- 1 - !"# $%& && '"( ) ! " # $ " % $ & & %$ '( % &) & ( *%*+ %$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' # $ , *$" %-"$ . $ /% $. . $ & & 0. % 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 4C42=3<<16D>9CB6=<4=94E4?994<69543369 :;<16?2=@25476=2A?2F27.>9C64=9 474:>?4C2 G8A?31A?<H?2:>=47IJ2=$A/%K>63<2A=2=C<16 K>4=<>B A8 @AB56=34<2A= 4=9 <16 724:272<; <A 2=96B=28; <164E4?94BA>=< 16 2=D>?69 @742B4=< 4C69 ;64?3 B6< E2<1 4= 4@@296=< A= 4=9 3>3<42=69 C?26FA>3 - 3 - 2=D>?263 6=@6 16 82769 4 @742B 56<2<2A= :68A?6 <16 ?2:>=47 366L2=C @AB56=34<2A= A8 3+%* 16 ?2:>=47 48<6? @A=3296?2=C <16 6=<2?6 6F296=@6 A= ?6@A?9 4E4?969 <16 @AB56=34<2A= A8 3/%* E2<1 2=<6?63< 4<+M56?4==>B8?AB<1694<6A856<2<2A=<277?6472N4<2A= 4=992?6@<69?635A=96=<A*=3>?4=@6AB54=;<A54; <16 @AB56=34<2A= CC?26F69 :; <16 3429 4E4?9 <16 =3>?4=@6AB54=;1435?686??69<123455647 64?9<164?C>B6=<3A8:A<1329634=956?>369 <16B4<6?24734F4274:76A=?6@A?9 ) < 23 @A=<6=969 :; 764?=69 @A>=367 8A? <16 4556774=<*=3>?4=@6AB54=;<14<<16?296?A8<162=3>?69 BA<A?@;@76 :64?2=C A *%*+ E43 =A< 1A792=C F4729 4=9 6886@<2F6 9?2F2=C 72@6=36 E12@1 4BA>=<3 <A F2A74<2A=A8<16<6?B34=9@A=92<2A=3A8<165A72@;4=943 3>@1 <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 23 =A< 724:76 <A 54; <16 @AB56=34<2A=>?<16?2<23@A=<6=969<14<4356?O+ @742B4=< E43 8>77; 9?>=L6= 4=9 =6C72C6=< 2= ?292=C <16 F612@76 6 ?67269A= <16D>9CB6=< A8 56O A>?< 2= <16 - 4 - @436 A8 E16?62=2<1431679<14<E16=<1656?3A=149=AF47294=9 6886@<2F672@6=36<A9?2F6<16F612@76A=94;A84@@296=<4=9 E43 1A792=C 9?2F2=C 72@6=36 <A 9?2F6 <A<477; 92886?6=< @7433 A8F612@76<16==3>?4=@6AB54=;23=A<724:76<A54;<16 @AB56=34<2A= @@A?92=C7; 16 5?4;3 8A? 477AE2=C <16 455647 6?@A=<?4764?=69@A>=3678A??635A=96=<A @742B4=< 3>55A?<3 <16 2B5>C=69 D>9CB6=< 4=9 4E4?9 4=95?4;38A?923B23347A8<16455647 + = 4?4 A) A8 <16 2B5>C=69 D>9CB6=< 2< 23 A:36?F69 :; <16 ?2:>=47 <14< ?635A=96=< A 143 5?A9>@69<166O<?4@<A8<16?296?A8<16BA<A?@;@7643 56? O 4=9 2< E43 3<4<69 16 143 :66= 4><1A?2N69 <A 9?2F6 <16 =A=*<?4=35A?< 4=9 <?4=35A?< F612@763 4=9 473A <16 $ 4=9 $ >3 %E2<=633 A8 <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=;49B2<<69<14<1A796?A8<1634299?2F2=C72@6=36 @4=?296<16BA<A?@;@76473A - 5 - - 16 ?2:>=47 ?67269 >5A= <16 .>9CB6=< A8 A* ?92=4<6 6=@1 A8 <123 A>?< 2= <16 @436 A8 ?65A?<692= !"##$ %#& '($E16?62=2<E431679 <14<2<@4==A<:63429<14<<169?2F6?14F2=C$72@6=@6 :>< 9?2F2=C <EA E16676? 3@AA<6? 4< <16 <2B6 A8 4@@296=< @4==A<:63429<14<16E43=A<14F2=C4F47294=96886@<2F6 A 2< 23 1679 <14< ?635A=96=< A 842769 <A 5?AF6 <14< <16 9?2F6? A8 <16 A886=92=C F612@76 143 =A 9?2F2=C 72@6=@6 64?=69 @A>=367 8A? <16 ?635A=96=< ?67269 >5A= <16 3429 49B2332A= A8 <16 ?635A=96=< A 4=9 <1>3 3>:B2<3 <14< <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; 23 724:76 <A 54; @AB56=34<2A= 9B2<<697;<169?2F6?A8<16A886=92=CF612@7623 14F2=C $ 72@6=@6 4=9 <1>3 16 @4==A< ?296 <16 BA<A?@;@76E2<1<16342972@6=@616?68A?6<16=3>?4=@6 AB54=;236=<2<769<A54;4=9?6@AF6?=O+2<E43 3<4<69<14<<16@742B4=<E432=49?>=L6=@A=92<2A=>< 4356?<1684@<3A8<16@43616B6<E2<14@@296=<9>6<A - 6 - <16?4314=9=6C72C6=<B4==6?A8<16BA<A?@;@76:64?2=C ?6C23<?4<2A=A *%*+4=92<=A<<16@436A8<16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; <14< <16?6 23 @A=<?2:><A?; =6C72C6=@6 :;<16@742B4=<16?68A?6<1634294?C>B6=<@4==A<:6 4@@65<69 / =<16?63>7<<168A77AE2=C& 2" 1645564723477AE692=54?<, 22" 16 =3>?4=@6 @AB54=; 23 92?6@<69 <A 965A32< 3/%* 47A=C E2<12=<6?63<4<<16?4<6A8+M56?4==>B 8?AB <16 94<6 A8 <16 56<2<2A= <277 <16 ?6472N4<2A=, 222" = 3>@1 965A32< <16 ?635A=96=< A%@742B4=< 23 56?B2<<69 <A E2<19?4E <16 4BA>=< 47A=C E2<1 2=<6?63< 4@@?>69A=2<, - 7 - 2F" 16 =3>?4=@6 @AB54=; 23 4< 72:6?<; <A ?6@AF6? <16 34B6 8?AB <16 AE=6?A8<16F612@76, F" 16 4BA>=< 965A32<69 :; <16 =3>?4=@6 AB54=; :68A?6 <123 A>?< 23 92?6@<69<A:6<?4=3B2<<69<A<16?2:>=47 8A?<1E2<1 *+ '&( % $ 23<A&7A&) &.