Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64797 (KAR)
MAQBOOL SAB @ MAQBOOB BAIG S/O MUKHTAR BAIG v. PUTLIBEE W/O MASTHAN SAB
RSA/7215/2009 · 2025-08-14
Shivashankar Amarannavar
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64797 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64797 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$%#% &&
' (&) *
! "! #$%&
'
(
)
* ! +
,,
,--&%$
) #%%%. )
! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"! #$%&
/ +" ($
,--&%$
) #%%%. )
! "! #$%& 0))
))1
! ! 1
)
+ (
-$&&% 0
)
1
)) ! %% ! ) ) + ))
" ) (2%% 1
" 1 ) %,%$%%. " ) .$,
)
) 1
"
"
!"
- 3 -
! "
"
+ 1
3
"
1 1
$ # 456 67*89/ ::7; 56 <5;7/ '= >47 ::7;;9>:;59>5<< :?=59@ >8 67> 65/7 >47 AB/@C79> 9/ /7*?77 />7/ %,%$%%. :667/ 59 8(2%% '= >47 ;7?97/ 5D5; "B/@7 ?9 6DE;=9 C: > BC9'/ 9/ >8 ?76>8?7 >47 AB/@C79> 9/ /7*?77 />7/ .%$%% :667/ 59 8.$, '= >47 )?59*5:; 5D5;"B/@7"?9BC9'/
47 ::7;;9>:;59>5<< 46 <5;7/ 6B5> 59 8.$, @596> >47 ?76:89/79>/7<79/9> 677E59@ /7*;?>589 >4> 47 56 >47 8F97? 8< >47 6B5> ;9/ '7?59@=8$2C76B?59@&*?76@B9>665>B>7/> /?@5 D5;;@7 BC9'/ ;BE 9/ ?7*8D7?= 8< :866766589 8< >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= <?8C >47
- 4 -
?76:89/79>/7<79/9> 47 :;59>5<< 46 ;68 68B@4> ?7;57< 8< /7*;?>589 >4> >47 ?7@56>7?7/ ?7;767 /77/ />7/ 2%&.$'7?59@8,($%7G7*B>7/'==>'7769B;; 9/D85/9/98>'59/59@B:89>47:;59>5<<9/>47:;59>5<< 5679>5>;7/>8@7>79>7?7/4569C759>47?7*8?/8<?5@4>59 ?76:7*>8<>476B5>;9/ & 47*678<>47:;59>5<<56'67/89>478?;@5<> 6>>7/ >8 4D7 '779 7G7*B>7/ '= 4A6' 59 456 <D8B? F479 47 F6 C598? 47 65/ 4A6' F6 C>7?9;
@?9/<>47? 8< >47 :;59>5<< 9/ 47 F6 >47 8F97? 8< >47 6B5>;9/ 47 65/4A6' 4/ 897689'= 9C7!>?B )>7;9/>4?77/B@4>7?6'=9C7 B99B'774C7/'77 9/ 5'5 47 689 8< >47 65/ 4A6' '= 9C7 !>?B )>7; F6 CB?/7?7/ '7<8?7 >47 :8;5*7 *>589 B?59@ >47 ;5<7>5C7 8< >47 65/ 4A6' >47 65/ !>?B )>7; /57/ ;7D59@ '7459/456 F5<7 '9'77 9/ /B@4>7? '= 9C7 =>'77 47 :;59>5<< 56 >47 689 8< >47 4C7/'77 9/ @?9/689 8< 4A6' 47 65/ 4A6' >47 C>7?9; @?9/<>47?8<>47:;59>5<</57/'8B><5D7=7?6<>7?>47
- 5 -
:8;5*7*>589>>47>5C78<456/7>4>47C8>47?8<>47 :;59>5<< '= 9C7 4C7/'77 ;89@ F5>4 >47 :;59>5<< B67/ >8?765/7F5>4>474A6'4765/4A6''759@>47 C>7?9; @?9/<>47? 8< >47 :;59>5<< 8B> 8< ;8D7 9/ <<7*>5899/;6867?D5*76?79/7?7/'=>47C8>47?8<>47 :;59>5<< 4/ @5<>7/ >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 59 <D8B? 8< >47 :;59>5<<;89@F5>4;;8>47?:?8:7?>57665>B>7/>/?@5 D5;;@7 9/ ;@? 69>4:B? D5;;@7 47 65/ @5<> F6 **7:>7/'=>47C8>47?8<>47:;59>5<<'=9C74C7/'77 89'74;<8<>47:;59>5<<6>47:;59>5<<F6C598?B9/7? >47*?79/*B6>8/=8<456C8>47?59>47C89>48<:?5; .%9/89>47D7?=6C7/=59:B?6B9*78<>478?; @5<> :866766589 8< >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= ;89@ F5>4 8>47? :?8:7?>576 4D7 '779 /7;5D7?7/ >8 >47 C8>47? 8< >47 :;59>5<<59*7>479>47:;59>5<<56597G*;B65D7:866766589 9/5979A8=C79>8<>476B5>:?8:7?>=>5;;47F6?7C9/7/ >8A5; ( 47 :;59>5<< F6 *89D5*>7/ '= >47 7665896 8B?>5/?59CB?/7?*679/47F65979>?;"5;
- 6 -
;'B?@5 B:>8 &%$.,. <>7? 456 ?7;767 <?8C '5; 476>?>7/>8?765/7>=/7?'/6>47*8C:;599>8< >4765/ CB?/7?
