- 1 - !!"# "$ ! % &#!!! % &#!& '!( !" # $ % & $'& % &() *+ ( !" # $ % ' , * "&- " . Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - /0 ' ( ( 1) 1) $(1) % 2345 6234725 89: ;<4= ;>247?27= 623524 3@@234879A;4=:2@2=8=8;724B =3=23756234725C;<7B26A;4 =:242B@;7527= :8B D48= @2=8=8;7 8B A8625 @43E879 =:8B ;<4= =; B2= 3B852 =:2 ;4524 53=25 " @3BB25 FE =:2 3473=3G3 =3=2 5?878B=43=8>2 48F<736 363F<4398 27C:$A;4B:;4=/ 0%87@@68C3=8;7;"&- :2 A3C=<36 ?3=48H ;A =:2 C3B2 8B =:3= 48 <75243E3 D;4G879 3B ;68C2 235 ;7B=3F62 5825 ;7 ! :2 ?;=:24 ;A =:2 42B@;7527=&3@@68C37= ?;>25373@@68C3=8;7F2A;42=:2;??37537=3473=3G3 =3=22B24>2;68C227936<4<42I<2B=879=;3@@;87=:24 53<9:=24;7C;?@3BB8;73=294;<752=8=8;724;8BB<25 - 3 - 2?;4375<? 53=25 "- 8758C3=879 =:3= 42B@;7527=&3@@68C37= 8B 7;= 26898F62 A;4 C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27=37536B;8758C3=25=;42B<F?8==:2@4;@;B36 27C2 ;72 ?;42 62==24 3A=24 42 >248AE879 =:2 3@@68C3=8;7 D3B98>272=8=8;724;:24287>85275;4B2?27=53=25 - 87=8?3=25 =:2 42B@;7527= =:3= B:2 8B 7;= 26898F62 A;4 C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= 27C2 =:2 42B@;7527=&3@@68C37=8737@@68C3=8;7;"&-:35 3@@4;3C:25 :2 366;D25 =:2 3@@68C3=8;7 375 I<3B:25772H<42 ,53=25-3755842C=25=:2 @2=8=8;724B:24287=;C;7B8524=:2C3B2;A=:23@@68C37=A;4 3@@;87=?27= ;7 C;?@3BB8;73=2 94;<75 D8=:87 3 @248;5 ;A A;<4 ?;7=:B A4;? =:2 53=2 ;A 42C28@= ;A =:2 C;@E ;A B385 ;452427C2=:2@42B27=D48=@2=8=8;78BA8625 " :2 ?387 C;7=27=8;7 ;A =:2 @2=8=8;724B F2A;42 =:8B;<4=8B=:3==:2;45248?@<97258B@3BB2539387B==:2 B2==625@487C8@62;A63D375897;437C2;AA3C=<3637562936 @;B8=8;7 :2 48F<736 :3B ;>24B=2@@25 8=B J<48B58C=8;7 3B 4<62 ?3G879 87 =:2 6298B63=8>2 @424;93=8>2 = 8B 36B; - 4 - C;7=27525 =:3= C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= 8B 7;= 3 429<634 B;<4C2 ;A 3@@;87=?27= F27= 37 2HC2@=8;7 = 8B C;7=27525 =:3= C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= 8B B;<9:= A;4 ?344825 53<9:=24 375 =:2 C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= C377;= F2 98>27 =; =:2 ?344825 53<9:=24 27C2 @2=8=8;724B @43E25 A;4 B2==879 3B852 =:2 ;4524 @3BB25 FE =:2 24 C;7=43 6234725 C;<7B26 3@@234879 A;4 =:2 42B@;7527= D;<65 B<F?8= =:3= =:2 8752=386 C;7B852425 =:2 ?3=24836 ;7 42C;45 375 =3G27 7;=2 ;A =:2 8?@<9725 ;4524 F234879 ;KLMN &KA&,&! - 53=25 - @3BB25FE42B@;7527= ; 87 =:2 B385 3@@68C3=8;7 = @343943@: ! :3B ;FB24>25 =:3= 772H<42 8B =:2 3AA853>8= BD;47 =; FE 3=:3 E;<7924 B8B=24 ;A =:2 3@@68C37= B=3=879 =:3= B:2 :3B 7; ;FJ2C=8;7 =; 3@@;87= :24 26524 B8B=24&3@@68C37= ;7 C;?