- 1 - ! " # $ % %% &'( ) !"# $ % & " ' ! ( !))!** ) ) +"" ) ' "#) $ % ( ), #" ") )#) "& Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - (( "*!%"& ( ( ( ")#! )#) )))#)" )###### (+- ( . ORAL JUDGMENT /01234/01567/839:;<:349=2/9 ) 4=9 0>>/0? =9 ;=?/2 050=893 0@012 :; 34/ 1=<680?=8 : )))#)"203/2") #! )#)>099/2<A 34/22? /8=:1=B=?625/082 030?0<6105= %;:194:13C34/1=<680?D& ! 8E61/2F?0=7083 05/2 A/019 2:=85 051=F6?361/7/3@=34080FF=2/83:8#! #+ )#)#082;=?/20 F?0=7 >/3=3=:8 F?0=7=85 F:7>/8903=:8 :; 9 )###### 4/ 1=<680? 0;3/1 F:89=2/1=85 /83=1/ /B=2/8F/ :8 1/F:12 51083/207:683:;9 ") G))*@=34=83/1/930334/103/ :;+->/108867;1:7203/:;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=903=:8 - 3 - 551=/B/2 <A 34/ 90=2 :12/1 34/ 0>>/??083 >1/;/11/2080>>/0?=8@4=F4=3=9F:83/82/234030>>/??083 96930=8/2=8E61=/9:B/1;:1/4/02F4=8:B/11=543 082 ?/;3 ?/5 ;10F361/ :; =<=0 (=<6?0 07>6303=:8 :; ?/;3 </?:@ H8// 082 :34/1 =8E61=/9 3 =9 ;6134/1 F:83/82/2 34034/3::H31/037/83;:1)I7:8349082@09/018=85 9 #####>/108867<A2:=85051=F6?361/ "082 ) J :F3:19 099/99/2 34/ 2=90<=?=3A <63 =3 @09 8:3 F:89=2/1/2 4/ 1=<680? 51083/2 =802/K603/ F:7>/8903=:80824/8F/1/K6/93/2;:1/8408F/7/83 /018/2 F:689/? ;:1 34/ 0>>/??083 F:83/82/2 340309>/13/7:9 )#082)":;F4/26?/:;F3 34/2=90<=?=3A;:107>6303=:8</?:@H8//=93:</099/99/2 09 #-08234691/K6/93/2;:17:2=;=F03=:8:;34/:12/1 :;34/1=<680? + /;63=8534/96<7=99=:89:;?/018/2F:689/?;:1 34/ 0>>/??083 ?/018/2 F:689/? ;:1 1/9>:82/83 : ) 409 F:83/82/2 3403 L "# =9 08 93=703=:8 =996/2 <A 0 >4A9=:34/10>=930828:3<A0F:7>/3/832:F3:134/1/;:1/ - 4 - 1/K6/93/2 8:3 3: F:89=2/1 34/ 90=2 09>/F3 FF:12=85?A 9:65433:2=97=9934/0>>/0? * >>/??083 409 9303/2 3403 4/ @09 2:=85 051=F6?361/ 082 /018=85 9 ##### >/1 7:834 <63 4/ 409 8:3 ;=?/2 08A 2:F67/83 3: >1:B/ 34/ 907/ / 7/3 @=34 08 0FF=2/83 :8 #! #+ )#)# 34/1/;:1/ 4=9 803=:80? =8F:7/ =9 3: </ 30H/8 09 9 "!* # >/1 7:834 09 >/1 34/ 56=2/?=8/9 :; 34/ 018030H0 303/ /50? /1B=F/9 634:1=3A 082 ) - =9 3: </ 022/2 3:@0129 ;6361/ >1:9>/F39=83/179:;:12/1:;:8D<?/>/L:6131/>:13/2 =8 B9 " 082 F:89=2/1=8534/05/:;34/=8E61/2F?0=708334/76?3=>?=/1 =93:</30H/809C"D >>/??083 /L07=8/2 ) 082 4/ =996/2 0 2=90<=?=3AF/13=;=F03/682/1L G=8@4=F4=3=99303/23403 0>>/??083 96930=8/2 ;10F361/ :; ?/;3 3=<=0 082 ;=<6?0 @=34 B09F6?01 =8E61A 082 4/ @09 31/03/2 @=34 B09F6?01 1/>0=1 /L3/180? ;=L03:1 0>>?=F03=:8 082 H8// 2=9013=F6?03=:8 / "%)#"*&"++# - 5 - F088:3@0?H08293082@=34:6308A96>>:13 4/1/=9?03 B=/@/B=2/8F/:;07>6303=:8:;?