Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65188 (KAR)
SMT. LAXSHMI AND ORS v. K.M. VIKRAM AND ORS
MFA/200745/2020 · 2025-12-01
H T Narendra Prasad, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65188 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65188 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
# $%#
$%!%&! ##
'&( )* ##
)
*
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"
#! $
% &
&'("#
)
*$$$
+
%
, -$- . . $ ("#
,,
- 3 -
/("#
%
, -
-.! % &("#
0+ /
%
,
' , -
-.! % & ("#
$
$,,
("# )
*$%
,1 ,1 ##
'*+ +
, ,
.*+ ,
,
% .### #.#! $ %
, .. ##-
2 #####- 2
- 4 -
)
*
/
$
$
# , / % &
&("# )
*$$$
+
%
, -$- . . $ ("#
- 5 -
,,
/("#
%
, -
-.! % &("# $
0+ /
%
,
' , -
-.! % & ("#
$
$,,
("# )
*$%
,1 ,1 #!#!#
'*+ +
, ,
.*+ ,
,
% .### # #! $ %
- 6 -
, ." ##-
2 #####- 2
,3 , , %
4$
%
4$
%
%
% *
4$
%
+
,5##. ##607899:;<=9>8?@69A=0<B0:@7 <:5#.#!;5C@69>90@65;>9A9079>0:D0EE0 0:D0:0@60:>,5##.##607899:;<=9>8? @69 A=0<B0:@7 <: 5# #! ;5C @69 >90@6 5;
>9A9079> 69F0C0EE0 60:>C0769F0C 89<:D 0DDC<9G9> 8? @69 A5BB5: HI>DB9:@ 0:> 0J0C> >0@9> .### E0779> 8? @69 >><@<5:0= <7@C<A@ 0:> 977<5:7 %I>D9 0:>0<A6IC*;5C765C@K@69C<8I:0=3+
,0A@7 D<G<:D C<79 @5 @69 ;<=<:D 5; @69 0EE90=7 8C<9;=?7@0@9>0C9@60@5:#"#"J69:@69>9A9079> 0:D0EE0 0:D0:0@6 0G0=< J07 C<><:D 0 B5@5CA?A=9 890C<:D C9D<7@C0@<5: 5-
-.! 0:> >9A9079>
- 7 -
69F0C0EE060:>C0769F0C070E<==<5:C<>9CJ69:@69? C90A69> :90C 070=0EIC 5: 0:G< @5 <:>60:IC C50> 0@ 085I@ # @69 >C<G9C 5; @69 0:F9C =5CC? 890C<:D 9D5-$- .A0B9J<@66<D67E99>0:><:0C076 0:>:9D=<D9:@B0::9C>0769>0D0<:7@@69B5@5CA?A=97 0 C97I=@ @69? 85@6 ;9== >5J: 0:> 7I7@0<:9> <:HIC<97 69 >9A9079>69F0C0EE060:>C0769F0C7IAAIB89>@5@69 <:HIC<97 0@ @69 7E5@ <@79=; J69C907 >9A9079> 0:D0EE0 0:D0:0@6 0G0=< 7IAAIB89> @5 @69 <:HIC<97 J6<=9 @0F<:D @C90@B9:@5:@6970B9>0? 69 A=0<B0:@7 5; 85@6 @69 >9A9079> ;<=9> E9@<@<5:7 I:>9C 9A@<5: 5; @69 5@5C 96<A=97 A@ 799F<:DA5BE9:70@<5:;5C@69>90@65;@69>9A9079>0=5:D J<@6<:@9C97@
E5:79CG<A95;:5@<A9C97E5:>9:@570:> 60G9 0EE90C9> @6C5ID6 A5I:79= 0:> ;<=9> @69<C JC<@@9:
7@0@9B9:@7 >9:?<:D @69 0G9CB9:@7 B0>9 <: @69 A=0<B E9@<@<5:97E5:>9:@5*0+J07E=0A9>9L-E0C@9
- 8 -
:@69807<75;@69E=90><:D75;@69E0C@<97@69 =0<B7 C<8I:0= ;C0B9> @69 <77I97 <: 85@6 @69 A0797 0:> @69C90;@9C C9A5C>9> @69 9G<>9:A9 69 C<8I:0= 8? @69 <BEID:9> A5BB5: HI>DB9:@ 0:> 0J0C> 607 E0C@=? 0==5J9>@69A=0<BE9@<@<5:70:>69=>@60@@69A=0<B0:@7<:
5#.#! 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 @5@0= A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7..###-0=5:DJ<@6<:@9C97@0@@69C0@95;"2E0 0:> ><C9A@9> C97E5:>9:@ 57 0:> @5 >9E57<@ .#2 5;
@69 @5@0= A5BE9:70@<5: 0:> ><C9A@9> C97E5:>9:@ 5 89<:D @69 <:7IC9C 5; 5;;9:><:D 0:F9C @5 >9E57<@ A5BE9:70@<5:0B5I:@0=5:DJ<@6<:@9C97@
<F9J<79 @69 A=0<B0:@7 <: 5# #!
