- 1 - ! "#$## #% &'(&)*+ ',&** - !"# $ % & " !# $ % & ' ( # ' #"#( #"")#"# #"#( ' ' ("!"#"#( ' ( "#"!* ''' !(' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' + %+ & ,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 6-037 5,- 899:1-; 03 2( "#"!235,-<0=-2<5,-=-8.3-;0/0=:;7-83; ' 03;870 01 0>4:73037 5,- ?:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- ;85-; ("!"#"#( 923/095037 ,0> <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 !( 2< 5,- -725086=- 315.:>-351 95 %<2. 1,2.5 @ 95A& 83; 1-35-39037 52 48B <03- 2< 1 !" """ C05, ;-<8:=5 1-35-39- C,09, C81 923<0.>-; 03 .0>038= 44-8= 2#"#(235,-<0=-2<5,-=-8.3-;;;050238=015.095 83; -110231 :;7- 0?8B84:.8 /0;- ?:;7>-35 ;85-; #"")#"# - 3 - # -8.; .0 878=0 =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- .-/01023 4-505023-. 83; .0 ,0/8383; 8558381,-550 =-8.3-;92:31-=<2.5,-.-1423;-35-.:1-;5,->85-.08=1 23.-92.; ( 5 01 5,- 9235-35023 2< 5,- 92>4=803835 6-<2.- 5,-.08= 2:.5 5,85 5,- 899:1-; ,8; 62..2C-; 81:>2< 1# "" """ 52 >--5 ,-. <0383908= 3--;1 ;:.037 2/->6-. #"!# 87.--037 52 .-48B 5,- 18>- C05,03 23- >235, 2C8.;1 .-48B>-35 2< =283 8>2:35 5,- 899:1-; 011:-; 5C2 9,-D:-1 81 4-. E1! 83; # <2. 1! "" """ -89, ,-3 5,- 180; 9,-D:-1 C-.- 4.-1-35-;<2.-3981,>-35 5,-18>-C-.-;01,232:.-;81 5,-.-C81031:<<090-35<:3;035,-8992:352<5,-899:1-; ,- =-78= 32509- 81 4-. E) C81 011:-; ,- 899:1-; ;-=06-.85-=B -/8;-; 5,- 1-./09- 2< 32509- 83; .-<:1-; 52 .-9-0/- 5,- 18>- /-3 8<5-. .-<:18= 2< 5,- =-78= 32509- 5,- 899:1-; ,8; 325 .-480; 5,- 9,-D:- 8>2:35 32. .-4=0-; 52 5,- 18>- 83; 5,-.-6B 92>>055-; 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=-:3;-.-95023!(2<95 - 4 - -55037 2:5 5,-1- <8951 83; 90.9:>15839-1 5,- 4.0/85- 92>4=8035 03 2(!#"!( 98>- 52 6- <0=-; 6-<2.-5,-.08=2:.5,-.08=2:.5522F92730G839-2< 5,- 2<<-39- 83; 1:>>23-; 899:1-; 6B .-7015-.037 2( "#"!,-899:1-;844-8.-;6-<2.-5,-.08= 2:.5 83; 4=-8;-; 325 7:0=5B <2. 5,- 2<<-39- 4:301,86=- :3;-. -95023 !( 2< 5,- 95 ,- 92>4=803835 -E8>03-;,0>1-=<81!83;725>8.F-;E1!52H03 1:442.52<,019235-35023,-899:1-;,81;-30-;8==5,- 039.0>0385037 >85-.08=1 8/80=86=- 23 .-92.; -E8>03-; ,-.1-=<81!83;725>8.F-;E1!52031:442.5 2< ,-. ;-<-39- ,- .08= 2:.5 8<5-. 58F037 0352 92310;-.85023 8== 5,-1- >85-.08=1 23 .-92.; 98>- 52 5,- 9239=:1023 5,85 5,- 92>4=803835 01 1:99-11<:= 03 4.2/037 5,-7:0=52<5,-899:1-;6-B23;.-812386=-;2:65 6:55,- 899:1-; ,81 325 .-6:55-; 5,- =-78= 4.-1:>45023 83; 5,-.-<2.- 01 =086=- <2. 