Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64906 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER v. KISHAN AND ANR
MFA/201870/2022 · 2025-09-18
H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64906 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64906 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#!$
$! % &!$!! % &! ! !$$
'() *+ ! !$$
'() ! !$$
'() ! !$$
'() ! !$$ ,
'() ! !$$
",
'() ! !$$ ,
'() ! !$$
","
'() ! !$$
",
'() ! !$$
"
'()
*
+
! Digitally signed by BASALINGAPPA SHIVARAJ DHUTTARGAON Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" #"
$ # ## % #
#
&
'
(()$)
#
"
)*)(()
(
" #
#
# )*)$( ! "& (+ $"
#&&$$ &# "
,#
( # ((( #" ((( ## #
#
# &
# ##
*
+ #
(
$$$
! " #"
- 3 -
$ # ## % #
#
&
'
(()$)
#
"
)*)(()
(
" #
#
# )*)$( ! "& (+
" $*((( $
#&&$$ &# "
,#
( # ((( #" ()(( ## #
#
# &
# ##
*
+ #
" (
-
! " #"
$ # ## %
- 4 -
#
#
&
'
(()$)
#
"
)*)(()
(
" #
#
# )*)$( ! "& (+
" (.*((( $
#&&$$ &# "
,#
( # ((( #" (.(( ## #
#
# &
# ##
*
+ #
(
)
! " #"
$ # ## %
- 5 -
#
#
&
'
(()$)
#
"
)*)(()
(
" #
#
# )*)$( ! "& (+ $"
#&&$$ &# "
,#
( # ((( #" ((( ## #
#
# &
# ##
,*
+
(*
($-
! " #"
$ # ## %
- 6 -
#
#
&
'
(()$)
#
"
)*)($$
(
" #
#
# )*)$( ! "& (+ $"
#&&$$ &# "
,#
( # ((( #" ((( ## #
#
# &
# ##
",*
+
" #
#
#
%
! "
$
- 7 -
-
)*)($
( # ## % #
#
. &
'
(()$) $($*$ #
"
)*)($ ! " $*-(() $+ ("
#&&$$ &# "
& #" ((( & & " , # (((( ,#
((((
#" (((
",#
"
,*
+
" #
#
#
%
! "
- 8 -
$ #
$
)
)*)($
( # ## % #
#
. &
'
(()$) $($*$ #
"
)*)$$ !
$("
#&&$$ &# "
& #" ((( & & " , # (((( ,#
((((
#" (((
",#
"
","*
+
" #
#
#
%
! "
- 9 -
$ # " $
-
)*)($
( # ## % #
#
. &
'
(()$) $($*$ #
"
)*)$$ ! $("
#&&$$ &# "
& #" (.(( & & " , # (((( ,#
((((
#" (.((
",#
"
",*
+
" #
#
#
%
! "
- 10 -
$ #
$
$$$
)*)($
( # ## % #
#
. &
'
(()$) $($*$ #
"
)*)$$ ! ("
#&&$$ &# "
& #" ()(( & & " , # (((( ,#
((((
#" ()((
",#
"
"
*
+
" #
#
#
%
! "
- 11 -
$
(
($-
).)($
( # ## % #
#
. &
'
(()$) $($*$ #
"
)*)$$ !
