- 1 - ! "# $!%!&!! !!&& '# ( ) !" # $ % && '! ( " $ % )" ) ( * ) & Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " # $( + '' % ( ( ,'$% ( & ( ( - % ./0122314/025363553789:.3;41/<1=:01>1/=0: :.3 ?7><3=: 1=7 1@157 71:37 /= A89:.3 1=77743=/A5/B/4?7>3/715 $6A5 0.A5: C:.3 :5/8?=14D% 033E/=> 3=.1=;3<3=: A6 :.3 ;A<23=01:/A=1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14 =3 1=0A:. A.1= A ?591 <3: @/:. 1;;/73=: A= ! 1=7 0?;;?<837 :A :.3 /=F?5/30 41/<1=:A/0:.3<A:.351=7;41/<1=:A/0:.361:.35 A6 :.3 73;31037 1=0A:. A.1= .39 6/437 ;41/< 23:/:/A= - 3 - 836A53:.3:5/8?=14033E/=>;A<23=01:/A=A60" .3:5/8?=1416:35;A=0/735/=>:.33=:/533B/73=;3A=53;A57 1@1573710?<A60) 14A=>@/:./=:3530:1::.3 51:3A6)G2351==?<65A<:.371:3A623:/:/A=:/44:.371:3 A6 5314/H1:/A= >>5/3B37 89 :.3 01/7 ?7><3=: 1=7 1@157 :.3 ;41/<1=: 253635537 :.3 25303=: 122314 033E/=> 3=.1=;3<3=:A6:.3;A<23=01:/A= ' : /0 <1/=49 ;A=:3=737 :.1: :.3 73;31037 @10 >3::/=> 014159 A6 0 235 <A=:. 1=7 140A 7A/=> <A:A5 B3./;43 @/=7/=> @A5E0 1=7 @10 315=/=> 0 235<A=:.?::.3:5/8?=14.10;A=0/73537A=490 235 <A=:. 3=;3 .3 53I?30:0 6A5 3=.1=;3<3=: A6 :.3 ;A<23=01:/A=1@1573789:.3:5/8?=14 .A?>.:.31223441=:00:1:37:.1::.373;31037 @10 315=/=> 0 235 <A=:. :.39 .1B3 =A: 25A7?;37 1=9 /=;A<3 25AA6 3=;3 10 .3 <3: @/:. 1= 1;;/73=: /= :.3 9315 10 235 :.3 >?/734/=30 A6 :.3 &15=1:1E1 :1:3 3>14 35B/;30 ?:.A5/:9 ./0 =A:/A=14 /=;A<3/0:A83:1E3=100', 235<A=:. - 4 - 0 235 :.3 7/;:?< A6 :.3 A=D843 23J A?5: /= :.3 ;103 A6 ;A=0/735/=>:.31>3A6:.373;31037G A6:.3/=;A<3.10:A8317737:A@15706?:?5325A023;:0 @./;./05/>.:49;A=0/7353789:.3 5/8?=14 .3<?4:/24/35 A6!1=7:.3737?;:/A=0:A@15702350A=143J23=030A6:.3 73;310371:G;A=0/7353789:.3 5/8?=14153140AF?0: 1=725A235 " .3536A53 :.3 4A00 A6 7323=73=;9 ;A<30 :A ',KG GJJ!L0,)% , (?5:.35 10 235 :.3 >?/734/=30 A6 :.3 A=D843 23JA?5:/=:.37/;:?<A6 ! " 1=7 # $ % & $ ':.31223441=:083/=>:.32153=:0A6:.373;31037 1 (2017) 16 SCC 680 2 (2018) 18 SCC 130 3 (2020) 9 SCC 644 - 5 - 153 3=:/:437 6A5 0 31;. :A@1570 4A00 A6 6/4/14 ;A=0A5:/?< ! .39 153 140A 3=:/:437 6A5 1= 1<A?=: A6 0' ?=735 :.3 ;A=B3=:/A=14 .3170 /3 4A00 A6 30:1:31=76?=35143J23=03010235:.3;/:1:/A=/=:.3;103 A6 ) 3=;3 :.3 ;A<23=01:/A= /0 5310030037 10 ?=735 A00A67323=73=;9 0,) A00A6;A=0A5:/?< 0!! A=B3=:/A=14.3170 0' A:14 3001@1573789:.3 5/8?=14 0), 0) =.1=;37;A<23=01:/A= 0," .3 =0?51=;3 A<21=9 .10 1453179 732A0/:37 :.3 1<A?=:1@1573789:.3 5/8?=14 .?0:.31223441=:0153 3=:/:4376A53=.1=;37;A<23=01:/A=A60," @/:. /=:3530:1:"G2165A<:.371:3A623:/:/A=:/445314/H1:/A= 1=7:.3536A53:.312231473035B30:A83144A@37/=215: - 6 - =:.3530?4::.36A44A@/=>A5735/0210037 $/% .3122314/0144A@37/=215: $//% .3 1223441=:0 153 3=:/:437 6A5 3=.1=;37 ;A<23=01:/A= A6 0," 14A=> @/:. /=:3530: 1:"G 2165A<:.371:3A623:/:/A=:/445314/H1:/A= A@3B3510 235 A5735 71:37 '' :.39 153 =A: 3=:/:437 6A5 /=:3530: 6A5 :.3 7341937 235/A7 A6 ) 7190 /= 6/4/=> :.3 122314 $///% 302A=73=: A =0?51=;3 A<21=9 /0 7/53;:37 :A 732A0/: :.3 16A5301/7 ;A<23=01:/A= 1<A?=: @/:./=A=3<A=:.65A<:.371:3A6:./0F?7><3=: $/B% = 0?;. 732A0/: :.3 1223441=:0 153 235</::37 :A@/:.751@:.33=:/531<A?=:14A=>@/:./=:3530:1;;5?37 A=/:/=:.33I?1425A2A5:/A= *+, '&!! ( % /0:A4A",