Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65176 (KAR)
LAXMAN v. SHRISHAIL AND ORS
CRP/200122/2023 · 2025-08-19
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65176 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65176 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"
#$% & $& &&
' ( )
!"#$% &
' (
)
%
"'*)% +
"',)%
"
"!%#!%#% Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"'-)%
"
%%
%"')%
+ %
%
+
! !"#$%
$%
+
"
+
!"#$%
%
+
+
!"#$%
%
$"
- 3 -
!"#$%
!%
+ +
+
!"#$%
.%
+
!"#$%
%
+
/ !"#$%
0%
+ $
!"#$% &
' ( "')1
( 0
"')$. 1
"' )
"')1
+1
- 4 -
. (( )
(
"" (
+
(
"0%#.%#
%% % !#"! ( (
%
( ( +
/ ( (
( ( %
(
+
2%
345 6745489 6:4:489 45 ;4<6= -3*<<69>49> :36 8?=6? =*:6= "0%#.%# @*556= 49 % 8%!#"! ,A :36 ==4:489*<6948? 474<B=>6*9= 4C*A*@B?*D36?649 :36 *@@<4-*:489 ;4<6= ,A :36 @6:4:4896? =6;69=*9: 8% B9=6? ?=6?B<6""8;
-*E6:8,6?6C6-:6=%
% 6*?=<6*?96=6948? 8B956<;8?:36@6:4:4896? *9=<6*?96=-8B956<5;8??65@89=69:85%"*9=!%
$% 65@89=69: 8%" @<*49:4;; 3*5 ;4<6= * 5B4: 49 %%8%!#"! *>*495: @6:4:4896? *9= ?65@89=69: 85%
- 5 -
:8 % 36 5*4= 5B4: 45 ;4<6= 566F49> =6-<*?*:489 :3*: :36 @<*49:4;; ?65@89=69: 8" 36?649 45 69:4:<6= :8 ?6:*49 :36 53*?658;=6;69=*9:85%":8$,A74?:B68;@?66E@:476 ?4>3:%36@?*A6?E*=649:36@<*49:?6*=5:3B51
! "#"#"$%& '( ) * )
+ ',
( (
' )
-
+. % 65@89=69: 8%" @<*49:4;;G5 545:6?5 4%6% *74:3?4*9=4C*A<*HE43*76;4<6=*5B4:;8?@*?:4:489*9= 56@*?*:6@85565548949 %%8%.0##.89:36;4<68;:36 ==4:489*< 6948? 474< B=>6 4C*A*@B?* *>*495: :36
- 6 -
@<*49:4;; *9= 8:36? 9496 @6?5895% :36? @6?5895 4%6% =6;69=*9: 85%" :8 $ 3*76 ;4<6= -8B9:6? -<*4E 566F49> *<<8:E69: 8; :364? 53*?65% 36 5*4= 5B4: -*E6 :8 ,6 =6-?66=% 65@89=69: 8%" @<*49:4;; 3*= ;4<6=
8%$.#" *9= 8%$0#" *9= :36A D6?6 @69=49> ,6;8?6
==4:489*< 45:?4-: *9= 6554895 B=>6 4C*A*@B?*-3*<<69>49>:36CB=>E69:*9==6-?66@*556=49 %%8%.0##.% 8:3 *@@6*<5 -*E6 :8 ,6 *<<8D6= E8=4;A49> 53*?65 8; @*?:465% 36 @<*49:4;; @?6;6??6= 8%###0##"! *9= 8%###0"#"! ,6;8?6 :345
8B?:-3*<<69>49>:36CB=>E69:@*556=4985%$.#" *9=$0#"%