$("
#&&$$ &# "
& #" ((( & & " , # (((( ,#
((((
#" (((
",#
"
# & #
,#"
# /#,
/#,#&
- 12 -
& /#,#&
0'120 30454 $ 6774685 94 #&'5($)((( ($$-((( ($)((( ($).(((($)*.(((($.(((($*.*((( ($*.-((( ($*((( : ((...((( 6;4 89534< 68'=2>930'304;677468594#&'(.(((?> #&'()--((( 6=< #&'($((( 59=?4 304;4 6;4 3>' ?'@@'= A1<2@4=35 06B9=2 3>' <9CC4;4=3 <634594(#"594#"'5.($-6=<($- <634< $$$(($ 6=< '304; ) #"5 D46;9=2 #"'5((( ((( ()(( (.(( 6=< (((<634< ((((DE 30456@4 ;9D1=68 6=<688 6;46;959=2'13'C56@46??9<4=3
( &'; D;4B93E $ 6774685 6;959=2 '13 'C #"'5((( ((( ()(( (.(( 6=< ((( '= (((( 6;4 <4?9<4< DE 6 5476;634 ?'@@'= ';<4; 6=< '304;
6774685 94
- 13 -
#&'(.((( ?> #&'()--((( 6=< #&'($((( 6;4 <957'54< 'C DE 6 5476;634 ?'@@'=';<4;
045434=67746856;4DE3046774886=39=51;4; 65>48865304?869@6=35?6889=29=F14539'=304?'@@'= A1<2@4=3 6=< 6>6;< <634< (((( 9= #" '5((( ((( ()(( (.(( 6=< ((( 76554<DE3044=9';9B98,1<24:#63 6<629;9'= 3042;'1=<'C896D9893E65>48865F16=31@
46;< ;9576889 846;=4< ?'1=548 C'; 304 6774886=3 9= #& '5($)*.((( ($.((( ($*.*((( ($*.-((( 6=< ($*((( 6=< ;9"44;6=62'1<6#68976398846;=4<?'1=54867746;9=2C'; 6774886=3 9= #& '5($((( ($)((( ($$-(((($)(((6=<($).((( ) =B94>'C'1;C9=<9=25'='9=3'$;426;<9=2 896D9893E 9=#&'(.(((6=<'304;3>'?'==4?34< @6334;5 <634< $*-(() ='309=2 51;B9B45 9= 30454 6774685'=3047'9=3'C896D9893E3'76E?'@74=5639'=59=?4
- 14 -
6883045467746856;959=2'13'C56@46??9<4=39=B'8B4<9= 304 6774685 53634< 5 51?0 >930'13 <489D4;639=2 @1?0'=3047'9=3'C896D9893E'1;C9=<9=2'=7'9=3'$9= 304677468553634<0'8<52''<9=3045467746853'' = 30454 ?9;?1@536=?45 304 9=51;4; 95 <9;4?34< 3' 76E ?'@74=5639'= >930 89D4;3E 3' ;4?'B4; 304 56@4 C;'@ 304 9=51;4< 'C 'CC4=<9=2 8';;E 3' 3063 4G34=3 304 6774685 DE 3049=51;4;6;4688'>4<9=76;3 .
883045467746856;4046;<'=304F16=31@'C ?'@74=5639'= ' C6; 65 F16=31@ 95 ?'=?4;=4< 304 #& '($$-((( 95 DE 304 ?869@6=3 6=< #& '($*.*(((95DE3049=51;4;;957688951D@935 3063304?869@6=395304<;9B4;'C304613';9?H506>6574; 304 '89?4 ;4?';<5 '>4B4; D4C';4 304 ;9D1=68 04 065 5177;4554< 3095 C6?3 6=< ?869@4< 09@548C 65 304 9=@63476554=24; = B94> 'C 3095 5177;4559'= 846;=4< ?'1=5481;24515306365304?869@6=3065='3677;'6?04< 304'1;3>930?846=06=<5095?869@743939'=D4<95@9554< 0'8<9=20495='34=39384<C';6=E?'@74=5639'= - 15 - '=B4;548E ;9"44;6=2'1<6 #68976398 51D@935 3063 304 @4;4 C6?3 9= <45?;9D9=2 304 ?869@6=3 65 9=@63476554=24; 'C 613' ;9?H506> 843 68'=4 >'18< ='3 29B4 6 ;9203 3' 304 9=51;4; 3' 544H C'; <95@95568 'C ?869@ 743939'= 6=< 3' 688'> 304 677468 '= 304 2;'1=< 'C 9=6<4F1634?'