Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2025 DAILYLAW 6545 (PNJ)
KULDEEP SINGH AND ANOTHER v. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
CWP/38070/2025 · 2026-04-23
Harkesh Manuja
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 6545 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 6545 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
CWP No.38070 of 202
**** ---- .'( .'( .'( .'( &'((") &'((") &'((") &'((") 2222 +/3 +/3 +/3 +/3 !"#$3 !"#$3 !"#$3 !"#$3 56 56 56 56 7 7 7 7 '6 5'4 5'4 1(' 54 5'4 1(' 5'4 5 5 5 5 894 (1'%% "('/ ,1% )($&%(1'( &'(0%%((1 )?"%%%( @*)CD%) 1('%'+)? 2025 (O&M) . (4 . (4 . (4 .
(4**** !"#$ ''0 !"#$ ''0 !"#$ ''0 !"#$ ''0 !"#$ %&'( (" ) !"#$ %&'( (" ) !"#$ %&'( (" ) !"#$ %&'( (" ) !"#$ %"&+( ( !"#$ %"&+( ( !"#$ %"&+( ( !"#$ %"&+( ( '( +/(&' %0& ' (1 !"#$ '( +/(&' %0& ' (1 !"#$ '( +/(&' %0& ' (1 !"#$ '( +/(&' %0& ' (1 !"#$ )(' ' 1"++!"#$ % )(' ' 1"++!"#$ % )(' ' 1"++!"#$ % )(' ' 1"++!"#$ % /3%1 /3(1 &'( (" )$ (1 /3%1 /3(1 &'( (" )$ (1 /3%1 /3(1 &'( (" )$ (1 /3%1 /3(1 &'( (" )$ (1 3 ' ( '(14 3 ' ( '(14 3 ' ( '(14 3 ' ( '(14 75 4 75 4 75 4 75 4 '45 (! " %'30() % '4%+&' 30() (' & % %( '4 4($ +% (%30() 1(' '4 %% " +30() (' '&( G4 '4 '" " +3 444 HHHH 34 34 34 34 & % %( 'G+ ( '3,/ / "'(1$ $"%') % # 1% (1 % ' ; <= 2= 1'($ (1&(%( %++ ) %( > (1 %# ( %' %( 3 ,%+% %( +$ %)%& '%$ '% () %( F )?"%'" ' %( +%# / *F@>@ *F@>@ *F@>@ *F@>@(1 @ 2A J5D (1 @ 2A J5D (1 @ 2A J5D (1 @ 2A J5D 444444444444 % %( ' % %( ' % %( ' % %( ' 44 &( 44 &( 44 &( 44 &( @@@@4@4@4@4@----4444 @ @ @ @ EEEE ) ) ) ) ****4@4@4@4@----4 @
E 4 @ E 4 @ E 4 @ E ( ,% ( ,% ( ,% ( ,% ****4@4@4@4@----4 @ E 4 @ E 4 @ E 4 @ E $ % $ % $ % $ % % % % %&'( (" ) &'( (" ) &'( (" ) &'( (" ) "++ "++ "++ "++ (11"++ (11"++ (11"++ (11"++ ( &&+%) ,+ ( &&+%) ,+ ( &&+%) ,+ ( &&+%) ,+ 5 5 5 5 4 " ! ,4 /(1&'&%%(3I%" #'&((':&/ 2= '&)%0+/ ( ) (1)"+&/$&' '($&%('&')/ +$ )3 @* A1(' ,'0%/3 B F(1)?"%%%()3F< /)+<2E4 1
") / ) ' )/% 3 B F<-3 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.38070 of 202
8 94 '% )($&'% % - ::<:: 1++% )?"%'1('0 ')(1+ (%1%)%( '&)%0+/ (1 '1'3 '&((4- (1)?"%' ,%##'%)"+"' 8*94 % &%%(':+( '%0% $'I0+" %%(+%' '@<4 ()$( &(%%( )$ (%'($& +$) 2025 (O&M) '%1+/ %#3 + (1 & ' (42>:: 3 2>::<3 - : ++%# % %++# %,,'3 0+(&$(1+%G$'%'G +1'($$*>4F@@$(-@E @>4@>4 @ @@<4@ 4 @ % 1 %(+ %#/ )3< ' "' )%( *GAD (4-:(@<4@-4 @ AK" +'(1423*E*:G&
"'++4 %%1% % 1('% ('("#',%'%(%0(I% ' >4@4 @ 2AK" +"'423@@3@@@:G&') '; =1'($(1(%1 @<4@-4 @ 4',%'('1"'' $("1'($(11%+%#(1 (1%';<=1('1%'/ $("1'($(1&(%( %('&')/% )3 @*4
&%%(' $"'%# F-4<F5' - :: :3 2>:: 3 2>::@:3 2>:: %+ %'%) "'&"' '%(+%#/(4G2 -@E42@@$(1(1
"!
