- 1 - !"! #$"%$% &' ! "#$ % &! '' ( ) ) !"### ) ! ' !!"### $ ) ! & ( Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' !!"### ) ' !! !"### * + "#$ )*)) + "#$ , )*)) + !"# * + ! " % &! ' )- ! ) )( ) ,) ) ) ) . ! #### ! $ ' * $ *) ) !) ) + ) ) - 3 - ) /!0 1!' 2345623472589:7;26<94=>2?2=@=@97246234725 <94 42;?97527= 9; =9 375 6234725 89:7;26 <94 42;?97527=9;=9 >2?2=@=@9724A3;3??9@7=2597B3; 43<=;27@7=>29<<@829<42;?97527=99753@6CA3D2 E3;2; >2 89?C 9< =>2 ;3@5 3??9@7=F27= 62==24 @; 3= 3772G:42<=2489F?62=@979<=27C234;=>2?2=@=@9724 >3; D@H27 42?42;27=3=@97 97 #BB =9 42D:634@;2 >@; ;24H@82 2;?97527=; >3H2 79= =3I27 37C 38=@97 97 42D:634@J3=@97 9< ;24H@82 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724 >2 ?2=@=@9724 3697D A@=> 9=>24 2F?69C22; <@625 9#, BBB A 9# =9 # BBB ?43C@7D <94 5@428=@97; =9 42;?97527=; =9 897;@524 =>2@4 83;2 <94 42D:634@J3=@97 9< ;24H@82375?3CF27=9<?3C;8362 - 4 - $ >29945@73=2!278>9<=>@;9:4=>3;3669A25 4@= 2=@=@97 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724 375 9=>24; EC 94524 53=25 ### 5@428=@7D 42;?97527= 9; =9 =>242@7 =9 897;@524 83;2 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724 375 9=>24; <94 42D:634@J3=@97 9< =>2@4 ;24H@82 @7 42;?28=@H2 83542 @< =>2C ;3=@;<CK:36@<@83=@97?42;84@E25<94=>2;3F2>2?2=@=@9724 375 9=>24 <@<=227 ?24;97; A>9 A242 ?2=@=@9724; @7 4@= 2=@=@97;A24279=42D:634@J2597=>2D49:75=>3==>242342 79H3837=?9;=;:75249452453=25####&3772G:42 )(:=9<;3@5<@<=227?24;97;=>2972?24;97A>9@;3= 6973F26C 4@35F373E>32969D@;=3??4938>25 =>@; 9:4= @7 9# ## ?43C@7D =9 K:3;> =>2 ;3@59452453=25####&3772G:42)(>2;3@54@= 2=@=@97 83F2 =9 E2 3669A25 EC 94524 53=25 ## 375 42;?97527=; =>242@7 342 5@428=25 =9 42D:634@J2 =>2 ;24H@829<=>2;3@5 4@35F373E>3A@=>@79:=246@F@=9< <9:4 F97=>; 375 @< =>2 H38378C @; 79= 3H3@63E62 ;:?247:F2434C ?9;= ;>366 E2 8423=25 =9 3889FF953=2 =9 >@F - 5 - >2?2=@=@9724>3;;9:D>=;@F@634?43C24@7=>2 ?42;27=4@=?2=@=@97;22I@7DK:3;>@7D9<=>29452453=25 #### &3772G:42 ")( =9 897;@524 >@; 42?42;27=3=@97 53=25 #B## &3772G:42( 375 53=25 ##$ &3772G:42( 375 42D:634@J2 >@; ;24H@82 375 D437= 366 897;2K:27=@36E272<@=;3;42D:6342F?69C22 >2 ?2=@=@9724 A3; A94I@7D 3; 43<=; 27 97 53@6CA3D2E3;@;375>2A94I25F942=>37=27C234;>2 ?2=@=@9724 A>9 A3; A94I@7D 3; 43<=; 27 97 53@6C A3D2 E3;@;>3;89F?62=25>@; 375375>2@;K:36@<@25=9 E23??9@7=253;43<=;27>2;24H@829<=>2?2=@=@9724 A3; 79= 42D:634@J25 3; =>242 @; 79 H3837= ?9;= >2 9 945@73=2 !278> 9< =>@; 9:4= @7 =>2 83;2 9< >3;>2653;:7524- 1 In W.P.No.80442/2010 decided on 12.04.2011 - 6 - !"# $ % $ & ' &( )*+#,-+ & .&'/ 0 / 1 2" 3 / - 7 - $ 4 5 >2 ?2=@=@9724 =>242@7 73F26C 4@ 35F373E>3 >3; 36;9 E227 @;;:25 A@=> 27594;2F27= ;=3=@7D =>3= =>242 @; 79 H3837= ?9;= 28945; 36;9 42H236 =>3==>2?2=@=@9724@;3= 69$@7=>26@;=9<53@6CA3D2; @7 3772G:42) >2 ?2=@=@9724 A>9 @; ;@F@6346C ?63825 =9 =>3= 9< 4@ 35F373E>3 >2 @; 36;9 27=@=625 =9 =>2 E272<@=9<42D:634@J3=@979<;24H@82>2?42;27=@F?:D725 27594;2F27=@;36;95236=EC=>29945@73=2!278>9<=>@; 9:4=375E272<@=9<42D:634@J3=@97>3;E227D@H27=9 4@ 35F373E>3A>9>3;E227;@F@6346C?63825=9=>3=9<=>2 ?2=@=@9724 >2 ?2=@=@9724 >3; 364235C 3==3@725 3D2 9< ;:?24377:3=@9797$#$# , 7H@2A9<=>23E9H2=>2<9669A@7D @( >24@=2=@=@97@; - 8 - @@( 2;?97527=; 342 5@428=25 =9 42D:634@;2 =>2 ;24H@82; 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724 3; 2346C 3; ?9;;@E62 E:=79=63=24=>37=>29:=246@F@=9<<9:4F97=>; <49F=>@;53C<=>2H38378C@;79=3H3@63E623 ;:?247:F2434C ?9;= ;>366 E2 8423=25 =9 3889FF953=2 =>2 ?2=@=@9724 @7 H@2A 9< =>2 ?2=@=@9724 3==3@725 3D2 9< ;:?24377:3=@97 97 $#$# @@@( >2 ?2=@=@9724 @; 27=@=625 <94 ?27;@97 375 ?27;@9734CE272<@=;3;42D:6342F?69C22 () &%$%' " @;=9 69