923/095023 992.;037=B 5,- 0>4:73-; ?:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- 98>-526-4811-; - 5 - -037877.0-/-;6B5,-18>- 5,-899:1-;,81 4.-<-..-;.0>038=44-8=2#"#(,-'0.1544-==85- 2:.523.-844.-90850232<5,->85-.08=123.-92.; <2:3; 5,85 5,-92>4=803835011:99-11<:=034.2/0375,-7:0=52< 5,- 899:1-; 6-B23; .-812386=- ;2:65 83; 8992.;037=B ;01>011-; 5,- 844-8= 6B 923<0.>037 5,- ?:;7>-35 2< 923/09502383;2.;-.2<1-35-39--037877.0-/-;6B5,- 18>- 5,-899:1-;016-<2.-5,012:.5 -8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- 4-505023-. 9235-3;-; 5,85 011:839- 2< 9,-D:-1 81 4-. E1! 83; # 52C8.;1 5,-;019,8.7-2<=-78==B-3<2.9-86=-;-65013254.2/-;6B 5,- 92>4=803835 81 =-3;037 2< 5,- 8>2:35 051-=< 01 325 4.2/-; 3 5,- 25,-. ,83; ! ;:.037 9.211 -E8>0385023 8;>055-; 5,85 ,- C81 ;2037 6:103-11 03 1,8.-183;5,-1-9,-D:-1C-.-011:-;8181-9:.05B,:1 5,- 899:1-; 01 1:99-11<:= 03 .-6:55037 5,- =-78= 4.-1:>45023,-.08=2:.583;5,-'0.1544-==85-2:.5 ,8/- 325 844.-9085-; 5,01 <895 83; 4.29--;-; 52 923/095 5,-899:1-; - 6 - ) ,- 1-923; 9235-35023 .801-; 6B 5,- =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- 4-505023-. 01 5,85 81 4-. -95023 !( 2< 95 >8E0>:> 1-35-39- 5,85 92:=; 6- 0>421-; 01 52 =-/B <03- :452 ;2:6=- 5,- 9,-D:- 8>2:35 6:5 03 5,- 4.-1-35 981- <03- 2< 1 !" """ C81 0>421-; 83; 5,- 18>- 01 68; :3;-. =8C 3 5,- 8=5-.385- =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2.5,-.-/010234-505023-.1--F1=-30-39B031-35-390375,- 899:1-; -. 9235.8 =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- .-1423;-35 244210375,-1:6>0110231>8;-6B5,-=-8.3-;92:31-=<2. 5,-4-505023-.9235-3;-;5,85 625,5,-9,-D:-18.-;85-; "!!#"!# 83; 5,- 92>4=803835 C81 >8;- 52 .:3 <.2> 40==8.524215-/-38<5-.!(B-8.1,-.-<2.- 5,-4-505023-. 01 325 -3505=-; <2. 83B =-30-39B 83; 8992.;037=B 4.8B1 <2. ;01>0118=2<5,-4-505023 H 3 /0-C 2< 5,- .0/8= 9235-350231 :.7-; 6B 5,- =-8.3-;92:31-=<2.625,5,-48.50-1 5,-420355,85C2:=; 8.01-<2.>B92310;-.8502301 - 7 - !" B831C-.525,-862/-4203501035,-+ <2.5,-<2==2C037 !! 3 4-.:18= 2< 5,- >85-.08=1 23 .-92.; 5,- 92>4=803835-E8>03-;81!14-90<098==B1585-;5,85 5,- 899:1-; ,8; 844.289,-; 5,- 92>4=803835 83; ,8; 58F-3 =2832<1# "" """4.2>0103752.-48B5,-18>-C05,03 23- >235, 2C8.;1 ;019,8.7- 2< 5,- =283 8>2:35 9,-D:-1814-.E1!83;#C-.-011:-; C,09,98>-52 6-;01,232.-;815,-.-C81031:<<090-35<:3;035,-8992:35 2< 5,- 899:1-; 3 1405- 2< 011:839- 2< =-78= 32509- 5,- 9,-D:- 8>2:35 C81 325 .-480; 83; 5,-.