- 1 - ! " #$%" #$%$ "" &$' ! !"# $ % &! ' " ! !" ! (! $$$) " !" " Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " !"*# $ !" % & ! +' ", ! " ""!!' " $ $ , $$-- $ ' ," , ! . ."" $ $ " " ( /"0 1 ! " . " ( " ! " ! ! . !' , " , ! ! " $ $ " ( ! . ( " ! !" " " ! " 1! . " ! " 1 , " 2 !2 "3 1! " " "3 1! %$ & 2"3 1! " "' 456 7859 :;;<:= 56 >5=<? @4:==<AB5AB 94< C8?<8 ?:9<? $ $ ;:66<? 5A ,859 <9595CA C $$-- $ DE - 3 - 94< =<:8A<? 5AB=< 1F?B< 74<8<5A ?56G566<? 94< 7859 ;<9595CA CA 94< D:656 C> 94< ?<@565CA C> 94< "CA0D=< ;<H !CF89 5A 94< @:6< C> :6 94< "CA0D=< F;8<G< !CF89 4<=? 94:9 94< ;<85C? 695;F=:9<? FA?<8 94< CA< 95G< 6<99=<G<A9 6@4<G< &4<8<5A:>9<8 8<><88<? :6 /0' @:AAC9 D<<H9<A?<?DE94<!CF89 <:8A<? @CFA6<= >C8 94< :;;<==:A9 I<4<G<A9=E @CA9<A?6 94:9 94<>:@9F:=:6;<@9 C>94<@:6< 5A @:AD<?5695ABF564:D=< A94<@:6<CA 4:A?94CFB4;:89;:EG<A97:6G:?<DF9?F<9C! ;:A?<G5@ @CF=? AC9 G:J< 94< ;:EG<A9 :A? :A :99<G;9 7:6G:?<9CG:J<<A958<;:EG<A95A A6;59<C>94< 6:G< =<:8A<? 5AB=< 1F?B< DE :;;=E5AB 94< :>C8<6:5? ?<@565CA4:6@CGG599<?:A<88C85A?56G5665AB94<;<9595CA =<:8A<? @CFA6<= :;;<:85AB >C8 94< 8<6;CA?<A96 5A 6F;;C89 C> 456 :8BFG<A9 6FDG596 94:9 94< 1 AIR 2022 SC 5517 - 4 - "CA0D=< ;<H !CF89 8<;<:9<?=E 4<=? 94:9 94< "5B4 !CF89 @:AAC9 <H<8@56< 94< ;C7<86 FA?<8 895@=< C> 94< !CA6959F95CA C> A?5: "< >F894<8 6FDG596 94:9 <H<8@56< C> ;C7<86FA?<8895@=<C>94<!CA6959F95CAC>A?5:<I<A >C8 <H9<A65CA C> 95G< >C8 C8 B5I5AB :AE G:A?:GF6 C8?<8 >C8 <H9<A65CA C> 95G< C8 B8:A95AB C> 95G< ?C<6 AC9 :856< <:8A<?@CFA6<=:=6C8<=5<?F;CA94<KF?BG<A9 C> "CA0D=< ;<H !CF89 5A 94< @:6< C> ! " :A? D8CFB49 9C 94< AC95@< C> 9456 !CF89 :A CD6<8I:95CA G:?< DE 94< "CA0D=< ;<H !CF89 5A ;:8:B8:;4 C 7594 8<B:8? 9C 94< C8?<8 ;:66<? DE 9456 !CF89 5A 94< <:8=5<8 C8?<8:A?4<=?94:994<"5B4!CF89B8:A95AB94<95G<:A? >F894<8 <H9<A?5AB 94< 95G< 56 AC9 5A @CA6CA:A@< 7594 94< 6@4<G< 2 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 722 - 5 - 956:=6CD8CFB499C94<AC95@<C>9456!CF8994< @=<:8 CD6<8I:95CA G:?