- 1 - !"#"" "$ % &'()&*+% '&++ , ! "#$% & '( ) * ! ! ! * !"#% & ' ) Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * ! + % * ! (! * * #%% (! (* ! # % * ** ! ! % **! (!%#%% (! %+ ! * * ! ,(!! ' ,(!!) -. /.012134 5.616134./2 7.148 9::;2.< 32 94<9/.1=5;841486-.>;<8=.463?:3401:613494<3/<./ 3?2.46.4:.<96.<#%%5922.<143# % 34 6-. ?1@. 3? 6-. @.9/4.< 101@ (;<8. 94< (* - 3 - -3/95;/ :3401:6148 6-.= ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./.:6134%94<3?4<194.49@3<.'?3/ 2-3/6 AB) 94< 2.46.4:148 63 ;4<./83 /183/3;2 1=5/1234=.46?3/95./13<3?%C.9/294<6359C9?14.3? 2%%%% ".9:-?3/6-.3??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./.:6134 3?D6359C?14.3?2%%%% ".9:-?3/6-.3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:6134 % 3? D 94< 63 59C ?14. 3? 2%%% ".9:-?3/6-.3??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./.:6134 3?E16-<.?9;@62.46.4:.2E-1:-E92:34?1/=.<14 /@ 3 %+ 7C 6-. @.9/4.< 126/1:6 94< .221342 (;<8.9<81/101<.>;<8=.46<96.<%#%% .9/< /1 94>9C 961@ @.9/4.< :3;42.@ ?3/ 6-. /.012134 5.616134./2 94< /1 359@F/12-49 9<901 @.9/4.< 18- 3;/6 30./4=.46 @.9<./ ?3/ 6-. /.2534<.46"696. ./;2.< 6-. =96./19@2 9091@97@. 34 /.:3/< - 4 - 4 01.E 3? 6-. /109@ :346.461342 ;/8.< 7C 6-. @.9/4.<:3;42.@2?3/736-6-.59/61.26-.531466-96E3;@< 9/12.?3/=C:3421<./9613412 C942E./636-.9730.5314612 B?3/6-.?3@@3E148 0.46-3;8-6-.5.616134./2-90./912.<2.0./9@ 8/3;4<2146-./.0121345.616134631=5;846-.>;<8=.463? :3401:613494<3/<./3?2.46.4:.5922.<7C6-./19@3;/6 94< 6-. >;<8=.46 5922.< 7C 6-. *1/26 55.@@96. 3;/6 @.9/4.< :3;42.@ ?3/6-. /.012134 5.616134./2 -92 /.26/1:6.< -129/8;=.4634@C632..F=3<1?1:961343?6-.>;<8=.463? :3401:6134 94< 3/<./ 3? 2.46.4:. 5922.< 9891426 9::;2.< - 5 - 32 94< . -92 25.:1?1:9@@C 2;7=166.< 6-96 6-. 5.616134./2 -90. 810.4 ;5 9@@ 36-./ 8/3;4<2 ;/8.< 14 6-. /.0121345.616134.G:.566-.?3@@3E148 $ 6 12 6-. :346.46134 3? 6-. @.9/4.< :3;42.@ ?3/ 6-.5.616134./26-96925./6-.0./21343?6-.14>;/.<" 16E9234@C9::;2.<3E-39229;@6.<E16-941/34 /3< H E-./.92 9::;2.< 3 9229;@6.< -1= E16- -94<2 ;6 6-. /19@ 3;/6 94< 6-. *1/26 55.@@96. 3;/6 :3==166.<94.//3/E-1@.:3401:6148736-6-.9::;2.<?3/ 6-.3??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./.:61343? 6 12 9@23 -12 :346.46134 6-96 6-. 14:1<.46 -9< 3::;//.<34%%$%E-1:-E92973;6C.9/279:F -./.?3/. 9::;2.< 3E-3 12:3401:6.< ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:6134 3? =9C 7. 2.46.4:.< 34@C E16- ?14. 