@74=5639'= * ' C6; 65#& '($((( 6=<?'==4?34< #&'($)*.((( 93 95 304 ?'=34=39'= 'C ;95768893063304?869@6=3506B4515369=4<C;6?31;4 'C 84C3 ?86B9?84 04 '?3'; >0' 065 D44= 4G6@9=4< '= D4068C'C?869@6=3506553634<$*I<956D9893E3'3041774; 89@D 04 ;9D1=68 065 ?'=59<4;4< 304 56@4 63 $I 6=< 6>6;<4< 6= 4G';D936=3 ?'@74=5639'= 'C 5* >09?0956269=533047;9=?97845869<<'>=DE3095'1;365 >48865 '=JD84 74G'1;3 9=1@7344==1@D4; 'C?6545 ?86B9?84 C;6?31;4 >'18< ='3 ;45183 6=E <956D9893E ?6159=2 8'55 'C 46;=9=2 ?676?93E 'C 6 74;5'= = 30454 ?9;?1@536=?45304?'@74=5639'=6>6;<4<1=<4;304046< - 16 - 'C K'55 'C C131;4 46;=9=2J 6=< '304; 046<5 3' 4G34=3 4G';D936=36;4;4F19;4<3'D4543659<4688'>9=2304677468 3'30634G34=3 - 04 846;=4< ?'1=548 C'; 304 9=51;4; 9= '304; 677468551D@9353063304;9D1=680656>6;<4<4G';D936=3 ?'@74=5639'=>04=?'@76;4<3'3049=A1;9456??';<9=28E 5'12033'688'>3046774685DE3049=51;4;6=<<95@955304 6774685DE304?869@6=35'=F16=31@ $ ;9"44;6=2'1<6 #68976398 846;=4< ?'1=548 67746;9=2 C'; 304 6774886=35?869@6=35 9= #& '5($((( ($)((( ($$-((( ($)((( 6=< ($).((( >930 688 B404@4=?4 51D@935 3063 304 ;9D1=68 065 6>6;<4< @4624; ?'@74=5639'=>04=?'@76;4<3'3049=A1;94551CC4;4<6=< <956D9893E ;451834< 304 ?'@74=5639'= 6>6;<4< 1=<4; 688 304 046<5 ;4F19;4< 3' D4 4=06=?4< 04 ;9D1=68 065 ?'=59<4;4<9=?'@4635$74;@'=3030456@495 ?'=3;6;E 3' 304 9=?'@4 7;4C4;;4< DE 304 6;=636H6 3634 42684;B9?45130';93EC';50';3K JC';54339=2304 - 17 - ?869@5D4C';4304'H6<6863574;304?06;33049=?'@4 C9G4<C';304E46;($-95635$() =3095846;=4< ?'1=548 5'1203 3' 688'> 304 6774685 DE 304 ?869@6=35 <95@9559=23046774685DE3049=51;4;'=F16=31@ $$ 6B9=2046;<304846;=4<?'1=54867746;9=2C'; 30476;394574;154<68830467746857674;565>488653;968 '1;3 ;4?';< 04 ?'@@'= 7'9=3 3063 >'18< 6;954 9= 688 304546774685C';'1;?'=59<4;639'=95 $( 1; 6=5>4; 3' 304 6D'B4 7'9=35 C'; ?'=59<4;639'= 95 K6;38E 9= 6CC9;@639B4J '=8E 9= #&'5($).((( ($)((( ($)((( 6=< ($)*.((( * *+ ",* $ 04543>'6774685 6;4DE304?869@6=365 >488 659=51;4; - 18 - $ =304?654'=06=<304?869@6=306551CC4;4< C;6?31;4 'C 84C3 ?86B9?84 5 ;92038E ?'=34=<4< DE 304 846;=4< ?'1=548 67746;9=2 C'; 304 6774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E 6 ?86B9?84 C;6?31;4 ?'18< ='3 ;45183 9= 6=E <956D9893E 6CC4?39=2 304 46;=9=2 ?676?93E 'C 6 74;5'= 0'120 304;4 95 4B9<4=?4 DE 304 '?3'; 53639=2 $*I <956D9893E9=B94>'C3041@7344==1@D4;'CA1<2@4=35'C 3095'1;365>48865304'=JD8474G'1;30'8<9=23063 ?86B9?84 C;6?31;4 ?'18< ='3 ;45183 9= 6=E <956D9893E 06=<9?6779=2 304 9=A1;4< 9= >';H9=2 04 ;9D1=68 065 C6984< 3' ?'=59<4; 3095 6574?3 'C 304 @6334; 6=< 6>6;<4< 4G';D936=3 ?'@74=5639'= 1=<4; 304 046< 8'55 'C C131;4 46;=9=2 ?676?93E 63 5(* ?'=59<4;9=2 304 <956D9893E63$I3'304>0'84D'<E0456@4;4F19;453' D4543659<46??';<9=28E543659<4'C6;65'304;046<5 6;4 ?'=?4;=4< 304 56@4 ;4F19;4 ;4B9593 4G?473 K#4<9?68 D9885J K&''<J K334=<6=3
