Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 65109 (KAR)
GAJANAND @ GAJANAN v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.RP/200117/2024 · 2025-09-12
M G Uma
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65109 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 65109 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#
$#!%!##
#&! '
(')*+
'!!**
,
! "#$%&%
'
'
! () ! *$ +**, ! ,&, ' %*&$,&,*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'
,& ,&,* !'' ! ! %$&%,&,* '! %#$, ,&%) ! !! ,)( ) $ &*" ! %$) !'
' ! ! +'
' -'''
-'''
./ 0/121234/5 6/247 1./ 899:;/< 24 3%#$, ,&%)341./=2>/3=1./>/854/<<<212348> 2?2> :<7/ 84< '! 2@8A80:58 B=35 ;.351 C1./ 528> 3:51DE2;2F0:742471./@:<7F/413=934?29123484<35</5 3= ;/41/49/ <81/< %$&%,&,* 934?291247 .2F =35 1./ 3==/49/; 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234; ,)( ) $ &* 3= 1./4<284
/48>3</%$&B=35;.351 C1./
DE84< /91234 %$) 3= 1./ '3135 /.29>/; 91 %($$ B=35 ;.351 C1./ ' 91DE 84< ;/41/49247 13 :4</573 ;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41=3580/523<3=1G3F341.;84<1308A=24/
- 3 -
3=;%&&& "=351./3==/49/0:42;.86>/:4</5/91234,)( 3=
H 13 :4</573 ;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41 =35 8 0/523< 3= 34/ F341. 84< 13 08A =24/ 3= ;%&&& " =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234 ) 3=
H 13 :4</573 ;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41=3580/523<3=34/F341.84<1308A=24/3= ;%#&& "=351./3==/49/0:42;.86>/:4</5/91234$3= H 13 :4</573 ;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41 =35 8 0/523< 3= ;2I F341.; 84< 13 08A =24/ 3= ;#&&& " =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234 &* 3=
H 84< 13 :4</573 ;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41 =35 8 0/523< 3= 1G3 F341.; 84< 13 08A =24/ 3= ;,&&& " =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234%$)3=1./'91G21.</=8:>1;/41/49/;G.29. 2; 934=25F/< 6A 1./ <<212348> 2;15291 84< /;;234; :<7/2@8A80:58B=35;.351C1./!25;100/>>81/3:51DE24 52F248> 00/8> 3,& ,&,* ?2</ 21; @:<7F/41 <81/< %*&$,&,*
, /85< 52 .2?8484<
811848;./112 >/854/< 93:4;/> =35 1./ 0/121234/5 84< 52 8F8<85 .8.86:<<24 >/854/<27.3:513?/54F/41
>/8</5=351./5/;034</41
- 4 -
J181/
/5:;/< 1./ F81/528>; 34 5/935< 249>:<247 1./ 528>3:5184<!25;100/>>81/3:515/935<;
4 ?2/G 3= 1./ 52?8> 9341/41234; :57/< 6A >/854/<93:4;/>=35631.1./08512/;1./032411.81G3:>< 852;/=35FA934;2</5812342;
'A 84;G/5 13 1./ 863?/ 03241 2; C
D=351./=3>>3G2475/8;34; !! * !891;3=1./98;/24652/=85/1.81
+"%6/247 1./ /A/G214/;; >3<7/< =25;1 24=35F81234 8; 0/5 I
"% 87824;11./899:;/<;1812471.811./899:;/<G8;<52?247 1./ 985 6/85247 /73", "(&, 24 8 58;. 84< 4/7>27/41F844/584<248.27.;0//<;38;13/4<847/5 1./.:F84>2=/84<<8;./<131./F31359A9>/52<</46A 1./ </9/8;/< 5=84 8; 8 5/;:>1 3= G.29.
