :5B@68958AB%7>>FB59N <<" 45A45: A45 7@@5==78AB 47H5 ?795#6FA E:6F89B A6 B5A#7B<95 A45 6:95: 6; A45 - 20 - =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 @7BB59 <8 G:<A @5A<A<68BN <<<" 47A6:95:N "-./0 1.2 .
7H<8E >68B<95:59 A45 6:95: @7BB59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 789 7=B6 A45 E:6F89B G4<>4 47H5 C558F:E59<8A45>68A5?@A@5A<A<68BA45E:<5H78>56;A45 >6?@=7<878AB <B A47A A45 6:95: @7BB59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5F9E5<B9<B6C5D59+>68A5?@ALF:<B9<>A<6847BA6C5 <8H6K59 ' 4<B 6F:A 7=:579D 5IA:7>A59 A45 6:95: @7BB59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 789 47H<8E >68B<95:59 A45 9<:5>A<68 <BBF59 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 <8 9<:5>A<68 6 <<" 6; 6@5:7A<H5 @6:A<68 A47A :5B@68958A 6' <B 7A =<C5:ADA67>JF<:5A45@:6@5:A<5B6;A45@5A<A<685:B<8A5:?B 6;A45<E4AA6(7<:6?@58B7A<68789:78B@7:58>D789 >JF<B<A<68547C<=<A7A<687895B5AA=5?58A>A')CD <BBF<8E BF<A7C=5 85>5BB7:D 86A<;<>7A<68 G<A4<8 7 @5:<69 6; B<IAD "97DB;:6?A4597A56;:5>5<@A6;7>6@D6;A45 - 21 - 6:95: ;7<=<8E G4<>4 A45 :5B@68958A 6* B47== 47896H5: A45@6BB5BB<686;A45@:6@5:A<5B6;A45@5A<A<685:BG<A4<87 @5:<69 6; B<IAD " 97DB A45:57;A5: <; 86A 7=:579D 7>JF<:59 ' 7H<8E >68B<95:59 A45 7;6:5B7<9 9<:5>A<68 A45 :5B@68958A 6'47B86A<BBF5985>5BB7:D86A<;<>7A<68789 458>5 >68A5?@A @:6>559<8EB <B <8<A<7A59 789 86G A45 ?7A5:<7= @=7>59 68 :5>6:9 C5;6:5 A4<B 6F:A A47A A45 :<8><@7= 5>:5A7:D G46 7@@57:59 A4:6FE4 H<956 >68;5:58>5479F895:A7K58A6<BBF5A4586A<;<>7A<68<8A45 @:5H<6FB 97A5 789 <8 A5:?B 6; A45 B7<9 F895:A7K<8E 86G <BBF59A45 86A<;<>7A<68 68 ''' 58>5 A45 B5>689 9<:5>A<68G7B>6?@=<596G5H5:G<A4:5E7:9A6>6?@=5A5 A45 @:6>5BB <B >68>5:859 45 BFC?<AB A47A <A <B 9<;;<>F=A A6 >6?@=5A5A45@:6>5BBG<A4<8B<IAD97DB789B6FE4A;F:A45: A<?5 '' 45 ?7<8 E:6F89 F:E59 <8 A45 G:<A 7@@57=B <B 7=B6A47AA459<:5>A<68E<H58CDA45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5<; A45 B7?5 <B 86A >6?@=<59 G<A4<8 B<IAD 97DB :5B@68958A - 22 - 6* B47== 4789 6H5: A45 @6BB5BB<68 6; A45 @:6@5:A<5B 6; A45@5A<A<685:BG<A4<87@5:<696;97DBA45:57;A5:45 :<8><@7= 5>:5A7:D 7=B6 G6F=9 BFC?<A A47A <; 799<A<687= A<?5<BE:78A59B7?5>6F=9C5>6?@=<59B<8>5A45D47H5 A6 ;6==6G A45 @:6>59F:5 6 7=B6 A45 >6F8B5= ;6: A45 >6?@=7<8AB BFC?<AB A47A A45D 7:5 :579D A6 5H58 A7K5 A45 86A<>5789866CL5>A<68B<8H<5G>6?@=<78>56;<BBF78>56; 86A<;<>7A<68 ') 6G5H5:K55@<8E<8?<89A45H5:D@:6H<B6G5 ;5=A A47A <A <B 7@@:6@:<7A5 A6 E:78A 4F89:59 " 97DB A<?5<8BA5796;B<IAD "97DB789A45:<8><@7= 5>:5A7:D 7=B6 7E:559 ;6: A45 B7?5 A6 96 A45 B7?5 G<A4<8 A<?5 458 BF>4 C5<8E A45 >7B5 A45 JF5BA<68 6; :5B@68958A 6*4789<8E6H5:A45@6BB5BB<686;A45@:6@5:A<5B6;A45 @5A<A<685:B G<A4<8 7 @5:<69 6; B<IAD " 97DB A45:57;A5: 965B83A 7:<B5 <8 H<5G 6; 86A<;<>7A<68 789 458>5 A45 :5=<5; B6FE4A <8 A45 G:<A 7@@57=B 7=B6 965B83A BF:H<H5 ;6: >68B<95:7A<68 789 A45 B7?5 <8 A45 5H58A 6; 868# - 23 - >6?