,0% %""')%(*G* <2E A1(' ,'0%/ B <2E ) D (1 <2E )3 & K"'
GD%#$'I0+ &'5'+A4F32F3@F@:G&') % ' @<4@-4 @ 3 I%#)%(*GA2D(1<2E K"'
G*D3+4',%'(' ')'+(#%@@=(+%"$ %1%)%("')%(*G"&( '%')&/$(1%';< 1&&+%)%(%++(1)" '2=&'"$'1' %(&')%(> (1%# )?"%%%(3,%+%%( 2 '+ :: 3 2% 0% *G3 )CD4 ,/ 0+" )'D 3 )3 ( <= )"+ '( %# MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of 202 8-94 , +1(1 & % ' ( @*) 31'( A A A A 8294 + ' ',% ' ( ;<=( ) ) " +&(% 3 ' % ' ) $(" 824 94 >4@4 @ 2 A @>4 4 @ * A5 G*: @ -DA ($$%%( 'G) ;<=&' "$ )($& %( '&( "+/&(% , ((%,"' 824*94 5:(+ '( 5:(+ '( 5:(+ '( 5:(+ '( A-D 44 A%0% A-D 44 A%0% A-D 44 A%0% A-D 44 A%0% 2025 (O&M) ,(0)%')"$ )3 &' & % %( 'G+ ( 'I% # % ))($& %( % '$ 1'($ (1&(%( %++ AD AD AD AD ' )(" + 1(' & % %( ' (' %+ )% # )($& ) $(" 1'($ (11%+% 3 ' % '$(1) %( > ; <= 1(' 1%' / ' " 1'($ (1 I% #&( ' )(" +1"' '",$% K"' G*D3 + ' ',% ' (' (4 G2: @ *DA K"' DA K"' G2D &' % % # ( )"$G',% ' ('3 + '%0%%( "$1(' 1%' / ' 2=&' '%# +/ '4 1(' 3% 1 ) 3 )($& %( ,/ &( (4 : ( '&) %0+ ( '4 ' )(" +,/ &+ )% # '+% ) '( + ('#% #04 %( ( '( + ('#% #04 %( ( '( + ('#% #04 %( ( '( + ('#% #04 %( ( %0% %0% %0% %0%+D*>2 +D*>2 +D*>2 +D*>2 %( 1 % %( 1 % %( 1 % %( 1 % ' & % %( , % % " %') %( ( '&( (#' (1 &'(0%%( (1) %( > (1 ) " +& /$ 4 'G+ ( ' )(
& %( 3 '' % #' % # % ' %+% #(1 &&+%) %( %++ > (1 @*) 3% ("# ( 2= &' "$ ' 1 ' ( %( 4 %+& % # ' (' '+% "&( '+%' ' "' G-D F4@F4 @ - A5 $ 0%++ # %,,'3 & %%( 3 + '3% %) % ' &' "$ ' 1 '( ) % ' ' 0' %+ ( $(" '$% '% : % 5:3 % )"&( )%%( ' ' %( (1 % ''&(' @ %( (1 % ''&(' @ %( (1 % ''&(' @ %( (1 % ''&(' @ ( '04 '$% # ( '04 '$% # ( '04 '$% # ( '04 '$% # 3 ( #' > (1 ' (1 0 (4 ,/ ' ) ,/ ' %) % @ @ @ @ ' ' ' ' MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of 202 '&(' A @ '&(' A @ '&(' A @ '&(' A @ (+ %"$ % '$(1) %( F<-) CD ' $ ("+ % " + ( % 4 824-94 4 ) %( > &&+%) ,+ ( ) @2A*D(1 @ ") $(%1%) %( % #' + )($&( % + ($(' $(" ", @*) ( A A A A 8E94 ",$% '$/ (1%+( <<E &' +% ,+ (,%$ 2025 (O&M) A @<D < *@- @<D < *@- A @<D < *@- @<D < *@- 1"' ' )( % ' )( % % ) %( *A ( F&'(0%(" ' )?" ' &&+%) ,+ ( )?"