- 1 - !" #!$ #!$ $% &' ! " # ! $ $ # ! % & ' Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ## (## ) # $ ) #!" () *) ) #!" % + * $ $ $ !( ! , -. ) ) / # / # # - 3 - &) / # ' 012 314 5414167 12 8195: ;< 405 4=45 6>537?574 @0=9957A17A 405 63:53 :=45: ! B=225: ;< 405 $=37=4=C=4=45:?171243=41>531;D7=9=4$=9=;D3=A1&863 20634 -405 31;D7=9.' 17 BB91@=4167 6!( E0535;<405=BB91@=41678195:;<405=BB91@=7440535170=2 ;557=996E5: 63 405 2=C5 68 @67>57157@5 405 B=34152 =35 3585335:46=2B53405133=7C17A;5863540531;D7=9 05 @=25 68 405 =BB91@=74 12 40=4 05 E=2 =BB61745: =2 3=:5 22124=74 =2453 17 1A0 @0669 4036DA0:135@435@3D14?574=7:B6245:466>537?5741A0 @0669 =1@0;=9 $=9=;D3=A1 :12431@4 D317A 405 <5=3 745312431@43=72853683=:5 1A0@0669 5=@0532 466C B9=@5 =7: 05 E=2 43=7285335: 836? $=9=;D3=A11>121674659=A=>11>12167=2B530126B4167 0535=8453 352B67:574 6 122D5: = 64181@=4167 :=45: - 4 - BD;912017A B36>12167=9 A3=:=4167 9124 68 405 6>537?574 1A0 @0669 3=:5 5=@0532 a2 67 F 67 405 ;=212 68 ?5314 E01@0 0=2 ;557 BD;91205: 17 405 6881@1=9 E5;2145 67 05 25716314< 68 405 =BB91@=74 E=2 =926 ?5741675: =7: 6;G5@41672 E535 @=995: 836? 405 =AA315>5: B532672 8453 @6721:5317A 405 2=?5 352B67:574 6 0=2 122D5: 817=9 25716314< 9124 67 ?5314 ;=212 67 F 7 405 817=9 25716314< 9124 405 =BB91@=74 E=2 :3=241@=99< BD205: :6E7 =7:E=2206E7;596E012GD71632 517A=AA315>5:;<405 817=925716314<9124405=BB91@=748195:0126;G5@41672s4=417A 40=4217@505E=2=BB61745:17405<5=3FF"=7:B6245: 46 $=9=;D3=A1 1>12167 =7: 40535=8453 05 E=2 43=7285335: 46 59=A=>1 1>12167 =7: B6245: =4 6>537?574 1A0 @0669 7A=9=A1 17:=A1 1G=BD3 =@@63:17A 46 405 6>537?574 13@D9=3 :=45: F! 405 25716314< 68 5=@0532E06E53543=7285335:46=7640531>12167;58635 F! 0=2 46 ;5 @6721:535: 836? 405 :=45 68 =BB6174?574 7 405 25716314< 9124 :=45: F 405 - 5 - =BB91@=740=2;557BD205::6E7=7:E=2206E7;596E012 GD71632052=?512@6743=3<464051>1953>1@52D952 517A =AA315>5: ;< 405 2=?5 05 0=2 2D;?1445: 012 35B352574=416746352B67:574 62 46863@6721:53=4167 17@5 405 35B352574=4167 2D;?1445: ;< 405 =BB91@=74 0=2 764 ;557 @6721:535: 05 =BB36=@05: 405 31;D7=9 @0=9957A17A 405 817=9 25716314< 9124 05 31;D7=9 ;< 63:53 :=45:!0=2=996E5:405=BB91@=4167=7::135@45: 352B67:574 62 46 46 @6721:53 405 35B352574=4167 68 405 =BB91@=74 517A =AA315>5: ;< 405 2=?5 405 4=45 6>537?57412;5863540126D34 " 5=375: ::14167=9 6>537?574 :>6@=45 =BB5=317A 863 405 352B67:5744=45 @67457:5: 40=4 405 =BB91@=74 E=2 =BB61745: 17 405 <5=3 FF" =7: B6245: 46 $=9=;D3=A11>12167701235HD52405E=243=7285335:46 59=A=>11>1216767 =7:B6245:=46>41A0 @0669 7A=9=A117:=A11G=BD3:12431@4217@505E=2 43=7285335:836?6751>1216746640531>12167050=246 ;5 B9=@5: ;596E 17 405 25716314< 9124 68 59=A=>1 1>12167 - 6 - 2 B53 D95 68 405 $=37=4=C= 6>537?574 53>=742 5716314< D952 F+ &863 20634 -405 D952.' 25716314< 9124 0=2;557B35B=35:6743=3<46405D95240531;D7=90=2 B=225:40563:53 5=3: 405 95=375: ::14167=9 6>537?574 :>6@=45 863 405 B5414167532 =7: B53D25: 405 E314 B=B532 =967AE140=775ID352 41276417:12BD4540=4=BB91@=74E=2=BB61745: =222124=74=24533=:5 1A0@06695=@0534036DA0 :135@435@3D14?574=7:B6245:466>537?5741A0@0669 =1@0;=9 $=9=;D3=A1 :12431@4 17 FF" 4 12 =926 764 17 :12BD45 40=4 67 405 35HD524 68 405 =BB91@=74 05 E=2 43=7285335: 46 59=A=>1 1>12167 17 405 <5=3 05 6>537?574 ;< 64181@=4167 :=45: F! 0=2 ;18D3@=45: 40355 :1>121672 863 6>537?574 5=@0532 17 :D@=4167 5B=34?574 7=?59< 6??12216753 863 D;91@ 7243D@4167 =7A=9635 6??12216753 863 D;91@ 7243D@4167 D9;=3A= =7: ::14167=9 6??12216753 863 D;91@ 7243D@4167 0=3E=: 58635 122D=7@5 68 - 7 - 64181@=4167:=45:F!863=9940522124=74=24532 E63C17A D7:53 405 6??12216753 863 D;91@ 7243D@4167 =7A=9635217A9525716314<91240=2;557?=174=175:D95 B36>126B36>1:5:40=4E053540543=7285312?=:5=4405 35HD524 68 405 6881@53 05 20=99 ;5 B9=@5: 17 405 25716314< 9124 68 405 @9=22 63 A3=:5 68 253>1@5 46 E01@0 05 12 43=7285335: ;596E =99 405 6881@532 ;6375 67 40=4 @9=22 63 A3=:568253>1@56763;58635405:=456840543=72853 + 7 405 B352574 @=25 E057 405 =BB91@=74 0=2 ;557 43=7285335: 40535 12 679< 675 5=: 68 405 5B=34?574 15 6??12216753 68 D;91@ 7243D@4167 =7A=9635 As 40535 E535 76 :18853574 5=:2 68 5B=34?574 217A95 4=45 5>59 5716314< 9124 0=2 ;557 ?=174=175: 79< =8453 122D=7@5 68 64181@=4167 :=45: F! 40355 :18853574 5=:2 68 5B=34?574 0=>5 ;557?=:517@540543=7285368405=BB91@=74E=2;58635 F! B36>126 46 D95 68 405 D952 12 764 =BB91@=;9546405@=25670=7: - 8 - ! 6721:5317A 4012 =2B5@4 68 405 ?=4453 405 31;D7=90=231A049<=996E5:405=BB91@=416705358635E5 817: 76 53363 63 1995A=914< 17 405 63:53 B=225: ;< 405 31;D7=905E314B541416712:5>61:68?5314@@63:17A9< 405E314B541416712 () &' $ () & $% ' $ 124 6)9 6)