- 1 - ! "!#!! ! $%&$' ()& $(( * ! ! " # # # $!#!%! & ' ( Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) $!#!%" * % $! + $!#!% & ' ) , * ) ,( ) " '( ) * * %# %% - ) ))#'( ) ) ) * . * - 3 - #! ' . *( /0 1220331456 70849 1::;60< =6 5= # 84 = %# =4 5/0 >830 => 5/0 301?40< <<858=413 0668=46 *;<90 1317;?198 '/0?0841>50? ?0>0??0< 5= 16 @?813 =;?5A( 1?0 8B2;94849 5/0 C;<9B045 => :=4D8:58=4 14< =?<0? => 604504:0 <150< %% :=4D8:5849 5/0B >=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0?0:58=4#'(? E=> 14<604504:8495=;4<0?9=68B2308B2?86=4B045>=?1 20?8=< => 5E= F01?6 14< 5= 21F >840 => 6%%% $ 01:/ E85/<0>1;35=>604504:0 01?< ?8 ;?06/ /14<?16/0G1? 04938 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 1220331456 ?8 =213 ?86/41 1<1D 301?40< 89/ =;?5 =D0?4B045 301<0? >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 =$5150 14< ?8 *198?<1? 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 = 0?;60< 5/0 B150?8136 84:3;<8495/0?813=;?5?0:=?<6 - 4 - 4 D80E => 5/0 ?8D13 :=450458=46 ;?90< 7F 301?40<:=;4603>=?7=5/5/021?58065/02=8455/15E=;3< 1?860>=?BF:=468<0?158=486 F 146E0? 5= 5/0 17=D0 2=845 86 84 5/0 >=?5/0>=33=E849 ! )1:56 => 5/0 :160 84 7?80> 1?0 5/15 ?062=4<045 =16:=B23184145>830<5/0>8?6584>=?B158=4E85/=B14 =38:0 5158=4 1317;?198 1918465 5/0 1::;60< 13309849 :=BB8668=4 => 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=46 #'( !% !% %" !% ? E => 5/0 4<814 0413 =<0 '>=? 6/=?5 @A( 14< 0:58=4 => =E?F ?=/87858=4 :5 '>=? 6/=?5 @ :5A( >50? 84D06589158=4 - 5 - :/1?906/005:1B05=70>830</0301?40<19865?1505==G :=948H14:0 14< :=BB8550< 5/0 B1550? 5= 5/0 0668=46 =;?5 ::;60< /1D0 12201?0< 70>=?0 5/0 ?813 =;?5 2301<0<4=59;835F = 2?=D0 5/0 9;835 => 5/0 1::;60< 5/0 2?=60:;58=4 0I1B840< 6 5= ! 9=5 B1?G0< 5/0 <=:;B0456 16 20? I6 5= ! 84 6;22=?5 => 856 :=450458=4 /0 1::;60< <0480< 133 5/0 84:?8B8415849 B150?8136 1D1831730 =4 ?0:=?< 14< 5/0F /1D0 4=5 30< 14F 0D8<04:0 84 6;22=?5 => 5/08? <0>04:0 =E0D0? 5/0F 9=5 B1?G0< I6 5= " <;?849 :?=66$0I1B84158=4 => 5/0 2?=60:;58=40D8<04:0 " >50?51G849845=:=468<0?158=41335/0B150?8136 =4?0:=?<5/0?813=;?5:1B05=5/0:=4:3;68=45/155/0 2?=60:;58=4 86 6;::066>;3 84 2?=D849 5/0 9;835 => 1::;60< =65=#>=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0?0:58=4#$ ? E => 70F=4< 133 ?016=41730 <=;75 14< 1::=?<8493F :=4D8:50< 14< 604504:0< 16 65150< 17=D0 - 6 - =E0D0? 5/0F E0?0 1:J;8550< >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 ;4<0? 0:58=46!%!%%"? E=>14<0:58=46 14< => :5 7F /=3<849 5/155/02?=60:;58=4 86 4=5 6;::066>;3842?=D8495/09;835=>5/01::;60<>=?5/0618< =>>04:06 0849 199?80D0< 7F 5/0 8B2;940< C;<9B045 => :=4D8:58=4 14< =?<0? => 604504:0 21660< 1918465 5/0B 1::;60<1?070>=?05/86=;?5 # /045/0B1550?8651G04;2>=?>8413<862=613 301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 1220331456 14< ?062=4<045 = 6;7B85 5/15 5/0 <862;50 705E004 1::;60< =6 5= # =4 5/0=40/14<14<?062=4<045==45/0=5/0?/14<86 13?01<F 605530< 1B8:173F 5 86 65150< 5/15 122033145 = 14<?062=4<045=/1D0>830<=" %!=45/0>830 => 5/0 301?40< ?84:8213 865?8:5 *;<90 )1B83F =;?5 1317;?198 600G849 >=? <8D=?:0 7F B;5;13 :=46045 5 86 65150< 5/15 5/0 618< 205858=4 :1B0 5= 70 133=E0< <;?849 *;40 %! 01?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 = 6;7B8565/1520?B14045138B=4F=> 6%%%%% $' ;2006 E=1G/643F( 86218<5=?062=4<045=14<6/0/16 - 7 - 13?01<FB1??80<191844<0?6;:/:8?:;B6514:06301?40< :=;4603 >=? 5/0 ?062=4<045 = 6;7B856 4= =7C0:58=4 5= 133=E5/0122013 /06;7B8668=461?0231:0<=4?0:=?< % /0 ?062=4<045 = 86 5/0 E8>0 => 1::;60< =5/0=5/0?1::;60<1?05/0?03158D06=>1::;60<= /0F E0?0 :=4D8:50< >=? 5/0 =>>04:0 2;486/1730 ;4<0? 0:58=4 #$ ? E => 1G849 845= :=468<0?158=4 5/0:=B2?=B8600450?0<845=705E0045/021?58061B=> 5/0=2848=45/155/0C;<9B045=>:=4D8:58=414<=?<0?=> 604504:0<21660<7F5/0?813=;?5863817305=605168<084 5/0 8450?065 => C;658:0 84:0 5/0 21?5806 /1D0 605530< 1B8:1730 14< 301<849 5/08? =E4 38>0 0360E/0?0 04:0 146E0?5/017=D02=845845/01>>8?B158D014<2?=:00<5= 21665/0>=33=E849 '8( /0?8B84132201386 - 8 - '88( /08B2;940<C;<9B045=>:=4D8:58=414< =?<0? => 04504:0 <150< %% 21660< 84 = %# =4 5/0 >830 => 301?40< <<858=413 0668=46 *;<90 1317;?198 :=4D8:5849 1220331456 1::;60< =65=#>=?5/0=>>04:0;4<0?0:58=4 #'(? E=>86/0?07F605168<0 '888( =460J;0453F 1220331456 1::;60< 1?0 1:J;8550<>=?5/0=>>04:02;486/1730;4<0? 0:58=4#'(? E=> '8D( 1837=4<=>5/01::;60<8>14F14<5/15 =>5/08?6;?058066/1336514<:14:0330< 'D( )8401B=;458>14F<02=6850<7F1::;60< 86 =?<0?0< 5= 70 ?0>;4<0< 5= 5/0B 1>50? 12201320?8=<86=D0? 09865?F 5= 604<71:G 5/0 ?813=;?5 0:=?<6 13=49 E85/:=2F=>5/86C;<9B045>=?84>=?B158=414<>=?400<>;3 1:58=4 +) $!!( # B6? 865=3=