%% %( $ "+ $(" ( %$&'$%%,+ '3 " ) "% # 0%(+ %( (1 4)(" ++ +/",$% &' F@(1 @*) 3,% #$( )?"%% %( " ' %( + @*) 44)(" +)( %( ( ( %+" )($& ( (1 )($& %( % +1 ', 1%)% +&'(0%%( '+ % # ( ,?" +/ ),/ + ' $(" '$% % 1%' % AD AD AD AD ( ' 3 + ' )(" # % ' (1 + ' (,!) %( " ') %( *-(1 &' '% & % %( ( $ % $%(" '%#+ /4 &'(0%%( '+ % # AGD A D % ' & / ,+ )?"%% %( ) 3F<-A1(','0% /3B " ' <2E) 3 % + %)'%$% %( , %$%+ (1 ' %)+ - (1 ( % " %( &'(0%%( '+ % # (% ' " $(', 1%)% +% "'3 ' + %# / ) % 0% (1 ) % %&'(0%%( &'$% ( %( 3 % ) % ' 1('$ +13
& % %( 'G+ ( ' (% ' % '$(1) %( > ' ',% ' (' ) %( F@(1 % ),/4 4-J2 4-J2 4-J2 4-J2 " + 1(' '&( (4- ',% ' ('3 & % %( ' 1 ',% ' %( J( )%+% %( % % ,+ ++ 3 '1('3 4 # ( ,+% 3B % +(1 %+ '+/ ( (1 " ' +( ) %( ( +/ ' > ( (1 2 ) 3 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
',% ' (' '' &'(0%%( (1 @* ) %# /) 3<2E%)( )' 2 (1 @* ) 3 %) ' 5 '("# (1 "'% # 4 @ " ' 4 @ '+ ( ' ' 4 1'($ 1 1'($ A2D(1 % ) ( 3% MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
%( ( )?"%'4 1"' '+ )+"% # %#' ' (1 % ' 8 %,+ ( ',/ )?"%' %( (1 +% %( $ ' " (1 '3 &+ (1 0% # ' %+/3 (1 <<> ("' '1(' % ' &'(0%( +/3 %( (1 AD(4 %% %( %% %( %% %( %% %( '4 '4 '4 '4 %$%+ ' "&' D "&' D "&' D "&' D4 '+/ +" ( ' 3 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
'$% 3 ," +( (+ %"$ % ' '$% 3 ," +( (+ %"$ % ' '$% 3 ," +( (+ %"$ % ' /$ (1)($& %( 4 '%," (1% /$ (1)($& %( 4 '%," (1% /$ (1)($& %( 4 '%," (1% /$ (1)($& %( 4 '%," (1% % ' % ( $'+/ '?"%' ( , & % ' % ( $'+/ '?"%' ( , & % ' % ( $'+/ '?"%' ( , & % ' % ( $'+/ '?"%' ( , & ))(" (1 ))& )( & ' (1 + ))(" (1 ))& )( & ' (1 + ))(" (1 ))& )( & ' (1 + ))(" (1 ))& )( & ' (1 + ))(" (1 + /% & /$ (1)($& ))(" (1 + /% & /$ (1)($& ))(" (1 + /% & /$ (1)($& ))(" (1 + /% & /$ (1)($& (' 0% # +( , 1% (1 " # (1 (' 0% # +( , 1% (1 " # (1 (' 0% # +( , 1% (1 " # (1 (' 0% # +( , 1% (1 " # (1 ($& ($& ($& ($& %( '+% 3 + /% & /$ %( '+% 3 + /% & /$ %( '+% 3 + /% & /$ %( '+% 3 + /% & /$ $ # ( + +('3 %)%'?"%' ( $ # ( + +('3 %)%'?"%' ( $ # ( + +('3 %)%'?"%' ( $ # ( + +('3 %)%'?"%' ( %( *A2D(1 <2E) (
