- 1 - ! " #$ % $$ $ & &'() & (( * !" # $ % & ' ( !) * $ $ + & $ $ $ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & $ $ # + $ $ && $ ) ! * $ $ & )# & #) & $ #!#" ( !#!#! #!#! & & & + $ & && $ $ && % & # " & , -$ -$ ./0/121234/567/2489::;6/< 36" 94< # 2452=/ 3#!#!3> 94<.2 ;4?3@2:/191234$2<950/4<248 24 3!#!#! 34 1./ >2@/ 3> @/954/< 524:209@ 2A2@ ;<8/ 94< & $2<95 5/8261/5/< >35 1./ 3>>/4:/6 0;426.97@/;4</5/:12346 794< 3>1./&35/284/56 - 3 - :1 %95/6//B24813C;96.1./:52=249@053://<2486 2421291/<98924611./= # &9:163>1./:96/24752/>95/1.911./3> 94<.2 ;4? 3@2:/ 191234 $2<95 5/8261/5/< 1./ & 24 52=/ 3#!#! 9892461 9::;6/< 3 9@@/8248 :3==266234 3> 1./ 3>>/4:/ 0;426.97@/ ;4</5 /:12346 9794<:3>1./&35/284/56:11269@@/8/<1.91 ./ 5/:/2A/< :5/<27@/ 24>35=91234 5/895<248 9::;6/< 3 24<;@8248 24 05309891234 3> 6@9= /A/4 1.3;8. ./ D96 9 E58EF61942 912349@ D.3 :9=/ 13 4<29 34 +269 / A23@91/<1./:34<2123463>+26994<1./5/7E:3==211/<1./ 973A/ 6191/< 3>>/4:/ >1/5 24A/612891234 :.958/ 6.//1 :9=/137/>2@/<98924619::;6/<3613">351./973A/ 692< 3>>/4:/ 6 0/5 :3@;=4 3 3> 1./ :.958/ 6.//1 1./6/0/121234/567/2489::;6/<36"94<#9::3=0942/< 9::;6/<3D.2@/./D96.9A248<26:3;56/241./96?2< ./ 0/121234/56 95/ 6//B248 13 C;96. 1./ :52=249@ 053://<24862421291/<98924611./= - 4 - " /95< 52 94/6. 9@7;582 @/954/< :3;46/@ >351./0/121234/5694<52 9=9<95.9.97;<<24@/954/< 28. 3;51 3A/54=/41 @/9</5 >35 5/6034</41 3 G 191/ /6034</413#1.3;8.6/5A/<D21.1./4312:/.96 5/=924/< ;45/05/6/41/< /5;6/< 1./ =91/529@6 34 5/:35< 4 A2/D 3> 1./ 52A9@ :341/412346 ;58/< 7E 1./ @/954/<:3;46/@6>35731.1./09512/61./032411.91D3;@< 9526/>35=E:3462</59123426 !"#$% E946D/5131./973A/0324126241./ >35 1./>3@@3D248 42129@@E& :9=/137/5/8261/5/<34@E9892461 9::;6/< 3 >1/5 24A/612891234 :.958/ 6.//1 :9=/ 13 - 5 - 7/>2@/<98924619::;6/<3613"/954/<:3;46/@>35 1./0/121234/56.96053<;:/<1./:30E3>1./35</5<91/< "!#!#! 0966/< 24 52=249@ /121234 3#!!%)#!#! 94< :344/:1/<=911/56D./5/241./ :52=249@053://<2486 2452=/3%#!#!3> 94<.2 ;4?3@2:/191234$2<95 0/4<248243!#!#!341./>2@/3>@/954/<524:209@ 2A2@ ;<8/ 94< & $2<95 9892461 9::;6/< 3 D96 C;96./<94<059E6>35C;96.2481./:52=249@053://<2486 9892461 9::;6/< 36" 94< #0/121234/56 34 1./ 79626 3> 09521E % ./ 35</5 <91/< "!#!#! C;96.248 1./ :52=249@ 053://<2486 9892461 9::;6/< 3 26 34 1./ 853;4<1.91./269&35/284912349@94<./D96D2@@24813 @/9A/ 1./ 3;415E 2==/<291/@E 7E 8/11248 /H21 0/5=21 4</5 6;:. :25:;=6194:/6 21 D96 >/@1 1.91 43 0;5036/ D3;@< 7/ 6/5A/< 7E 0536/:;1248 .2= >35 A23@91248 :34<2123463>1./+269961./69=/D3;@</H1/4<.26619E 241./3;415E>359>;51./50/523<94<21D2@@7/97;5</4 >35 1./ 191/ 4</5 6;:. :25:;=6194:/6 :52=249@ - 6 - 053://<24869892461.2=D96C;96./<9@348D21.62=2@95@E 0@9:/< 31./5 9::;6/< 24 31./5 :52=249@ 053://<2486 94< 5/6034</41 191/ D96 <25/:1/< 13 =9B/ 4/:/6695E 955948/=/41 >35 266;94:/ 3> 1./ /H21 0/5=21 94< /46;5/ 1./25/H21>53=4<29>351.D21.2>1./E95/4315/C;25/<24 94E31./5:96/6;7?