0C99:@<@=9>@5@5@0=A5BE9:70@<5:5;7." ##-0=5:D J<@6 <:@9C97@ 0@ @69 C0@9 5; "2 E0 0:> ><C9A@9> C97E5:>9:@ 57 0:> @5 E0? .#2 5; @69 @5@0= A5BE9:70@<5:0:>;IC@69C><C9A@9>C97E5:>9:@570:> @5E0?C9B0<:<:D#25;@69A5BE9:70@<5:0B5I:@0=5:D J<@6 <:@9C97@ 0:> ><C9A@9> C97E5:>9:@ 57 0:> 89<:D @69 <:7IC9C7 5; @69 5;;9:><:D G96<A=97 @5 >9E57<@ @69
- 9 -
A5BE9:70@<5: 0B5I:@ $9<:D 0DDC<9G9> @69 EC979:@ 0EE90=760G9899:;<=9> . 69 =90C:9> A5I:79= ;5C @69 A=0<B0:@7 607 C0<79>@69;5==5J<:DA5:@9:@<5:7 0+ ,<C7@=? 0AA<>9:@ 607 5AAICC9> >I9 @5 @69 :9D=<D9:A9 5;>C<G9C5;@69@0:F9C=5CC?9A0B9@5@699L@C9B9C<D6@ 7<>90:>>0769>@5@69B5@5CA?A=969C<8I:0=6079CC9> <:65=><:D@60@C<>9C5;@69B5@5CA?A=96070=75A5:@C<8I@9> @5@699L@9:@5;#2 8+ 9A5:>=? <BB9><0@9=? 0;@9C @69 0AA<>9:@ @69 A5BE=0<:@607899:=5>D9>0D0<:7@@69>C<G9C5;@69=5CC? 69A=0<B0:@0=759L0B<:9> J65<7@699?9J<@:977@5 @690AA<>9:@9607A0@9D5C<A0==?7@0@9>@60@>C<G9C5;@69 =5CC? J07 :9D=<D9:@ <: A0I7<:D @69 0AA<>9:@ 7 E9C @69 7E5@060M0C9E5C@0:>@697F9@A6<@<7A=90C@60@ >C<G9C5;@69=5CC?J07:9D=<D9:@<:A0I7<:D@690AA<>9:@ A+ 6<C>=? @69 A=0<B0:@7 <: 5# #! 0779C@ @60@@69>9A9079>69F0C0EE0J070D9>085I@"?90C70@
- 10 -
@69 @<B9 5; @69 0AA<>9:@ 0:> 60> 0 B5:@6=? <:A5B9 5; 7###-8?J5CF<:D070075:69A=0<B0:@7<: 5#.#!A5:@9:>9>@60@@69>9A9079>0:D0EE0J07 0D9> 085I@ ?90C7 0@ @69 @<B9 5; 0AA<>9:@ 0:> J07 90C:<:D B5:@6=? <:A5B9 5; 7###- 8? J5CF<:D 07 0 075: 5J9G9C @69 077977B9:@ 5; B5:@6=? <:A5B9 5;
85@6 @69 >9A9079> 0@ 7!###- 8? @69 C<8I:0= <7 I:HI7@<;<9>0:>9CC5:95I7 >+ ,5IC@6=? 7<:A9 @69C9 0C9 ;5IC A=0<B0:@7 <:
5# #! @69 C<8I:0= 607 JC5:D=?>9>IA@9> C>5;
@69 <:A5B9 5; @69 >9A9079> @5J0C>7 E9C75:0= 9LE9:797 <:7@90>5;@6 9+ 7E9C@69HI>DB9:@5;@695:38=9IEC9B95IC@<:
@69 A079 5; !" # $ " !%" &' (
' 90A6 5; @69 A=0<B0:@7 <: 85@6 @69 A0797 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7####- I:>9C @69 690> 5; K=577 5; =5G90:>0;;9A@<5:0:>A5:75C@<IB3
- 11 -
;+ 07@=? A5:7<>9C<:D @69 0D9 0:> 0G5A0@<5: 5; @69 >9A9079> <: 85@6 @69 A0797 @69 5G9C0== A5BE9:70@<5:
0J0C>9> 8? @69 C<8I:0= <7 <:0>9NI0@9 0:> 5: @69 =5J9C 7<>9 <@6 @69 085G9 A5:@9:@<5:7 @69 =90C:9> A5I:79= 75ID6@@50==5J@690EE90=7
" : @69 5@69C 60:> @69 =90C:9> A5I:79= ;5C C97E5:>9:@5-:<@9>:><0:7IC0:A95BE0:? <B<@9> 607C0<79>@69;5==5J<:DA5I:@9C-A5:@9:@<5:7 0+ ,<C7@=? 0AA<>9:@ 607 5AAICC9> >I9 @5 @69 :9D=<D9:A9 5; @69 >C<G9C 5; @69 =5CC? 07 J9== 07 @69 C<>9C 5; @69 B5@5CA?A=9 8+ 9A5:>=?07E9C7E5@B060M0C0:>7F9@A6@69J<>@6 5; @69 C50> J07 # ;@ 69 C<>9C 5; @69 B5@5CA?A=9 J07 C<><:D@69B5@5CA?A=9<:@69B<>>=95;@69C50>69C9J07 7I;;<A<9:@7E0A95:@69=9;@7<>95;@69B5@5CA?A=90:>69 J07 A5B<:D <: 6<D6 7E99> 0:> <: C076 0:> :9D=<D9:@ B0::9C0:>>0769>@5@69=5CC?69E5=<A9C9D<7@9C9>@69 , 0D0<:7@ @69>C<G9C 5;@69 =5CC?07 J9== 07 @69C<>9C5;
@69 B5@5CA?A=9 0:> ;<=9> @69 A60CD9 7699@ 0D0<:7@ @69
- 12 -
>C<G9C 5; @69 =5CC?
0:> 080@9> A60CD9 7699@ 0D0<:7@ @69 C<>9C 5; @69 B5@5CA?A=9 5:7<>9C<:D @6<7 07E9A@ 5; @69 B0@@9C 0:> A5:7<>9C<:D @69 7F9@A6 B0E 9E5C@ 0:> 7E5@B060M0C@69C<8I:0=607C<D6@=?69=>@60@>C<G9C5; @69=5CC?607A5:@C<8I@9>@50:9L@9:@5;.#20:>C<>9C5;
B5@5CA?A=9 607 A5:@C<8I@9> @5 0: 9L@9:@ 5; #2 @5 @69 0AA<>9:@ A+ 6<C>=? 0=@65ID6 @69 A=0<B0:@7 A=0<B @60@ @69 85@6 @69 >9A9079> J9C9 90C:<:D 7###- E9C B5:@6 @69? 60G9 ;0<=9> @5 7I87@0:@<0@9 @69<C A=0<B J<@6 7IEE5C@<:D >5AIB9:@7 5:79NI9:@=? @69 C<8I:0= 607 A5CC9A@=? 0779779>@69<:A5B95;@69>9A9079>:5@<5:0==? >+ ,5IC@6=? 