- 1 - !" # $% # $% !%"! ## &"' ( ! " #$% % & ' % $ !( ) $ & * %% ! Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " # + *)' * * ,( # ' * - ' *$'* . ) !))!)) -()! * * * $ $ . $ $ / -()( $ $*0$ ' ** * . 1$ 1$ - 3 - % #1$ ' 23/ 455647 89:6; 6<=3>9 ,(# ' >? >=>; 623<76/ <= - #26;6394?=6; ;6?6;;6: => 4/ @=26 <=0' 24/ A669 ?376:AB=26<743C49=A639D4DD;36E6:AB=26F8:DC69=49: 4G4;: :4=6: ) !))!)) 54//6: AB 26 >8;= >? 26 ::3=3>947693>;3E378:D649: 3F4B458;439 >-()! ) *4<=/ D3E39D ;3/6 => =26 ?3739D >? =26 455647 A;36?7B /=4=6: 4;6 =24= >9 ! !)! , 4= 4A>8= (! =26<743C49=49:49>=26;56;/>9G6;65;><66:39D=>G4;:/ 4HH474H3 >9 C>=>;<B<76 A64;39D >% )&(! 26 <743C49= G4/ ;3:39D =26 C>=>;<B<76 39 4 /7>G 49: <48=3>8/ C4996; G269 =26 <743C49= G4/ 5;><66:39D >9 >24D49E >24D49E >4: 964; =26 749: >? 4C8 %4E474D3 8=> 3<H/24G A64;39D 6D>% ) )- <4C6 ?;>C >55>/3=6 /3:6 :;3E69 4= 23D2 /566: 39 4 ;4/2 49:96D73D69=C4996;49::4/26:4D439/==26C>=>;<B<76 - 4 - / 4 ;6/87= >? =26 4?>;6/43: 4<<3:69= =26 <743C49= /8/=4396:D;36E>8/39F8;36/49:G4/2>/53=473I6: ( 26<743C49=?376:456=3=3>989:6;6<=3>9 >?=26 <=/66H39D<>C569/4=3>9=G4/5764:6:=24=26 /569= /3D93?3<49= 4C>89= =>G4;:/ C6:3<47 6J569/6/ <>9E6B49<6<24;D6/49:>=26;;674=6:<>/=/=G4/?8;=26; 5764:6: =24= =26 4<<3:69= ><<8;;6: />767B >9 4<<>89= >? ;4/2 49:96D73D69= :;3E39D >? =26 >??69:39D E623<76 AB 3=/ :;3E6; 5>9/6;E3<6>?9>=3<6=26;6/5>9:69=> 49: )45564;6:=2;>8D2<>89/6749:?376:4G;3==69/=4=6C69= :69B39D=264E6;C69=/C4:639=26<743C56=3=3>9 9=26A4/3/>?=265764:39D/>?=2654;=36/=26 743C/;3A8947?;4C6:=263//86/49:=26;64?=6;;6<>;:6: =26 6E3:69<6 26 ;3A8947 AB 3C58D96: F8:DC69= 49: 4G4;:24/54;=7B477>G6:=26<743C56=3=3>949:267:=24= =26<743C49=3/69=3=76:=>4<>C569/4=3>9>?/!,- 47>9DG3=239=6;6/=4==26;4=6>?K5449::3;6<=6:=26 - 5 - ;6/5>9:69= >) => :65>/3= =26 <>C569/4=3>9 4C>89= 47>9D G3=2 39=6;6/= $639D 4DD;36E6: =26 5;6/69= 455647 24/A669?376: 26764;96:<>89/67?>;=26<743C49=24/;43/6: =26?>77>G39D<>9=69=3>9/ 4' *3;/=7B =26 <743C49= 4//6;=/ =24= 26 G4/ 64;939D /)!!!! 56; C>9=2 AB G>;H39D 4/ 4D;3<87=8;6 G>;H >G6E6; =26 ;3A8947 24/ 6;;6: 39 =4H39D =26 39<>C6 4/ C6;67B4// !)!56;C>9=2 A' 6<>9:7B =26 <743C49= 24/ 6J4C396: =26 :><=>; 4/ .(26;3A894789:6;E4786:=26<743C49=1/G2>76A>:B :3/4A373=B4= )K<>9=;4:3<=39D=266E3:69<6>?=26:><=>; =24==26<743C49=/8??6;6:!K=>K:3/4A373=B=>;3D2= 7>G6; 73CA 49: K => ;3D2= 8556; 73CA 26 ;3A8947 4 6:G2>76A>:B:3/4A373=B )K3/7>G6;/3:6 <' 4/=7B :86 => =26 4<<3:69= =26 <743C49= 24/ /8/=4396:D;36E>8/39F8;36/6G4/=;64=6:4/3954=369=?>; 4 56;3>: >? :4B/ E69 4?=6; :3/<24;D6 ?;>C =26 - 6 - 2>/53=4726G4/9>=3945>/3=3>9=>:3/<24;D623/;6D874; G>;H 6 24/ /8??6;6: 7>= >? 5439 :8;39D =;64=C69= >9/3:6;39D =26 /4C6 =26 >E6;477 <>C569/4=3>9 4G4;:6: AB=26;3A89473/>9=267>G6;/3:6 , .3=2=264A>E6<>9=69=3>9/=26764;96:<>89/67 />8D2==>477>G=26455647 6; <>9=;4 ;3 49E69:;4 6::B 764;96: <>89/67 45564;39D ?>; =269/8;49<6 >C549B 24/ ;43/6: =26?