Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65507 (KAR)
SHAKUNTALA AND ORS v. THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER
MFA/201527/2017 · 2025-10-15
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65507 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65507 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!" #$ !"
#%
$%
& #
%'' %
$# $ (%
!)*
+
"
!)*
+
"
Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
' " ,)) $
$ %
'#*
-#! $ ./ -')#!$/ #%
$%
$# %' %
# %* %
'
# % %
*
# % %
#
0# %.' % . # %.) % #
- 3 -
( $ (
% %)* +
"
!)* +
"
' " ,)) $
$%! ! *#*
-#! $ ./ -)#! $/
$ % %
- 4 -
%
"
12-2344235-136272289:52;<8;2=2>?:@8' " @9@?@=21:>52->?,)) 12=2:839?2==292==2;?@3-A?12 >?B" 7C ?12 >53:D38?#- 72:8E 3EE=:262; 7C ?12 F<;ED28? 38; ;2>=22 ;3?2; 43--2; 7C ?12 ;;:?:@835 38;;;:?:@835:-?=:>?<;E2:;3=-:??:8E3?135G:
9@= -1@=? A?12 =:7<835B" :8 @-'#* 38;
*#* =2-42>?:625C :8>2 ?12 >135528E2 :- ?@ ?12 >@DD@8F<;ED28?7@?1?12344235-3=2>5<772;?@E2?12= 123=;38;>@DD@8F<;ED28?:-72:8E43--2;
12 7=:29 93>?- E:6:8E =:-2 ?@ ?12 9:5:8E @9 ?12 344235-3=2?13?@8**?12:8F<=2;>53:D38?38; ;2>23-2;3;38383F:H2=24=@>22;:8E9=@D:53-4<=?@ 3573=E3 @8 3 D@?@=>C>52 723=:8E =2E:-?=3?:@8 @! '#!., 38; -3:; 3;38 383F: H3- 4:55:@8 =:;2= 38; ?12>53:D38?H3-=:;:8E?12D@?@=>C>52H:?1;<2>3<?:@8:8 38@=D35-422;@84=@42=-:;2@9?12=@3;?37@<?,* 1@<=- H128 ?12C >3D2 823= 2H 2?=@5 <D4 @8 :;3=! - 5 -
135G: =@3; 3? ?13? ?:D2 @82
7<- 723=:8E =2E:-?=3?:@8@
!')#!*72:8E;=:6287C:?-;=:62=H:?1 1:E1-422;38;:83=3-138;82E5:E28?D3882=>3D29=@D 135G: -:;2 38; ?12 -3:; ;=:62= 5@-? >@8?=@5 @62= ?12 7<- 38;;3-12;?@?12D@?@=>C>52-3=2-<5?@9?1239@=2-3:;
3>>:;28? =:;2= 838; -<-?3:82; E=:26@<- :8F<=:2- 12 72>3D2;:-3752;D3838;5@-?9<?<=223=8:8E>343>:?C38;
3;38 -<-?3:82; E=:26@<- :8F<=:2- 38; -<>><D72; ?@ ?12 :8F<=:2- ' 12>53:D38?-9:52;42?:?:@8-<8;2=2>?:@8.. @9?12>?-22G:8E>@D428-3?:@8?H3-4523;2;?13??12C -428? 1<E2 3D@<8? ?@H3=;- D2;:>35 2I428-2- >@862C38>29<82=352?>?H3-9<=?12=4523;2;?13??12 3>>:;28? @>><==2; 4<=25C @8 3>>@<8? @9 ?12 =3-1 38; 82E5:E28?;=:6:8E@9?12@9928;:8E621:>527C:?-;=:62= * 8 -2=6:>2 @9 8@?:>2 ?12 =2-4@8;28? 34423=2;