< 5A 94< ?<@565CA C> @:6< &6F;8:' 74<8<5A :=6C @:9<BC85@:==E 4<=? 5A ;:8:B8:;4 C 94:9 AC 7859 C> G:A?:GF6 @:A D< 566F<?DE94<"5B4!CF895A<H<8@56<C>895@=<C>94< !CA6959F95CA C> A?5: ?58<@95AB 94< >5A:A@5:= 5A6959F95CA D:AJ9C;C6595I<=EB8:A9:D<A<>59C>9C:DC88C7<8:A? :=6CG:?<59@=<:894:994<B8:A9C>D<A<>59C>6@4<G< 56 6FDK<@9 9C 94< <=5B5D5=59E @859<85: :A? 94< BF5?<=5A<6 566F<?>8CG95G<9C95G< "<:8? 94<=<:8A<? @CFA6<= >C8 94< :;;<==:A9:6 7<==:6=<:8A<?@CFA6<=:;;<:85AB>C894<8<6;CA?<A96:A? 94< =<:8A<? 5AB=< 1F?B< 745=< ;:665AB :A C8?<8 5A 8<K<@95AB 94< 7859 ;<9595CA 9:J<A AC9< C> 94< ?<@565CA C> &6F;8:' :A? 74<A 6;<@5>5@:==E 4<=? 94:9AC7859C>G:A?:GF6@:AD<566F<?DE94<"5B4!CF89 5A <H<8@56< C> 895@=< C> 94< !CA6959F95CA C> A?5: ?58<@95AB 94< >5A:A@5:= 5A6959F95CA D:AJ 9C ;C6595I<=E B8:A9 - 6 - 94< D<A<>59 C> 9C : DC88C7<8 :A? @:AAC9 ?58<@9 94< :AJ9C?C94<6:G< - A94<@:6<CA4:A?5956I<8E@=<:894:974<A 94< :;;=5@:95CA 7:6 >5=<? D<>C8< 94< :AJ :A? G:?< 94< ;:89;:EG<A9AC9B8:A9<?94<6@4<G<C> 4<8<>C8< :;;<==:A9 :;;8C:@4<? D<>C8< 94< =<:8A<? 5AB=< 1F?B< DE >5=5AB : 7859 ;<9595CA <:8A<? 5AB=< 1F?B< 4:I5AB @CA65?<8<?94<;85A@5;=<6=:5??C7ADE"CA0D=<;<H!CF89 5A &6F;8:' @:6< 85B49=E CD6<8I<? 94:994<!CF89@:AAC9B8:A96F@48<=5<> # ":I5AB9:J<AAC9<C>94<8<:6CA5AB:A?:=6C94< ;85A@5;=<6=:5??C7A5A &6F;8:'@:6< :67<==:68<@<A9?<@565CAC> #&6F;8:'7< ?C AC9 >5A? :AE <88C8 @CGG599<? DE 94< 5AB=< 1F?B< 5A ?56G5665AB94<7859;<9595CA ) 4< I<8E @CA9<A95CA C> 94< @CFA6<= :;;<:85AB >C8 94< :;;<==:A9 94:9 94< >:@9F:= :6;<@96 C> @:6< 56 ?5695ABF564:D=< @:AAC9 D< :@@<;9<? - 7 - 74<8<5A @:9<BC85@:==E 4<=? 94:9AC 7859C> G:A?:GF6 @:A D<5AICJ<?<H<8@565AB94<895@=<6C>94<!CA6959F95CA C>A?5: ,4<A6F@4CD6<8I:95CA56G:?<7<?CAC9>5A? :AE G<859 5A 94< 6FDG5665CA C> 94< @CFA6<= :;;<:85AB >C8 94< :;;<==:A9 588<6;<@95I< C> ;:89 ;:EG<A9 7:6 G:?< A?<894<@58@FG69:A@<67<?CAC9>5A?:AEG<8595A94< 7859:;;<:= $ A I5<7 C> 94< ?56@F665CA6 G:?< 7< ;:66 94< >C==C75AB2 ,859:;;<:=56?56G566<? () &"' % () &$' % " 569C 2=C 2 !2