@=<78>56;9<:5>A<68 6 <<"6;A45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5 6:95: '* 45 H5:D >68A58A<68 F:E59 <8 A45 7@@57=B A47A A45:5 >7886A C578 6:95: 6;4789<8E 6H5:A45@6BB5BB<68 6; A45@:6@5:A<5BB<8>5 A45 B7?5 <B FB59 ;6: G<958<8E6; A45 :679 A <B 7=B6 86A <8 9<B@FA5 A47A A45 CF<=9<8E G7B 95?6=<B459 789 A45 :679 G7B G<95859 789 >6?@=7<878AB 7=B67>>5@A59A45B7?5 ' 7H<8E>68B<95:59A459<:5>A<68 6 <H"A47A7B :5E7:9B A45 97?7E5 >6BA A6 A45 @5A<A<685:B <8 =<5F 6; A45 F8=7G;F= 95?6=<A<68 789 A7K<8E 7G7D A45 @:6@5:A<5B 6; @5A<A<685:B=<C5:ADG7BE<H58A6A45@5A<A<685:BA6;<=5A45 @5A<A<68>=7<?<8E97?7E5B789458>5JF5BA<686;H<6=7A<68 6;9<:5>A<68 6*965B83A7:<B5 ' 45 9<:5>A<68 6 H" <B 7=B6 H5:D >=57: A47A <8 A455H58A6;:5B@68958A 6'>466B<8EA67>JF<:5A45=789 7>JF<B<A<68 B47== C5 >6?@=5A59 789 85>5BB7:D
>6?@58B7A<68A6C5@7<9A6A45@5A<A<685:BF895:A45<E4A - 24 - A6(7<: 6?@58B7A<68789 :78B@7:58>D 789 >JF<B<A<68 547C<=<A7A<68 789 5B5AA=5?58A >A ') CD A7K<8E A45 H7=F56;A45=7897B68A4597A568G4<>4A4586A<;<>7A<68 <B <BBF59 A45 86A<;<>7A<68 B47== C5 <BBF59 86A =7A5: A478 B<IAD "97DB;:6?A4597A56;:5>5<@A6;>5:A<;<59>6@D6; A456:95:547H57=:579D@6<8A596FAA47AA45B7?5G7B 86A >6?@=<59 789 458>5 >68A5?@A @:6>559<8EB 7:5 <8<A<7A59 ', 6G 86A<;<>7A<68 <B 7=:579D <BBF59 789 7=B6 <8 95A7<=9<B>FBB597C6FAA45@5:<696;B<IAD "97DBG4<>4 <B 5IA58959 A6 685 4F89:59 " 97DB 789 458>5 >68A<8F<8E6;>68A5?@A@:6>559<8EB<8:5B@5>A6;9<:5>A<68 6B <<"789 <H"7=B6965B83A7:<B5 ' 6GA45>6F8B5=7@@57:<8E;6:A45>6?@=7<878AB C:6FE4A A6 86A<>5 6; A4<B 6F:A A45 9<:5>A<68 6) A47A <::5B@5>A<H5 6; A45 6@A<68 >46B58 A45 A7A5 B47== ?7K5 @7D?58A 6; 97?7E5B A6G7:9B A45 FB5 6; @:6@5:A<5B ;:6? A45 A<?5 6; @6BB5BB<68 A47A G7B F87FA46:<B59=D A7K58 A6 A4597A568G4<>4A45@6BB5BB<68<B4789597AB%#@5:
- 25 -
BJF7:5 ;55A @5: ?68A4 C5<8E O 68 A45 H7=F5 6; A45 @:6@5:A<5B7B7E:559A6C5@7<9F895:A45>6?@:6?<B5<8
6',.%''*789>6885>A59?7AA5:B '. A<B86A<89<B@FA5A47A57:=<5:>6?@:6?<B5G7B 58A5:59<8 6',.%''*789A4<B6F:A7=B6A7K58 86A5 6; 57:=<5: 9<B@6B<8E 6;; A45 @5A<A<68B CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 F9E5 <8 >6885>A59 ?7AA5:B G<A4 :5E7:9 A6 A45 B<?<=7: JF5BA<68B <8H6=H59 <8 A45 ?7AA5: 7B A45 :5=<5; <B B6FE4A <8 A45 G:<A @5A<A<68B 789 <A <B 7=B6 86A <8 9<B@FA5 A47A 78 7?6F8A G7B 95@6B<A59 @7:A<>F=7:=D <8
6'','%'787?6F8A6;B**'%#789<8 @7:7E:7@4 6* 6; A45 7;;<97H<A ;<=59 CD A45 :5B@68958A
6' 7=B6 :5<A5:7A59 A45 B7?5 <5 A6 78 5IA58A 6; )) BJF7:5 ;55A <8 6'','%' 6; A45 @:6@5:A<5B C5=68E<8EA6A45@5A<A<685:
) 458 BF>4 95@6B<A G7B ?795 <8 ' 789 <8 H<5G6;9<:5>A<68CDA45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5A45;7>AA47A A45 97?7E5B G5:5 >7FB59 A6G7:9B A45 FB5 6; A45 @:6@5:A<5B ;:6?