?1=@<E1 >@<8-25 38; 9:52; H=:??28 -?3?2D28? :8 H1:>1 ?12 362=D28?- D3;2 :8 ?12 42?:?:@8- H2=2 ;28:2; 12 3E2 36@>3?:@8 38; :8>@D2 @9 ?12 ;2>23-2; 38; ?12 >53:D38? - 6 -
38;?12D2;:>352I428-2-3=2;28:2;?H3-4523;2;?13? ?12J<38?<D@9>@D428-3?:@8>53:D2;7C?12>53:D38?-:- 1:E1 38; 2I@=7:?38? ? H3- 9<=?12= 4523;2; ?13? ?12 3>>:;28?H3-;<2?@?12=3-138;82E5:E28?;=:6:8E@9?12 =2-4@8;28?B- 621:>52
723=:8E =2E:-?=3?:@8 @
! ')#!* :86@562; :8 3>>:;28? 12 >53:D38?- :8 @=;2= ?@ >53:D D3I:D<D >@D428-3?:@81362 935-25C;2>@=3?2; ?12 42?:?:@8-H:?1@<?38C52E354=@@912=2:-8@82E5:E28>2 @8?1243=?@9?12;=:62=@9?127<-:8>3<-:8E3>>:;28?38;
?12 3>>:;28? ?@@G 453>2 ;<2 ?@ ?12 82E5:E28>2 @9 @8 ?12 43=? @9 ?12 =:;2= @9 ?12 D@?@=>C>52 38; ?12=27C ?12 =2-4@8;28?:-8@?5:3752?@43C?12>@D428-3?:@828>2 12-@<E1?9@=;:-D:--35@9?1242?:?:@8-
8?1273-:-@9?124523;:8E-@9?1243=?:2-?12 =:7<835 9=3D2; ?12 :--<2- 38; ?12=239?2= =2>@=;2; ?12 26:;28>2 8 @'#* ?12 :8F<=2; >53:D38? H3- 2I3D:82; 1:D-259 3- $! 38; @>?@= ! 3D35 H3- 2I3D:82; 3- $! 38; E@? D3=G2; ;@><D28?- 83D25C I-, ?@ I 8 @*#* H:92 @9
- 7 -
;2>23-2; 12=-259H3- 2I3D:82; 3-$ 38; E@? D3=G2;
;@><D28?- 83D25C I ?@ I) 8 721359 @9 ?12 =2-4@8;28?
@82 H:?82-- :2 ;=:62= @9 ?12
H3- 2I3D:82; 3- $! 38; 8@ ;@><D28?- E@? D3=G2; 12 =:7<8357C?12:D4<E82;F<;ED28?125;?13? ?123>>:;28??@@G 453>2@8 3>>@<8? @9 =3-1 38;82E5:E28? ;=:6:8E@9?12@9928;:8E621:>527C:?-;=:62=3-3=2-<5?@9 H1:>1 ?12 >53:D38? -<-?3:82; :8F<=:2- 38; ?12 ;23?1 @9 3;38383F:12=:7<8359<=?12=125;?13??12>53:D38?- 3=2 28?:?52; ?@ 3 >@D428-3?:@8 @9 -#! :8 @'#* 38; -#! :8 @*#* 35@8EH:?1:8?2=2-?3??12=3?2@9./4338;;:=2>?2;?12 =2-4@8;28?!@=4@=3?:@8 ?@ ;24@-:? ?12 >@D428-3?:@8 3D@<8? 35@8E H:?1 :8?2=2-? 2:8E 3EE=:262; 7C ?12 F<;ED28?38;3H3=;?12-2344235-136272289:52;
! "# $! % . 12523=82;>@<8-2534423=:8E9@=?12>53:D38? >@8?28;2;?13??123>>:;28?@>><==2;;<2?@?12=3-138;
- 8 -