*6746 >4?7>797/ >47 :;59>5<< >8>E7 456 ;5<7 47 :;59>5<< 67D79 C89>46 :?58? >8 <5;59@ 8< >47 6B5> *C7 '*E >8 /?@5 D5;;@7 9/ C/7 9 79HB5?= '8B> >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 9/ 47 *C7 >8 E98F >4> >47 /7<79/9> )B>;5'77 56 B9B>48?5I7/;= 9/ 5;;7@;;= *B;>5D>59@ >47 6B5> ;9/ 59 456 '679*7 47 :;59>5<< 8'>597/?7*8?/8<?5@4>68<>476B5>:?8:7?>=9/*C7>8 E98F >4> >47 /7<79/9> '7459/ '*E 8< >47 :;59>5<< @8> 79>7?7/47?9C7>8>476B5>:?8:7?>=89>47'6568<>47 ?7;767/77/;;7@7/>84D7'7797G7*B>7/'==>'77 8!>?B)>7;4765/=>'774/98?5@4>9/>5>;7 8D7?>476B5>;9/47?7<8?7647*998>7G7*B>7>4765/ ?7;767/77/59<D8B?8<>47/7<79/9>59?76:7*>8<>47 6B5>;9/
47 /7<79/9> 59 F?5>>79 6>>7C79> *89>79/7/ >4> 4A6' F6 >47 8F97? 9/ :8667668? 8< >47 6B5> ;9/ 9/ 47 4/ 689 '= 9C7 !>?B )>7; 47 65/
- 7 -
4A6'/57/'8B>=7?6'*E9/>47?7<>7?456689 !>?B )>7; /57/ '8B> % =7?6 '*E 4A6' /57/ '7<8?7 >47 :8;5*7 *>589 9/ !>?B )>7; /57/ <>7? >47 :8;5*7*>5894765/!>?B)>7;/57/;7D59@'7459/456 F5<7 '5= '77 9/ /B@4>7? '= 9C7 =>'77 47 /7<79/9> *89>79/7/ >4> >47 /7*767/ 4A6' 97D7? @5<>7/ F= >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 59 <D8B? 8< >47 :;59>5<< >4?8B@4 456 C8>47? 4C7/'77 > 56 >47 :;59>5<< 9/ 456 C8>47? 98> ?765/7/ ;89@ F5>4 >47 4A6' 9/ 98> ?79/7?7/ 9= 67?D5*76 >8 45C 47 :866766589 8< >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 46 98> '779 /7;5D7?7/ 59 <D8B? 8< >47 :;59>5<< '= /7*767/4A6' 8 CB>>589 46'779 69*>5897/ 59>479C78<>47:;59>5<<89>47'6568<>47;;7@7/8?;
@5<> 47 /7<79/9> *HB5?7/ >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= B9/7? >47 ?7;767/77/7G7*B>7/ '= ;>7=>'77 >47/B@4>7?8< !>?B )>7; 47 65/ !>?B )>7; F6 >47 8F97? 9/ :8667668? 8< >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 9/ <>7? 456 /7C567 456 /B@4>7?46'7*8C7>478F97?9/:8667668?8<>476B5> :?8:7?>= 9/ /B?59@ 47? ;5<7>5C7 647 7G7*B>7/ >47
- 8 -
?7@56>7?7/?7;767/77/59?76:7*>8<>476B5>:?8:7?>=89 2%&.$ 9/ 659*7 >479 >47 /7<79/9> *C7 59 *>B;
:866766589 9/ 79A8=C79> 8< >47 6B5> :?8:7?>= 6 >47 8F97?9/CB>>7/47?9C759>47:?8:7?>=?7*8?/6 2 9 >47 '656 8< >47 65/ :;7/59@6 >47 ?5; 8B?>46<?C7/>47<8;;8F59@566B76
! "
# $ %$
&
'
( '(
! - 9 -
)
*++++,- $$
. /
$
0 1
, 47 @797?; :8F7? 8< >>8?97= 48;/7? 8< >47 :;59>5<< 46 '779 7GC597/ 6 )+ 9/ @8> 7GC597/ 897F5>97666)+9/@8>C?E7/
G6)>8,<>7? ?7C9/ 8< >47 6B5> >47 :;59>5<< 46 '779 7GC597/ 6 )+& 9/ @59 @797?; :8F7?