5: 0EEC9A<0@<5: 5; 5C0= 0:> >5AIB9:@0C? 9G<>9:A9 0:> A5:7<>9C<:D @69 0D9 0:> 0G5A0@<5: 5; @69 >9A9079> @69 5G9C0== A5BE9:70@<5: 0J0C>9> 8? @69 C<8I:0=<:85@6@69A0797<7HI7@0:>C9075:08=9 9+ 07@=?<:=<D6@5;@69<G<7<5:$9:A6>9A<7<5:5;@6<7 5IC@ <: @69 A079 5; ( ! ) " *!% +,- ,.!% , " *!%
- 13 -
!@69C0@95;
<:@9C97@ 0J0C>9> 8? @69 C<8I:0= 0@ "2 E0 5: @69 A5BE9:70@<5: 0B5I:@ <7 5: @69 6<D69C 7<>9 <@6 @69 085G9A5:@9:@<5:7@69=90C:9>A5I:79=75ID6@@5><7B<77 @690EE90=7 ! 90C> @69 =90C:9> A5I:79= ;5C @69 E0C@<97 0:> E9CI79>@69HI>DB9:@0:>0J0C>5;@69C<8I:0= # 69A0795;@69A=0<B0:@7<7@60@5:#"#" >9A9079>69F0C0EE00:>0:D0EE0J9C9EC5A99><:D5:0 B5@5CA?A=9 890C<:D 9D5-
-.! J6<A6 J07 C<>>9: 8? >9A9079> 0:D0EE0 0:> 69F0C0EE0 J07 0 E<==<5:C<>9C 69:@69?C90A69>:90C070=0EIC5:0:G< @5 <:>60:IC 0@ 085I@ # @69 >C<G9C 5; @69 =5CC? A0B9 J<@6 6<D6 7E99> 0:> <: C076 0:> :9D=<D9:@ B0::9C 0:> >0769> 0D0<:7@ @69 B5@5CA?A=9 I9 @5 @69 70<> 0AA<>9:@ @69? ;9== >5J: 0:> 7I7@0<:9> <:HIC<97 0:> 7IAAIB89> @5 @69 <:HIC<97 5 EC5G9 @69<C A079 @69 A=0<B0:@7 60G9 9L0B<:9> B@ 0F76B< 07 0:> B@0B0=0BB007 0:>5:99?9J<@:977C<0:@576
- 14 -
07
7 0:> 60G9 C9<@9C0@9> @69 7@0@9B9:@7 B0>9 <: @69 A=0<B E9@<@<5:
607 A0@9D5C<A0==?7@0@9> @60@0AA<>9:@6075AAICC9>>I9@5:9D=<D9:A95;@69>C<G9C 5;@69=5CC? :>9C @69 5@5C 96<A=97 A@ <: @69 A=0<B E9@<@<5:89;5C9@69=0<B7C<8I:0=@697@0:>0C>5;EC55;<7 BIA6 89=5J @60: J60@ <7 C9NI<C9> <: 0 AC<B<:0= A079 07 J9== 07 <: @69 A<G<= A079 5 >5I8@ 89;5C9 @69 C<8I:0= @69C9 BI7@ 89 75B9 B0@9C<0= 5: @69 807<7 5; J6<A6 @69 C<8I:0= A0: 0CC<G9 5C >9A<>9 @6<:D7 :9A9770C? @5 >9A<>9 ;5C 0J0C><:D A5BE9:70@<5: 8I@ @69 C<8I:0= <7 :5@ 9LE9A@9>@5@0F95C@50>5E@0:<A9@?5;0A<G<=5CAC<B<:0= A079 ;@9C 0== <@ <7 0 7IBB0C? 9:NI<C?