82E5:E28? ;=:6:8E @9 ?12 ;=:62= @9 ?12 @9928;:8E 621:>52 H12=2:8?12>53:D38?13--<-?3:82;E=:26@<-:8F<=:2- 3" 2>@8;5C12H3-38:843?:28?9@=342=:@;@9* ;3C-;<2?@?123>>:;28?2:-<83752?@;@1:-;3C?@;3C 3>?:6:?:2- 2 13- 35-@ -<992=2; ;:-37:5:?C 38; 43:8 ?1=@<E1@<? 1:- 5:92 12 >@D428-3?:@8 3H3=;2; 7C ?12 =:7<8359@=43:838;-<992=:8E5@--@93D28:?:2-38;@?12= :8>:;28?352I428-2-3553=2@85@H2=-:;2 7" 3-?5C1213->@8?28;2;?13??12>53:D38?13- 4=@;<>2; D2;:>35 7:55 3D@<8?:8E ?@ -..#! 1@H262=?12=:7<83513-3H3=;2;@85C-#!<8;2= ?12123;@943:838;-<992=:8E:-@85@H2=-:;228>212 -@<E1?9@=28138>2D28?@9>@D428-3?:@8
2= >@8?=3 523=82; >@<8-25 34423=:8E 9@= 8-<=38>2 @D438C 13- >@8?28;2; ?13? ?12 :8F<=:2- -<992=2;7C?12>53:D38?:-D:8@=:883?<=238;?12=2:-8@ ;:-37:5:?C 12=29@=2 ?12 =:7<835 13- 8@? 3H3=;2; 38C >@D428-3?:@8 <8;2= ?12 123; @9 5@-- @9 9<?<=2 23=8:8E
- 9 -
@8-:;2=:8E?1:-3-42>?D2;:>35=2>@=;-4=@;<>2;7C?12 >53:D38? ?12 @62=355 >@D428-3?:@8 3H3=;2; 7C ?12 =:7<835 :- F<-? 38; =23-@83752 28>2 12 -@<E1? 9@= ;:-D:--35@9?12344235 ) 23=; ?12 523=82; >@<8-25 34423=:8E 9@= ?12 43=?:2- 38; 42=<-2; ?12 F<;ED28? 38; 3H3=; @9 ?12 =:7<835 , ? :- 8@? :8 ;:-4<?2 ?13? >53:D38? 13- -<992=2; E=:26@<-:8F<=:2-:83=@3;?=399:>3>>:;28?13-@>><==2;@8 **;<2?@=3-138;82E5:E28?;=:6:8E@9;=:62=@9 7<- 723=:8E =2E:-?=3?:@8 @
')* <2 ?@ -3:; 3>>:;28?>53:D38?13--<992=2;?129@55@H:8E:8F<=:2-K
!"#$
12 @>?@= L
3D35 H1@ ?=23?2; ?12 >53:D38? H3- 2I3D:82; 3- $ 12 >53:D38? 4=@;<>2; ;:-37:5:?C >2=?:9:>3?2 H1:>1 :- D3=G2; 3- I 38; ;:->13=E2
- 10 -
-<DD3=C 3- I- ?@ ' @8-:;2=:8E ?12 ;:-37:5:?C >2=?:9:>3?2D2;:>35=2>@=;-38;>53:D38?H3-3;D:??2;?@ 1@-4:?353-:843?:28?9@=342=:@;@9*;3C-H23=2@9?12 @4:8:@8 ?13? ?12 >@D428-3?:@8 3H3=;2; 7C ?12 =:7<835 ?@H3=;- 43:8 38; -<992=:8E 13- ?@ 72 28138>2; 9=@D -#! ?@ -#! 38; ?@H3=;- >@862C38>2- 38; 8@<=:-1D28? 13- ?@ 72 28138>2; 9=@D -#! ?@ -'#! 12 =:7<835 13- 8@? E=38?2; 38C >@D428-3?:@8 ?@H3=;- 5@-- @9 3D28:?:2- 12=29@=2 >@8-:;2=:8E?1283?<=2@9:8F<=:2--<992=2;7C?12>53:D38? :? :- F<-? 38; 4=@42= ?@ 3H3=; 3 -<D @9 -#! ?@H3=;- 5@-- @9 3D28:?:2- @8-:;2=:8E ?12 D2;:>35 7:55- 4=@;<>2; 7C ?12 :8F<=2; >53:D38? 3- I- ?@ ?12 ?@?353D@<8?--428?9@=D2;:>352I428-2-:--..#!