8< >>8?97= 48;/7? 46 '7797GC597/6)+(9/@8>7GC597/897F5>97666 )+F4856>47F5>9766>8>478?;@5<>9/@8>C?E7/ G6)$ >8 47 /7<79/9> 7GC597/ 47?67;< 6 + 9/7GC597/>F8F5>9766766+9/+&9/@8> C?E7/
G6>8. $ 47?5;8B?><>7?47?59@>47?@BC79>689 '8>4 65/76 ::?7*5>7/ >47 7D5/79*7 89 ?7*8?/ 9/
- 10 -
96F7?7/566B786>8&29/,59>47<<5?C>5D79/ 566B786(9/59>4797@>5D79//7*?77/>476B5>8< >47:;59>5<< . 759@ @@?57D7/ '= >47 65/ AB/@C79> 8< >47 ?5; 8B?> >47 ?76:89/79>/7<79/9> 46 <5;7/ 8(2%% 47 !5?6> ::7;;>7 8B?> <>7? 47?59@ >47?@BC79>689'8>465/7646<8?CB;>7/>47<8;;8F59@ :859>6<8?*8965/7?>589 (
$ ! ( $
& +4>8?/7?JK
% 47!5?6>::7;;>78B?>96F7?7/:859>86 9/59>47<<5?C>5D79/;;8F7/>47::7;'=67>>59@ 65/7 >47 AB/@C79> 9/ /7*?77 :667/ 59 8.$,
- 11 -
47!5?6>::7;;>78B?>89;=89>47:859>>4> >47C8>47?*998>*>98?*9'7::859>7/6:?8:7?>= @B?/598<>47C598?9/6477HB;;=*998>*>6;7@;
@B?/59 47;/ >4> >47 8?; @5<> C/7 '= 4A6' 59 <D8B? 8< >47 :;59>5<< 56 98> D;5/ @5<> 9/ >47 :;59>5<< *998>'7*8C7>478F97?8<>476B5>;9/89>47'6568< >4765/8?;@5<>
47 67*89/ ::7; *C7 >8 '7 /C5>>7/ >8 *8965/7?>47<8;;8F59@HB76>5898<;F L+47>47? 59 >47 <*>6 *5?*BC6>9*76 9/ 7D5/79*7 89 ?7*8?/ >47 ;8F7? ::7;;>7 *8B?> F6AB6>5<57/59/56C56659@$,JK
& 7?/ ;7?97/ *8B967; <8? >47 ::7;;9> 9/ ;7?97/*8B967;<8?>47?76:89/79> ( 7?97/ *8B967; <8? >47 ::7;;9> F8B;/ *89>79/>4>>47C8>47?8<>47:;59>5<<7D79>48B@498> @B?/59 B9/7? 7*>589 &. 8< >47 84CC7/9 F64756@B?/59B9/7?7*>589&28<>47
- 12 -
84CC7/9F 8965/7?59@>47 65/ 6:7*> >47?5;
8B?> 46 ?5@4>;= 47;/ >4> >47 8?; @5<> 56 D;5/ 9/ /7*?77/>476B5>
7?97/ *8B967; <8? >47 ?76:89/79> F8B;/ *89>79/ >4> >47 C8>47? 56 98> ;7@; @B?/59 8< 47? C598?6899/5>56>47<>47?<>47?M6<>47??7>47;7@; @B?/59B9/7?7*>589&.8<>4784CC7/9F9/ >47?7<8?7:86676658989>47'6568<>478?;@5<>**7:>7/ '=>47C8>47?8<>47:;59>5<<89'74;<8<47?C598?68956 98>D;5/9>4>:859>647:;*7/?7;59*789>47/7*56589 8< >47 89M';7 :7G 8B?> 59 >47 *67 8<
?7:8?>7/59
9>476C7 :859> 647 ;68 :;*7/ ?7;59*7 89 >47 /7*56589 8< >47 89M';7:7G8B?>59>47*678<
! " ?7:8?>7/59"#$ %&&' $ %'