6=< '1;950@4=3J 68'=2 >930 K'=B4E6=?4?06;245J - 19 - $) =3063B94>'C3046D'B4'=;4<434;@9=639'= 304?869@6=3954=39384<C';304?'@74=5639'=65C'88'>5 !- ./01234.51/675 3856 1 $ 69=6=<1CC4;9=2 ( 69< 17 74;9'< <1;9=2 3;463@4=3 5$()G -) #4<9?684G74=545 ).$ '55'C6@4=93945 ) 334=<6=3 C''< 6=< ='1;950@4=3 68'=2 >930 ?'=B4E6=?4?06;245 () ,"* $. ??';<9=28E3046774886=3?869@6=36;44=39384< C'; ;4<434;@9=4< ;4<1?4< ?'@74=5639'= 'C 1,"* $ &'; 304C';42'9=2;465'=5>4 7;'?44<3' 7655 304C'88'>9=2
9 04 677468 C984< DE 304 6774886=3?869@6=3 95 99 04677468C984<DE3046774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E95/--9.0754/:6
- 20 -
999 04 6774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E 7;9@6;98E95896D843'76E304?'@74=5639'= >93030489D4;3E3';4?'B4;3046@'1=3C;'@ 304'>=4;'C304'CC4=<9=28';;E 9B 04A1<2@4=36=<6>6;<<634<(((( 9=#"'(((76554<DE4=9';9B98 ,1<24 6=< # 6<29;9 95 @'<9C94< ;4<1?9=2 304 ?'@74=5639'= 3' 1,"* 04 ;4<1?4< ?'@74=5639'= 50688 ?6;;E 9=34;453 63 304 ;634 'C .I 74; 6==1@ C;'@ 304 <634 'C 743939'=3988;4689L639'= B 04 6@'1=3 9= <47'593 9= #&'($)*.((( 50688 D4 3;6=5@9334< 3' 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 C';30>930 C'; <95D1;54@4=3 B9 04 6774886=3 =51;6=?4 '@76=E 95 <9;4?34< 3' <47'593 304 D686=?4 ;4<1?4< ?'@74=5639'= 68'=2 >930 304 9=34;453 53634<
D4C';4 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 >9309= .
>44H5 C;'@ 304 <634 'C ;4?4973 'C ?'7E 'C 3095 ';<4; '= 7;'74; 9<4=39C9?639'=
- 21 -
B99 = <47'593 4=39;4 ?'@74=5639'= 50688 D4 ;484654< 9= C6B'1; 'C 304 ?869@6=3 '= 7;'74;9<4=39C9?639'=
1 *
/50
","*
0454 3>' 6774685 D49=2 #& '5($$-((( ($*.*((( 6;4 DE ?869@6=3 65 >488 65 9=51;4; 04 ?869@6=36@<65 >65 304 <;9B4; 'C 304 613' ;9?H506> 0'>4B4; D4C';4 304 ;9D1=68 04 065 ?869@4< 65 6= 9=@63476554=24; 9= 304 613' ;9?H506> 6=< ='3 65 304 <;9B4; >09?0 95 6269=53 304 '89?4 ;4?';<5 65 ;92038E ?'=34=<4< DE 304 846;=4< ?'1=548 67746;9=2 C'; 304 6774886=39=51;4; 04 ?869@6=3 51CC4;4< C;6?31;4 'C =6568 D'=46=<?1386?4;634<>'1=<'B4;304C;'=368;429'=G$ ?@84C376;943684<4@66D;659'='B4;C''3H=449=06=< 04 '?3'; 065 53634< ((I <956D9893E 3' 304 >0'84 D'<E 304 ;9D1=68 065 ?'=59<4;4< 304 56@4 63 $I 0'120 304 ?869@6=3 065 @95;47;454=34< D4C';4 304 ;9D1=68 304 C6?3 3063 ;4@69=5 1=<957134< 95 304 9=A1;945 51CC4;4< DE 09@ 9= 304 6??9<4=3 0'120 3095 '1;3 95 'C