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
,% % #"%3% $") (1% ' $" ,% % #"%3% $") (1% ' $" ,% % #"%3% $") (1% ' $" ,% % #"%3% $") & % ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% / 1(' + / & % ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% / 1(' + / & % ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% / 1(' + / & % ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% / 1(' + / + +('(1 )($& %( $(" 3," + +('(1 )($& %( $(" 3," + +('(1 )($& %( $(" 3," + +('(1 )($& %( $(" 3," & %( ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% /4+ & %( ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% /4+ & %( ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% /4+ & %( ,/ )?"%'% # " ('% /4+ (1 + ,% # '?"%' ( , & % (1 + ,% # '?"%' ( , & % (1 + ,% # '?"%' ( , & % (1 + ,% # '?"%' ( , & % & /$ (1)($& %( +() "% !"'/ & /$ (1)($& %( +() "% !"'/ & /$ (1)($& %( +() "% !"'/ & /$ (1)($& %( +() "% !"'/ (,)($& ,/& /$ (1% ' 4 (,)($& ,/& /$ (1% ' 4 (,)($& ,/& /$ (1% ' 4 (,)($& ,/& /$ (1% ' 4 9 ( %( 4 $ $ $ $ ' 3 +3 '$ (1 1<2E %) 1<2E ( ( ,'% # 3 ( ( , , ) , %( 4 +'%# 3 "3 / (1!" , ,
, , $ I% # $ I% # $ I% # $ I% # ") ") ") ") + / ( + / ( + / ( + / ( ," ( ," ( ," ( ," ( + + + + % % % % "'/ "'/ "'/ "'/ 4 4 4 4 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
/$ (1% ' ( +/ ' ( ) " +&(% 3 '% (% )' ( ) " +&(% 3 '% (% )' ( ) " +&(% 3 '% (% )' ( ) " +&(% 3 '% (% )' ( <2E4 % &) , + % % <2E4 % &) , + % % <2E4 % &) , + % % <2E4 % &) , + % % % #7 ) % #7 ) % #7 ) % #7 ) A"&' D3 K ' ) % & A"&' D3 K ' ) % & A"&' D3 K ' ) % & A"&' D3 K ' ) % & #('%) ++/% %) (+ %"$ % ' #('%) ++/% %) (+ %"$ % ' #('%) ++/% %) (+ %"$ % ' #('%) ++/% %) (+ %"$ % ' 1 @*4 1 @*4 1 @*4 1 @*4 24F4%,% #1(' ' ( )% %N %)'%$% # % ( ))(" (1 )?"%'4 )("+, 0'/ $)% %N )("+,%11' )% %N (+(+ " 24<4 %' +/3%1% % $)% %N +(% # %' +/3%1% % $)% %N +(% # %' +/3%1% % $)% %N +(% # %' +/3%1% % $)% %N +(% # % %N ) ( , &'(0% %)'%$% ('/ % %N ) ( , &'(0% %)'%$% ('/ % %N ) ( , &'(0% %)'%$% ('/ % %N )
