- 1 - ! " # $%&$'()*+$(( , ! " # """" "$ " % " " " " " $" & ' ! "" # % Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " " " $ " " $'() & $ " *" " " " " ( & " " " * " & & " *" " "" " " ( & &(&& & " " *"*$"" "+" + " " " "$ $" " "" ",* # ",*% -. /.012134 5.616134./ 7.148 9::;2.< 14 "3( & 34 6-. =1>. 3= >.9/4.< <<> 101> *;<8. 94< *$ 14892;8;/ #-./.149=6./ /.=.//.< 63 92 ?/19> 3;/6@%121A5;841486-.B;<8A.463=:3401:613494<3/<./ 3= 2.46.4:. <96.< &(&& & :3401:6148 -1A =3/ 6-. 3==.4:. 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:61342 )( ' #% 3= 6-. 4<194.49> 3<. & #=3/ 2-3/6 ?@% 94< &) 3= 6-. 363/ .-1:>.2 :6 &( #=3/ 2-3/6 ? :6@% 94< 2.46.4:14863;4<./8321A5>.1A5/1234A.46=3/6-.5./13< 3= 21C A346-2 94< 59D =14. 3= 2& =3/ 6-. 3==.4:. - 3 - 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:6134 )( 3= E 2.46.4:148 63 ;4<./8321A5>.1A5/1234A.46=3/6-.5./13<3=21CA346-2 94< 59D =14. 3= 2 =3/ 6-. 3==.4:. 5;412-97>. ;4<./.:6134' #%3=E94<6359D=14.3=2' =3/6-.3==.4:.5;412-97>.;4<./.:6134&)3=:6 F16- <.=9;>6 2.46.4:.2 F-1:- F92 :34=1/A.< 14 /1A149> 55.9> "3( & 34 6-. =1>. 3= 6-. >.9/4.< /14:159> 126/1:694<.221342*;<8.91:-;/#-./.149=6.//.=.//.< 63 92 ?$1/26 55.>>96. 3;/6@% 01<. B;<8A.46 <96.< & & 7D <12A1221486-. 955.9> 94< :34=1/A148 6-. B;<8A.465922.<7D6-./19>3;/6 -. :92. 3= 6-. 5/32.:;6134 14 7/1.= 12 6-96 &6-.:3A5>91494694<6-.14B;/.<.D.F164.22>3<8.< 6-. =1/26 14=3/A96134 F16- 14892;8;/ 3>1:. 9891426 6-. 9::;2.<9>>.8148:3AA1221343=3==.4:.25;412-97>.;4<./ .:61342)(' #%3=94<.:6134&)3=:6 46-.792123=6-.=1/2614=3/A96134>3<8.<7D6-. $ :9A. 63 7. /.8126./.< 94< 140.261896134 F92 ;4<./69G.4=6./140.261896134 :-9/8. 2-..6 :9A.63 7. - 4 - =1>.<9>>.81486-969::;2.<7.1486-.</10./3=6-.3==.4<148 155./ 7.9/148 /.8126/96134 "3( </30. 6-. 29A. 14 9 /92- 94<4.8>18.46 A944./ 94< <92-.< 63 6-. A363/:D:>.7.9/148/.8126/96134 "3' ' F-1:- F92/1<<.47D6-.<.:.92.<929/.2;>63=F-1:--.<1.< 146-.9::1<.46-.14=3/A9467.1486-.51>>134/1<./ 2;26914.<14B;/1.2 ' .9/4.< 98126/96. 633G :3841H94:. 3= 6-. 3==.4:.2/.8126./.<6-.:/1A149>:92.94<2;AA34.<6-. 9::;2.< -. 9::;2.< 955.9/.< 7.=3/. 6-. /19> 3;/6 5>.9<.