0:> <@ <7 @69 =9D<7=0@<5:;5C@69J9=;0C95;@695A<9@?69EC5A99><:D7 I:>9C @69 5@5C 96<A=97 A@ 0C9 :5@ 0F<: @5 @69 EC5A99><:D7 I:>9C A<G<= CI=97 9:A9 7@C<A@ CI=97 5; 9G<>9:A90C9:5@C9NI<C9>@589;5==5J9><:@6<7C9D0C>: @69A0795;+,
- 15 -
#! ' -( ! @69 5:38=9 E9L5IC@60769=>0769C9<:89=5J
" # $% ! & $ '( (% $ )& & * %(+ ,) ) -, & .-$% & & & ) /$ & (% 0 &.&$!&)*!& -*%1&$*0 & 0 0 & ! (!(%&)00%0) $ $ &( % .& $ & % % & & * & %($0&-'(-,&.-$%
& $&
--%, %, & -, -% $- $% &* - %2
BB9><0@9=? 0;@9C @69 0AA<>9:@ A079 J07 C9D<7@9C9>0D0<:7@@69>C<G9C5;@69=5CC?0:>C<>9C5;@69 B5@5CA?A=960CD97699@<70=75;<=9>0D0<:7@@69>C<G9C5;
- 16 -
@69=5CC?0:>080@9>A60CD97699@0D0<:7@@69C<>9C5;@69 B5@5CA?A=9 ./ 01203045
960G9E9CI79>@697E5@B060M0C*
L+7 E9C
L 0AA<>9:@ @55F E=0A9 5: 0:G<-<:>60:IC 6<D6J0?F9@A6I:>9C
LC9G90=7@60@C50><77@C0<D6@ C50> B907IC<:D #;@ J<>9 69 E=0A9 5; 0AA<>9:@ <7 >9E<A@9> 0@ 0 ><7@0:A9 5; ;@ ;C5B @69 =9;@ 9>D9 5; @69 C50>J6<A6EC5A99>7;C5B0:G<@5J0C>7<:>60:IC@<7 0: I:><7EI@9> ;0A@ @60@ @69 >9A9079> E9C75:7 J9C9 EC5A99><:D5:0B5@5CA?A=9;C5B0:G<@5J0C>7<:>60:IC 0:> @69 @0:F9C A0B9 ;C5B 5EE57<@9 ><C9A@<5: 7 E9C @69 7F9@A6 <@ <7 G9C? A=90C @60@ @69 >C<G9C 5; @69 5;;9:><:D @0:F9C 607 A5B9 @5 @69 9L@C9B9 C<D6@ 7<>9 0:> >0769> 0D0<:7@@69B5@5CA?A=9@<7G9C?A=90C@60@>C<G9C5;@69 =5CC? J07 :9D=<D9:@ <: A0I7<:D @69 0AA<>9:@ 5 ><7EC5G9 @69A0795;@69A=0<B0:@7@69:7IC0:A95BE0:?607:5@ 9L0B<:9> @69 >C<G9C 5; @69 =5CC? 69? 60G9 9L0B<:9>
J65 <7 @69 5;;<A9C 5; C97E5:>9:@ 5 :7IC0:A9
- 17 -
5BE0:? 5:7<>9C<:D @69 7E5@ B060M0C C9E5C@ 9G<>9:A95; J90C95;@695E<:<5:@60@0AA<>9:@607 5AAICC9>75=9=?>I9@5@69:9D=<D9:A95;@69>C<G9C5;@69 =5CC? ./ 67184799:.8;1408
8&
) <
69 A=0<B0:@7 A=0<B @60@ >9A9079> 0:D0EE0 J0790C:<:D7###-E9CB5:@68I@;0<=9>@5EC5>IA9 7IEE5C@<:D>5AIB9:@7@57I87@0:@<0@9@69<CA=0<B:@69 0879:A95;EC55;5;<:A5B9@69:5@<5:0=<:A5B9607@589 0779779> AA5C><:D @5 @69 DI<>9=<:97 <77I9> 8? @69 0C:0@0F0 @0@9 9D0= 9CG<A97 I@65C<@? ;5C 0AA<>9:@7 5AAICC9> <: @69 ?90C #" @69 :5@<5:0= <:A5B9 5; @69 >9A9079> 760== 89 @0F9: 0@ 7.#- EB 5 @69 0;5C970<> <:A5B9 #2 607 @5 89 0>>9> 5: 0AA5I:@ 5;
;I@IC9 EC57E9A@7 <: G<9J 5; @69 =0J =0<> >5J: 8? @69 5:7@<@I@<5: $9:A6 5; @69 IEC9B9 5IC@ <: =! !" -#-/0!% "*!%1$ &
0 &
23 6I7 @69 B5:@6=?
