- 1 - !" # $% # $% ## &'( ) !"!#$% & & #'# & #("" & & ) $"$%%$%' & ) ""%$%# * & & ) Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & ) + + ,) ,) & % + ,) & -./ 011203 ./ 45 011233067 8 9:19:07.96 ;033.6< .6 =>2/7.96 7-2 ?>@<A267 06@ 0B0:@ @072@ $"$%%$%' .6 9""%$%# 10//2@ 45 7-2 :.6;.103 26.9: .C.3 )>@<2D 070304>:0<.967-2<:9>6@9E3.04.3.750/ B2330/=>067>A % -2 @072 9E 0;;.@267 .6C93C2A267 9E C2-.;32/ @207- 9E -0:060110 9 >:>10@0110 03506 ./ 697 .6 @./1>72-2@./1>72./9635.6:2/12;79E3.04.3.75.6C.2B 9E .6C93C2A267 9E 7B9 C2-.;32/ .2 >/ 42396<.6< 79 7-2 011233067 8 9:19:07.96 06@ :.@2: 9E 2:9 96@0 979:;5;32/903/9=>067>A9E;9A126/07.96 - 3 - ' 20:@:.2210F0:0@320:62@;9>6/23E9: 7-2 011233067 8 9:19:07.96 06@ :. 04> 270<>@@0 320:62@;9>6/2301120:.6<E9:7-2:2/196@2678;30.A067 G :. 2210F 0:0@ 70F.6< >/ 7-:9><- 7-2 ?>@<A267 06@ 0B0:@ C2-2A26735 ;96726@2@ 7-07 7-2 :.4>603 -0/ 2::2@ .6 E0/726.6< 7-2 3.04.3.75 96 7-2 0112330678 9:19:07.96/.6;27-2;-0:<2 /-227./E.32@45 7-2 93.;2 :2C203/ 7-07 7B9 C2-.;32/ .2 >/ 06@ 2:9 96@0 1326@9: .6C93C2@ 06@ .6 7-07 C.2B 9E 7-2 A0772: 3.04.3.75 9><-7 79 -0C2 4226 E0/7262@ 96 7-2 :.@2: 9E 7-2 979:;5;32 .2 @2;20/2@ 0/ -2 -0/ 03/9 ;967:.4>72@ 79B0:@/7-20;;.@267-./0/12;79E7-2A0772:./A.//2@ 45 7-2 :.4>603 B-.32 06/B2:.6< .//>2 9# 2 E>:7-2: />4A.7/ 7-07 7-2 :.4>603 -0/ 0B0:@2@ 2H9:4.7067 ;9A126/07.96.67-204/26;29E0651:99E9E.6;9A2.7- 7-./ -2 /22F/ 79 0339B 7-2 011203 06@ /22F/ 79 E0/726 3.04.3.75 96 7-2 :.@2: 9E 7-2 A979:;5;32 06@ A9@.E5 7-2 ;9A126/07.96 - 4 - ! 2E>7.6<7-2/>4A.//.96/9E7-2320:62@;9>6/23 E9: 7-2 011233067 9:19:07.96 :. 2E>7.6<7-2/>4A.//.96/9E7-2320:62@;9>6/23 E9: 7-2 011233067 9:19:07.96 :. 04> 270<>@@0 B.7- 033 C2-2A26;2 />4A.772@ 7-07 7-2 9B62: 9E 7-2 979:;5;32 B0/ 697 A0@2 0/ 10:75 42E9:2 7-2 :.4>603 -293.;2:2<./72:2@7-2;0/2E9:7-29EE26;2/1>6./-0432 >6@2:2;7.96/'$G 06@%(9E 0<0.6/77-2@:.C2:9E 7-2 9EE26@.6< 4>/ 42396<.6< 79 7-2 9:19:07.96 -2 :.4>603 B-.3206/B2:.6< .