A45 A<?5 6; @6BB5BB<68 A47A G7B
- 26 -
F87FA46:<B59=DA7K58A6A4597A568G4<>4A45@6BB5BB<68 G7B4789596H5:<B7=B686A<89<B@FA5 ) 458 BF>4 C5<8E A45 >7B5 A45 7?6F8A G4<>4 G7B7=:579D95@6B<A59A6A45AF856;B**'%#A6C5 79LFBA59<8H<5G6;9<:5>A<68B6;A45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5 <89<:5>A<68 6 <<<"789BF:@=FB7?6F8A>6F=9C579LFBA59 A6G7:9BA457G7:9A6C5@7BB59<8H<5G6;A4586A<;<>7A<68 <BBF59CDA45:5B@68958AB >68B5JF58A F@68A459<:5>A<68
6B'789*6;=57:859 <8E=5F9E5 )' 458BF>4?7A5:<7=G5:57=B6A7K5886A56;789 7B 6CB5:H59 <8 A45 G:<A @5A<A<68B JF5BA<68 6; >68A<8F<8E A45>68A5?@A@:6>559<8EB965B83A7:<B5<8H<5G6;95A7<=59 9<B>FBB<68?7957C6H57897==A459<:5>A<68B7:5?795CD <BBF<8E 86A<;<>7A<68 7B G5== 7B A45 79LFBA?58A 7B 9<:5>A59 7C6H5 58>5 G5 47H5 E<H58 >68B><6FB 7@@=<>7A<68 6;
?<89 :5E7:9<8E >68A5?@A 7B G5== 7B G:<A 7@@57=B 789 <8 H<5G 6; >6?@=<78>5 6; A45 9<:5>A<68 E<H58 CD A45 =57:859 <8E=5 LF9E5 JF5BA<68 6; ;:7?<8E 6; >47:E5B 7E7<8BA A45
- 27 -
:5B@68958AB965B83A7:<B545:5;6:5>68A5?@A@:6>559<8E 47BA6C59:6@@59 )) 67=B6A45E:6F89BG4<>447H5C558F:E59<8 A45 G:<A 7@@57=B @7:A<>F=7:=D G<A4 :5E7:9 A6 A7K<8E 6;
@6BB5BB<68 <B >68>5:859 7=:579D 86A<;<>7A<68 <B <BBF59 <8 H<5G6;A459<:5>A<68 6'6;A45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5A45 JF5BA<686;4789<8E6H5:A45@6BB5BB<687=B6965B83A7:<B5 B<8>5 A45 @:6@5:AD G4<>4 G7B FB59 CD A7K<8E A45 @6BB5BB<68 A46FE4 F87FA46:<B59=D CFA ;6: A45 @FC=<> @F:@6B5<5;6:G<958<8EA45:679789>68B5JF58A=DG:<A 7@@57=B 7:5 7=B6 965B 86A BF:H<H5 ;6: >68B<95:7A<68 B<8>5 A4586A<;<>7A<687=:579D<BBF5978968=D:5?7<8<8E@:6>5BB A6 C5 9685 <B @7BB<8E 6; 7G7:9 789 458>5 JF5BA<68 6; 95=<H5:<8EA45@6BB5BB<68965B86A7:<B57BF895:A7K58CD A45:5B@68958AB )* <A4 A45 7C6H5 6CB5:H7A<68B A45 >68A5?@A @:6>559<8EB7:59:6@@59789G:<A7@@57=B7:59<B@6B596;
7B A45 JF5BA<68 6; 4789<8E 6H5: A45 @6BB5BB<68 7B 6CB5:H59CDA45=57:859 <8E=5F9E5965B83A7:<B5<8H<5G
- 28 -
6; BFCB5JF58A 95H5=6@?58AB 6; <BBF78>5 6; A45 86A<;<>7A<68 ) 45 :5B@68958AB 47H5 @=7>59 68 :5>6:9 A45 7>A<68<8<A<7A597E7<8BA5::<8E6;;<><7=B7B9<:5>A5958>5 9<:5>A59A6BFC?<AA45:5@6:A:5E7:9<8EA45:5BF=A6;7>A<68 A7K58 7E7<8BA A45 5::<8E 6;;<><7=B C5;6:5 A4<B 6F:A G<A4<8 A4:55?68A4B 8 H<5G 6; 9<B@6B7=
6'',%''*
6'').%''* 789
6''*%''*
6'%''*<8A45:5B@5>A<H57@@57=B9686ABF:H<H5;6: >68B<95:7A<68
2( &" ' %
2( &#' %
<BA 6& = 6& &