- 22 -
304 '79=9'= 3063 04 95 ='3 4=39384< C'; 304 ?'@74=5639'= D13 06B9=2 ;426;< 3' 304 C6?3 3063 304 ?3 95 6 D4=4C9?968 842958639'= 6=< 304;4 95 =' <957134 3063 04 065 51CC4;4< 9=A1;9456551?0304@95;47;454=3639'=D4C';4304;9D1=68 ?6=='3 D4 6 5'84 E6;< 539?H 3' <958'<24 095 ?869@ DE '13 ;92038E ;4A4?39=2 095 ?869@ 743939'= 65 ?'=34=<4< DE 304 846;=4< ?'1=548 C'; 304 9=51;4; '>4B4; 36H9=2 ?'2=9L6=?4'C095?'=<1?3304?869@6=395='34=39384<C';
6=E 4=06=?4@4=3 04 ;9D1=68 065 7;'74;8E ?'=59<4;4< 6=< 6>6;<4< 304 677;'7;9634 ?'@74=5639'= 4 <' ='3 C9=< 6=E 9=C9;@93945 9= 304 C9=<9=25 'C 304 ;9D1=68 ??';<9=28E>47655304C'88'>9=2
9 '30 304 6774685 '= F16=31@ 6;4
99 04677468C984<DE3046774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E 9= #& '($*.-((( 95
!! '=8E 3' 304 4G34=3 'C <9;4?39=2 304 6774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E
- 23 -
7;9@6;98E 3' 76E 304 ?'@74=5639'= >930 304 89D4;3E3';4?'B4;30456@4C;'@304'>=4; 'C304'CC4=<9=28';;E 999 04 6@'1=3 9= <47'593 9= #&'($*.*((( 50688 D4 3;6=5@9334< 3' 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 C';30>930 C'; <95D1;54@4=3C';30>930 9B 04 6774886=3 =51;6=?4 '@76=E 95 <9;4?34< 3' <47'593 304 D686=?4 ?'@74=5639'= 68'=2 >930 304 9=34;453 ';<4;4<DE304;9D1=68>9309=.>44H5C;'@ 304<634'C;4?4973'C?'7E'C3095';<4; B 04 ';<4; ;484654 6=< <47'593 DE 304 ;9D1=6895H4739=36?3 B9 '';<4;653'?'53
5 ,*
2*9
"
*
04543>'67746856;4DE304?869@6=36=<9=51;4;'= F16=31@ ( 04 ?869@6=3
9506= 624< (.
E46;5 065 51CC4;4< C;6?31;4 'C 6568 D'=4 <958'?639'= 'C 84C3 ;6<915
- 24 -
6=<046<9=A1;E574;304'?3';0406551CC4;4<$I <956D9893E 304 ;9D1=68 065 36H4= )I 6=< ?'=59<4;9=2 9=?'@4 63 5$( 7@ 6>6;<4< ?'@74=5639'= 5 53634<6D'B43049=?'@4C';304E46;($-1=<4;?06;3DE K
J 95 63 5$() 5 ?'18< D4 544= C;'@ 304 ?'@74=5639'= 6>6;<4< 1=<4; 46?0 046<5 4G?473 304 @4<9?68D98856334=<6=3C''<6=<='1;950@4=36;4;4F19;4< 3' D4 ;4?'=59<4;4< = B94> 'C ?'=59<4;9=2 304 09204; 9=?'@465C9G4<1=<4;304?06;3635$()74;@'=30 C'; 304 E46; ($- 304 ?'@74=5639'= 6>6;<4< DE 304 ;9D1=68;4F19;45;4?'=59<4;639'=
=3063B94>'C304@6334;'=;4<434;@9=639'= 3046774886=3954=39384<C';304?'@74=5639'=65C'88'>5 !-
./01234.51/675 3856 1 $ '55'C&131;46;=9=29=?'@4 $()G$(G$G)I $)$) ( '55'C#4<9?68D9885 -*. 69=6=<51CC4;9=2
'55'C869<1774;9'< 5$()G -) ) '55'C334=<6=?4?06;2456=< C''< ='1;950@4=3 ?06;245
() . '55'C6@4=93945
,*
- 25 -
??';<9=28E 304 ?869@6=3 95 4=39384< C'; ;4 <434;@9=4<?'@74=5639'='C5.