28>2?12>@D428-3?:@83H3=;2;7C?12=:7<835?@H3=;- D2;:>352I428-2-13-?@7228138>2;9=@D-#!?@ -..#!38;?12:8F<=2;>53:D38?:-35-@28?:?52;9@= >@D428-3?:@8 ?@H3=;- A5@-- @9 :8>@D2 ;<=:8E ?12 53:; <4
- 11 -
42=:@;B9@=342=:@;@9-:ID@8?1-3??12=3?2@9-# 28>2?12-3D2>@D2-?@-*#! #!I."
>>@=;:8E5C ?12 >53:D38? :- 28?:?52; ?@ ?12 9@55@H:8E>@D428-3?:@8%
@D428-3?:@8<8;2= ;:992=28?23;- -3H3=;2;7C ?12=:7<835 -" -3H3=;2;
7C?1:-@<=? -" 3:838;-<992=:8E-
2;:>352I428-2-
.. @@;8@<=:-1D28? >@862C38>2
' @--@9:8>@D2;<=:8E 53:;<442=:@; ! * @--@93D28:?:2- ! &'( ))! *))! 8?12=2-<5??129@55@H:8E@=;2=:-43--2;%
3" 12344235:-'((+,-. /'0& 7" 12F<;ED28?@9?1253:D-=:7<835:-D@;:9:2; >" 12 >53:D38? :- 28?:?52; ?@ 3 ?@?35 >@D428-3?:@8 @9 1*))! 3- 3E3:8-? 3 -<D @9 -#! 3H3=;2;7C?12=:7<835
- 12 -
;" 12 8-<=38>2 @D438C :- ;:=2>?2; ?@ ;24@-:? ?12 >@D428-3?:@8 3D@<8? 35@8E H:?1 :8?2=2-? & ./ 43 9=@D ?12 ;3?2 @9 9:5:8E @9 ?12 >53:D 42?:?:@8?:55?12;3?2@9=235:M3?:@8H:?1:8342=:@;@9 -:I H22G- 9=@D ?12 ;3?2 @9 =2>2:4? @9 >@4C @9 ?1:- F<;ED28? 2" 12;24@-:?38;=2523-2@93D@<8?-135572D3;2:8 ?2=D-@9?123H3=;@9?12=:7<835
! "#
%
=:37<2?3E<;;3523=82;>@<8-259@=?12 >53:D38?-13-=3:-2;?129@55@H:8E>@8?28?:@8-% 3" :=-?5C ?12 >53:D38?- >53:D ?13? ?12 ;2>23-2; 3;38383F:H3-3E2;37@<?'C23=-3??12?:D2@9?12 3>>:;28? 38; 12 H3- 23=8:8E -#! 42= D@8?1 7C ;@:8E 7<-:82-- @9
:=383 38; E282=35 -?@=2 12 =:7<835 13- 3--2--2; 8@?:@835 :8>@D2 @9 ?12 ;2>23-2; 3- -.#!42=D@8?1H1:>1:-@8?125@H2=-:;2
- 13 -
7" 2>@8;5C 3- 42= ?12 53H 53:; ;@H8 7C ?12 @8B752 <4=2D2 @<=? :8 ?12 >3-2 @9
:8>3-2?12;2>23-2;H3- -259!2D45@C2;@=@839:I2;-353=C383;;:?:@8@9*/@9 ?12 2-?375:-12; :8>@D2 ?@H3=;- A9<?<=2 4=@-42>?-B -1@<5; 72?12H3==38?H12=2?12;2>23-2;H3-725@H?123E2@9 *C23=-12-3D2-135572>@8-:;2=2; >" 1:=;5C :8 6:2H @9 ?12 53H 53:; ;@H8 7C ?12 @8B752 <4=2D2 @<=? :8 ?12 >3-2 @9 !"#! $%"&! $'
%#()"!*'+ ", "+ "!,) *-./0
?12 D<5?:45:2=3445:>37529@=?123E2E=@<4@9.?@'C23=-:- AB <? ?12 =:7<835 13- H=@8E5C >@8-:;2=2; ?12 D<5?:45:2=3-AB ;" @<=?1 3- 42= ?12 F<;ED28? @9 ?12 @8B752 <4=2D2 @<=? :8 ?12 >3-2 @9 1 1
2$
3 4 3 5 23>1 @9 ?12 >53:D38?- 3=2 28?:?52; 9@=
- 14 -
>@D428-3?:@8 @9 -*#! <8;2= ?12 123; @9 A5@-- @9 5@62 38; 3992>?:@8 38; >@8-@=?:<DB 28>2 12 -@<E1? 9@= 28138>2D28?@9>@D428-3?:@8 2" 3-?5C ?12=2 3=2 -:I >53:D38?- 8 6:2H @9 ?12 F<;ED28?@9@8B752<4=2D2@<=?:8?12>3-2@9!"#! $%"&! -<4=3" ?12 =:7<835 13- ;2;<>?2; #'=; :8-?23; @9;2;<>?:8E#*?1
8 ?12 @?12= 138;
D? 38E22?3 13;=3-12??C 523=82; >@<8-25 34423=:8E 9@= ?12 =2-4@8;28?!@=4@=3?:@8 13- =3:-2; ?12 9@55@H:8E >@<8?2= >@8?28?:@8-% 3" :=-?5C 2628 ?1@<E1 ?12 >53:D38?- >53:D ?13?
