Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65265 (KAR)
KALLURKAR RAMARAO AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS
CCC/200009/2025 · 2025-09-18
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65265 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65265 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
! #"$! #"$"
%"!! &
! " #
$ ! #
$
%! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
#
$
%! $
"! #
$
! &
#
$
! #
$
! ! &
"& $$
! #
"
- 3 -
$
! "
$
! $
$
! '
$
! (
& )
"
"!&
"
&
- 4 -
)
"
"!&
$
! & (
"& $
! $
! ! &
$
! # (
&
$$
! - 5 -
$$
! "# $$
! "
"&
$
! * + ,
' '
$
%& *'
' $
%!"$
- 6 -
-
$
%!" $
*
+$'''. '/,
'
' '
'
' 0
"#
+ ,# - '$ 1
'
2 2 3 $
3 $ '
- 7 -
+23 $ , 4567894:456;47<=>;?4:5@@456A;BC=6894<=D@:5A;5;8? 5;75:?=894<=>;?4:5@@456A;BC=664?@=;74;8=?5;7"
94<=>;?4:5@@456A;BC=6894<=D@:5A;5;8?E6=>B98 8=894;=8A<4=C89A?=>68894=6746758475;75:?= 894 CA;5: =6746 75847 # @5??47 A; 6A8 48A8A=;
="#
FA74 ;;4G>64 ; @565B65@9 =" =C 894 ?5A7 H6A8 @48A8A=; 7A64<847 894 @48A8A=;46? 8= D5I4 =;4 D=64 64@64?4;858A=;5:=;BHA898947485A:?=C894:5;7??5A78=95F4 E44;?>ED46B477>6A;B894<=;?86><8A=;=C894E5665B45;7AC ?><9 5 64@64?4;858A=; A? D574 5:=;B HA89 ?>@@=6847
64:4F5;8 7=<>D4;8?8=64?@=;74;8;=?5;7"HA89A;C=>6H44I?C6=D 894 7584 =C 89464<4A@8 =C 894 <468ACA47 <=@J=C 89A? =6746 894 ?5A7 64?@=;74;8? ?95:: <=;?A746 894 ?5D4 HA89A; 4AB98 H44I? C6=D8947584=C64<4A@8=C64@64?4;858A=;C6=D894@48A8A=;46? 456;47 <=>;?4: 5@@456A;B C=6 894 <=D@:5A;5;8? H=>:7 ?>EDA8 8958 894 64@64?4;858A=; H5? BAF4; 5? @46 ;;4G>64 =; # 5;7 5:?= 894 :4B5: ;=8A<4 5? @46 ;;4G>64;?@A84=CA8894?5A764?@=;74;8?95F4;=885I4;
- 8 -
5;J 5<8A=; 5;7 94;<4 A;A8A5847 894 <=;84D@8 @6=<447A;B? E4C=6489A?=>68
" 4?@=;74;8 =? 5;7 95F4 CA:47 5 <=D@:A5;<4 5CCA75FA8 =; ! 5:=;B HA89 <=@J =C 894 4;7=6?4D4;8 75847 !! FA74 ;;4G>64 >8 89A? =>68 ;=8 ?58A?CA47 HA89 894 ?5D4 7A64<847 8= <=;7><8 894 ?>6F4J 5;7 5<<=67A;B:J?>6F4JA?5:?=<=;7><847
=H5;577A8A=;5:5CCA75FA8A?CA:47E4C=6489A?=>68 5:=;BHA89;;4G>64?5;75;7A45;<95;5D5 <=@J =C 894 :A?8 =C :5;7? @4685A;A;B 8= >::>;75BA A::5B4 5;7 ;;4G>64 <=@J =C 894 :A?8 =C 894 :5;7? @4685A;A;B 8= >75:5BA FA::5B4 5;7 A; ?>@@=68 =C 894 7=<>D4;8? 5:?= 5 64C464;<4 A? D574 A; @565B65@9 = =C 894 5CCA75FA8 8958 ADD47A584:J 5C846 894 64<4A@8 =C 64@64?4;858A=; C6=D 894 <=D@:5A;5;8? <6=@ <=D@4;?58A=; HA:: E4 @5A7 ?>EK4<8 8= 894 <=D@:5A;5;8?95FA;B;=8<:5AD475;J<6=@<=D@4;?58A=;C6=D =8946 B=F46;D4;8 =6 64F4;>4 74@568D4;8? 94 <6=@ <=D@4;?58A=; HA:: E4 @5A7 E5?47 >@=; 894 ;58>64 =C <6=@? B6=H;EJ894<=D@:5A;5;8?5?@4689464F4;>464<=67? - 9 -
& '>68946 >;74685I4; A; 894 5CCA75FA8 8958 A; C>8>64 5:?=C=65;J:=??=C<6=@?7>48=894?>ED46B4;<4?=C894E5<I H5846?
C6=D 894 5::>6 5665B4 E4:=H ' :4F4: <6=@ <=D@4;?58A=; HA:: E4 @5A7 5? @46 894 @6=<47>64 :5A7 7=H; A;
56;585I566AB58A=; <8 8A:: +, ;=8ACA<58A=; A? A??>47 >;746 6AB98 8= @5J
C5A6 <=D@4;?58A=; 5;7 865;?@564;<J A; :5;7 5<L>A?A8A=;6495EA:A858A=;5;764?488:4D4;8<8
5FA;B <=;?A74647 894 5CCA75FA8 CA:47 456:A46 5:=;B HA89 ;;4G>64 5;7 5:?= 894 ?>E?4L>4;8 5CCA75FA8 75847 # 5:=;B HA89 ;;4G>64? 8=
5;7 5:?= <=;?A746A;B 894 7A64<8A=; BAF4; EJ 894 :456;47 A;B:4 $>7B4 H9A:4 7A?@=?A;B =C 894 H6A8 @48A8A=; 7A64<8A=; A? BAF4; 8958 AC 5;JC64?964@64?4;858A=;A?BAF4;<=;?A746894?5D45;7@5?? 5@@6=@6A584=6746 ! ; FA4H =C @5??A;B =C 894 5@@6=@6A584 =6746 5;7 @568A<>:56:J 85IA;B ;=84 =C 894 5F46D4;8? D574 A; @565B65@9 = =C 894 5CCA75FA8 894 ?5D4 A? <=D@:A47 HA89 C A8 A? ;=8 ?58A?CA47EJ894<=D@:5A;5;8?HA898945CCA75FA85;7;;4G>64? 8=A8A?:4C8=@4;8=894D8=L>4?8A=;894?5D4
- 10 -
# 4;<4A;FA4H=C<=D@:A5;<45;75:?=894A??>5;<4 =C456:A46;;4G>645?H4::5?;;4G>64?8==C894 @64?4;8 ;=89A;B ?>6FAF4? C=6 <=;8A;>A;B =C 89A? <=;84D@8 @6=<447A;B? <<=67A;B:J894<=;84D@8@6=<447A;BA? '( )!* $
'( )"* $
A?8=2:=2