Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65184 (KAR)
MANISHA AND ORS v. DADABHAU AND ANR
MFA/201264/2024 · 2025-11-20
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65184 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65184 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#
$!%!&!! !!&&
'# ( )
! "
# $
" ! %
!! !&!! &
$!'# "
(!! )&&$ $*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&
+ +
#!!!& $
&
!) * '#
$! $!'# "
(! )& $+, $#! *
++
%)*+ $ ! &+ ! " !& !! $
'$ $!$
!! +
$
-&
! %
./01. 2.3 455346 78 678239 :/; 49<7887/= >72. 2.3 ?/=83=2/:634;=39?/0=836:/;@/2.2.354;2738727824A3= 05:/;:7=469785/846
.78 455346 78 :7639 4147=82 2.3 B091<3=2 4=9 4>4;9 94239 " 548839 @C 2.3 !;7=?7546 3=7/;
- 3 -
7D76 0913 4=9 '$ $7B4C450;4 7= $ / /:
=3
4E<4= / 48.4;42. 423 <32 >72. 4= 4??793=2 /= 4=9 808247=39 1;73D/08 7=B0;738 4=980??0<@392/2.384<3.3;3:/;3.78>7:3?.769;3= 4=9 54;3=28 :7639 4 ?647< 532727/= @3:/;3 2.3 ;7@0=46 ?647<7=1 ?/<53=8427/= /: 8"#' .3 ;7@0=46 ?/=8793;7=1 2.3 3=27;3 3D793=?3 /= ;3?/;9 1;4=239 ?/<53=8427/= /: 8F"' >72. 7=23;382 42 "G 54 :;/< 2.3 9423 /: 532727/= 2766 ;34678427/= 4=9 97;3?239 ;385/=93=2/'=80;4=?3/<54=C2/935/8722.384<3
11;73D39@C2.38479B091<3=24=94>4;92.3 ?647<4=28 .4D3 5;3:3;;39 2.78 455346 7= >.7?. 72 78 ?/=23=9392.422.393?34839>4834;=7=18'53; </=2.@C9/7=12476/;7=1>/;A@022.3;7@0=46.4824A3= .78 7=?/<3 /=6C 42 8%#' 53; </=2. +020;3 5;/853?28 >48 =/2 49939 >.763 ?46?06427=1 2.3 6/88 /:
9353=93=?C 4=9 5;/53; 4</0=28 4;3 =/2 4>4;939 0=93;
- 4 -
?/=D3=27/=46 .3498 .3;3:/;3 ;3H038239 :/; 3=.4=?3<3=2/:?/<53=8427/= # 34;92.34;10<3=28/:@/2.87938
" ./01.2.34553664=288242392.422.393?34839 >48 34;=7=1 8' 53; </=2. 2.3C .4D3 =/2 :7639 4=C 7=?/<3 5;//: .3;3:/;3 2.3 ;7@0=46 .48 ;71.26C 24A3=.78=/27/=467=?/<3428%#'53;</=2.4853;
2.3 1079367=38 /: 2.3 4;=424A4 2423
3146 3;D7?38 02./;72C 48 2.3 4??793=2 78 /: 2.3 C34; .3 >48 413 /: 2.3 93?34839 >48 24A3= 48 C34;8 4=9 2.3 <06275673;>48;71.26C24A3=48I#J853;2.3?72427/=/:
2.3 /=J@6353E/0;27=
?/=8793;7=1 2.3 413 /: 2.3 93?34839 #G /: 2.3 7=?/<3 78 2/ @3 49939 2/>4;98 :020;3 5;/853?28 4=9 48 2.3;3 4;3 " 9353=93=28 2.3 ;7@0=46 .48 ;71.26C 9390?39 2. 2/>4;98 53;8/=46 3E53=838 /: 2.3 93?34839 .08 2.3 6/88 /: 9353=93=?C ?/<382/
1 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 5 -
8%# K #G L 8% E E # E L 8 ' % +0;2.3; 48 53; 2.3 1079367=38 /: 2.3 /=J@63 53E /0;2 7=
! " 4=9 #
$ % & $ ' 4553664=2 / @37=1 2.3 >7:3 /: 2.3 93?34839 78 3=272639 :/; 8' 2/>4;98 6/88 /: 85/0846 ?/=8/;270< 4553664=2 /8 2/ @37=1 2.3 ?.769;3= /: 2.3 93?34839 4;33=272639:/;8'34?.2/>4;986/88/:54;3=246 ?/=8/;270<4=94553664=2/8#4=9"@37=12.354;3=28/: 2.3 93?34839 4;3 3=272639 :/; 8' 34?.
2/>4;98 6/88/::76746?/=8/;270<
.3C 4;3 468/ 3=272639 :/; 4= 4</0=2 /:
8' 0=93; 2.3 ?/=D3=27/=46 .3498 73 6/88 /:
2 (2018) 18 SCC 130 3 (2020) 9 SCC 644
- 6 -
3824234=9:0=3;463E53=8384853;2.3?72427/=7=2.3?483 /:)05;4* F 3=?3 2.3 ?/<53=8427/= 78 ;348838839 48 0=93; /88/:9353=93=?C 8 ' /88/:?/=8/;270< 8"' /=D3=27/=46.3498 8' /246 3884>4;939@C2.3;7@0=46 8"% ' 8F"' *+,*-./-01.*2,34* 256
.3 =80;4=?3 /<54=C .48 46;349C 935/87239 2.3 4</0=24>4;939@C2.3;7@0=46.082.34553664=284;3 3=272639:/;3=.4=?39?/<53=8427/=/:8"F '>72. 7=23;38242"G54:;/<2.39423/:532727/=2766;3467M427/= 4=92.3;3:/;32.34553469383;D382/@3466/>397=54;2 =2.3;380622.3:/66/>7=1/;93;78548839 )7* .345534678466/>397=54;2 )77* .3 4553664=28 4;3 3=272639 :/; 3=.4=?39 ?/<53=8427/= /: 8"F '46/=1 >72. 7=23;382 42"G 54:;/<2.39423/:532727/=2766;3467M427/= />3D3;48
- 7 -
53; /;93; 94239 # 2.3 4553664=28 4;3 =/2 3=272639:/;7=23;382:/;2.39364C3953;7/9/:"94C87= :767=12.3455346 )777* 385/=93=2 /'=80;4=?3 /<54=C 78 97;3?239 2/ 935/872 2.3 4:/;38479 ?/<53=8427/= 4</0=2 >72.7=/=3</=2.:;/<2.39423/:2.78B091<3=2 )7D* =80?.935/8724553664=2/@37=12.3>7:3 /: 2.3 93?34839 78 53;<72239 2/ >72.9;4> 2.3 3=27;3 4</0=246/=1>72.7=23;3824??;039/=72
2/6 '&!! ( %
782/6/"