@3BB8;73=294;<75>27=:23@@68C37=:3BBD;47=;37 3AA853>8=3B@24772H<42 =:3=;=:24=:37:24B26A:24 ?;=:24 375 :24 B8B=24 7; ;=:24 A3?86E ?2?F24B 342 62A= - 5 - FE=:252C23B25 ;>247?27= 24>37=375=:3=B:28B7;= 2?@6;E2526B2D:242=D3B36B;B=3=25=:3==:23@@68C37= :24B26A:3B=;6;;G3A=24:24?;=:24=866:24523=:A4;?;<= ;A =:2 B3634E =:3= D;<65 F2 @385 =; :24 :2 3= @343943@: :3B 36B; ;FB24>25 =:3= J<B= F2C3<B2 =:2 3@@68C37= :3B 7;= ?27=8;725 3F;<= =:2 3>;C3=8;7 375 87C;?2 ;A :24 :<BF375 :242 C638? A;4 3@@;87=?27= ;7 C;?@3BB8;73=294;<75C377;=F242J2C=25A=:287C;?2;A =:2 :<BF375 ;A =:2 3@@68C37= 8B F26;D =:2 87C;?2 68?8= ?27=8;72587=:24262>37=4<62B4263=879=;3@@;87=?27=;7 C;?@3BB8;73=2 94;<75 =:2 3<=:;48=82B 342 F;<75 =; C;7B8524 =:2 C3B2 ;A =:2 3@@68C37= A;4 3@@;87=?27= ;7 C;?@3BB8;73=2 94;<75 = 36B; =;;G 7;=2 ;A =:2 C;?@42:27B8>2 52C8B8;7 =3G27 FE =:2 48F<736 ;7 ,, 87 @@68C3=8;7 ;-,& F3B25 ;7 )3E3??30B C3B2 375 366;D25 =:2 3@@68C3=8;7 375 98>27 B<C: 5842C=8;7 :2 @2=8=8;724B C377;= A875 A3<6= D8=: =:2 B3?2 - 6 - 3>879:2345=:26234725C;<7B26A;4=:2@34=82B 375:3>879C;7B852425=:2A3C=<363B@2C=B;A=:2C3B28=8B 7;= 87 58B@<=2 =:3= A3=:24 ;A =:2 42B@;7527= 82 <75243E3;68C2235;7B=3F6258255<4879=:2C;<4B2 ;A 2?@6;E?27= ;7 ! = 8B 36B; 7;= 87 58B@<=2 =:3=373@@68C3=8;7D3B?;>25FE=:242B@;7527=0B?;=:24 375 =:2 B3?2 D3B 7;= C;7B852425 375 37 87=8?3=8;7 D3B 98>27 =:3= 42B@;7527= 8B 7;= 26898F62 A;4 C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= >852 2?;4375<? 53=25 - 375 :27C242B@;7527=3@@4;3C:25=:2 :2 :3>879 C;7B852425=:2?3=24836;742C;45@34=8C<6346E=:2E;<7924 B8B=24;A=:242B@;7527=A8625373AA853>8=B=3=879=:3=B:2 :3B7;;FJ2C=8;7375D8=:429345=;87C;?2;A=:2:<BF375 36B; 37 ;FB24>3=8;7 8B ?352 87 @343943@: 375=3G879 7;=2;A=:2C;?@42:27B8>252C8B8;7=3G27FE=:248F<736 F3B25 ;7 )3E3??30B C3B2 I<3B:25 =:2 C;??<78C3=8;7 53=25 - 375 5842C=25 =:2 @2=8=8;724B :24287 =; C;7B8524 =:2 C3B2 ;A =:2 3@@68C37= A;4 3@@;87=?27= ;7 - 7 - C;?@3BB8;73=294;<75D8=:873@248;5;AA;<4?;7=:BA4;? =:253=2;A42C28@=;A=:2C;@E;A=:2B385;4524 , 7 >82D ;A =:2 52C8B8;7 ;A =:2 89: ;<4= =:3= ?344825 53<9:=24B 342 36B; 27=8=625 A;4 3@@;87=?27= ;7 C;?@3BB8;73=23@@;87=?27=375C;7B2I<27=<@;7=:2B385 5842C=8;7 =:2 ;>247?27= :3B 3?27525 =:2 @4;>8B8;7B 3754<62B':27B<C:F2879=:2C3B2=:2@2=8=8;724B:3>2 =;=3G27;=2;A;76E=:226898F868=EC48=2483=;C;?@6ED8=: =:2 4<62B <7524 =:2 C;?@3BB8;73=2 3@@;87=?27= :242A;42D25;7;=A87537E94;<75=;87=24A242D8=:=:2 8?@<9725;4524@3BB25FE=:2 :2428B7;?248=87 =:2@2=8=8;7 ! 7>82D;A=:23F;>258BC<BB8;7BD2@4;C225=; @3BB=:2A;66;D879( :2D48=@2=8=8;78B58B?8BB25 2=8=8;724B3425842C=25=;C;?@6ED8=:=:25842C=8;7B 8BB<25FE=:2 87@@68C3=8;7;"&-D8=:873 - 8 - @248;5;A289:=D22GBA4;?=:253=2;A42C28@=;A3C;@E;A =:8B;4524 !)* '!!( # !)* '&( # 8B=;( 6;(" (