( , &'(0% %)'%$% ('/ %11' ) $ 4)( +/3%1 ' ' %11' ) $ 4)( +/3%1 ' ' %11' ) $ 4)( +/3%1 ' ' %11' ) $ 4)( +/3%1 ' ' %11' ) $ 3 ( )% %N ) %11' ) $ 3 ( )% %N ) %11' ) $ 3 ( )% %N ) %11' ) $ 3 ( )% %N ) %) ("+ +( $(" (%)'%$% %( % %) ("+ +( $(" (%)'%$% %( % %) ("+ +( $(" (%)'%$% %( % %) ("+ +( $(" (%)'%$% %( % % 4 % 4 % 4 % 4 24@4 "3 ) (1 @* , $ (1 ' )($& %( % )( )' 4 ,%+% %( 3 $%($ %$ ( &&+ 244",$%%( (1 + ' )(" + +( (& %)'%$% ('/&(+%)%% $" ' ) (1 @* % '&) % %( ) %( *A2D(1 ) (1<2E4($ &( ,% # % '"$ +% /(1 % ( % ") ',% ' '/$ '4 24 24 24 24 4 0% (1 $ '3 ' 4 0% (1 $ '3 ' 4 0% (1 $ '3 ' 4 0% (1 $ '3 ' )+"% #(+ %"$ )+"% #(+ %"$ )+"% #(+ %"$ )+"% #(+ %"$ % ' 3%'?"%' ( % ' 3%'?"%' ( % ' 3%'?"%' ( % ' 3%'?"%' ( 443<=&4 4" %+ (1&(%( 443<=&4 4" %+ (1&(%(
443<=&4 4" %+ (1&(%( 443<=&4 4" %+ (1&(%( 24*4) ( 1 ' )($% #% (1( 24*4) ( 1 ' )($% #% (1( 24*4) ( 1 ' )($% #% (1( 24*4) ( 1 ' )($% #% (1( ' & ' )/% )?"%% %( 3 ' & ' )/% )?"%% %( 3 ' & ' )/% )?"%% %( 3 ' & ' )/% )?"%% %( 3 ,%+% ,%+% ,%+% ,%+% % ' ("+,+% ,+ (,& %( +/ % ' ("+,+% ,+ (,& %( +/ % ' ("+,+% ,+ (,& %( +/ % ' ("+,+% ,+ (,& %( +/ %# /) 3<2E4M %# /) 3<2E4M %# /) 3<2E4M %# /) 3<2E4M ) (1 @* , ,'("# % ( ) (1 @* , ,'("# % ( ) (1 @* , ,'("# % ( ) (1 @* , ,'("# % (1( 1(' 1( 1(' %'?"%' (,& % <=&4 4" %+ %'?"%' (,& % <=&4 4" %+ %'?"%' (,& % <=&4 4" %+ %'?"%' (,& % <=&4 4" %+ 1)("'30 " ' )?"%% %( 1)("'30 " ' )?"%% %( 1)("'30 " ' )?"%% %( 1)("'30 " ' )?"%% %( %' (,& %4 %' (,& %4 %' (,& %4 %' (,& %4 % ' % &)% + &'(0%%( % (1 ' % ' % &)% + &'(0%%( % (1 ' % ' % &)% + &'(0%%( % (1 ' % ' % &)% + &'(0%%( % (1 ' A2D(1 ) (1<2E3 %'?"% A2D(1 ) (1<2E3 %'?"% A2D(1 ) (1<2E3 %'?"% A2D(1 ) (1<2E3