6;69=*9:85%":8$3*76*554>96=:364? 53*?65=6-<*?6=4985%$.#"*9=$0#"49;*78? 8; =6;69=*9: 8% ;8? 5BE 8; 5%".###/ 89 $%"%#",A?6>45:6?6=554>9E69:
66=@6?:*4949>:8 5B4:@?8@6?:A%36=6;69=*9:8%/@6:4:4896?36?6493*= ;4<6= (
8%0#"! ;8? 69;8?-49> 53*?65 *554>96= ,A =6;69=*9:85%":8$:834E%365*4=554>9E69:
66= 3*5 ,669 6H6-B:6= =B?49> :36 @69=69-A 8;
- 7 -
8%###0##"!% 65@89=69: 8%" 3*5 58B>3: ?6<46; 8; @?6/6E@:489:8?6:*4953*?658;=6;69=*9:85%":8$D38 3*76*554>96=:364?53*?6549;*78?8;=6;69=*9:8D38 45 @6:4:4896? 36?649 ,A 554>9E69: 66= =*:6= $%"%#"% 36 5*4= 5B4: 45 ;4<6= 89 "!%"%#"!% 36 -*B56 8; *-:489 5:*:6= 49 :36 5B4: 45 =*:6 8; 554>9E69:
66= 6H6-B:6= ,A =6;69=*9: 85%" :8 $ 49 ;*78? 8; =6;69=*9:8%=*:6=$%"%#"%
% 769:38B>3:36@?*A6?E*=649:365B4:4598: 3*@@4<AD8?=6=,B:?6<46;-<*4E6=,A?65@89=69:36?64945 ?4>3: 8; @?6/6E@:489 49 ?65@6-: 8; 53*?65 *554>96= ,A =6;69=*9:85%":8$49;*78?8;=6;69=*9:8%%
!% 6*?96=6948? 8B956<;8?:36@6:4:4896?D8B<= -89:69=:3*::36?64598-*B568;*-:489;8?;4<49>5B4:;8?
@?6/6E@:489%36@?6/6E@:48945>876?96=B9=6?6-:489 8; :36 49=B B--655489 -: "0!% 36 @*?:4:489 45 6;;6-:6= *5 53*?65 *?6 *<<8::6= :8 @*?:465 49
85%$.#"*9=$0#"%36?6;8?6:36?64598?4>3:8; @?6/6E@:489 ;8? ?65@89=69: 8%" @<*49:4;;%
- 8 -
36?6;8?6 :36?6 45 98 -*B56 8; *-:489 ;8? :36 5B4:% 6 5B,E4:5:3*:?65@89=69:8%"@<*49:4;;-*9;4<6*@@<4-*:489 B9=6? 6-:489 8; :36 49=B B--655489 -: -<*4E49> ?4>3: 8; @?6/6E@:489 49 :36 @69=49> (
8%0#"!% (B?:36? 36 5B,E4::6= :3*: :36 5*4= (
8%0#"! 45 =45@856=8;*9=8%!#" 3*5,6695*:45;46=%
.% 6*?96= -8B956< ;8? ?65@89=69: 8%" D8B<= -89:69= :3*: 49 @*?* 8%"# 8; :36 @<*49: -*B56 8; *-:489 3*5,6695@6-4;4-*<<A5:*:6=*5:36=*:68;554>9E69:8; 66=%365B4:45;4<6=;8?@?6/6E@:489:8?6:*4953*?658; =6;69=*9:85%":8$,A?65@89=69:8%"%589:36=*:6 8; 5B4: (
8%0#"! D*5 @69=49> *9= 53*?65 8; =6;69=*9:85%":8$6769:38B>3=6-<*?6=:36AD6?698:
=6E*?-*:6= ,A E66:5 *9= ,8B9=5% 8954=6?49> :36 5*4= *5@6-::36:?4*< 8B?:3*5?4>3:<A?6C6-:6=:36*@@<4-*:489 ;4<6=,A:36@6:4:4896?B9=6? ?=6?B<6""8;
%
% 6*?96= -8B956< ;8? ?65@89=69: 8%! D8B<= -89:69=:3*:*>*495::368?=6?@*556=49(