>77>G39D<>9=69=3>9/ 4' *3;/=7B =26 39F8;B /8??6;6: AB =26 <743C49= 3/ C39>;3994=8;6E69=2>8D2=26:><=>;24/4 6:=26 :3/4A373=B 4= ! => K 26 24/ 9>= 4 6: =26 G2>76 :3/4A373=B49:263/9>=4=;64=6::><=>;>9/3:6;39D=26 C6:3<47;6<>;:/49:6E3:69<6>?=2654;=36/=26;3A8947 24/;3D2=7B4 6:=26G2>76A>:B:3/4A373=B4= )K A' 6<>9:7B <>9/3:6;39D =24= 6E3:69<6 >? :><=>; 49:C6:3<47;6<>;:/G>89:<6;=3?3<4=6J,49::3/4A373=B <6;=3?3<4=6 4= J 26 ;3A8947 24/ ;3D2=7B 4 6: - 7 - =26<>C569/4=3>9?>;543949:/8??6;39D7>//>?4C693=36/ 49:>=26;6J569/6/69<626/>8D2=?>;:3/C3//47>?=26 455647 - 64;: =26 764;96: <>89/67 ?>; =26 54;=36/ 49: 56;8/6:=26F8:DC69=49:4G4;:>?=26;3A8947 ! = 3/ 9>= 39 :3/58=6 =24= =26 <743C49= 24/ /8/=4396:39F8;36/39=26;>4:=;4??3<4<<3:69=><<8;;6:>9 ! !)! , :86 => ;4/2 49: 96D73D69= :;3E39D >? =26 >??69:39DE623<76 86 => =26 4<<3:69==26<743C49=24/ /8??6;6: =26?>77>G39D39F8;B ! " # ! " $%$ & - 8 - ) 26 <743C49= 24/ 6J4C396: ; /2>H 4:24E 4/.(923/6E3:69<62624/>5396:=24=<743C49=24/ /8??6;6: 56;C4969= :3/4A373=B >? ! => K => =26 ;3D2= 7>G6; 73CA K 56;C4969= :3/4A373=B => ;3D2= 8556; 73CA >9/3:6;39D =26 6E3:69<6 >? :><=>; :3/4A373=B <6;=3?3<4=6 49:C6:3<47;6<>;:/G64;6>?=26>5393>9=24==26G2>76 A>:B:3/4A373=B24/=>A64 6: K26<743C49=3/ 4D6: 4A>8= B64;/ 4= =26 =3C6 >? =26 4<<3:69= 49: C87=35736; 45573<4A76 => 23/ 4D6 D;>85 3/ @ 0 28/ =26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: ?>; <>C569/4=3>9 >? )** + #/ !)!L )L L K' >9 4<<>89= >? 17>// >? ?8=8;6 39<>C61 ( 86=264<<3:69==26<743C49=24//8??6;6:=26 4A>E6/43:39F8;36/49:26G4/3954=369=?>;456;3>:>? :4B/624//8??6;6:47>=>?5439:8;39D=26=;64=C69= 624/=>/8??6;=23/:3/4A373=B49:892455396//=2;>8D2>8= 23/73?6>9/3:6;39D=266E3:69<6>?=26:><=>;49:39F8;B /8??6;6: AB =26 <743C49= G6 39<7396: => 69249<6 =26 <>C569/4=3>9?>;@543949:/8??6;39D0?;>C/)!!!!=> - 9 - )+@7>// >?39<>C6 :8;39D 743: 8556;3>:0 3/ => A6D;49=6:?>;=2;66C>9=2/36)+# !)!J ( C>9=2/' *8;=26; @7>// >? 4C693=36/0 3/ => A6 69249<6: ?;>C/)!!!!=>)+ 26 <>C569/4=3>9 4G4;:6: AB =26 ;3A8947 >9 >=26;264:/3/F8/=49:;64/>94A76 28/ =26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: => =26 ?>77>G39D <>C569/4=3>9 ,-./)012/ 3/4.542.5./1 .04) )06054.4 7819. 5273/0: &)' )06054.4 78192)351 &)' 43949:/8??6;39D /)!!!! /!!!! 6:3<476J569/6/ / ( - / ( - >//>?64;939D :8;39D743:8556;3>: / !)! /(!,! >//>??8=8;6 64;939D>94<<>89=>? 56;C4969=:3/4A373=B / ,))!! /(!--! >//>?4C693=36/49: ?8=8;6892455396// /)!!!! /!!!! ==69:49=:36= <>9E6B49<649: >=26;<24;D6/ /(!!!! /(!!!! 10: ) * ) * - 10 - 9=26;6/87==26?>77>G39D>;:6;3/54//6: 4' 264556473/ A' 26 F8:DC69= >? =26 743C/ ;3A8947 3/ C>:3?36: <' 26 <743C49= 3/ 69=3=76: => 4 =>=47 <>C569/4=3>9>?) *+4/4D439/= /!,-4G4;:6:AB=26;3A8947 :' 26 9/8;49<6 >C549B 3/ :3;6<=6: => :65>/3= =26 <>C569/4=3>9 4C>89= 47>9D G3=239=6;6/=K54?;>C=26:4=6>??3739D >? =26 <743C 56=3=3>9 =377 =26 :4=6 >? ;6473I4=3>9 G3=239 4 56;3>: >? /3J G66H/ ?;>C =26 :4=6 >? ;6<635= >? <>5B >? =23/ F8:DC69= 6' 26:65>/3=49:;6764/6>?4C>89=/2477A6 C4:639=6;C/>?=264G4;:>?=26;3A8947 4+ &# ' % 4+ &!%"!' % 3/=> 7>) $