- 1 - !! " #$ %#&!!!# # # ' '()* '!!)) + ! " # $ %!! ! & " " #' (! ( Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ %(( " ) !& ( " " " ( * " + , ( " " ( ( -(*(( % -(*((& ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9009/7/5: 3.2 4;82; 89328 190028<=3.2 ;/5>/197/03;/>3958200/450 *?8:2/89;/5200/4509024 .2 123/3/452;0 03958 >.9;:2#0.22328 64; 3.2 9772:28 46625>2 46 @?;82; 46 9 @/54; >./78 ?;/5: 3;/97 - 3 - 3.2 1;402>?3/45 2A9@/528 B C.4 /0 ./@0276 9 @/54; C/35200 .2 1;20253 123/3/452;0 .98 3.2 4114;3?5/3= 34 >;400#2A9@/52./@/:5/6/>9537=973.4?:. B98@/3328 /5 ./0 2D/825>2#/5#>./26 3.93 .2 C90 9>E?9/5328 C/3. 3.2 9>>?02812;0450.2>729;7=0393283.93.28420543F54C .4C./0<;43.2;9.?78/2826?;3.2;82140283.93.2/0 ?59C9;2 C.23.2; 9>>?028 4 9009?7328 9.?7 201/32 3./0 >;?>/97 82D/93/45 6;4@ 3.2 1;402>?3/45 59;;93/D2 3.2 ?<7/> ;402>?34; 8/8 543 022F 12;@/00/45 34 3;293 3.2 C/3520090.403/72 + 3 /0 93 3./0 039:2 3.93 3.2 123/3/452;0 6/728 95 9117/>93/45 ?582; 2>3/45 + 46 3.2 482 46 ;/@/597 ;4>28?;2022F/5:;2>977 46 B 64;3.2 7/@/3281?;1402 46 >456;453/5:./@ C/3. ./0 29;7/2; 3203/@45= ;2>4;828 90 <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72 *?03/>2 49;8 .2 1;402>?3/45 034?37=41140283.29117/>93/45.2729;528/03;/>3*?8:2 ;2G2>328 3.2 123/3/452;0H 1729 4<02;D/5: 3.93 95= 6?;3.2; 2A140?;2463.2@/54;C/3520034>;400#2A9@/593/45C4?78 179>2 ?58?2 10=>.474:/>97 1;200?;2 45 ./@ 958 @9= - 4 - /567?25>2 ./0 3203/@45= .2 ;/97 4?;3 9704 179>28 0?<03953/97 2@1.90/0 45 3.2 32582; 9:2 46 3.2 C/35200 C.4/09;4?58 34+=29;0 29;528 >4?5027 64; 3.2 123/3/452;0 >4532580 .4C2D2; 3.93 3./0 ;29045/5: /:54;20 9 @932;/97 958 ?58/01?328 >/;>?@0395>2 .2 1;402>?3/45 /30276 9632; @4;23.95452=29;9586/D2@453.06/728959117/>93/45 ?582; 2>3/45+ 46 ; 64;;2>977/5: B 958 3.2 09@2 C909774C2845,' ./04?;3/0/564;@28 3.933.282625>2>4?50272A1;2007=>45>2828958;2>4;828 I544<G2>3/45H3.2;2<=259<7/5:3.21;402>?3/45346?;3.2; 2A9@/52 B933.93<279328039:2 29;528 >4?5027 0?<@/30 3.93 .9D/5: >4412;9328 C/3. 3.2 1;402>?3/45 958 .9D/5: 9774C28 3.2 1;402>?3/45 34 ;2>977 958 2A9@/52 B 6?;3.2; 9632; 9 0/:5/6/>953 79102 46 3/@2 3.2 123/3/452;0 >95543 54C <2 825/28 3.2 4114;3?5/3= 34 ;2>977 3.2 09@2 C/35200 64; 9 03;/>37= 7/@/328 1?;1402 .2 82625>2 8420 543 022F 34 3;9D2;02 <2=458 >456;453/5: B C/3. ./0 1;/4; - 5 - 82140/3/45 <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72 *?03/>2 49;8 958 3.2 0>41246;2>977/059;;4C958>729;7=826/528 B 5 3.2 43.2; .958 729;528 /:. 4?;3 4D2;5@253 72982; 9;:?20 3.93 3.2 82625>2 .98 982E?9324114;3?5/3=8?;/5:3.229;7/2;>;400#2A9@/593/45 9583.93;21293280?@@45/5:469>./78C/35200C4?78<2 411;200/D2>453;9;=34./0C2769;2958823;/@25397343.2 1;402>?3/452012>/977=/59>902/5D47D/5:9:;9D246625>2 ' ./0 4?;3 .90 >9;26?77= >450/82;28 3.2 ;/D97 0?<@/00/45095812;?0283.2@932;/9745;2>4;8.4?:./3 /03;?23.933.282625>2>4?78.9D2<225@4;28/7/:253/5 98D2;3/5: 34 3.2 2D/825>2 46 B ;2>4;828 <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72*?03/>249;8/3@?03<2<4;52/5@/583.933.2 ;/:.3 46 95 9>>?028 34 9 69/; 3;/97 /0 9 64?5893/4597 :?9;95322.2<?;825461;4D/5::?