) &'; 304C';42'9=2;465'=5>4 7;'?44<3' 7655 304C'88'>9=2
9 '3030467746856;4/--9.0754/:6 99 04 6774886=3=51;6=?4 '@76=E 7;9@6;98E 896D84 3' 76E 304 ?'@74=5639'= >930 304 89D4;3E 3' ;4?'B4; 304 6@'1=3 C;'@ 304 '>=4; 'C 304 'CC4=<9=2 8';;E 304 677468 DE 3049=51;4;3'30634G34=395688'>4<9=76;3 @'<9CE9=2 304 A1<2@4=3 6=< 6>6;< <634< (((( 9= #"'((( '>4B4;
304 677468 DE 9=51;4; '= F16=31@ 95 <95@9554< 999 04 ?869@6=3 95 4=39384< 3' ;4<434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'= 'C 1
,* 6=< 50688 ?6;;E9=34;45363304;634'C.I74;6==1@ C;'@304<634'C743939'=3988;4689L639'= 9B 04 6@'1=3 9= <47'593 9= #&'($*(((50688D43;6=5@9334<3'
- 26 -
304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 C';30>930 C'; <95D1;54@4=3C';30>930 B 046774886=3=51;6=?4?'@76=E95<9;4?34< 3' <47'593 304 D686=?4 ;4<434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'=68'=2>9303049=34;45353634< 517;6D4C';4 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 >9309= .>44H5C;'@304<634'C;4?4973'C?'7E'C 3095';<4; B9 04 4=39;4 6@'1=3 '= <47'593 50688 D4 ;484654<9=C6B'1;'C304?869@6=3'=7;'74; 9<4=39C9?639'= B99 '';<4;653'?'53
*
/50 ,*
04543>'67746856;4DE?869@6=365>488659=51;4; '=F16=31@ ( 04 ?869@6=3#'=6776 624< E46;5 65 74;
G. 065 51CC4;4< C;6?31;4 'C ;9203 34@7';68 D'=4 >930 <9CC154 ?4;4D;68 4<4@6 C;6?31;4 'C ;9203 ';D93 C6?31;4 'C ;9203LE2'@639?6;?06=<2;94B'159=A1;945'='304;76;35 'C 095 D'<E 5 74; 304 '?3'; 304 ?869@6=3 065
- 27 -
51CC4;4<<956D9893E3'4G34=3'C.I<956D9893E3'304>0'84 D'<E 04 ;9D1=68 065 36H4= $)I 6=< ?'=59<4;4< 304 9=?'@4 63 5$( 74; @'=30 6=< 6>6;<4< ?'@74=5639'= 5 74; 304 9=?'@4 C9G4< 1=<4; 304 ?06;3 53634< 517;6 304 9=?'@4 74; @'=30 @153 D4 36H4= 63 5$() 4369=9=2 304 <956D9893E 63 $)I 6=< ?'=59<4;9=2 304 9=?'@4 63 5$() 304 ?'@74=5639'= ;4F19;45 3' D4 ;4B95934< 1=<4; 688 046<5 4G?473 K#4<9?68 9885 K334=<6=3J K&''< 6=< '1;950@4=3J 6=< K69= 6=< 1CC4;9=2J
=3063B94>'C3046D'B4'=;4<434;@9=639'= 304?869@6=3954=39384<C';304?'@74=5639'=65C'88'>5 !-
./01234.51/675 3856 1 $ '55 'C &131;4 6;=9=2 9=?'@4 $()G$(G$G$)I )) ( '55'C#4<9?68D9885 ..$
69=6=<51CC4;9=2 )
'55'C869<1774;9'< 5$()G -) ) '55 'C 334=<6=?4 ?06;245 6=< C''< ='1;950@4=3 ?06;245 () . '55'C6@4=93945
"*
- 28 -
??';<9=28E 304 ?869@6=3 95 4=39384< C'; 6 ;4 <434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'= 'C 1
"* >930 .I 76 ) &'; 304C';42'9=2;465'=5>4 7;'?44<3' 7655 304C'88'>9=2
9 '3030467746856;4 !!
