- 1 - !" #!$$ !! %&' ! " #$%$ & "$$" ' $$" () "$$" "() * """ ""()* ) $"$$+ "&%+ "" %+ "" Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ()* ! "" #$%"&*,- %"&)' + " & " ".&""&""" & + " & $" " " /0 " $ " 1234565 $ 5237 89:;<=7 9; >=?57@ 9@ A3A:;B:15A 15AC:;D5EE5@9A2?=E=23239;=A@9AA=<E9;D=;2<29* 5;D 5;D A35<5F5A54 "5DC9:D5 89:;<=7 @9A A=<E9;D=;2 "9)?5G=5EE=5A=D3;E=A<9; ?=E=23239;5G=A1=;2<5A=5<:;D=A 2 3< <252=D 2?52 2?= 75;D >=5A3;C 6"9 H 2925776 1=5<:A3;C 8A= * :;25< <32:52=D 52 %5F575C=A5 3775C= 57:B3;D?5;:A3<2A382538?:AF5<5;5;8=<2A57EA9E=A269@ 9;="5A5<5115+ 95;B5;;5?=58I:3A=D2?=2327=9G=A2?= 75;D :;D=A 5 E5A23239; 2?52 5EE=5A< 29 ?5G= 25B=; E758= 3; 5<<:8??=A;51=851=29>=1:252=D3;5772?=A=G=;:= - 3 - A=89AD< 5;D <?= F5< 3; E=58=@:7 E9<<=<<39; 988:E5239; 5;D 8:723G5239; 9@ 2?= <53D 75;D ?= E=23239;=A 89;2=;D< 2?52 "5A5<5115@9A?=A@513765;D92?=A7=C57;=8=<<323=<=;2=A=D 3;29 5 <57= 5CA==1=;2 F32? ?31 5;D 5CA==D 29 <=77 2?= 5>9G= 75;D295;=J2=;29@ 8A=:;25<9; *@9A29257 89;<3D=A5239; 9@ <) 5;D <?= A=8=3G=D 5DG5;8= 519:;29@< 23<89;2=;D=D2?52"5A5<5115D3D ;92=J=8:2=2?=<57=D==D?=;8=2?=E=23239;=AF5<89;<2A53;=D 29 @37= 5 <:32 3; "9.. ) <==B3;C D=8A== 9@ <E=83@38 E=A@9A15;8= 9; 2?= @37= 9@ A7 3G37 %:DC= 3;D?5;:A :A3;C 2?= E=;D=;86 9@ 2?= <:32 2?= E=23239;=A 5;D "5A5<5115 =;2=A=D 3;29 891EA913<= 889AD3;C76 2?= <:32 F5D D=8A==D >5<=D9;5891EA913<=9; ) < 2?3;C< <299D 2?:< 5@2=A 891EA913<= "5A5<5115 @537=D 29 =J=8:2= 2?= <57= D==D ?=;8= 2?= E=23239;=A 3;32352=D =J=8:239; EA98==D3;C< 3; "9.* 9F=G=A "5A5<5115D3D;925EE=5A>=@9A=2?=J=8:23;C9:A2=;8= 2?=E=23239;=AC92=J=8:2=D2?=<57=D==D3;A=<E=829@2?=<53D 75;D2?A9:C?9:A29113<<39;=A5EE93;2=D>62?=891E=2=;2 3G379:A2 - 4 - ?= E=23239;=A 5@2=A =J=8:239; 9@ 2?= <57= D==D >6 2?= 9:A2 9113<<39;=A E:A<:5;2 29 2?= D=8A== 3; "9.. ) 5EEA958?=D 2?= 5?<37D5A 29 1:252= ?3< ;51=3;A=<E=829@2?=<:>4=8275;D3;2?=89;8=A;=D?= @9:A2?A=<E9;D=;2@37=D9>4=8239;<5;D2?=5?<37D5AG3D=9AD=A D52=D A=4=82=D 2?= A=I:=<2 9@ 2?= E=23239;=A >6 <2523;C2?52 ?=85;;921:252=2?=;51=9@2?=E=23239;=A5;D A=7=C52=D2?=E5A23=<295EEA958?2?=3G379:A2CCA3=G=D>6 2?= <53D 9AD=A 2?= E=23239;=A EA=@=AA=D 5; 5EE=57 >=@9A= 2?= <<3<25;2 9113<<39;=A ?= <<3<25;2 9113<<39;=A G3D= 9AD=A D52=D ) * D3<13<<=D 2?= 5EE=57 < 5C53;<2 2?= <53D 9AD=A 2?= E=23239;=A @37=D 5 A=G3<39; E=23239; >=@9A= 2?= =E:26 9113<<39;=A ?= =E:26 9113<<39;=A G3D= 9AD=A D52=D *D3<13<<=D2?==G3<39; =23239;;D=A2?=<= 83A8:1<25;8=<2?=E=23239;=A3<>=@9A=2?3<9:A2 * 9:;<=7 @9A 2?