/:113:34<212346./5/>35/C;96.248 1./ :52=249@ 053://<2486 D96 431 34 1./ 853;4< 1.91 1./ 2421291234 3> 1./ :52=249@ 053://<2486 D96 24 97;6/ 3> 053:/66 3> @9D /4:/ C;96.248 3> 6;:. 053://<2486 98924619::;6/< 3D2@@ 431 /4;5/ 13 1./ 7/4/>213> 1./ 05/6/410/121234/56 1261./:341/412343>1./0/121234/561.911./E 7/248 1./ 4<294 912349@6 D/5/ 431 9D95/ 3> 1./ :34<212346 3> +269 266;/< 24 >9A3;5 3> 9::;6/< 3 94< 1./5/>35/ 1./ :52=249@ 053://<248698924611./= 26 13 7/ C;96./< ) 4 0/5;69@ 3> 1./ :.958/6.//1 =91/529@6 1./ 34@E 9@@/891234 9892461 1./6/ 0/121234/56 26 1.91 1./E - 7 - 9::3=0942/<9::;6/<3D.2@/./D96.9A248<26:3;56/ 24A9523;696?2<694<1./5/7E1./E.9A/:3==211/<1./ 3>>/4:/ 0;426.97@/ ;4</5 /:1234 3> 1./ &35/284/56 :1 /:1234 3>&35/284/56:1053A2</60/49@1E >3597/1=/41./:15/>/55/<13;4</5/:1234 935 7 =;61 .9A/ 7//4 97/11/< &35/284 912349@ 5/=9242482494E95/9244<29>3590/523</H://<2481./ 0/523<>35D.2:.1./+269D96266;/<13.2=I35<3/694E 9:1 24 A23@91234 3> 1./ :34<212346 3> 1./ A9@2< +269 :34159A/4/6 1./ 053A262346 3> 1./ &35/284/56 :1 35 94E 35</5=9</1./5/;4</53594E<25/:12346/1:/:1234 5/>/56131./0/49@1E>35/415E245/6152:1/<95/9694< $ 5/>/56130/49@1E>35;6248>358/<096603514A2/D3>1./ 60/:2>2: 9@@/8912346 =9</ 24 1./ :.958/6.//1 9::;6/< 326692<13.9A/:3==211/<1./3>>/4:/;4</5/:1234 73>&35/284/56:194<1./6/0/121234/56.9A/97/11/< :3==2662343>6;:.3>>/4:/ - 8 - ! ./ 0536/:;1234 .96 :21/< 96 =94E 96 D214/66/6,6%13)95/1.//E/D214/66/6,./46;:. 60/:2>2: :341/412346 D/5/ 5926/< 7E 1./ 0536/:;1234 5/895<248 :3==266234 3> 1./ 3>>/4:/ ;4</5 /:1234 5/9<D21./:1234 73>&35/284/56:11./:341/41234 3> 1./ @/954/< :3;46/@ >35 1./ 0/121234/561.91 0/121234/56 D/5/ 431 9D95/ 3> 1./ :34<212346 3> +269 :94431 7/ 9 853;4<>35C;96.2481./:52=249@053://<2486843594:/ 3>@9D.9643/H:;6/24:52=249@3>>/4:/611./=36121 =9E 7/ 9 </>/4:/ 1.91 :3;@< 7/ 19B/4 7E 1./ 0/121234/56 7/>35/1./529@3;51/4:/9=3>1./30242341.911./ 0/121234/56 95/ 431 /4121@/< >35 1./ 5/@2/> 3> C;96.248 1./ :52=249@053://<2486 /954/< :3;46/@ >35 1./ 0/121234/56 .96 0@9:/< 5/@294:/ 34 1./ </:26234 3> 1./ 34J7@/ 0/H 3;51 24 1 52=249@00/9@3#%#!## - 9 - # 4 1./ 692< :96/ 9 .24/6/ :212F/4 A2621/< 1./ 621/911./7/./613>1./9::;6/<1./5/2494<1./5/D9643 24<2:91234 1.91 1./ 9::;6/< D/5/ 9D95/ 94< .9A248 B43D@/<8/1.911./692<.24/6/:212F/4159A/@/<3413;5261 +269$;1241./05/6/41:96/1./A/5E</>/4:/19B/47E 1./ 0/121234/56 26 1.91 1./E D/5/ 431 9D95/ 3> 1./ :34<212346 3> 1./ +269 $;1 1./E D/5/ A/5E =;:. 9D95/ 1.91 9::;6/< 3 26 9 &35/284 912349@ 94< 159A/@248 24 4<29 34 3;5261 +269 ./5/>35/ 1./ </:26234 3> 1./ 34J7@/0/H3;51241.91:96/:944317/=9</900@2:97@/ 13C;96.1./:52=249@053://<2486241./05/6/41:96/ " 4 A2/D 3> 1./ <26:;66234 ./@< 973A/ 9= 3> 1./30242341.911./0/121234/5695/431/4121@/<>35859413> 1./5/@2/>96059E/<>35::35<248@E946D/51./973A/ 03241241./94<053://<1309661./>3@@3D248 ./:52=249@0/12123426 - 10 - 4 A2/D 3> <26=2669@ 3> 1./ 0/121234 #!# >35 619E <3/6 431 6;5A2A/ >35 :3462</591234 94< 1./ 69=/ 26 9::35<248@E<26=266/< +) &$$( % $ 2613@3 !