<:A5B9 A5B97 @5
- 18 -
7 #- <:A9 @69C9 0C9 # >9E9:>9:@7 <@ <7 0EEC5EC<0@9@5>9>IA@@65;@69<:A5B95;@69>9A9079> @5J0C>7E9C75:0=9LE9:7970:>C9B0<:<:D0B5I:@607@5 89@0F9:076<7A5:@C<8I@<5:@5@69;0B<=?69>9A9079> J070D9>085I@ ?90C70@@69@<B95;@690AA<>9:@0:> BI=@<E=<9C 0EE=<A08=9 @5 6<7 0D9 DC5IE <7 K3 6I7 @69 A=0<B0:@7 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7#.#- *7 #OOO+ 5: 0AA5I:@ 5; K=577 5; >9E9:>9:A?3 : 0>><@<5: @69 A=0<B0:@7 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 A5BE9:70@<5:5;7###-5:0AA5I:@5;K=5775;97@0@93 0:> A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7###- 5: 0AA5I:@ 5; K;I:9C0= 9LE9:7973=0<B0:@5J<;95;@69>9A9079><79:@<@=9> ;5CA5BE9:70@<5:5;7####-I:>9C@69690>5;4=5775; 7E5I70=A5:75C@<IB4 : G<9J 5; @69 =0J =0<> >5J: 8? @69 IEC9B9 5IC@ <: @69 A079 5; 4
!" 3+ *7IEC0+ A=0<B0:@ 57 0:> E0C9:@7 5; @69 >9A9079> 0C9 9:@<@=9> ;5C A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7####-
- 19 -
90A6I:>9C@69690>5;K=5775;;<=<0=A5:75C@<IB3=0<B0:@ 57 @5 A6<=>C9: 5; @69 >9A9079> 0C9 9:@<@=9> ;5C A5BE9:70@<5:5;7####-90A6I:>9C@69690>5;K=577 5;E0C9:@0=A5:75C@<IB3 . 6I7@69A=0<B0:@70C99:@<@=9>@5@69;5==5J<:D A5BE9:70@<5: 9:.8;140878>.? >0.?.84.1>; 978408 ';( 5775;>9E9:>9:A? #.# ,I:9C0=9LE9:797 ### 5775;97@0@9 ### 5775;7E5I70=A5:75C@<IB #### 5775;0C9:@0=A5:75C@<IB #### 5775;,<=<0=A5:75C@<IB
"#### 413
"<"
8& ) <
" 69A=0<B0:@7A=0<B@60@>9A9079>69F0C0EE0 J0790C:<:D7###-E9CB5:@68I@;0<=9>@5EC5>IA9 7IEE5C@<:D>5AIB9:@7@57I87@0:@<0@9@69<CA=0<B:@69
- 20 -
0879:A95;EC55;5;<:A5B9@69:5@<5:0=<:A5B9607@589 0779779> AA5C><:D @5 @69 DI<>9=<:97 <77I9> 8? @69 0C:0@0F0 @0@9 9D0= 9CG<A97 I@65C<@? ;5C 0AA<>9:@7 5AAICC9> <: @69 ?90C #" @69 :5@<5:0= <:A5B9 5; @69 >9A9079> 760== 89 @0F9: 0@ 7.#- EB 5 @69 0;5C970<> <:A5B9 #2 607 @5 89 0>>9> 5: 0AA5I:@ 5;
;I@IC9 EC57E9A@7 <: G<9J 5; @69 =0J =0<> >5J: 8? @69 5:7@<@I@<5: $9:A6 5; @69 IEC9B9 5IC@ <: =/ 0!% 5 *7IEC0+ 6I7 @69 B5:@6=? <:A5B9 A5B97 @5 7 #- <:A9 @69C9 0C9 # >9E9:>9:@7 <@ <7 0EEC5EC<0@9@5>9>IA@@65;@69<:A5B95;@69>9A9079> @5J0C>7E9C75:0=9LE9:7970:>C9B0<:<:D0B5I:@607@5 89@0F9:076<7A5:@C<8I@<5:@5@69;0B<=?69>9A9079> J070D9>085I@"?90C70@@69@<B95;@690AA<>9:@0:> BI=@<E=<9C 0EE=<A08=9 @5 6<7 0D9 DC5IE <7 K.3 6I7 @69 A=0<B0:@7 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7 "#- *7 #OO.O+ 5: 0AA5I:@ 5; K=577 5; >9E9:>9:A?3