./ <2/< 34 1./
- 5 -
;031 84< 1./ 02>>234 52</5 G.3 2; /I8F24/< 8;
+", ;:;1824/< 24@:52/; =1/5 1./ 8992</41 1./ 899:;/< 584 8G8A=53F1./;031G21.3:124=35F2471./03>29/863:11./ 8992</411./5/6A1./899:;/<.8;93FF211/<1./8>>/7/< 3==/49/;
# =1/524?/;12781234=248>5/035198F/136/=2>/< /854/< '872;1581/ 133K 93742L849/ 3= 1./ 3==/49/; 84< 5/72;1/5/< 3%#$, ,&%) ./ 899:;/< 800/85/< 6/=35/ 1./ 528> 3:51 0>/8</< 431 7:2>1A 84< 9>82F/< 13 6/ 152/<
53;/9:1234 /I8F24/<
+;"% 13 # 84< 731 F85K/< I;
"% 13 % 24 ;:00351 3= 21; 9341/41234 99:;/<</42/<8>>1./24952F2481247F81/528>;8?82>86>/34 5/935< 6:1 .8; 431 >/< 84A /?2</49/ 24 ;:00351 3= .2; </=/49/./528>3:518=1/518K2472413934;2</5812348>> 1./;/ F81/528>; 34 5/935< 98F/ 13 1./ 9349>:;234 1.81 1./ 053;/9:1234 2; ;:99/;;=:> 24 053?247 1./ 7:2>1 3= 1./ 899:;/<6/A34<5/8;3486>/<3:6184<89935<247>A08;;/< 1./ 2F0:74/< @:<7F/41 3= 934?291234 84< 35</5 3= ;/41/49/8;;181/<863?/
- 6 -
/247 87752/?/< 6A 1./ ;8F/ 1./ 899:;/< 05/=/55/<52F248>00/8>3,& ,&,,./!25;100/>>81/ 3:51 34 5/"8005/9281234 3= 1./ F81/528>; 34 5/935< <2;F2;;/< 1./ 800/8> G.2>/ 934=25F247 1./ 2F0:74/< @:<7F/41 3= 934?291234 84< 35</5 3= ;/41/49/ 08;;/< 6A 1./528>3:51/24787752/?/<6A1./;8F/1./899:;/< 2;6/=35/1.2;3:51
) ?/41.3:7.;/?/58>753:4<;85/582;/<6A1./ 0/121234/5241./5/?2;2340/121234>/854/<93:4;/>=351./ 0/121234/5 5/;15291/< .2; 857:F/41 34>A 13 ;//K >/42/49A G.2>/ ;/41/49247 1./ 899:;/< =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234 &* 3=
/854/< 93:4;/> ;:6F211/< 1.81 1./ 0/121234/5 .8; 72?/4 :0 8>> 31./5 9341/41234;
582;/< 24 1./ 5/?2;234 0/121234 84< 89935<247>A 058A; =35 8>>3G2471./0/121234
$
40/5:;8>3=1./F81/528>;345/935<212;9>/85 1.81
+"% 2; 84 /A/G214/;; G.3 >3<7/< =25;1 24=35F81234 8; 0/5 I
"% ;181247 1.81 1./ </9/8;/< G8; 0539//<247
- 7 -
34 .2; F3135 9A9>/ 8>347 G21. .2; F31./5 84< <8:7.1/5 84< 1./ 899:;/< 6/247 1./ <52?/5 3= 1./ 3==/4<247 985 <53?/ 1./ ;8F/ 24 8 58;. 84< 4/7>27/41 F844/5 84< 81 .27. ;0//< ;3 8; 13 /4<847/5 1./ .:F84 >2=/ G.29.