-6B 5,- 899:1-; ,81 92>>055-; 5,- 862/- 180; 2<<-39- ! C81 9.211 -E8>03-;85=-375, 6:515.837-=B325,037011:77-15-;52 - 8 - 5,- C053-11 862:5 5,- ;-<-39- 2< 5,- 899:1-; 5 01 325 >8;-9=-8.8152C,B83;C,-39,-D:-181E1!83;# C-.- 011:-; 6B 5,- 899:1-; ,- 5-32. 2< 5,- 9.211 -E8>0385023 2< ! ;019=21-1 5,85 5,- 899:1-; 01 325 ;014:50375,85E1!83;#6-=237152,-.683F8992:35 83; 05 6-8.1 ,-. 107385:.-1 39- 5,- 899:1-; 8;>051 011:839-2<9,-D:-1C05,,-.107385:.-1 5,-4.-1:>45023 :3;-. -95023 !! 83; !(H 2< 95 C2:=; 8.01- ,- 6:.;-3 1,0<51 23 5,- 899:1-; 52 .-6:5 5,- =-78= 4.-1:>45023 !# ,- 899:1-; -35-.-; 5,- C053-11 62E 83; ;-421-; 81! 52 9235-3; 5,85C,0=-;-8=037 C05, 5,- 1,8.-1 1,-,8;011:-;E1!83;#811-9:.05B83;5,- 18>-C-.->01:1-;6B5,-92>4=8038351,8/-8=.-8;B 325-; 321:9,1:77-150231C-.->8;-52!;:.037,01 9.211-E8>0385023 5 01 <2. 5,- <0.15 50>- 1:9, 8 ;-<-39- C81 58F-3 C,-3 5,- 899:1-; -35-.-; 5,- C053-11 62E 3;-. 1:9, 90.9:>15839-1 ;2 325 <03; 83B .-8123 52 899-451:9,;-<-39-83; 05,81526-.-?-95-;,-35,- - 9 - 899:1-;<80=-;52.-6:55,-=-78=4.-1:>45023 1,-01=086=- <2.923/095023 !( ,8/-723-5,.2:7,5,-0>4:73-;?:;7>-352< 923/09502383;2.;-.2<1-35-39-4811-;6B5,-.08=2:.5 83;8=125,-?:;7>-354811-;6B5,-'0.1544-==85-2:.5 25, 5,- 2:.51 ,8/- 58F-3 0352 92310;-.85023 8== 5,-1- >85-.08=123.-92.;83;.07,5=B923/095-;5,-899:1-;;2 325<03;83B.-812352035-.<-.-C05,5,-18>- ! ,-.08=2:.5C,0=-923/0950375,-899:1-;<2. 5,-2<<-39-4:301,86=-:3;-.-95023!(2<5,-95 ,811-35-39-;,-.5248B<03-2<1 !" """ C,09,0103 -E9-11 2< ;2:6=- 5,- 9,-D:- 8>2:35 3 /0-C 2< 5,- 1:6>0110231 >8;- 6B 5,- =-8.3-; 92:31-= <2. 5,- 4-505023-. 8>2<5,-24030235,85 12>-=-30-39B>8B6- 1,2C3C,0=-1-35-390375,-899:1-;992.;037=B 831C-. 5,-862/-42035@ 83;4.29--; 5248115,-<2==2C037 - 10 - 8& .0>038=.-/010234-50502301 6& ,- ?:;7>-35 2< 923/095023 83; 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- ;85-; ("!"#"#( 4811-; 03 2( "#"! 23 5,- <0=- 2< 5,- =-8.3-; 0/0= :;7- 83; ' 03;70 01 ,-.-6B 923<0.>-; 9& ,- 2.;-. 2< 1-35-39- ;85-; ("!"#"#( 4811-; 6B 5,- .08= 2:.5 01 >2;0<0-; 81 :3;-. %0& ,- 4-505023-.899:1-; 01 1-35-39-; 52 48B <03- 2< 1( " """ 52 6- ;-42105-; C05,03 8 4-.02; 2< 10E C--F1 <.2>52;8B %00& :5 2< 5,- <03- 8>2:35 52 6- ;-42105-; 6B 5,- 899:1-; 8 1:> 2< 1( """ 01 52 6- 480; 52 5,- - 11 - 92>4=803835 81 92>4-3185023 :3;-. -95023()2<. -7015.B01;0.-95-;521-3;689F5,-.08=2:.5 .-92.;1 83; '0.15 44-==85- 2:.5 .-92.;1 8=237 5,- 924B2<5,-?:;7>-35<2.03<2.>8502383;<2.3--;<:= 895023 .+ &##* $ 0152!=2(