//>2 9#07 10:0<:01- 9/#" 06@#(-0/<.C26;320:E.6@.6<7-07.7./7-2@:.C2:9E7-2 4>/B-9./:2/196/.432E9:7-20;;.@26706@.67-07:2/12;7 7-2 ;30.A067 -0/ 1:9C2@ 62<3.<26;2 96 7-2 10:7 9E 7-2 @:.C2: 9E 7-2 4>/ 7-2:2E9:2 7-2 :.4>603 06/B2:2@ .//>2 9#.67-2EE.:A07.C2 9E0: ;9A126/07.96 ./ ;96;2:62@ 7-2 :.4>603 -0C.6< 70F26 7-2 .6;9A2 .6 72:A/ 9E 7-2 .6;9A2 E.H2@ >6@2:7-2 -0:71:210:2@457-20:6070F02<032:C.;2/ >7-9:.75E9:7-2520:%$%$06@70F.6<.679;96/.@2:07.96 9E30B30.@@9B6457-2 96I43212H 9>:7.67-2;0/29E - 5 - 0@@2@ G$J E>7>:2 1:9/12;7/ F221.6< .6 C.2B 7-07 7-2 @2;20/2@ B0/ %" 520:/ 0/ 96 7-2 @072 9E @207- 06@ 7-2 A>37.13.2: # B0/ :.<-735 70F26 06@ 7-2 ;9A126/07.96 0B0:@2@>6@2:0337-2-20@/./?>/706@1:912:B.7-.67-2 2H1:2//.96K?>/7;9A126/07.96IB-.;-@92/697;033E9:065 .672:E2:26;2 07 7-2 -06@/ 9E 7-./ 9>:7 06@ /9><-7 79 @./A.//7-2011203 0C.6< -20:@ 7-2 320:62@ ;9>6/23 E9: 7-2 10:7.2/ 12:>/2@ 7-2 267.:2 011203 1012:/ 7-2 9635 19.67 7-070:./2/E9:;96/.@2:07.969E7-./ 9>:7./+ -27-2: 7-2 :.4>603 ./ ?>/7.E.2@ .6 E0/726.6< 267.:23.04.3.75967-2@:.C2:9E7-24>/42396<.6< 79 7-2 011233067 8 9:19:07.96 06@ 0B0:@2@ 0@2=>072 ;9A126/07.96 B.7-.6 7-2 2H1:2//.96 ?>/7;9A126/07.96L " >:06/B2:797-2049C219.67E9:;96/.@2:07.96 ./.6EE.:A07.C2E9:7-2E9339B.6<+ 1 2009 ACJ 1298 - 6 - /;9>3@42/226E:9A7-2:2;9:@7-2.//>2E:0A2@ 9635 0<0.6/7 7-2 62<3.<26;2 96 7-2 10:7 9E @:.C2: 9E 7-2 9EE26@.6< 4>/ 42396<.6< 79 7-2 9:19:07.96 -2 93.;2 E.32@ & 0<0.6/7 @:.C2: 9E 7-2 9EE26@.6< 4>/ E9: 7-2 9EE26;2/1>6./-0432>6@2:2;7.96/%(06@'$G9E -2 :219:7 07 H#" -0/ 4226 :2E2::2@ 45 7-2 :.4>6030710:0<:01-9#"79/-9B@0A0<2//226967-2 9EE26@.6< 4>/ 7-07 ;320:35 /-9B/ :0/- 06@ 62<3.<267 @:.C.6< 45 7-2 @:.C2: 9E 7-2 4>/ C26 7-2 /F27;- B-.;- -0/4226130;2@457-2320:62@;9>6/23E9:7-2:2/196@267 ;320:35/-9B/7-077-2@:.C2:<9.6<267.:235967-2B:96< 7-2/.@29E7-2:90@@0/-2@0<0.6/77-2A979:;5;32E:9A 42-.6@/12:7-2;9A130.67.7.//7072@7-077-2@:.C2:9E 7-2 9:19:07.96 B-.32 .6 7-2 1:9;2// 9E 9C2:70F.6< 7-2 ?221 @:9C2 7-2 4>/ .6 0 :0/- 06@ 62<3.