?12 ;2>23-2; H3- 23=8:8E -#! 42= D@8?1 7C =<88:8E
:=383 38; 282=35 ?@=2 ?12 -3D2 :- 8@? 2-?375:-12; 7C ?12 >53:D38?- 7C 4=@;<>:8E ;@><D28?- 12=29@=2?12=:7<83513-=:E1?5C>@8-:;2=2;?128@?:@835 :8>@D2@9?12;2>23-2;3--.#!42=D@8?1
- 15 -
7" 2>@8;5C -:8>2 ?12 >53:D38?- 1362 8@? 2-?375:-12;?12:8>@D2@9?12;2>23-2;?12=:7<83513- =:E1?5C8@?E=38?2;9<?<=24=@-42>?- >" 3-?5C>@8-:;2=:8E?123E238;36@>3?:@8@9?12 ;2>23-2; ?12 @62=355 >@D428-3?:@8 3H3=;2; 7C ?12 =:7<835 :- F<-? 38; =23-@83752 28>2 -12 -@<E1? 9@= ;:-D:--35@9?12344235 ' 23=; ?12 523=82; >@<8-25 9@= ?12 43=?:2- 38; 42=<-2;?12F<;ED28?38;3H3=;@9?12=:7<835 * ? :- 8@? :8 ;:-4<?2 ?13? 3;38 383F: ;:2; :8 ?12 =@3; ?=399:> 3>>:;28? @>><==2; @8 ** ;<2 ?@ =3-1 38; 82E5:E28? ;=:6:8E @9 ;=:62= @9 ?12 7<- 723=:8E =2E:-?=3?:@8@
!')#*
12 >53:D38?- >53:D ?13? ?12 ;2>23-2; H3- 23=8:8E -#! 42= D@8?1 7C =<88:8E 7<-:82-- @9 G:=38338;E282=35-?@=27<??12C13628@?4=@;<>2;38C ;@><D28?-?@4=@62?12-3D28?1237-28>2@94=@@9@9 :8>@D2 ?12 8@?:@835 :8>@D2 13- ?@ 72 3--2--2; - 42=
- 16 -
?12 E<:;25:82- :--<2; 7C ?12
3=83?3G3 ?3?2 2E35 2=6:>2-<?1@=:?C9@=?123>>:;28??3G28453>2:8?12C23= * 8@?:@835 :8>@D2 @9 ?12 ;2>23-2; 13- ?@ 72 >@8-:;2=2; 3? -#! 42= D@8?1 @ ?12 39@=2-3:;
:8>@D2 */ 13- ?@ 72 3;;2; @8 3>>@<8? @9 9<?<=2 4=@-42>?-:86:2H@9?1253H53:;;@H87C?12@8-?:?<?:@8 28>1@9?12<4=2D2@<=?:86 7 -<4=3" 1<-?12D@8?15C:8>@D2>@D2-?@-#! . :8>2?12=23=2-:I;2428;38?-:86:2H@9?12 F<;ED28?@9@8B752<4=2D2@<=?:8?12>3-2@9!"#! $%"&! -<4=3" :? :- 344=@4=:3?2 ?@ ;2;<>? #*?1 @9 ?12 :8>@D2 @9 ?12 ;2>23-2; ?@H3=;- 42=-@835 2I428-2- 38;
