- 1 - ! "!# $%!&!&"%% '%( ! " ## $ $ # $ # % " " & '$ ! " ( " " $ $ Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ "#) $ " $ $ ## $ $ * "! # $ * "! # # $ * "! # ## $ $ * "! # + " # %% $ * "! # "! # ) ! $ - 3 - "! # $ ! ! "! # ! ! "! # ! !$$ ! " $ $ #+ ! ! " "! # ! ! " "! # # ! ! " "! # ! "! # + $ $ ! - 4 - # # ! ! "! # ) " ! $ "! # " ! "! # " ! $ )#"$ $$ ## "! ! $ $ $ $ # ! % "! # $! ) - 5 - % "! # # "! # " $ $ %% "! # + ! " "! # * " # "! # ) %, ! # $ % * "! # ! ! - 6 - "! # & '$ "$ " % +- . " . " # #- ) %%. " # / $% ( % + % % % % 0123415 242625 37859:; <70 =4: >:=1=175:09 25? 012@1 $2=1;37859:;<700:9>75?:5=9=7+25? =7 42@:2>>:20:?15>:0975 4:70?:0?2=:? >299:?AB=4: ??; :5170 1@1; !8?C: 25? !% "162B2>802 75 7 25? 7# 15 7 @1?: 55:D80: 19 32;;:? 15=7 E8:9=17515=41901=:=1=175759:@:02;C0785?9299:=78=15 =4::F7025?8F7<01=:=1=175 - 7 - 7859:; <70 =4: 0:9>:3=1@: >20=1:9 80C:? 9:@:02; 375=:5=1759:20?=4:20C8F:5=925?>:089:?=4:01=>2>:09 G1=4320: 8<<13: 1= =7 57=: =42= =4: >;215=1<<9 <1;:? 2 981= <70 >20=1=175 25? 9:>202=: >799:99175 <=:0 =4: 9:0@13: 7< =4: 98FF759 ?:<:5?25=9 =7 + <1;:? 2 G01==:5 9=2=:F:5= = 19 57=:? =42= ?:<:5?25=9 =7 32F: 75 0:370? 75 25 1F>;:2?15C2>>;132=175:53:=4:>;215=1<<G293759=0215:?=7 F7@:252>>;132=17515 7#85?:0 0?:0)8;:25? 7< <70C025=7<=:F>7020B156853=175=70:9=0215?:<:5?25=9 =7<07F2;1:52=15C25?3425C15C=4:52=80:7<=4:981=;25?9 A:2015CB7+H)F:298015C# 30:985=29'85=29 >7=I4202A(25?B7+H F:298015C 30: #85=29 91=82=:? 2= 242;A2C2B2= "162B2>8024: 92F: G29 7>>79:? AB?:<:5?25=9=74:>;215=1<<2;97<1;:?252>>;132=17515 7 85?:0 :3=175 # 7< =7 <1;: 2 0:>;132=175 =7 =4: ?:<:5?25=9J>;:24:012;780=@1?:70?:0?2=:? 0:6:3=:? 725?70?:0:?=42= 7#G1;;A:4:20?25? =2I:5 8> 2;75C G1=4 =4: F215 981= :53: =4: >:=1=175:0 19 A:<70:=419780= - 8 - 7859:; 012@1 $2=1; 15 >0:9:5=15C 419 20C8F:5=9 @:4:F:5=;B 375=:5?:? =42= =4: 012; 780= 42? >299:? =4: 70?:0 75 7 75 :53: =4: 012; 780= 19 689=1<1:? 15 F2I15C 25 70?:0 =42= 7# G1;; A: 37591?:0:?2;75CG1=4=4:F215981=7859:;>;23:?0:;1253:75 =4:<7;;7G15C?:3191759 ( % " K ( ! " ! K # % # 7859:;012@1$2=1;98AF1=9=42=2F:F7429A::5 <1;:? <80519415C =4: 37>B 7< =4: 70?:0 94::= 7< =4: 012; 780= 25? =4: 92F: F2B A: >;23:? 75 0:370? 25? 25 2>>07>012=: 70?:0F2BA:>299:? :F7<80519415C=4:37>B7<=4:70?:094::=7<=4:012; 780=19>;23:?750:370? # >:0892; 7< =4: 70?:0 94::= 7< =4: 012; 780= 0:<;:3=9=42=70?:0G29>299:?75 =19 >1@7=2;=757=:=42==4:1F>;:2?15C2>>;132=175G292;;7G:?75 - 9 - 4: 70?:0 7< G29 >0170 =7 =4: 70?:0 F2?: 75 1F>;:2?15C 2>>;132=175 4: 1F>;:2?15C 2>>;1325=9 G:0: B:= =7 37F: 75 0:370? 