%'?"% (1<=&4 4( ))($& %( (1<=&4 4( ))($& %( (1<=&4 4( ))($& %( (1<=&4 4( ))($& %( (2=&4 4" ') %( *A2D(1 ) (2=&4 4" ') %( *A2D(1 ) (2=&4 4" ') %( *A2D(1 ) (2=&4 4" ') %( *A2D(1 ) %+ ,/ ( 7,+ &K ("' % %+ ,/ ( 7,+ &K ("' % %+ ,/ ( 7,+ &K ("' % %+ ,/ ( 7,+ &K ("' % ' ' ' ' & ' (4 -F3 2 2 3 %) )+ '+ & ' (4 -F3 2 2 3 %) )+ '+ & ' (4 -F3 2 2 3 %) )+ '+ & ' (4 -F3 2 2 3 %) )+ '+//// ' ("+ +( 0 (,& %" ' ' ("+ +( 0 (,& %" ' ' ("+ +( 0 (,& %" ' ' ("+ +( 0 (,& %" ' %N (1 )(" '/) ( ,%11' % ) $ " ' %) + , (+(+ " '%11' ) $ " ' $('%11' ) $ 4 % #+ " '% % #+ " '% % #+ " '% % #+ " '%11' ) $ 3 0 11' ) $ 3 0 11' ) $ 3 0 11' ) $ 3 0 ('/ )($& %( :(+ %"$ (' % ' " ('/ )($& %( :(+ %"$ (' % ' " ('/ )($& %( :(+ %"$ (' % ' " ('/ )($& %( :(+ %"$ (' %
' " '%11' (1)% %N +(% #+ " '%11' (1)% %N +(% #+ " '%11' (1)% %N +(% #+ " '%11' (1)% %N +(% #+ " ( ')%0 ( ')%0 ( ')%0 ( ')%0 %#' $(" ( %#' $(" ( %#' $(" ( %#' $(" ( ( % '$(1' %)+ ( % '$(1' %)+ ( % '$(1' %)+ ( % '$(1' %)+- - - -(1 ( % " %( (1 ( % " %( (1 ( % " %( (1 ( % " %( $ &&+%) ,+ " %1('$+/ ( ++ )?"%% % 4 ( 0'3 % '&) (1 ' +$ &&+%) ,+ ( & ' %)"+ ' )?"%% %( 4 +1(' &( % +( $") 1('($+ +('% ' %& % % %( ' % ' %("# (,& % &(+%)/%1 (& %'?"%' (,&') %'?"%' (% 1 %' ' & ' $ ' (% (4 ,/ (+% # )($& % ' (% (4 ,/ (+% # )($& % ' (% (4 ,/ (+% # )($& % ' (% (4 ,/ (+% # )($& % (,) +)"+ % '$(1 ) (1 @ (,) +)"+ % '$(1 ) (1 @ (,) +)"+ % '$(1 ) (1 @ (,) +)"+ % '$(1 ) (1 @ 2=&4 4 ' 1 '4 2=&4 4 ' 1 '4 2=&4 4 ' 1 '4 2=&4 4 ' 1 '4 (1(')(1 %# ( %'($& %( (1(')(1 %# ( %'($& %( (1(')(1 %#
( %'($& %( (1(')(1 %# ( %'($& %( ,%+% %( +$ ) 3 @*3)( ,%+% %( +$ ) 3 @*3)( ,%+% %( +$ ) 3 @*3)( ,%+% %( +$ ) 3 @*3)( +/% '$(1) %( +/% '$(1) %( +/% '$(1) %( +/% '$(1) %( ****ADA2D(1 %( ADA2D(1 %( ADA2D(1 %( ADA2D(1 %( A$& %"&&+%D 10 1(')3 1(')3 1(')3 1(')3 ( ) 3 ( ) 3 ( ) 3 ( ) 3 (1 ' (1 ' (1 ' (1 ' ?"%' ?"%' ?"%' ?"%' %( %+ %( %+ %( %+ %( %+++++ ) (1 ) (1 ) (1 ) (1 '$ '$ '$ '$ / / / / ) ) ) ) (' , 3(' 0'/ 0'/ 0'/ 0'/ " ' " ' " ' " ' " ' " ' " ' " ' ( '3 ( '3 ( '3 ( '3 %( (1 %( (1 %( (1 %( (1 %% %( & % &' ) 3 $ ' %( 3 %( 3 %( 3 %( 3 1 @*3 1 @*3 1 @*3 1 @*3 %( %( %( %( ( ( ( ( %( + %( + %( + %( + MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.38070 of 202
L@4 <2E )3 &/$ (1<= )% &% %' HHHH E4 (&%% , K&' %+ ' ) '") >4 &'(0% 1%' )?" 8<4-94 " (+ %'&)(1)?