"#$#% &' 99 046774886=3=51;6=?4'@76=E7;9@6;98E 896D84 3' 76E 304 ?'@74=5639'= >930 304 89D4;3E 3' ;4?'B4; 304 6@'1=3 C;'@ 304 '>=4;'C304'CC4=<9=28';;E3'30634G34=3 304 A1<2@4=3 6=< 6>6;< <634< (((( 9= #" '((( 76554< DE 4=9'; 9B98 ,1<24 6=< # 6<29;9 95 @'<9C94< 688'>9=2 304 677468 9=76;3 0'>4B4; <95@9559=2'=F16=31@ 999 04 ?'@74=5639'= 6>6;<4<DE 304;9D1=68 95 ;4<434;@9=4< 3' 5$(*$ >09?0 50688 ?6;;E 9=34;453 63 304 ;634 'C .I 74; 6==1@ C;'@ 304 <634 'C 743939'= 3988 ;4689L639'=
- 29 -
9B 04 6@'1=3 9= <47'593 9= #&'($.((( 50688 D4 3;6=5@9334< 3' 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 C';30>930 C'; <95D1;54@4=3C';30>930 B 04 6774886=3 =51;6=?4 '@76=E 95 <9;4?34< 3' <47'593 304 D686=?4 ;4 <434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'= 68'=2 >930 304 9=34;45353634< D4C';4 304?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 >9309= . >44H5 C;'@ 304 <634 'C ;4?4973'C?'7E'C3095';<4; B9 04;4846546=<<47'59395;4369=4< B99 '';<4;653'?'53
*
2*9
",*
04543>'67746856;4DE?869@6=365>488659=51;4; ?6889=29=F14539'=304F16=31@'C?'@74=5639'= ( =304?654'=06=<304?869@6=3#'=E6624< E46;506551CC4;4<C;6?31;4<84C3=6568D'=4>930046< 9=A1;E G$- 7;'<1?4< ?'=C9;@5 304 C;6?31;4 9=A1;E >930 046<9=A1;E04'?3';06553634<I<956D9893E3'
- 30 -
>0'84D'<E6574;G($04;9D1=68065?'=59<4;4<63 $)I3'304>0'84D'<E>09?09='1;?'=59<4;4<'79=9'=95 A1536=<7;'74;'>4B4;3049=?'@4635$(74;
@'=30 ?'=59<4;4< DE 304 ;9D1=68 95 6269=53 304 9=?'@4 6574;304?06;37;476;4<DE
635$()C';304 E46;($-
= 3063 B94> 'C 6D'B4 304 ?'@74=5639'= 6>6;<4<DE304;9D1=684G?4731=<4;304046<5K#4<9?68 9885JK334=<6=3JK&''<6=<'1;950@4=3J;4F19;45;4B9593 ??';<9=28E304?869@6=3954=39384<3' !-
./01234.51/675 3856 1 $ '55'C&131;46;=9=2 $()G$G$(G$)I )) ( #4<9?68G74=545 (.-$
69=6=<1CC4;9=2
1;9=2 3;463@4=3 869< 17 74;9'< 5$()G -) ) '55'C6@4=93945
. 334=<6=?4 'C ='1;950@4=3 ?06;245 (
*
- 31 -
??';<9=28E 304 ?869@6=3 95 4=39384< C'; ;4 <434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'= 'C 1
* ;'1=<4< 'CC 3'1
,*>9309=34;45363.I76 ) &'; 304C';42'9=2;465'=5>4 7;'?44<3' 7655 304C'88'>9=2
9 '3030467746856;4 !! "#$#% &' 99 04 6774886=3 =51;6=?4 '@76=E 7;9@6;98E 896D84 3' 76E 304 ?'@74=5639'= >93030489D4;3E3';4?'B4;3046@'1=3C;'@ 304 '>=4; 'C 304 'CC4=<9=2 8';;E 3' 3063 4G34=3 304 A1<2@4=3 6=< 6>6;< <634< (((( 9= #"'()(( 76554< DE 4=9'; 9B98 ,1<24 6=< # 6<29;9 95 @'<9C94< 688'>9=2 6774689=76;3 0'>4B4; <95@9559=2'=F16=31@ 999 04?'@74=5639'=6>6;<4<DE304;9D1=68 95 ;4<434;@9=4< 3' 1
,* >09?0 50688 ?6;;E 9=34;453 63 304 ;634 'C .I 74;
6==1@ C;'@ 304 <634 'C 743939'= 3988 ;4689L639'=
- 32 -
9B 04 6@'1=3 9= <47'593 9= #&'($*.-((( 50688 D4 3;6=5@9334< 3' 304 ?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 C';30>930 C'; <95D1;54@4=3C';30>930 B 04 6774886=3 =51;6=?4 '@76=E 95 <9;4?34< 3' <47'593 304 D686=?4 ;4 <434;@9=4< ?'@74=5639'= 68'=2 >930 304 9=34;45353634< D4C';4304?'=?4;=4< ;9D1=68 >9309= . >44H5 C;'@ 304 <634 'C ;4?4973'C?'7E'C3095';<4; B9 484654 6=< <47'593 ';<4; DE ;9D1=68 95 ;4369=4< B99 '';<4;653'?'53
#### 953'$8'
!0* '$!!) &
!0* ') &