/;3?:@/1?=7<2=930?3: %</A:82&?/;3H8//E:=83</?:@?:@/1/82:;?/;3;/761082 34/2:F3:10?9:9303/234/2=90<=?=3A03#-3:34/?/;3?=7< 0820?9:3:34/@4:?/<:2A03#- G >>/??083 409 ;=?/2 L "# ?=8=F0? 1:934/3=F 99/997/83 /30=?9 5=B/8 <A 34/ :134:>/2=F 9615/:8 @4/1/=84/@099655/93/2;:1013=;=F=0??=7<0825=B/834/ 2/30=?9 :;34/013=;=F=0? ?=7< @4=F4 F:939 9 +### ;:1 /B/1A A/019<63=3@098:3F:89=2/1/2<A34/1=<680? /@09027=33/2=834/4:9>=30?;:1"*20A9 4/1/;:1/ ?:99:;;6361//018=85F0>0F=3AF:7/93: "!* #M) -L")L"L#-N)!"##+* "# 4/ 31=<680? 51083/2 08 07:683 :; 9 ) *)* 3:@0129 7/2=F0? /L>/89/9 082 =3 8//29 8: =83/1;/1/8F/ "" :89=2/1=85 34/ 05/ :; 34/ 0>>/??083F?0=7083 >/1=:2 :; 4:9>=30?=O03=:8 082 0B:F03=:8 :; 34/ 0>>/??083 - 6 - 34=9 :613 ;=829 =3 1/09:80<?/ 3: /8408F/ 07:683 :; 9 * ### 3:@0129 >0=8 082 96;;/1=85 9 !#### 3:@0129 ?:99 :; 07/8=3=/9 082 9 #### 3:@0129 31089>:1303=:8/L3108:61=947/83082033/82083F4015/9 ") / 7=543 8:3 40B/ 033/82/2 08A :34/1 @:1H 03?/093;:10>/1=:2:;9=L7:834934/1/;:1/9 ) ## %"!* #L+&3:@0129?:99:;=8F:7/261=85?0=26>>/1=:2 "! 4/ 1=<680? 51083/2 9 )##### 3:@0129 013=;=F=0? ?=7< /L>/89/9 4/8F/ 34=9 :613 ;=8291/09:8 3: /8408F/34/907/3:9 ##### " 8 0?? 34/ 3:30? F:7>/8903=:8 F:7/9 3: !"G+)G @=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; +- >/1 08867 ;1:734/203/:;>/3=3=:83=??1/0?=O03=:8 " 4/ F:7>/8903=:8 0@012/2 <A 34/ 1=<680? =9 7:2=;=/209682/1 *+,- ./0120- " 0=808296;;/1=85 * ### ) :99:;07/8=3=/9 !#### - 7 - ! /2=F0?/L>/89/9 ) *)* 1089>:1303=:8 /L310 8:61=947/83 082 033/82083 F4015/9 #### 13=;=F=0??=7</L>/89/9 ##### + :99:;/018=85261=85?0=26> >/1=:2 ) ## * :99 :; ;6361/ /018=85 F0>0F=3A )!"##+* :30? !34 35 FF:12=85?A 34/ F?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 3:30? F:7>/8903=:8 :; -!34 35 09 050=893 9 ") G))* 0@012/2 <A 34/ 1=<680? = / /8408F/2 F:7>/8903=:8:;-!3 4 5 "+ 834/1/96?334/;:??:@=85:12/1=9>099/2 =& 4/0>>/0?=9 ==& 4/ F?0=7083 =9 /83=3?/2 ;:1 3:30? F:7>/8903=:8 :; 9 !"G+)G @=34 =83/1/93 03 34/ 103/ :; +- >/1 08867 ;1:7 34/ 203/ :; >/3=3=:8 3=?? 1/0?=O03=:8 - 8 - ===& /9>:82/83 896108F/ F:7>08A 0?1/02A 2/>:9=3/2 34/ 0@012/2 07:683 </;:1/ 34/ 1=<680?34/1/;:1/1/9>:82/83: )=92=1/F3/2 3: 2/>:9=3 34/ /8408F/2 F:7>/8903=:8 :; 9 "G!*#+* @=34 =83/1/9303 34/ 103/ :; +- @=34=8:8/7:834;1:734/203/:;34=9:12/1 =B& 8 96F4 2/>:9=3 34/ 0>>/??083 =9 >/17=33/2 3: @=34210@34//83=1/07:6830?:85@=34=83/1/93 0FF16/2:8=3 -,5 &% ( $ THM List No.: 1 Sl No.: 18 CT:RJ