/737/200E?9;27=453.2 1;402>?3/45 <?3 3.2 82625>2 @?03 <2 9664;828 2D2;= ;290459<72 4114;3?5/3= 34 >.97725:2 3.2 1;402>?3/45 >902 2662>3/D27= .93 900?@20 >;/3/>97 0/:5/6/>95>2 /5 3.2 1;20253 >902 /0 3.2 ?58/01?328 69>3 3.93 3.2 1;402>?3/45 - 6 - /30276/5D4F282>3/45+; 958;2>977283.2C/35200 9632;90?<03953/978279=46@4;23.95'@453.09583.2 82625>2<=2A1;2007=0393/5:I544<G2>3/45H69>/7/393283.93 1;4>200 .25 3.21;402>?3/45 .909D9/728 3.2 <2526/346 ;2>977 93 0?>. 9 <279328 039:2 /3 C4?78 <2 C.477= /52E?/39<7234825=90/@/79;3.4?:.7/@/328/58?7:25>234 3.2123/3/452;0 .2 @2;2 69>3 3.93 B /0 9 >./78 46 + =29;0 >95543 <= /30276 64;@ 3.2 <90/0 64; ;2G2>3/5: 3.2 82625>2 ;2E?203 2012>/977= C.25 3.2 82625>2 ?582;39F20 9583./04?;39>>21303.933.26?;3.2;>;400#2A9@/593/45 C/77<203;/>37=>456/52834>456;453/5:3.2C/35200C/3../0 29;7/2; 3203/@45= <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72 *?03/>2 49;8 2;@/33/5: ;2>977 64; 3./0 ;203;/>328 1?;1402 C4?78 543 >9?02 95= 02;/4?0 1;2G?8/>2 34 3.2 1;402>?3/45 C.2;290 82>7/5/5: 0?>. 12;@/00/45 C4?78 @932;/977= /@19/; 3.2 123/3/452;0H;/:.334>458?>3952662>3/D282625>2/59>902 /5D47D/5:02;/4?09772:93/450 - 7 - , 53.2>450/82;28D/2C463./04?;33.2;264;2 3.2;/974?;3.90984132895?58?7=32>.5/>97911;49>. /5 ;2G2>3/5: 3.2 2>3/45 + 46 ; 9117/>93/45 .2 ;26?09734;2>9773.2C/352008201/323.21;402>?3/45H04C5 1;/4; ;2>977 958 8201/32 3.2 7/@/328 593?;2 463.282625>2 ;2E?203?5G?03/6/9<7=>?;39/703.2123/3/452;0H;/:.334969/; 958 @295/5:6?7 3;/97 .2 /@1?:528 4;82; >95543 <2 0?039/528958C9;;9530/532;62;25>24502E?2537=343.2 7/@/3282A3253/58/>93283./04?;36/580/3911;41;/93234 :;9533.2/58?7:25>204?:.3 "4; 3.2 64;2:4/5: ;290450 3./0 4?;3 1;4>2280 3419003.264774C/5: %/& .2;/@/597 23/3/450395809774C285D/2C46 3.2 69>3 3.93 3.2 1;402>?3/45 /30276 /5D4F28 2>3/45 + 46 3.2 482 46 ;/@/597 ;4>28?;2 34 ;2>977 B 9632; 9 >450/82;9<72 79102 46 3/@29583.2123/3/452;0.982A3258283.2/;6?77 >4412;93/45<=>45>28/5:I544<G2>3/45H340?>. - 8 - ;2>9773./04?;3/0463.2>450/82;28D/2C3.93 825/97 46 9 0/@/79; 4114;3?5/3= 34 3.2 82625>2 C4?78 02;/4?07= /@1/5:2 ?145 3.2 123/3/452;0H ;/:.334969/;3;/97 %//& .2 /@1?:528 4;82; 89328 190028 <= 3.2 ;/5>/197 /03;/>3 958 200/450 *?8:2 /89; /5 200/450 902 4 /0 .2;2<= E?90.2895802390/82.2;/974?;3H0;26?097 34 2532;39/5 3.2 123/3/452;0H 9117/>93/45 ?582; 2>3/45 + ; 8201/32 3.2 7/@/328 593?;2 463.2;2E?2039583.21;402>?3/45H04C5?0246 3.209@21;4D/0/45939./:.7=<279328039:2/0 64?5834<2?50?039/59<72 %///& .2 2D/825>2 46 B 0.977 <2 ;2>97728 .2 ;2>977 /0 12;@/3328 04727= 34 259<72 3.2 123/3/452;0 34 >456;453 3.2 C/35200 C/3. ./0 29;7/2; 82140/3/45 ;2>4;828 <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72 *?03/>249;890 - 9 - %/D& .2123/3/452;00.97703;/>37=>456/523.26?;3.2; >;400#2A9@/593/45 34 3.2 7/@/328 1?;1402 46 >456;453/5: B C/3. ./0 1;2D/4?0 3203/@45= <264;2 3.2 *?D25/72 *?03/>2 49;8 4 43.2; E?203/450 <2=458 3./0 59;;4C 958 >729;7= 826/5280>4120.977<212;@/3328250?;/5:3.93 3.2 ;2>977 02;D20 457= 3.2 72:/3/@932 52280 46 3.2 82625>2 958 8420 543 >9?02 ?58?2 /5>45D25/25>2343.2@/54;C/352000?<G2>334 82140/3460?@460 #19=9<7234 B !,* '!!# #) & /034 74