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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
$ ,/ 3( +' /, $ ,/ 3( +' /, $ ,/ 3( +' /, $ ,/ 3( ,/% )("' (1( 7,+% %( ,/% )("' (1( 7,+% %( ,/% )("' (1( 7,+% %( ,/% )("' (1( 7,+% %( )%')"$ ) (1 ) 3 % ("+ + (1 &&+%) ; 423@@3@@@:G A$& %"&&+%D 13 %( 4 "' % % ++/ K"' '+%' 4 @ - %,,'3 %) '( ") (1 '% + % 4 %) +1(' +1(' +1(' +1(' ' ' ' ' %( (1 %( (1 %( (1 %( (1 @3@@@: @3@@@: @3@@@: @3@@@:GGGG 3( +/ 3( +/ 3( +/ 3( +/ % %( + % %( + % %( + % %( + "+ , G&' MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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
% " 0 +%#'(" ( $ % 1 ) , #' % 3 ("+?" ++/ 0 '$/ ) ,/ % 0(I% # &'(0%%( ) 3 <<E4 1 %+"' (1 + ' '+/% " + ( '3&% '+% %)'%$% ('/(" )($ " %( (1 % 3& ' %)"+ '+/ $ ?" +&'( ) %( (1+ 4 / '&( & % %( " ') %( *-(1 ',% ' % ' '% & % %( % '1(' 0% (1 + + % % ) (' @ "&'$(" @ "&'$(" @ "&'$(" @ "&'$(" 1' )" ') %( *-% ''( +/ ( % ',% ' + ' '(1 ' K ' ) '" ' 14 1 ++ %( '3 % ' ' ( / % /(1 (1 ' +% ) ") %( ' ' %( ( (1 ("' ("' ("' ("' '( +/ ' 1(' MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.38070 of 202
%%)++/ %" &'()%# &%%(''% '0(&'(+(# )('(0'/+% %!"%)%4 8 94
"' '3A<F2D* '3A<F2D* '3A<F2D* '3A<F2D* '")("'
"''%)+ E +'%0'$ K"%((1 '"+(1+4/ 8*94 K '0 K '0 K '0 K '0 ("' &+ (" K"%((1'$ A%D. % A%%D ) A%%%D !"%) A%0D ('S A0D.
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
(''% ( +0%(+ %( (1&'% )%&+ 16 ( ( +/ + / /% % %) %( ?" ?"%' ' )($ )($ )($ )($ '$ + (1 '$ +% / ( (1 &+ (1 & +3 &+(1 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of 202 8-94 1 '&(' @ @ @ @ '+# & )($& %( % ) % '% !"'%%) % %) ("+( + L 4 (' ' ( ' ',% ) " 4 '&( 8294 % %) ++/&+ ) (1 )($& (11 % # 1" " ' ) %( * )( 1% ( +/ ))('% #+/3% '% !"'%%) %( )+ '+/ !" %1% & % %( '%#' 2025 (O&M) 1 ) 3 %0%%( )(1 %( @EA2D A%0%+D*-- @EA2D A%0%+D*-- @EA2D A%0%+D*-- @EA2D A%0%+D*-- % %$%+ & ' % ( ',% ' + &'()4 % '&) (1 %$%+ '+/ % " % 1% +% /3 ("' ) %( 3 (K $, 1% ' ( +/&'(+( # $ '4 +0 4 0% (1 1(' %!"#$ ''& ,/ ' +(0' $ '$% %( (1 $(" (1)($& %( ' + ( ' % 1% +% /3 ',% ' (' %++( +/+ / '$% "" ) '/ ' $ ( + ( 4 ( ?" +/3 ++( & &( (& / )($& %( ( *4@4 @ 1% +%% '&) (1 &' ) 3 + ' )+ ( '0 ("#( +/ %( 3 ) ',% ' '%+/ 1" $ + &'% )%&+ (1 1 %' & *- ("+ ( 11(' / 11) / ( % # % ' % &)"+% '1 ) )%')"$ ( " '' %)+ E(1 ( ( '$/ $ %1 ',% ' !" ?"% ,+)($& ("' % %'% #04 %( (1 %'% #04 %( (1 %'% #04 %( (1 %'% #04 %( (1 $%+ ' 1 ) " + , )I'(&3 )+% 4 I% # ( (1 1 ) + ( ' +' / , $% &&'(&'% 3% K')% ' ' )($&+ 1''1' K)'& %'&'(")'% " 3 $% &&'(&'% (
% )+% % # '1' ) (',% ' (' %( 4" % ) '% '&) (1 +% /3 &'()"' 1(' &&(% $ (1 % %( (1 $(" (1)($& %( ( '4 &' '% & % %( %') ( + ( '% '$(1 1 ( '+ ( '4M ',% ' ('3 ,/ /% # & '% / +/ % '# ' (% ' )($&( % ,' ) (1 ' %)+ -3 ' ' &'()"'4 5('(0'3 '$ ) %0 (' ", %0 '+%13 % % (" &( ' (1 $(%1%) %( )(1 ) 3 K')% % " %( 3,% #&+ '/% "'3 ',% ' '% ( "' %( 4 17 1 % 1 % 1 % 1 % ( , %(1 ' ) '6G % ('1(' (1 (1 ( ) ' / ( ( ',/ $/ % % %( 4 %(1 '3% MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment CWP No.38070 of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attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.38070 of 202
04 $ E4 (' 1"' ''% &"'&( ,3 >4( ,%# %+ 11%) '$ (' ) F4" 1"' )($& % <4$ 0%G ' #'0 ') @4.
