- 1 - ! " # $% & & ## '&( ) ! " #$ % &'&($ )('$" &*)*"(' & ' &*)*"(' Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + '()(* " %! ",'"! - % % (#&(,&(' $#(" % . % " /01 233425 01 60547 89 :/4 ;520<2=: 144>0=? 4=/2=;4<4=:@6;@<34=12:0@=2A2B7470=:/4 C7?<4=:2=7 2A2B7 72:47 (#(,(' 0= @$#(" 89 :/4 770:0@=25 4=0@B 0D05 C7?4 2=7 2528CB2?0 6@B 1/@B:E:/4:B08C=25F! /462;:154270=?:@6050=?@6:/4;520<34:0:0@=2B4 21C=74B /2: @= ('"(( 2: 28@C: )(( 3< =42B 2?CB 8B07?4 2?CB D0552?4 :/4 ;520<2=: 2=7 /01 6B04=7 A4B4 - 3 - 3B@;4470=? @= 2 <@:@B;9;54 842B0=? B4?01:B2:0@= @& '&$,( :@A2B71 :/40B D0552?4 2: :/2: :0<4 2=@:/4B <@:@B;9;54 842B0=? B4?01:B2:0@= @&'&($ 840=? 7B0D4=890:1B074B0=2B21/2=7=4?50?4=:<2==4B721/47:@ :/4 <@:@B;9;54 @6 :/4 ;520<2=: 7C4 :@ A/0;/ :/4 ;520<2=: 1C1:20=47?B04D@C10=GCB041/4;520<2=::2>4=:B42:<4=:0= :/4 @130:25 2=7 :/4B426:4B 60547 ;520< 34:0:0@= 846@B4 :/4 :B08C=25/4:B08C=2521141147:/4;@<34=12:0@=2=7321147 :/4 2A2B7 /4 ;520<2=: 144>0=? 4=/2=;4<4=: @6 :/4 1207 ;@<34=12:0@=/2160547:/43B414=:233425 ' 42B7 :/4 542B=47 ;@C=145 6@B :/4 2334552=: 2=7 :/4 542B=47 ;@C=145 6@B :/4 B413@=74=: @&=1CB2=;4 ;@<32=9 # 42B=47 ;@C=145 6@B :/4 2334552=: A@C57 ;@=:4=7 :/2: :/4 ;520<2=: /21 1C1:20=47 6B2;:CB4 @6 546: :0802 2=7 608C52 2=7 2: :/4 :0<4 @6 :/4 2;;074=: :/4 2334552=: A21 2?47 $ 942B1 @=1074B0=? :/4 6B2;:CB4 2=7 @:/4B 0=GCB041 :/4@;:@BA/@4H2<0=47/0<04 %/21011C4770128050:9 ;4B:060;2:4&H "' 1:2:0=? :/2: :/4 ;520<2=: /21 1C664B47 - 4 - '(I 34B<2=4=: 70128050:9 8C: :B08C=25 /21 4BB47 0= :2>0=? 70128050:92:*I46CB:/4B1C8<0:1:/2::/4;@<34=12:0@= 2A2B74789:/4:B08C=25C=74B70664B4=:/427104320=2=7 1C664B0=? 5@11 @6 0=;@<4 7CB0=? 5207 C3 34B0@7 2=7 5@11 @6 2<4=0:041 2B4 @= 5@A4B 1074 4 6CB:/4B 1C8<0:1 :/2: 6@B B4<@D25 @6 0<352=:1:/4 ;520<2=:2334552=: /21:@C=74B?@ 1CB?4B96@BA/0;//4B4JC0B416C:CB4<470;254H34=1412=7 :/4@;:@B/211:2:47:/2:6@B:/2::/4;520<2=:B4JC0B412 1C<@61'*(((&%0:/:/01/43B2947:@255@A:/4233425 * 42B=47 ;@C=145 6@B :/4 B413@=74=: @& =1CB2=;4 ;@<32=9 A@C57 ;@=:4=7 :/2: :/4 :B08C=25 /21 B0?/:59:2>4=:/470128050:9;@=1074B0=?:/46B2;:CB44:;2=7 251@ :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2A2B747 C=74B @:/4B /4271 2B4 GC1: 2=73B@34B%0:/:/01/43B29476@B701<01125@6:/4233425 $ 2D0=?/42B7:/4542B=47;@C=1451:/01 @CB:/21 34BC147:/40<3C?=47 C7?<4=:2=7:B025 @CB:B4;@B71 , /472:4@62;;074=:2?4@6;520<2=:2=75028050:9 @6 :/4 =1CB2=;4 ;@<32=9 2B4 =@: 0= 7013C:4 /4 2;;074=: /21 :2>4= 352;4 @= ('"(( 2=7 21 @= :/2: 72:4 :/4 - 5 - ;520<2=: A21 2?47 , 942B1 D4= :/@C?/ 0: 01 ;@=:4=747 :/2: :/4 ;520<2=: A21 7B0D4B 89 @;;C32:0@= /01 7B0D0=? 50;4=;4/21=@:844=3B@7C;470=:/2:B4?2B7 ) % 01 :/4 @;:@B A/@ /21 011C47 H "'& 7012850:9;4B:060;2:41:2:0=?:/2::/4;520<2=:01/2D0=?'