- 21 -
! : 0>><@<5: @69 A=0<B0:@7 0C9 9:@<@=9> @5 A5BE9:70@<5:5;7###-5:0AA5I:@5;K=5775;97@0@93 0:> A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7###- 5: 0AA5I:@ 5; K;I:9C0= 9LE9:7973=0<B0:@5J<;95;@69>9A9079><79:@<@=9> ;5CA5BE9:70@<5:5;7####-I:>9C@69690>5;4=5775; 7E5I70=A5:75C@<IB4 # : G<9J 5; @69 =0J =0<> >5J: 8? @69 IEC9B9 5IC@ <: @69 A079 5; 4
!" 3+ *7IEC0+ A=0<B0:@ 57 0:> E0C9:@7 5; @69 >9A9079> 0C9 9:@<@=9> ;5C A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7####- 90A6I:>9C@69690>5;K=5775;;<=<0=A5:75C@<IB3=0<B0:@ 5->0ID6@9C 5; @69 >9A9079> <7 9:@<@=9> ;5C A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7####- I:>9C @69 690> 5; K=577 5; E0C9:@0=A5:75C@<IB3 6I7@69A=0<B0:@70C99:@<@=9>@5@69;5==5J<:D A5BE9:70@<5: 9:.8;140878>.?
>0.?.84.1>; 978408 ';( 5775;>9E9:>9:A? "#
- 22 -
,I:9C0=9LE9:797 ### 5775;97@0@9 ### 5775;7E5I70=A5:75C@<IB #### 5775;0C9:@0=A5:75C@<IB #### 5775;,<=<0=A5:75C@<IB
"#### 413
""-
:@69C97I=@@69;5==5J<:D5C>9C<7E0779>
690EE90=70C9 6" ! 8+ 69HI>DB9:@5;@69=0<B7C<8I:0=<7B5><;<9> A+ 69A=0<B0:@7<:5#.#!0C99:@<@=9>@50 @5@0= A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7
"<"
- 07 0D0<:7@ 7..###-0J0C>9>8?@69C<8I:0= >+ 69A=0<B0:@7<:5# #!0C99:@<@=9>@50 @5@0= A5BE9:70@<5: 5; 7
""-- 07 0D0<:7@ 7." ##-0J0C>9>8?@69C<8I:0= 9+ ,5==5J<:D@69HI>DB9:@5;@69<G<7<5:$9:A65;@6<7 5IC@<:@69A0795;= ( !) 5*7IEC0+"@69
- 23 -
9:60:A9> A5BE9:70@<5: 760== A0CC? <:@9C97@ 0@ 2 E0 ;+ 97E5:>9:@ 5-:7IC0:A9 5BE0:? <7 ><C9A@9> @5 >9E57<@ @69 9:@<C9 A5BE9:70@<5: 0B5I:@ 0=5:D J<@6 <:@9C97@ 0@ 2 E0 ;C5B @69 >0@9 5; ;<=<:D 5; @69 A=0<B E9@<@<5: @<== @69 >0@9 5; C90=<M0@<5: J<@6<: 0 E9C<5>5;7<LJ99F7;C5B@69>0@95;C9A9<E@5;0A5E? 5;@6<7HI>DB9:@ D+ 69 0EE5C@<5:B9:@ >9E57<@ 0:> C9=9079 5; 0B5I:@ 760== 89 B0>9 <: 0AA5C>0:A9 J<@6 @69 @9CB7 5; @69 0J0C>5;@69C<8I:0=
>) '#( %
>) '!%&!( %
<7@5=5 "