<4368;1>6D94<:>91A.<637.6/1.<-.5/32.:;6134 .C9A14.<2&6394<836A9/G.<C2&63&-. 9::;2.< -92 <.41.< 9>> 6-. 14:/1A1496148 A96./19>2 9091>97>. 34 /.:3/< 7;6 -. -92 436 >.< 94D .01<.4:. 14 2;553/63=-12<.=.4:. -. /19> 3;/6 9=6./ 69G148 1463 :3421<./96134 9>> 6-. A96./19>2 34 /.:3/< :9A. 63 6-. :34:>;2134 6-96 6-. 5/32.:;6134 12 2;::.22=;> 14 5/30148 6-. 8;1>6 3= 6-. 9::;2.< =3/ 6-. 9=3/.291< 3==.4:.2 94< 9::3/<148>D - 5 - :3401:6.< 94< 2.46.4:.< 6-. 9::;2.< 92 2696.< 9730. .148 988/1.0.< 7D 6-. 29A. 6-. 9::;2.< 5/.=.//.< 955.9>14/1A149>55.9>"3( &-.$1/2655.>>96. 3;/6 34 /.955/.:196134 3= 6-. A96./19>2 34 /.:3/< :34=1/A.<6-.1A5;84.<B;<8A.463=:3401:613494<3/<./ 3=2.46.4:.7D<12A1221486-.955.9>.148988/1.0.<7D 6-.29A.9::;2.<-925/.=.//.<6-12/.0121345.616134 .9/< /1 "989494< >.9/4.< 2.413/ :3;42.> 955.9/148 =3/ /1;<9/2-94 =3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./ 94< A6/961 961> >.9/4.< 18- 3;/6 30./4A.46>.9<./=3/6-./.2534<.46I696../;2.< 6-.A96./19>234/.:3/< 4 01.F 3= 6-. /109> :346.461342 ;/8.< 7D 6-. >.9/4.<:3;42.>=3/736-6-.59/61.26-.531466-96F3;>< 9/12.=3/AD:3421<./9613412 - 6 - D942F./636-.9730.5314612146-. =3/6-.=3>>3F148 ) 6126-.:346.461343=6-.5/32.:;61346-966-. 9::;2.<7.1486-.</10./3=6-.3==.4<148155./</30.6-. 29A. 14 9 /92- 94<4.8>18.46 A944./ 94< <92-.< 63 6-. A363/:D:>. /1<<.4 7D 6-. <.:.92.< 92 9 /.2;>6 3= F-1:- -. <1.< 7.148 6-. 234 3= 6-. <.:.92.< >3<8.< 6-. =1/26 14=3/A96134 2696148 6-96 6-. </10./ 3= 6-. 3==.4<148 155./ 7.9/148 /.8126/96134 "3( -9< :9;2.< 6-.9::1<.4694</.J;.26.<6-.53>1:.63/.8126./6-.:92. 94<631416196.>.89>9:6134 .F92.C9A14.<7.=3/.6-. /19> 3;/6 92 & ;/148 :-1.=.C9A1496134 -. 2696.< 6-96 -. G43F2 6-. 9::;2.< F-3 :9;2.< 6-. 9::1<.46 3F.0./<;/148:/322.C9A14961349659/98/95-"3)-. 25.:1=1:9>>D <.532.2 6-96 34 6-. <96. 3= 6-. 14:1<.46 -. -9<4362..46-.9::;2.<-.F92436G43F148-1249A. 94<9<</.2273;6=3;/<9D29=6./6-.14:1<.466-.53>1:. -90. 2-3F4 6-. 9::;2.< 14 6-. 53>1:. 2696134 94< 2696.< - 7 - 6-96 -. F92 6-. </10./ 3= 6-. 3==.4<148 155./ 4 6-. 792123=6-.29A.-.<.532.<7.=3/.6-.3;/6 2 5./ 6-. :-9/8. 2-..6 =1>.< 7D 6-. 40.261896148 ==1:./ 2 94< ) 9/. :16.