Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65126 (KAR)
BANDAGISAB AND ANR v. SIDDARAYA AND ANR
MFA/200540/2023 · 2025-11-14
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65126 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65126 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!! ""#$"%&! ! '! #(#)##"
# #))
*&"+
# #))
*&+
! ! !" ! ! !" #$% &! '
" "
!(
"
! ! # ! ! !" #$%)*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! ! ! ! ! " #$%) & ! ' ! ! "
! "
!)*))
! ! (
! +'(
"! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ))
! ! " !#"!" "
+*)
! ! !" ! ! !" #$% &! '
" "
!(
"
! ! # ! ! !" #$%)*
! ! ! ! ! - 3 -
" #$%) & ! ' ! ! "
! "
!)*))
! ! (
! +'(
"! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ))
! ! " !#"!" "
%)
! ! ! "! ,
! (" '
,
! (
-.//.01213421561557489:;73<0-<61= 70<.3<><= ?4@7104!#""<A1916?31<0".+*.B)104" .%.B)41:74))
,
!;<516671=<5B<=7489:;7-=1</10:51@1<05::;712134<0
".+*.B)
071<@1/813/7:2<:;101--<470:.0 )))1044<74<561370:5B<=74-=1</67:<:<.0-=1</<0@ -./67051:<.0 .B 5$))))))# !;7 !3<8?01= -.05<47374 :;7 70:<37 7><470-7 .0 37-.34 104 @310:74 10 1/.?0: .B 5%%)))#2<:;<0:7375:31:7.B%C673100?/B3./41:7
- 4 -
.B 67:<:<.0 :<== 371=<D1:<.0 104 15575574 :;7 -.0:3<8?:.39 07@=<@70-7 .0 :;7 613: .B 8.:; :;7 43<>735 7E?1==9 <7 <0 :;7 31:<..B$)$)1044<37-:743756.0470:.5104:.476.5<:
:;7-./67051:<.0<0:;751<431:<. @@3<7>74 89 :;7 51<4 .3473 :;<5 16671= <5 B<=74 <0 2;<-; <: <5 -.0:70474 :;1: 1<@1/813 615574 ! 215 4.<0@ 63<>1:7 573><-7 2.3F 104 7130<0@ 5))))# 673 /.0:; ?:
:;7 :3<8?01= ;15 :1F70 5$))# 673 /.0:; 104 474?-:74 $)C:.213456735.01=104=<><0@7G670575!;7=.55.BB?:?37 63.567-:5 215 0.: 14474 104 /71@73 1/.?0:5 2737 @310:74 ?0473:;7.:;73;7145104:;7<0:7375:<51=5.:.8770;10-74 !;?537E?75:74B.3/.4<B<-1:<.0.B:;7.3473
!;7 =713074 -.?057= B.3 :;7 1667==10:5#-=1</10:5 -.0:70474:;1:-;13@75;77:<5B<=741@1<05:3<47.B/.:.3-9-=7 ?0473 7-:<.0.B:;7"-:15;7;150.43<><0@=<-70-7 104 :;7 70:<37 07@=<@70-7 <5 .0 :;7 43<>73 .B :;7 :31-:.3 104 :31<=73 104 :;737B.37 :;7 -.0:3<8?:.39 07@=<@70-7 B<G74 89 :;7 :3<8?01= <5 :. 87 /.4<B<74 2;73715 =713074 -.?057= B.3 :;7 3756.0470:#<05?310-7 -./6109 -.0:70474 :;1: <0 ><72 .B :;7 -;13@75;77:B<=74.08.:;:;743<>735:;7:3<8?01=;153<@;:=9
- 5 -
15575574:;7-.0:3<8?:.3907@=<@70-715$)C:.71-;.B:;7/ 104<:077450.<0:73B7370-7
$7134:;713@?/70:5.B8.:;5<475
% !;7 !3<8?01= .8573>74 :;1: ?0473 G#-;13@7 5;77: <: 215 5:1:74 :;1: :;737 215 07@=<@70-7 .0 :;7 613: .B :;743<>73.B:;7:31-:.31041=5.3<473.B:;7/.:.3>7;<-=7 : 215 1=5. .8573>74 :;1: 67:<:<.07353756.0470:5 ;1>7 0.: -;1==70@74:;7-;13@75;77:104:;79;1>70.:5.?@;:B.337# <0>75:<@1:<.0 37@134<0@ -.0:3<8?:.39 07@=<@70-7 104 :;?5 <:
15575574 :;7 -.0:3<8?:.39 07@=<@70-7 .0 :;7 613: .B 8.:; :;7 43<>735 7E?1==9 <7 <0 :;7 31:<. .B $)$) 104 4<37-:74 3756.0470:.5104:.476.5<::;7-./67051:<.0<0:;751<4 31:<.