5/;:>1/< 24 1./ 8992</41 ./ 48F/ 3= 1./ 0/121234/5 2;
;0/92=298>>A F/41234/< 6A
+"% 24 1./ =25;1 24=35F81234 :034G.29.!8;0/5I
"%&98F/136/5/72;1/5/<
( +"%G8;/I8F24/<6/=35/1./528>3:5184< .8;=:>>A;:00351/<1./98;/3=053;/9:1234
+",2;1./ 02>>23452</5G21.1./</9/8;/<84<;./.8;8>;3;:00351/< 1./ 98;/ 3= 053;/9:1234
+", 6/247 1./ 24@:5/< /A/G214/;;./5?/5;234;184<;34.27./5=33124784<1./5/ 85/ 43 5/8;34; 13 <2;6/>2/?/ 1./ ;8F/ ./ G3:4< 9/512=2981/ 0/51824247 13
+", 2; 8>;3 053<:9/< 6A 1./ 053;/9:12348;0/5I
"=1.//?2</49/3=
+;"%84<, 8>347G21.1./F81/528>;1.8185/0>89/<6/=35/1./3:51 85/18K/42413934;2</5812341./053;/9:12342;;:99/;;=:> 24 053?247 1./ 7:2>1 3= 1./ 899:;/< =35 1./ 3==/49/; 0:42;.86>/:4</5/91234;,)()$84<&*3=
- 8 -
<F211/<>A 1./ 899:;/< .8< 431 24=35F/< 1./ =891:F 3= 98:;247 8992</41 13 1./ 4/85/;1 03>29/ ;181234 6:1 =>/< =53F1./;031/49/./2;8>;3>286>/=35934?291234:4</5 /91234%$)3='91
%& ./ 528> 3:51 84< 1./ !25;1 00/>>81/ 3:51 .8?/ 8005/9281/< 1./ F81/528>; 34 5/935< 24 0530/5 0/5;0/912?/84<934?291/<1./899:;/<=351./863?/;82< 3==/49/; <3 431 =24< 84A 5/8;34 13 241/5=/5/ G21. 1./ ;8F/
%% 1 2; 43129/< 1.81 1./ 528> 3:51 84< 1./ !25;1 00/>>81/ 3:51 .8?/ 0539//</< 13 934?291 1./ 899:;/<
631. =35 1./ 3==/49/; 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234; ,)( 84< &*3= ==/49/:4</5/91234,)(3=
6/2471./ F2435 3==/49/ F/57/; G21. 1./ F8@35 3==/49/ :4</5 /91234&*3=
24?2/G3=1./</92;2343=1./34D6>/ 0/I 3:51 24
4?2/G3=1./;8F/8F3=1./
1 (2012) 8 SCC 734
- 9 -
30242341.811./0/121234/52;431>286>/136/;/41/49/<=35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234 ,)( 3=
:9. 35</53=;/41/49/2;>286>/136/;/18;2</
%, ./ 8992</41 24 M:/;1234 .8< 399:55/< 34 &*&(,&%/49/ >/42/49AF8A 6/;.3G424=8?3:53= 1./0/121234/524;/41/49247.2F
% 4?2/G3=1./863?/84;G/51./863?/03241 C0851>A 24 1./ 8==25F812?/D 84< 0539//< 13 08;; 1./ =3>>3G247
2 ./ 52F248> /?2;234
/121234 2;
22 ./ 2F0:74/< @:<7F/41 3= 934?291234 <81/< %$&%,&,* 08;;/< 24 3%#$, ,&%) 6A 1./ <<212348> 2?2> :<7/ 84< '! 2@8A80:582;./5/6A
- 10 -
222 ./ 35</5 3= ;/41/49/ 08;;/< 87824;1 1./ 0/121234/5 =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234,)(3=
2;
2? !24/ 8F3:41 2= 84A </03;21/< 6A 1./ 0/121234/5 =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234,)(3=
2;35</5/<136/5/=:4</< 34<:/2</412=2981234 ? ./ 35</5 3= ;/41/49/ 08;;/< 6A 1./ 528> 3:51 =35 1./ 3==/49/; 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234; ) $ 3=
84< :4</5/91234 %$)3='912;./5/6A ?2 ./ 35</5 3= ;/41/49/ 08;;/< 6A 1./ 528> 3:51 =35 1./ 3==/49/ 0:42;.86>/ :4</5 /91234&*3=
2;F3<2=2/<8;:4</5 ./0/121234/52;;/41/49/<13:4</573 527353:; 2F052;34F/41 =35 8 0/523< 3= 1.5// F341.; 84< 13 08A =24/ 3= ;%&&&& " 24 </=8:>1 1308A=24/./
- 11 -
;.8>> :4</573;2F0>/ 2F052;34F/41=35 80/523<3=34/F341. ?22
/121234/52;/4121>/<=351./6/4/=213=;/13== 8;053?2</<:4</5/91234*,$3=5
/72;15A 2; <25/91/< 13 ;/4< 689K 1./ 528> 3:51 5/935<; 8>347 G21. 930A 3= 1.2; @:<7F/41 =35 24=35F81234 84<4//<=:>891234
!-+ '##* %
+ 2;13%>3,(