8%0#"! <6>*< ?6@?6569:*:4765 8; =6;69=*9: 8%" 4%6% ?65@89=69:
- 9 -
8%! 36?649 3*5 ;4<6= 8%"#"0 *9= 4: 3*5 ,669 =45@856= 8; 89 #%#%##% 3*<<69>49> :36 5*E6 :36 6-89= @@6*< 45 ;4<6= 49 8%##" .## *9= 4: 45 @69=49>,6;8?6:345 8B?:%65B,E4:5:3*::36@69=69-A 8; 5*4= 4:56<; 49=4-*:6 :3*: ;49*< =6-?66 45 98: A6: *::*496=;49*<4:A%
0% *749> 36*?= <6*?96= -8B956<5 :345 8B?: 3*5 @6?B56=:36E*:6?4*<5@<*-6=89?6-8?=%
"#% 9 @6?B5*< 8; :36 @<*49: :36 @?*A6? 8; :36 @<*49:4;; 45 ?4>3: 8; @?6/6E@:489 :8 ?6:*49 53*?65 8;
=6;69=*9: 85%" :8 $ D34-3 *?6 *554>96= :8 =6;69=*9: 8%%36-*B568;*-:4895:*:6=49:36@<*49:456H6-B:489 8; 554>9E69: =66= =*:6= $%"%#"% : 45 * ?6>45:6?6= =66=%8%###0##"!D*5@69=49>*589:36=*:68; 66=8;554>9E69:6H6-B:6=,A=6;69=*9:85%":8$49 ;*78? 8; =6;69=*9: 8% :36 @?6<4E49*?A =6-?66 3*5 98:
*::*496=;49*<4:A%36@?6569:5B4:45;4<6=89"!%"%#"! D4:349 896 A6*? ;?8E :36 =*:6 8;
66= 8;
554>9E69: =*:6= $%"%#"% 36 -*B56 8; *-:489 ;8? - 10 -
69;8?-49>?4>3::8@?6/6E@:489*?456589:36=*:68;
66= 8; 554>9E69: =*:6= $%"%#"% ?:4-<6 0. 8; :36 4E4:*:489-:?6*=5:3B51
/0 1
*
+ 2 ( 3
' & (
(& &
' *
(
(&
+. 9 @6?B5*< 8; $?= -8<BE9 8; ?:4-<6 0. 4: 45 -<6*? :3*: :8 69;8?-6?4>3:8;@?6/6E@:489:36@6?48=8;<4E4:*:48945896 A6*?;?8E:36?6>45:?*:4898;*9495:?BE69:8;5*<6%
""% 36?6745489@6:4:4896?=6;69=*9:8%D*598: @B:49@8556554898;53*?65*554>96=:834E,A=6;69=*9: 85%" :8 $ *9= :36?6;8?6 36 3*= ;4<6= (
8%0#"! 566F49> @855655489 8; 53*?65 *554>96= :8 34E B9=6?
:36 66= 8; 554>9E69: =*:6= $%"%#"% 8954=6?49> :36
- 11 -
5*E6 :36 -*B56 8; *-:489 ;8? :36 @<*49:4;; D38 45 ?65@89=69:8%"36?649:8;4<6*5B4:;8?@?6/6E@:489*?4565 89 :36 =*:6 8; ?6>45:?*:489 8; 554>9E69:
66= 89 $%"%#"%
6;69=*9: 8% 45 98: * ;*E4<A E6E,6? 8; ?65@89=69: 8%"/@<*49:4;; *9= 36 45 5:?*9>6?% 8954=6?49> :36 5*4= *5@6-: :36?6 45 -*B56 8; *-:489 ;8? ?65@89=69: 8%"@<*49:4;;:8;4<65B4:;8?@?6/6E@:489%
"% 8954=6?49> :36 5*4= *5@6-: :36 <6*?96= :?4*<
8B?: ?4>3:<A @*556= :36 4E@B>96= 8?=6? ?6C6-:49> :36 *@@<4-*:489;4<6=,A:36@6:4:4896?B9=6? ?=6?B<6"" 8;
%
"$% 9 :36 ?65B<: :36 6745489 6:4:489 45
*+ ' & $&( %
45:8%"<8%