F45*4 46 '779 ?7;57/ '= >47 !5?6> ::7;;>7 8B?> 47 <B?>47? 6B'C5>6 >4> *8965/7?59@ >47 65/ 6:7*> >47 !5?6>
- 13 -
::7;;>7 8B?> 46 ?5@4>;= ;;8F7/ >47 ::7; 9/ 67> 65/7>47/7*?77:667/'=>47?5;8B?> 2 8965/7?59@>47'8D7F4>56>8'7*8965/7?7/ 56F47>47?>47C8>47?8<>47::7;;9>:;59>5<<F48*>7/ 6456@B?/59/B?59@456C598?5>=*9*>6@B?/598< 47? C598? 689 <8? ?7*75D59@ :866766589 8< :?8:7?>=B9/7? 8?;@5<>J , 7*>58928<>4784CC7/9F?7/66 B9/7? (%' )
! *
)
+
$
$ $
$
! ! ! 2
$ 8965/7?59@>4765/:?8D565895>56*;7?>4> @5<> >8 C598? '= :7?689 8>47? >49 456 <>47? 8? @B?/59 C= '7 *8C:;7>7/ '= /7;5D7?= 8< :866766589 >8 >47<>47?8?@B?/59
- 14 -
. 7*>589&.8<>4784CC7/9F?7/66 B9/7? ,(-& #+ + ) **!3! ! $
4- '( 5 '(#
$ 6! 5 '"( 6 5 '&(#
$! 6 1
% 47 :7?6896 648F9 B9/7? >456 7*>589 ?7 >47 ;7@; @B?/596 8< C598?
<8? 456 :?8:7?>= 4767 @B?/596?7 @B?/5968<C598?8<456:?8:7?>=
7*>589&28<>4784CC7/9F?7/66 B9/7? ,(-'% . )/ +
$ '7")8(
$ 9 '7".+( $ $
- 15 -
$
$
$
1
9>47'679*78<;7@;@B?/59B9/7?7*>589 &.8<>4784CC7/9F:7?689D8;B9>?5;=:;*7/ 45C67;<59*4?@78<>47:7?6899/:?8:7?>=8<C598?56 *;;7/ @B?/59 47 C8>47? '?8>47? B9*;7 9/ ;; ?7;>5896 8>47? >49 >47 <>47? 9/ <>47?M6 <>47? ?7 @B?/59647@B?/594698:8F7? >8>?96<7?9=?5@4>8?59>7?76>8<95CC8D';7:?8:7?>= 8< >47 C598? 9/ >4> 6B*4 >?96<7? 56 98> C7?7;= D85/';7'B>D85/ &
9>47*678949/>47C8>47?8<>47:;59>5<< 9C7;= 4C7/'77 4698> >?96<7??7/ 9= ?5@4> >5>;7 8? 59>7?76>8<>47:?8:7?>=8<C598?689 (
9
>47 89M';7 :7G 8B?> 47;/ >4> >47 C8>47? *998> *> 6 :?8:7?>= @B?/59 F479 >47 <>47? 56 ;5D7 9
- 16 -
>47 89M';7 :7G 8B?> 46 47;/>4B6 + 9
:
; ! < =! 6
; %
9 $
9
>
? 222
@
:
?22 A $BC*8.&9/)D! $-
-
! ; $
-
$ @ < =! $ ! # 3 ! $
$ $ $
$ C
$ ! 3 ! - 17 -
$$
! $ C
! #
3;
! C < <
$ <
> # #BC*80? $9 +0D ! $ ! ! ! $ ! C< ? BC=*8""*+8D ! C<<
$ #
! $
! ! ! $
! 3 9 >
? 222
@ ' ( 4 E ! ! 3$
! $
! C
- 18 -
E 3 >
? 222 @ ' (
$ ! C ! ! ! ! - 9
# ; ! 9
> ? 222
@ ' (
-
C
$ ! $
! ! -
! ! ! $ : 9
>
? 222 @4 EC
! <$! -
-! ! $
$ 2
- 19 -
F %
! ! ! < =! ! 6 ! ! 3 2
! !$! ! $<$
-
-! $
E 0 3
! 9
1
)
+ ) )
23
/ /
/ ! * /
**
+ )
1/
/ ) % ! ! # $ !