<267 A0662: 06@ <962967-22H7:2A2:.<-7/.@29E7-2:90@06@@0/-2@79 7-296;9A.6<A979:;5;32967-232E7/.@2-07010:77-2 - 7 - /197/F27;-1:210:2@457-293.;20C0.30432.67-2:2;9:@ ;320:35/-9B/7-07.7./7-2@:.C2:9E7-24>/B-9B0/:0/- 06@ 62<3.<267 .6 @:.C.6< 7-2 4>/ 06@ 7-2 :.4>603 -0C.6< ;96/.@2:2@7-2267.:2:2;9:@/;9A2/7901:912:;96;3>/.96 -93@.6< 7-07 7-2 @:.C2: 9E 7-2 9EE26@.6< 4>/ 42396<.6< 79 7-2 9:19:07.96 ./ :2/196/.432 E9: :0/- 06@ 62<3.<267 @:.C.6<06@;0>/2@7-20;;.@267;;9:@.6<35.//>29# 06/B2:2@ .6 7-2 0EE.:A07.C2 B2 @9 697 E.6@ .6E.:A.75 96 7-2E.6@.6</9E7-2:.4>60396:0/-06@62<3.<267@:.C.6< 457-2@:.C2:9E7-24>/ ( 9E0: 0/ =>067>A ./ ;96;2:62@ 0/ ;9>3@ 42 /226E:9A7-2:2;9:@7-2:.4>603-0C.6<;96/.@2:2@7-2 520:9E0;;.@26770F267-2.6;9A29E@2;20/2@0/E.H2@45 7-2 0:6070F0 7072 2<03 2:C.;2/ >7-9:.75 07 /#'!$ 1A 0@@2@ G$J 79B0:@/ E>7>:2 1:9/12;7/ 70F.6<.679;96/.@2:07.967-20<29E@2;20/2@0/%"520:/ 0/ /7072@ .6 9/7A9:72A :219:7 8 H! 06@ 0B0:@2@ 011:91:.072 ;9A126/07.96 >6@2: 7-2 39// 9E @2126@26;5 903/97-2;9A126/07.960B0:@2@>6@2:97-2:-20@/0:2 - 8 - .672:A/9E7-230B30.@@9B6457-2 96I43212H 9>:7.6 ;07260 9E ;0/2/ 2 @9 697 E.6@ 065 .6E.:A.7.2/ 2C26 ;9A126/07.960B0:@2@.672:A/9E30BB.7-.67-2A206.6< 9EK?>/7;9A126/07.96I #$ &9:7-2E9:2<9.6<:20/96/B2E.6@69.6E.:A.7.2/ .6 7-2 ?>@<A267 06@ 0B0:@ 10//2@ 45 7-2 :.4>603 ;;9:@.6<35 7-2 19.67 E9: ;96/.@2:07.96 E:0A2@ ./ 06/B2:2@ 0<0.6/7 7-2 9:19:07.96 6 C.2B 9E 7-2 /0A2 B21:9;22@7910//7-2E9339B.6<+ . -2011203E.32@457-20112330678 9:19:07.96 ./@./A.//2@M .. -20A9>67.6@219/.742E9:27-./ 9>:742 7:06/A.772@ 79 7-2 ;96;2:62@ :.4>603 E9: @./4>:/2A267 ... -240306;20A9>670396<B.7-.672:2/70/ 9:@2:2@ 45 7-2 :.4>603 /-033 42 @219/.72@ 45 7-2 011233067 8 9:19:07.96 B.7-.6 /.H - 9 - B22F/ E:9A 7-2 @072 9E :2;2.17 9E ;915 9E 7-./9:@2:42E9:27-2:.4>603 .C 9E0: 0/ @./4>:/2A267 06@ 0119:7.96A267 9E;9A126/07.96./;96;2:62@7-29:@2:9E 7-2:.4>603./F217.670;7 C 99:@2:0/79;9/7 *+ &# ( % *+ &( % ./79+#39+'" +)