+!;7!3<8?01=B?3:;73.8573>74:;1::;7.2073104:;7 <05?373 .B :;7 /.:.3-9-=7 2737 0.: 14474 : <5 B.3 :;7 <05?310-7-./6109:.6=71410463.>7-.0:3<8?:.3907@=<@70-7 ?:<0:;7<3-.?0:73:;79;1>70.:6=71474!;7-157<5B<=74 1@1<05: :;7 .2073 104 :;7 <05?373 .B :;7 :31-:.3 104 :31<=73 .05<473<0@:;7/10073.B1--<470:104:;756.:/1;1D13:;<5
- 6 -
.?3: B<045 :;1: :;7 1--<470: 215 .--?3374 .0=9 4?7 :. :;7 07@=<@70-7.0:;7613:.B:;743<>73.B:;7:31-:.3104:31<=73 !;737 215 0. 43<><0@ =<-7057 B.3 :;7 3<473 .B :;7 /.:.3-9-=7 !;737B.37 :;7 -.0:3<8?:.39 07@=<@70-7 <5 :. 87 15575574 15 )C.0:;73<473.B:;7/.:.3-9-=7104*)C.0:;743<>73.B :;7:31-:.3104:31<=73
!;71@7.B:;747-7157415673G;<8<:2155;.20 15)971351::;7:</7.B:;71--<470:104:;7/?=:<6=<73<5 !;7 -=1</10:5 ;1>7 0.: 63.4?-74 109 <0-./7 63..B 7 /7:
2<:; 10 1--<470: .0 ))) !;737B.37 15 673 :;7 @?<47=<075 .B 1301:1F1 :1:7 7@1= 73><-75 ?:;.3<:9 ;<5 0.:<.01= <0-./7 <5 :. 87 :1F70 15 5+$)# 673 /.0:;
)C <5 :. 87 @310:74 :.21345 B?:?37 63.567-:5 15 673 :;7 A?4@/70: .B :;7 .0,8=7 ?637/7 .?3: <0 :;7 -157 .B
104 15 :;7 47-71574 215 1 81-;7=.3 $)C <5 :. 87 474?-:74 :.213456735.01=7G67057515673:;7@?<47=<075.B:;7.0,8=7
?637/7 .?3: <0 :;7 -157 .B
1 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 7 -
!;?5 =.55.B47670470-9-./75:. 5)+*)))#'+$)H)C#$)CGG(
*?3:;7315673:;7@?<47=<075.B:;7.0I8=7 ?637/7 .?3: <0 :;7 -157 .B
! "#
"$ %104<0 :;7 1?:;.3<:9 87:2770 &
! '()' * petitioner-claimant Nos.1 and 2, being the parents of the deceased, each of them are entitled for an amount of Rs.44,000/- towards filial consortium. Apart from that, 15 673 :;7 @?<47=<075 .B .0,8=7
?637/7.?3:<0:;7-157.B
+they are also entitled for an amount of Rs.33,000/- under the conventional heads. ) 0 1== :;7 -=1</10:5 137 70:<:=74 B.3 :;7 -./67051:<.0.B5)))))#2<:;<0:7375:1:%C673100?/ 151@1<05:5%%)))#121347489:;7!3<8?01=
2 (2009) 6 SCC 121 3 (2018) 18 SCC 130 4 (2020) 9 SCC 644 5 (2017) 16 SCC 680
- 8 -
!;712134.B-./67051:<.061557489:;7!3<8?01= <5/.4<B<7415?0473 7145 /.?0:<05 .55.B7670470-9 )+*)))# .55.B.05.3:<?/')))G( )))# !.21345-.0>70:<.01=;7145 )))# !.:1=
,
!;<516671=<5B<=7489:;7<0A?374-=1</10:<0".% .B ) -=1</<0@ -./67051:<.0 .B 5$)))))# !;7 !3<8?01=-.05<47374:;770:<377><470-7.037-.34104@310:74 101/.?0:.B5*))#2<:;<0:7375:1:%673-70:673100?/ B3./:;741:7.B67:<:<.0:<==371=<D1:<.0
@@3<7>7489:;751<4.3473:;<516671=<5637B73374 89:;71667==10:#-=1</10:<02;<-;<:<5/1<0=9-.0:70474:;1: ;72151@74)971351047130<0@5))))#673/.0:;104 ;7 5?5:1<074 /?=:<6=7 B31-:?375 ?: :;7 !3<8?01= @310:74 5+))# B.3 /74<-1= 7G670575 104 @=.81= -./67051:<.0 .B 5$)))# ?0473 :;7 .:;73 ;7145 104 <0:7375: <5 :. 87
- 9 -
70;10-74 :.