29 7< =4: ?2=: 7< =4: 70?:04:5:@:0=:F>7020B156853=1752>>;132=17519F7@:?2 ?8=B 329=9 75 =4: 780= =7 ?19>79: 7< =4: 2>>;132=175 15?:>:5?:5=;B 7G:@:0 15 =4: >0:9:5= 329: =4: 012; 780= ?:<:00:? 4:2015C 7< =4: =:F>7020B 156853=175 2>>;132=175 1: 7# :<:0015C =:F>7020B 156853=175 2>>;132=175 19 1F>:0F1991A;: 4:0:<70: =419 780= ?::F9 1= >07>:0 =7 ?10:3= =4: 012; 780= =7 4:20 75 7# 25? ?19>79: 7< =4: 92F: G1=41575:F75=4<07F=7?2B 9 <20 29 0:6:3=175 7< 7 19 3753:05:? =4: >;215=1<<9 0:E8:9=:? =4: 012; 780= =7 <1;: 0:>;132=175 =7 =4: ?:<:5?25=9J >;:2 5 =4: G01==:5 9=2=:F:5= =4: ?:<:5?25=9 ?:51:? =4: @:0B 0:;2=175941> 4:0:<70: =4: >;215=1<<9 G:0: 3759=0215:?=7F7@:252>>;132=175=7<1;:0:>;132=1754:012; 780= 75 25 :0075:789 2>>07234 3753;8?:? =42= =4: >;215=1<<9 32557= A: >:0F1==:? =7 <1;: 98A9:E8:5= >;:2?15C9 1: 0:>;132=175 9153: =4:0: G29 57 3785=:0 3;21F <07F =4: ?:<:5?25=94191985=:52A;: - 10 - 5?:0 =4: 7?: 7< 1@1; 073:?80: '( L98A9:E8:5= >;:2?15C9M C:5:02;;B 0:<:09 =7 25B >;:2?15C <1;:? 2<=:0 =4: ?:<:5?25=J9G01==:59=2=:F:5=:D3;8?15C=479:0:;2=:?=79:= 7<<703785=:03;21F:>;132=17529>;:2?15C1537FF75;2G19 F2?: AB =4: >;215=1<< 15 25 259G:0 =7 =4: ?:<:5?25=J9 >;:2 8A9:E8:5=>;:2?15C9F1C4=153;8?:20:>;132=175'20:>;B=7=4: G01==:5 9=2=:F:5=( 8A9:E8:5= >;:2?15C9 4:;> 3;201<B =4: 1998:9 25? :5980: 2<210 =012; <=:0 9308=151915C =4: >;215= 25? =4: G01==:5 9=2=:F:5= =4: 780= F2B ?10:3= =4: <1;15C 7< 2 0:>;132=175 29I15C =4: >;215=1<< =7 6715 9>:31<13 >;:2?15C9 =7 2 329:9>:31<132;;B 25? 5:G;B 0219:? AB =4: ?:<:5?25= 15 =4: G01==:59=2=:F:5=4:>;215=1<<3259::I=4:;:2@:7<=4:780= =7<1;:20:>;132=175 :@:0=15C =7 =4: <23=9 7< =4: 329: =4: >;215=1<<9 42@: F2?: 3:0=215 2@:0F:5=9 15 =4: >;215= 4: ?:<:5?25=9 <1;:? 2 ?:=21;:? G01==:5 9=2=:F:5=. ?:51:? =4: >;215= 2@:0F:5=9 25? 9>:31<132;;B ?19>8=:? =4: 0:;2=175941> 4:0:<70: =4: >;215=1<<9 G:0:689=1<1:?150:E8:9=15C=4:780==7<1;:0:>;132=175=7=4: ?:<:5?25=9J >;:2 4: 012; 780= 19 ?10:3=:? =7 >:0F1= =4: >;215=1<<9=7<1;:0:>;132=175 - 11 - 7859:;012@1$2=1;>;23:?0:;1253:75=4:?:3191759 0:<:00:?=798>02$8=?757==415I=4:;2G1975?78A=234 ?:319175=8059751=97G5<23=94:>0:9:5=329:192;97=:9=:? 15=4:;1C4=7<=4:2<70:921??:3191759 + 4: 01= 7< :0=170201 19 70?:0:? 4: 70?:0 ?2=:? >299:? AB =4: ??; :5170 1@1; !8?C: 25? !%"162B2>80275 725? 7#15 7 @1?: 55:D80:19E8294:?4:>;215=1<<920:>:0F1==:?=7<1;: 2 0:>;132=175 =7 =4: ?:<:5?25=9 >;:2 3370?15C;B 7 19 2;;7G:? 4: 012; 780= 19 ?10:3=:? =7 4:20 75 7# 25? ?19>79:7<=4:92F:G1=41575:F75=4<07F=7?2B :98;=25=;B=4:01=:=1=17519 !)* '&"%%( & 19=7 ;7