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
3 V + ) VD3 # '1' )" ') %( F(1 + ,/ "%)% + ("' 3 )($&'%% # '% % %( + % '%) "#4 ' 1"' "' 3 "0 %#("' &( ) 1('$ (&% %( '6$ 'I 0 +" ( ' ( '% ' & ' % , ( + " ('/ , 1% %#' ' %# ( %'($& %( ' & ' +$ ) 3 @*A% (' 3 V ) '3 (+ % )?"%'" ' <2E )?"%' ( " ' ) 3 0, % (" /% ++%#%,+%11' % 4%+ 1 1%' ) #('/3 $+/3 ( (+ + %0 %($%)' %,+1'($ $) 11) )?"%% %( " ' %) $ "$ '( 0+(&$ (1 %( ("#") +#%+ %0&(+%)/%+ " ,+3&'% % ) %+ "'% # + ( ' %( 1(' )?"%'+ % $$ + ' )?"%'" ' +) ('" % +(1('% 1' '") "' +0+(&$ 4 +(' "## %( (1 % ( ' %' ,%+% /(1,'% #% #& '% /% $ %( (1 $ 'I 0 +"(1 )?"%'+ %( (1 % 4M 19 $ (' / ,/ 3 '"$% $ / '+%' D3 ' +) %% # 1"' ' &( ' +"(1 , ' (1 ' )/ ) VD4 2E) 3 , ( + %$ ) $" %( + 3&'%$ / $ ' '" ' ("+ $ ' % MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment
CWP No.38070 of 202
8>94 &%%('G+( !"%)%+'0%) %3(, +((0(% 8F94
")'/' ("')(%' K& 1%'/'2 &(%(%' %' ( ))(')% 8<94 .% %#&&+%) &'%+ &'%+ &'%+ &'%+ ****3 @ 3 @ 3 @ 3 @ EEEE %I . . 2025 (O&M) &)"+%' 1) )%')"$ (',+1%(11% )(1''"&(%("'"' (,%0(I%(''(()($&+ %)'%$%%(%%)& 0% (1 1('%3 % ( '%&("+"1'($' '%!"&&'(&'%($(%1/ &%%('G+(''+ 2=&'"$'1'( '$(1)%(> (1 @* $(" (1 )($&%( ('%# %&'(0%%((1)%(F@(1 % 1('% (,'0%(3 )%(AD3%1/+++(% '&I%#:'( : ''&(',+ :
$) (1 &' )3 11%))%("'$/%#4 ''%)+ E(1(%"%( &+!"%),&'% &%%(',$("4 ('' ( (,0% 1"'' +/ '$1('1'!"%)%(3 %1/' >4@4 @ 2( +%+(%';<=1(' )$("1'($ )4"''/'+(%+ '%#%++/ '$% ,/ (1 @*)4 3 &' &%%( % %&( %&( %&( %&( %&((14 A5 D A5 D A5 D A5 D :( :( 20 3 "3 ((1 / 3% ( ' (1 +( % (1 (1 (1 (14 MOHMED ATIK 2026.04.23 16:56 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this
order/judgment