= A=<E=823G= E5A23=< :AC=D <=G=A57 89;2=;239;< 9:;<=7A35<5F5A54"5DC9:D5@9AA=<E9;D=;2"9)3; EA=<=;23;C?3<5AC:1=;2<<:>132<2?52<252=1=;29@9>4=8239;< 3<@37=D5;D2?=<51=156>=E758=D9;A=89AD=5AC:=D>6 - 5 - <563;C2?522?=@9:A2?A=<E9;D=;2?5D25B=;<?=72=A>=@9A=2?= 9:A29@75F>6@373;C5<:32<==B3;C2?=A=73=@9@E5A23239;5;D <=E5A52= E9<<=<<39; 3; "9 5;D 2?= E=23239;=A0< G=;D9A"5A5<51153<D=@=;D5;2"9)3;2?=<53D<:32=57<9 <:>1322=D2?522?=A3579:A2G3D=9AD=AD52=D( ?5D CA5;2=D 5; 3;4:;8239; 9AD=A A=<2A53;3;C 2?= D=@=;D5;2< ;92 29 573=;52=2?=EA9E=A23=<23772?=D3<E9<579@2?=<:329F=G=A2?= @9:A2? D=@=;D5;2 =;2=A=D 3;29 891EA913<= F32? D=@=;D5;2 =;2=A=D 3;29 891EA913<= F32? 2?= E=23239;=A @9A <57= 9@ 2?= EA9E=A26 9:;<=7 <:>132< 2?52 2?= E=23239;=A F5< 57<9 5AA56=D 5< D=@=;D5;2 "9 3; 2?= <53D <:32 9:;<=7 2?=A=@9A=<:>132<2?522?=+A32 =23239;156>=D3<13<<=D 4:<23@3=D 2?= 9AD=A< 9@ 2?= A=G=;:= 5:2?9A323=< AC3;C<=G=A5789;2=;239;<<:>132<2?522?=+A32 =23239; 156>=D3<13<<=D ) =5AD2?=5AC:1=;2<5;DE=A:<=D2?=+A32E5E=A< F32?85A= ?= @582< 5A= <:@@383=;276 <53D 5;D D9 ;92 A=I:3A= A=32=A5239;?=3<<:=@577<F32?3;5;5AA9F891E5<<5;DA=752=< 29 2?= 582 9; 2?= E5A2 9@ 2?= E=23239;=A0<G=;D9A 29=;2=A 3;29 891EA913<= :@@38= 32 29 ;92= 2?52 2?= E=23239;=A F5< - 6 - 89;<2A53;=D 29 @37= 5 <:32 @9A <E=83@38 E=A@9A15;8= 5;D 2?= E=23239;=A0< G=;D9A =;2=A=D 3;29 891EA913<= 5;D 5CA==D 29 =J=8:2= 2?= <57= D==D 3; A=<E=82 9@ 2?= 75;D >=5A3;C 6"9 H 29 5; =J2=;2 9@ 8A= :;25< +?52 3< A=I:3A=D 29 >= 89;<3D=A=D 3< F?=2?=A 2?= E=23239;=A0< G=;D9A 89:7D?5G==;2=A=D3;295891EA913<=F32?2?=E=23239;=A23< <3C;3@385;2 29 ;92= 2?52 2?= @9:A2? A=<E9;D=;2 @37=D 5 <:32 <==B3;C 2?= A=73=@ 9@ E5A23239; 5;D <=E5A52= E9<<=<<39; 3; "9 5;D5;5EE7385239;A=<2A53;3;C2?=D=@=;D5;2< @A91573=;523;C2?=<:32<8?=D:7=EA9E=A23=<F5<57<9@37=D?= 89E69@2?=D53769AD=A<?==23;"9 3<@:A;3<?=D 579;C F32? <252=1=;2 9@ 9>4=8239;< E=A:<57 9@ 2?= <51= F9:7DA=@7=822?522?=A3579:A2G3D=9AD=AD52=D( A=<2A53;=D2?=D=@=;D5;2<@A91573=;523;C2?=<:32EA9E=A23=<2377 2?= D3<E9<57 9@ 2?= <:32 ?= EA9E=A26 F?38? 3< <97D >6 2?= E=23239;=A0<G=;D9A3<57<92?=<:>4=821522=A9@2?=<:32=;8= <?= 89:7D ;92 ?5G= =;2=A=D 3;29 891EA913<= 5B3;C ;92= 9@ 2?= E=;D=;86 9@ 2?= <:32 <9 57<9 2?= 3;2=A31 9AD=A 9@ ;9; 573=;5239;2?=A=G=;:=5:2?9A323=<5A=4:<23@3=D3;A=4=823;C2?= 875319@2?=E=23239;=A@3;D;9CA9:;D<293;2=A@=A=F32?2?= - 7 - 9AD=A<E5<<=D>6 2?= A=G=;:= 5:2?9A323=< ?= +A32 =23239; 3< D=G93D9@1=A32<5;D3<735>7=29>=D3<13<<=D =<:725;2762?=+A32 =23239;3< =85:<= 9@ D3<13<<57 9@ +A32 =23239; E=;D3;C 3;2=A798:29A6 5EE7385239;< 3@ 5;6 5A= D3<E9<=D 9@ 5;D 3;2=A31 D3A=8239;3@5;63<D3<8?5AC=D (& %$ !!' $ " 3<2"97"9)