(I 34B<2=4=:70128050:9/4;520<2=:/211C1:20=476B2;:CB4@6 546::08022=7608C52 @=1074B0=?:/42?4@6:/4;520<2=:2=7 :/46B2;:CB41/41C664B47:/470128050:9:2>4=89:/4:B08C=25 2:*I01@=5@A4B10744=;4:/470128050:901:@84:2>4=2: "*I/40=;@<42=7:/4<C5:03504B:2>4=89:/4:B08C=252B4 3B@34B 2=7 ;@BB4;: = D04A @6 :/4 28@D4 :/4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:54:@5@11@66C:CB40=;@<421C=74B *! +,-! -!+-!./* +, @=1074B0=? :A@ 6B2;:CB41 :/4 ;@<34=12:0@= 2A2B747 C=74B :/4 /427 @6 320= 2=7 1C664B0=? 0= 2 1C< @6 1#((((&89:/4:B08C=2501@=5@A4B1074/4;520<2=:01 4=:0:54:@1*((((&C=74B:/4/427@6320=2=71C664B0=? /4 :B08C=25 /21 2A2B747 5@11 @6 0=;@<4 7CB0=? 5207 C3 34B0@70=21C<@61,*((& @=1074B0=?:/40=GCB0412=7 - 6 - 6B2;:CB41:/45@11@60=;@<47CB0=?5207C334B0@7/21:@84 2A2B747 6@B :/B44 <@=:/1 0= 2 1C< @6 1#"*(& 1"',*(&-'<@=:/1!/4:B08C=25/21B0?/:592A2B747 <470;254H34=141@61)""(&2=71((((&C=74B:/4 /427@62::4=72=:6@@7704:2=7;@=D492=;4;/2B?41 "( /4;520<2=:A212?47,942B121@=:/472:4@6 :/42;;074=:/4B4;@B717@=@:0=70;2:4:/2::/4;520<2=: 01 <2BB047 @B =@: @=1074B0=? :/4 2?4 @6 :/4 ;520<2=: 2=7 :/46B2;:CB411C664B47/4014=:0:54:@5@11@62<4=0:0410=2 1C<@61"(((((&212?20=1:1((((&212A2B74789 :/4 :B08C=25 /4 @;:@B /21 ?0D4= 4D074=;4 :/2: :/4 0<352=:12B460H472=76@BB4<@D25@6:/412<4:/4;520<2=: B4JC0B41:@C=74B?@1CB?4B96@BA/0;/21C<@61'*(((& 01 B4JC0B47 :@A2B71 6C:CB4 <470;25 4H34=141 /4 :B08C=25 /21 =@: 2A2B747 2=9 2<@C=: 6@B 6C:CB4 <470;25 4H34=141 @=1074B0=? :/4 1207 4D074=;4 :/4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:54 :@ 2 1C<@61'((((&:@A2B716C:CB4<470;254H34=141 "" = D04A @6 :/4 28@D4 :/4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:54 :@ :@:25;@<34=12:0@=216@55@A1 - 7 - 0 123*45617*2897 5617*2897 2:2;313 <= 8>9*?;8 " @11@66C:CB442B=0=?1 1#(,*(& 20=2=71C664B0=?1 1*((((& ' 470;254H34=141 1)""(& # @11 @6 0=;@<4 7CB0=? 5207 C3 34B0@7 1#"*(& * ::4=72=: 6@@7 704: 2=7 ;@=D492=;4;/2B?41 1((((& $ @11@62<4=0:041 1"(((((& , C:CB4<470;254H34=141 1'((((& 820 *+ !, " /4 ;520<2=: 01 4=:0:54 :@ :@:25 ;@<34=12:0@= @6 1,#'"(& 21 2?20=1: 1'))*& 21 2A2B747 89 :/4 :B08C=25A0:/0=:4B41:2::/4B2:4@6$I34B2==C< "' =D04A@6:/428@D4:/46@55@A0=? 0! /423342501255@A470=&32B:+ 00! /42334552=:;520<2=:014=:0:54:@:@:25 ;@<34=12:0@= @6 1,#'"(& 21 2?20=1: 1'))*& 21 2A2B747 89 :/4 :B08C=25 A0:/ 0=:4B41:2::/4B2:4@6$I34B2==C<6B@<:/472:4 @634:0:0@=:055B4250K2:0@=+ 000! 413@=74=: @&=1CB2=;4 ;@<32=9 1/255743@10::/42A2B72<@C=:A0:/0=:4B41:A0:/0= - 8 - 234B0@7@640?/:A44>16B@<:/0172962050=?A/0;/ 0:01502854:@3290=:4B41:2:I34B2==C<+ 0D! /4 @B74B @= 743@10: 321147 89 :/4 :B08C=25B4<20=1C=&25:4B47 3, ' & &( % 01:@" 5@#*