< 63 7. 6-. .D.F164.22.2 63 6-. 14:1<.46 2 5./ 6-. 3/<./ 2-..6 3= 6-./19>3;/6<96.<' &)>.9/4.<22126946;7>1: /32.:;63/ 2;7A166.< 6-96 2 63 9/. 6-. -.9/29D F164.22.294<6-./.=3/.-.2..G25./A1221343=6-.3;/6 63 810. ;5 6-32. F164.22.2 ::3/<148>D 6-. .C9A1496134 3=6-32.F164.22.2F92810.4;5-./.=3/.6-.34>D.D. F164.22 .C9A14.< 7.=3/. 6-. /19> 3;/6 12 & 2 94< ' 9/. 6-. 40.261896148 ==1:./ 12 6-. F164.22=3/6-.2536A9-9H9/4<./6-.2.:1/:;A2694:.2 .0.46-3;8-6-.5/32.:;6134122;::.22=;>145/301486-96 6-./. F92 9 /39< 6/9==1: 9::1<.46 F-1:- /.2;>6.< 14 6-. <.96-3=<.:.92.<16-924365/30.<6-966-.9::;2.<F92 6-.</10./3=6-.3==.4<1480.-1:>.966-.61A.3=9::1<.46 .4:.6-.9::;2.<12.4616>.<=3/9:J;1669> - 8 - ( -90.834.6-/3;8-6-.1A5;84.<B;<8A.463= :3401:613494<3/<./3=2.46.4:.5922.<7D6-./19>3;/6 94<6-.B;<8A.463=6-.$1/2655.>>96.3;/6:34=1/A148 6-. B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 3= 6-. /19> 3;/6 36- 6-. 3;/62-90.1843/.<6-12=9:694<5/3:..<.<63:3401:66-. 9::;2.< 23>.>D 34 6-. 79212 3= 6-. .01<.4:. 3= -./.=3/. 9A 3= 6-. 3514134 6-96 6-. 1A5;84.< B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 94< 3/<./ 3= 2.46.4:. 5922.< 7D 6-. /19> 3;/6 94< 6-. B;<8A.46 3= 6-. $1/26 55.>>96. 3;/69/.>197>.637.2.6921<.::3/<148>D942F./6-. 9730. 53146 14 6-. 94< 5/3:..< 63 5922 6-. =3>>3F148 1% /1A149>/.0121345.61613412 11% -. B;<8A.46 3= :3401:6134 94< 3/<./ 3= 2.46.4:. <96.< &(&& & 5922.< 14 "3( & 34 6-. =1>. 3= >.9/4.< <<161349>101>*;<8.94<*$14892;8;/94< 6-. B;<8A.46 <96.< & & 5922.< 14 /1A149> 55.9> "3( & 34 6-. =1>. 3= - 9 - >.9/4.< /14:159> 126/1:6 94< .221342 *;<8. 91:-;/ :34=1/A148 6-. B;<8A.463= :3401:6134 94<3/<./3=2.46.4:.9/.-./.7D2.6921<. 111% 342.J;.46>D6-./.0121345.616134./9::;2.<12 9:J;166.< =3/ 6-. 3==.4:.2 5;412-97>. ;4<./ .:61342 )( ' #% 3= 94< &) 3= :6 10% -. 791> 734< 3= 6-. 9::;2.< 94< 6-96 3= -12 2;/.61.21=94D2694<:94:.>>.< 0% -. =14. 9A3;46 1= 94D <.53216.< 7D 6-. /.012134 5.616134./2-9>> 7. /.=;4<.< 63 -1A34 <;.1<.461=1:96134 .8126/D 12 <1/.:6.< 63 2.4< 79:G 6-. /19> 3;/6 /.:3/<2 9>348 F16- 6-. :35D 3= 6-12 B;<8A.46 =3/ 14=3/A9613494<4..<=;>9:6134 -) $ ( " 126"3&>"3