=2D3:8:8E 3D@<8? 13- ?@ 72 ?3G28 3- 1:- >@8?=:7<?:@8 ?@ ?1293D:5C12;2>23-2;H3-3E2;37@<?'C23=-3??12 ?:D2 @9 ?12 3>>:;28? 38; D<5?:45:2= 3445:>3752 ?@ 1:- 3E2 E=@<4 :- AB >>@=;:8E5C A5@-- @9 ;2428;28>CB 13- 7228 =23--2--2;3--..#! -III'#*"
- 17 -
8 3;;:?:@8 ?12 >53:D38?- 3=2 28?:?52; 9@= >@D428-3?:@8@9-#!@83>>@<8?@9A5@--@92-?3?2B 38; >@D428-3?:@8 @9 -#! @8 3>>@<8? @9 A9<82=35 2I428-2-B ) 8 6:2H @9 ?12 53H 53:; ;@H8 7C ?12 @8B752 <4=2D2 @<=? :8 ?12 >3-2 @9 61 1 7 -<4=3">53:D38?@H:92@9?12;2>23-2; :-28?:?52;9@=>@D428-3?:@8@9-*#!<8;2=?12123;
@9 A5@-- @9 -4@<-35 >@8-@=?:<DB 53:D38? @- ' 38; * >1:5;=28@9?12;2>23-2;3=228?:?52;9@=>@D428-3?:@8@9 -*#! 23>1 <8;2= ?12 123; @9 A5@-- @9 43=28?35 >@8-@=?:<DB 53:D38? @- 38; . 43=28?- @9 ?12 ;2>23-2; 3=2 28?:?52; 9@= >@D428-3?:@8 @9 -*#! 23>1<8;2=?12123;@9A5@--@99:5:35>@8-@=?:<DB , 1<-?12>53:D38?-3=228?:?52;?@?129@55@H:8E >@D428-3?:@8%
- 18 -
2/, 1'&. 3 -,0 -.,0, & ,'-1 23 &. "1% 23 &. "1% @--@9 ;2428;28>C -#! -..#! <82=35 2I428-2- -#! -#! @--@92-?3?2 -#! -#! @--@9-4@<-35 >@8-@=?:<D -#! -*#!
@--@93=28?35 >@8-@=?:<D -!!#! -#! @--@9:5:35 >@8-@=?:<D -!!#! -)#! &'( 1))! 1*)
)! 8?12=2-<5??129@55@H:8E@=;2=:-43--2;%
3" 12344235:-!## 8%9)*+!", 7" 12 F<;ED28? @9 ?12 53:D- =:7<835 :- D@;:9:2; >" 12 >53:D38?- 3=2 28?:?52; ?@ 3 ?@?35 >@D428-3?:@8 @9 -).#! 3- 3E3:8-? -#! 3H3=;2; 7C ?12 =:7<835 38;
- 19 -
35@8E H:?1 :8?2=2-? 3? ?12 =3?2 @9 ./ 42= 388<D ;" 12 =2-4@8;28?!@=4@=3?:@8 :- ;:=2>?2; ?@ ;24@-:? ?12 >@D428-3?:@8 3D@<8? 35@8E H:?1 :8?2=2-?3?./439=@D?12;3?2@99:5:8E@9?12 >53:D42?:?:@8?:55?12;3?2@9=235:M3?:@8H:?1:8 342=:@;@9-:IH22G-9=@D?12;3?2@9=2>2:4?@9 >@4C@9?1:-F<;ED28? 2" 12 344@=?:@8D28? ;24@-:? 38; =2523-2 @9 >@D428-3?:@8 -1355 72 3- 42= ?12 @=;2= @9 ?12 =:7<835
4-! "54%
4-! "6#6%
:-?@%5@%.*%