87
- 9 -
70;10-74 :. *C 673 100?/ --.34<0@=9 37E?75:74 B.3 70;10-7/70:<0-./67051:<.0
7134:;713@?/70:5.B8.:;5<475
$ 5 673 2.?04 -73:<B<-1:7 J G 67:<:<.073 5?5:1<074 18315<.0 .>73 =7B: :;<@; G-/ 18315<.0 .>73 3<@;:
@371: :.7 G$-/ 61<0 104 :704730755 .0 :;7 -;75: 104 184./<01=37@<.0'0.><5<8=72.?04637570:(
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
- 10 -
:;79713))104:;737B.37;<50.:<.01=<0-./7<5:.87:1F70 155+$)#15673:;7@?<47=<075.B 1301:1F1 :1:77@1=
73><-75?:;.3<:<75!;?55$)#'+$)G(<5@310:74 ?0473:;7;714=.55.B<0-./74?3<0@=1<4#?6673<.4
+ !;?5 <0 1== :;7 -=1</10: <5 70:<:=74 B.3 :;7 -./67051:<.0.B5$*%$)#2<:;<0:7375:1:%C673100?/ 151@1<05:5*))#121347489:;7!3<8?01=
!;712134.B-./67051:<.061557489:;7!3<8?01= <5/.4<B<7415?0473 7145 /.?0:<05 0A?3<75
$)))# 74<-1=7G670575
+))# 1<0104 ?BB73<0@
))))# $ !31056.3:1:<.0 104 7G:31 0.?3<5;/70:
))))# %.55.B7130<0@4?3<0@:;7=1<4?6 673<.4
$)# -./ $
* 0 :;<5 -157 :;7 67:<:<.073 <5 1 6<==<.0 3<473 .0 1 /.:.3-9-=7 104 :;7 -;13@7 5;77: <5 B<=74 1@1<05::;7 43<>73 .B
- 11 -
:;7:31-:.3104:31<=7355?-;<05?310-7-./6109<54<37-:74 :.476.5<:5$*%$)#2<:;<0:7375:1::;731:7.B%673-70: 673100?/
) 0:;7375?=::;7B.==.2<0@.3473<5615574 '<( .:;:;716671=51371==.274<0613: '<<( !;7=1</10:5<0.))$))13770:<:=74 B.3:;7:.:1=-./67051:<.0.B5)))))#2<:;<0:7375:1:% 673-70: 673 100?/ B3./ :;7 41:7 .B 67:<:<.0 :<== :;7 41:7 .B 371=<D1:<.0 '<<<( !;7=1</10:<0.))*)$)<570:<:=74B.3 :;7 :.:1= -./67051:<.0 .B 5$*%$)# 2<:; <0:7375: 1: % 673-70: 673 100?/ B3./ :;7 41:7 .B 67:<:<.0 :<== :;7 41:7 .B 371=<D1:<.0 *01+ 23 4356,73,-0,584.,93 9:6.,; 0,
2.5./43.7;73650-37<.=.4737 .:8,- >; -23 40>8,./ 23; .43 ,= /0.>/3 - 6.; <
-23 9:63,5.-0, 234343 4356,73,- 0,584.,93 9:6.,; 05 70439-37 - 73650- -23 >./.,93 9:63,5.-0, ./,? =0-2 0,-3435- .- -23 4.-3
< =0-20,,3:,-24:-237.-396;-2054734,
- 12 -
589273650->-2-2363-0-0,349/.0:.,-5.43634:0--37 - =0-274.= -23 3,-043 .:8,- ./,? =0-2 0,-3435- .994837-2343,3@8.//; '>( !;7 3756.0470:#<05?310-7 -./6109 <0
.))*)$) ;15 1=37149 476.5<:74 $)C .B -./67051:<.0 104:;737B.37:;791374<37-:74:.476.5<::;781=10-71/.?0: 2<:;<0:7375:1:%C673100?/2<:;<0.07/.0:;B3./:;741:7 .B -.69 .B :;<5 .3473
0 5?-; 476.5<: 89 :;7 3756.0470:# <05?310-7-./6109:;7-=1</10:<5673/<::74:.2<:;4312:;7 70:<371/.?0:1=.0@2<:;:;7<0:7375:1--3?74.0<:
57 *)##"+ ("
<5:. =.*