- 1 - !"#"" "$$ %& %'' ( ! "#$ % &' ( " ) ! "# * ) ! "# + +# ! "#$ % & ) ", ' ) +( Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) "&(&+( ) &( * " ) "# +#+ ) )) "" &+( -& ( - +- "&+(""!&"( )+#+- -&"(&.(&/( ) &( ) ) '&( ) ' * 0 ' ORAL JUDGMENT (PER: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE M G UMA) 11233456728594::;/2<="85.8>2="# +#+ =? 58@2./86A =38:2 6468=5 8/6.8:6 4347;.498 .298/62.2< ?=. 6B2 =??25:2/ 1;58/B4732 ;5<2. 2:68=5/ "" &+( -& ( - +- "&+(""!&"(=?6B2B4.468A4A4A445B864+#+- 45< 2:68=5 -&"(&.(&/( =? 6B2 :B2<;32< 4/62/ 45< :B2<;32< .872/ &.2@2568=5 =? 6.=:8682/( :6 +#" &B2.2854?62. .2?2..2< 6= 4/ C & ( :6D ?=. /B=.6( 125<859=56B2?832=?6B2324.52<<<868=5438@83';<92 - 3 - &.5( 4347;.498 8/ /22E859 9.456 =? 4568:8146=.A 7483 =56B2411.2B25/8=5=?728594..2/62< + 24.< .8 '4E4 324.52< :=;5/23 ?=. 6B2 411233456.8=143E.8/B544<4@324.52<89B=;.6 =@2.5>256 324<2. ?=. .2/1=5<256 ="6462 45< .8 '4<B4@ 47;.4= >74.4= 324.52< :=;5/23 ?=. .2/1=5<256=+2.;/2<6B2>462.843/=5.2:=.< - 5 @82F =? 6B2 .8@43 :=562568=5/ ;.92< 7A 6B2 324.52<:=;5/23?=.7=6B6B214.682/6B21=8566B46F=;3< 4.8/2?=.>A:=5/8<2.468=58/ ! "#$%& A45/F2.6=6B247=@21=8568/85C29468@2D?=.6B2 ?=33=F859 B2/6462>256=?.2/1=5<256=+F4/.2:=.<2< FB25B2F4/4<>8662<6=6B2B=/1864345<6B2):4>26= - 4 - 72.298/62.2<85.8>2="# +#+ 49485/64::;/2<=/" 6=-?=.6B247=@2/48<=??25:2/B285G;.2<85?=.>456B4/ /6462< 6B46 =5 6B2 1.2@8=;/ 589B6 82 =5 "#$+#+ 46 "#-# 1> 6B2 4::;/2< F4A348< B8> 47;/2< 85 ?836BA 3459;49245<B;>838462<7A.2?2..8596=B8/:4/62::;/2< =/-45<+B4@24//4;362<B8>F86BB45</FB8324::;/2< =" B4/ 4//4;362< F86B 722. 7=6632 45< :4;/2< 7322<859 85G;.82/ 6 8/ 6B2.24?62. 6B2 85G;.2< F4/ 64E25 6= 6B2 B=/18643 6 8/ 6B2 :=562568=5 =? 6B2 324.52< :=;5/23 ?=. 6B2 411233456 6B46 4 :=;562. :=>134856 85 .8>2 ="H +#+ =?58@2./86A=38:26468=5F4/.298/62.2<=5 6B274/8/=?6B2?8./685?=.>468=53=<92<7A4::;/2<=+ B24::;/2<856B2/48<:4/24.243.24<A2534.92<=57483 68/43/=/6462<6B464::;/2<=/+45<-856B21.2/256 :4/24.243/=2534.92<=57483;66B2/4>2:455=6724 9.=;5<6=9.456.2382?=?4568:8146=.A74836=6B2411233456 6 8/ 43/= 5=68:2< 6B46 6B2 411233456 8/ B4@859 :.8>8543 4562:2<256/4/868//6462<6B46/2@25=6B2.:.8>8543:4/2/ - 5 - 4.2 .298/62.2< 49485/6 B8> ==E859 6= 6B2 /12:8?8: =@2.6 4:6 433292< 49485/6 6B2 411233456 6B46 B2 4//4;362< 6B2 85G;.2<85?=.>456F86B722.7=663245<:4;/2<6B27322<859 85G;.82/ 85 /1862 =? 6B2 /4>2 .2>4852< 47/:=5<859 45< 43/=6B2?4:66B46B28/B4@859:.8>85434562:2<256/4> =? 6B2 =1858=5 6B46 6B2 411233456 8/ 5=6 2568632< ?=. 4568:8146=.A7483 $ 5@82F=?6B247=@245/F2.6B247=@21=856 856B2529468@245<1.=:22<6=14//6B2?=33=F859 B24112438/ )& %""' # LG List No.: 1 Sl No.: 10