- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " #$% & #'()* & + #! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - && ,% ! & & & ) *) *- '(*$ & & . $ /01201345/6789:;97<8=2/8 <=80>>/0?=8:=?/2;@7</A?0=5067030=6877</ B4235/67 062 0C012 207/2 ) *) *- >088/2 ;@ 7</ /6=91 =D=? 423/ 062 # 422/;=<0? E:91 8<917F1=;460?GH=6 9 '(*$8//I=63/6<06A/5/67 9:A95>/6807=96 % </ =6B41/2 A?0=5067 03/2 ' @/018 5/7 C=7< 06 0AA=2/67 96 ( * 062 84870=6/2 31=/D948 =6B41=/8 </A?0=5067;/=635=691<=8:07</1:=?/20A?0=5 >/7=7=96 ;/:91/ 7</ 1=;460? 8//I=63 A95>/6807=96 9: 8 -*****# </ 1=;460? 0:7/1 A968=2/1=63 7</ /67=1/ - 3 - /D=2/6A/ 96 1/A912 0C012/2 7</ A95>/6807=96 9: 8 %(***# C=7< =67/1/87 07 )J >/1 06645 :195 7</ 207/ 9: >/7=7=96 7=?? 1/0?=K07=96 062 2=1/A7/2 1/8>962/67 9 #9C6/1 9: 7</ D/<=A?/ 79 >0@ 7</ A95>/6807=96 062 /L96/107/21/8>962/679 #684106A/95>06@:195=78 ?=0;=?=7@ 331=/D/2 ;@ 7</ 80=2 0C012 7</ A?0=5067 <08 >1/:/11/27<=80>>/0? $ /016/2 A9468/? :91 7</ A?0=5067 50=6?@ A967/62/2 7<07 7</ 1=;460? <08 0C012/2 5/031/ A95>/6807=96 062 /11/2 =6 697 0C012=63 06@ A95>/6807=96:91:4741/5/2=A0?/L>/68/8?9889:=6A95/ 241=63 ?0=2 4> >/1=92 062 /L710 6941=8<5/67 7 =8 A967/62/27<07:915/2=A0?/L>/68/8</<08=6A411/2591/ 7<068 '****#;477</1=;460?<080C012/25/031/ 059467 7 =8 0?89 A967/62/2 7<07 7</ A?0=5067 C08 /016=63 8 (***# >/1 5967< ;@ C91I=63 08 99?=/ ;47 7</ 1=;460? <08 697 A968=2/1/2 7</ 805/ 062 7<48 1/M4/87/2 :91 /6<06A=63 7</ A95>/6807=96 C=7< J =67/1/87>/106645=6<=8:0D941 - 4 - ' 25=77/2?@03/9:7</A?0=5067C08'@/01808 >/1L ,N9462/17=:=A07/062*N=8A<013/012 8 >/1 9462 /17=:=A07/ A?0=5067 84870=6/2 :10A741/ 9: :/541A962@?/1=3<7I6//:10A741/9:7=;=0A962@?/?9C/1 7<=12 7=;=0 062 A148< =6B41=/8 96 7</ :997 C<=A< 01/ 31=/D948=660741/ ) ?0=5067 C08 71/07/2 08=6>07=/67:91 20@8 968=2/1=637</60741/9:=6B41=/8>/1=929:<98>=70?=K07=96 06297</11/?/D067:0A79187<=89417:=628=71/08960;?/79 0C012060594679:8 $'***#:91=6B41=/88 '****# :91 >0=6 062 84::/1=63 8 '***# :91 ?988 9: 05/6=7=/8 0628 %****#:9171068>91707=96/L7106941=8<5/67062 077/62067 A<013/8 &417</1 24/ 79 =6B41=/8 7</ A?0=5067 5=3<7697<0D/077/62/206@C91I07?/087:910>/1=929:) 5967<8 87</0AA=2/67=89:7</@/01*<=8697=960? =6A95/ =8 70I/6 08 8 )'**# >/1 5967< 08 >/1 7</ 34=2/?=6/8 =884/2 ;@ 7</ 016070I0 707/ /30? /1D=A/8 47<91=7@ AA912=63?@7<=894170C01288 %-***#:91 ?988 9: =6A95/ 241=63 ?0=2 4> >/1=92 9C/D/1 7</ - 5 - A95>/6807=969:8 ,(***#0C012/2;@7</1=;460?:91 5/2=A0?/L>/68/86//2869=67/1:/1/6A/ , </ A95>/6807=96 0C012/2 ;@ 7</ 1=;460? =8 592=:=/208462/1 ? 9 /028 C012;@7</ 1=;460? C012;@7<=8 9417 6B41=/8 ## 8 $'***# 0=6 062 84::/1=63 8 '****# 8 '****# % /2=A0? L>/68/8 8 ,(***# 8 ,(***# $ 1068>91707=96 /L710 6941=8<5/67 062 077/62067 A<013/8 8 '***# 8 %****# ' 988 9: 05/6=7=/8 8 '***# 8 '***# ) 988 9: =6A95/ 241=63 ?0=2 4> >/1=92 ## 8 %-***# 970? 8 %(***# 8 ),***# </1/C=??;//6<06A/5/679:8 -***# - 6 - ( </ 1=;460? </?2 7<07 1/8>962/67 9 <08 D=9?07/2 7</ 7/158 062 A962=7=968 9: 7</ >9?=A@ 08 7</ 9::/62=63D/<=A?/<0869>/15=7:91/671@=679016070I0 0627<48/L96/107/21/8>962/679 :195=78?=0;=?=7@ - 67<=81/3012?/016/2A9468/?:917</A?0=5067 <081/?=/2967</B4235/679:7</>/L9417=67</A08/ 9: =6 C<=A< =7 <08 ;//6 </?2 7<07 7</ 684106A/ 95>06@ <08 79 >0@ 7</ A95>/6807=96 062 1/A9D/1 7</ 805/:1957</9C6/19:7</D/<=A?/ </1/:91/>0@062 1/A9D/1=8912/1/2 * 67</1/84?77</:9??9C=63912/1=8>088/2 =! >>/0?=8 ==! </ A?0=5067 =8 /67=7?/2 :91 7</ /6<06A/2 A95>/6807=96 9: 8 ),***# C=7< =67/1/87 07 )J >/1 06645 :195 7</ 207/ 9: >/7=7=967=??7</207/9:1/0?=K07=96 1 *( )) - 7 - ===! /8>962/67 9 N 684106A/ 95>06@ =8 2=1/A7/2 79 2/>98=7 7</ 7970? A95>/6807=960594670?963C=7<=67/1/87C=7<=6 96/5967<:1957</207/9:7<=8B4235/67062 7</1/0:7/1 1/A9D/1 7</ 805/ :195 1/8>962/67 9 =D! 6 84A< 2/>98=7 7</ A?0=5067 =8 >/15=77/279C=7<210C7<//67=1/0594670?963 C=7<=67/1/870AA14/296=7 *+, &% ( $ =879 ?9 ,-