1 C:4656B::;57/
9>47'8D7*67>47<>47?8<>47C598?F6 ;5D7 9/ >47?7<8?7 >47 C8>47? *8B;/ 98> 4D7 '779 ::859>7/>8*>6@B?/598<>47C598?9/>8**7:> >47@5<>89456'74;<
- 20 -
2
9 >47 *67 89 49/ 89 *;867 ?7/59@ 8< >47 :;7/59@68?;7D5/79*79//8*BC79>6>47?7F6989= ?7<7?79*7 >4> >47 <>47? 8< >47 :;59>5<< F6 ;5D7 > >47 >5C78<8?;@5<>/B?59@:?5;.% , +45D:: 8B6659:: 59 :?@?:4 8(8<4567GC59>589-59-*457<466>>7/>4><>7?>47 /7>48<!>?B)>7;>47::7;;9>:;59>5<<F5>4456C8>47? *C7>8D5;;@7/?@59/F6/859@*88;57F8?E+ 7D79>48B@4 F6 @7/ '8B> $ =7?6 6 89 >47 />78< 7GC59>589-59-*457< 46 98> 6>>7/ ?7@?/59@ >47 <>47? 8<>47:;59>5<<F47>47?;5D78?98>689>47/>78<8?;
@5<> /B?59@ :?5; .%
D79 >47?7 56 98 9= ?7<7?79*7 ?7@?/59@>47<>47?M6<>47?8<>47:;59>5<<F47>47?;5D7 8?98>689>47/>78<8?;@5<>/B?59@:?5;.%47 /7*56589 ?7;57/ B:89 '= >47 ;7?97/ *8B967; <8? >47 ?76:89/79>/87698>::;=>8>47*678949/659>4> *67 >47 <>47? 8< >47 C598? F6 ;5D7 9 >47 :?7679> *675<>47<>47?9/<>47?M6<>47?8<>47C598?:;59>5<< F7?7 ;5D7 6 89 >47 />7 8< >47 8?; @5<> /B?59@ :?5;
- 21 -
.%>476C75698>:;7/7/59>47:;7/59@68?6>>7/59 >477D5/79*747?7<8?759>47'679*78<;7@;@B?/59 <>47? 8? <>47?M6 <>47? B9/7? 7*>589 &. 8< >47 84CC7/9 F >47 C8>47? F48 56 >47 @B?/59B9/7?7*>589&28<>4784CC7/9F*9 *>6@B?/598<:?8:7?>=89'74;<8<47?C598?6899/ **7:>>478?;@5<>C/7'=47?<>47?4A'59<D8B? 8< 456 @?9/689 H'88; ' :;59>5<< 8965/7?59@ >47 65/ 6:7*> >47 ?5; 8B?> 46 ?5@4>;= ::?7*5>7/ >47 7D5/79*7 89 ?7*8?/ 9/ ?5@4>;= /7*?77/ >47 6B5> 8< >47 ::7;;9>:;59>5<< 47 !5?6> ::7;;>7 8B?> 46 7??7/ 59 ;;8F59@ >47 ::7; 9/ /56C56659@ >47 6B5> **8?/59@;= HB76>5898<;F5696F7?7/ $
9>47?76B;>>47<8;;8F59@
477@B;?7*89/::7;56;;8F7/
47 5C:B@97/ AB/@C79> 9/ /7*?77 />7/ %,%$%%.:667/'= >475D5; "B/@7 ?9
- 22 -
6DE;=9 C: > BC9'/ 59 8(2%%5667>65/7 & 47 AB/@C79> 9/ /7*?77 />7/ .%$%% :667/ 59 8.$, '= >47 )?59*5:;
5D5; "B/@7 "?9 BC9'/ 56 47?7'= ?76>8?7/
,( '%#%) $
) 56>8;8 1