3? 2%%%% " 1426.9< 3? 1=532148 2;72694610. 2.46.4:. .4:. -. 5/9C2 ?3/ 9@@3E148 6-. /.0121345.616134 - 6 - # @.9/4.< 18- 3;/6 30./4=.46 @.9<./?3/6-./.2534<.46"696.35532148-122;7=122134 5/9C2 ?3/<12=1229@ 3?6-. /.012134 5.616134 3E.0./ -. 2;7=1626-967.1486-.14>;/.<.C.E164.227.148 6-..C.E164.22-90.2696.<6-9616E929::;2.<3E-3 9229;@6.<6-.E16-941/34/3<94<9::;2.<3-9< 2@955.<-1= + .89/<148=3<1?1:961343?6-.2.46.4:.@.9/4.< 18- 3;/6 30./4=.46 @.9<./ 2;7=162 6-96 16 12 @.?6 63 6-.<12:/.61343?6-.3;/6 % 45./;29@3?6-.=96./19@.01<.4:.34/.:3/< 14:@;<148 6-. .01<.4:. 3? 7.148 6-. 14>;/.< .C.E164.22E-3126-.?1/2614?3/=94694<6-..01<.4:.3? 6-. " 6-. .C.E164.22 63 6-. 14:1<.46 16 E92 34@C 9::;2.<3E-39229;@6.<E16-941/34/3<H E-./.92 9::;2.< 3 9229;@6.< -1= E16- -94<2 !4<./ 2;:- :1/:;=2694:.2 9= 3? 6-. 3514134 6-96 9::;2.<3:3;@<7.9:I;166.<?3/6-.3??.4:.5;412-97@. - 7 - ;4<./ .:6134 3? E-1@. :3401:6148 -1= ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:.2;4<./.:6134294<%3? .89/<1486-.30./6"9:62:3==166.<7C9::;2.< 3736-94<-90.25.:1?1:9@@C2696.<6-96-. -92 9229;@6.< E16- 94 1/34 /3< H 94< -92 9@23 97;2.<14?1@6-C@948;98.E16-94146.4613463:3==16 7/.9:- 3? 5.9:. 6-./.7C -. -92 :3==166.< 6-. 3??.4:. 5;412-97@.;4<./.:6134%3? *;/6-./ 16 12 6-. 25.:1?1: :346.46134 3? 6-. 5/32.:;6134 6-96 16 E92 34@C 9::;2.< 3 E-3 :9=. 9/=.<E16-941/34/3<H E-1@.9::;2.<3E92 4369/=.<E16-94CE.95342!4<./2;:-:1/:;=2694:.2 16:944367.291<6-969::;2.<3294<-9<9:3==34 146.4613463:3==166-.3??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./.:6134 3? /32.:;6134 12 2;::.22?;@ 14 =9F148 3;6 :3==1221343?6-.3??.4:.25;412-97@.;4<./.:61342 94< % 3? 9891426 9::;2.< 3 -./.92 16 12 - 8 - 2;::.22?;@ 14 5/30148 6-. 8;1@6 3? 9::;2.< 3 ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:.2 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:61342 94< % 3? -90.834.6-/3;8-6-.1=5;84.<>;<8=.463? :3401:613494<3/<./3?2.46.4:.5922.<7C6-./19@3;/6 E-1:-E92:34?1/=.<7C6-.*1/2655.@@96.3;/6 -./19@ 3;/6 :3401:6.< 9::;2.<32 94< ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:.2 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:6134 94< 2.46.4:.<6-.=E16-/183/3;21=5/1234=.46?3/95./13<3? %C.9/294<6359C?14.3?2%%%% ".9:-61234@C 9::;2.<3E-3:3==166.<943??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./ .:61343? $ 2 5./ G 6-. 3;4< ./61?1:96. 122;.< 7C 6-. #"3:63/ 6-. 14>;/.< -92 436 2;26914.< 94C .G6./49@ 14>;/C 7;6 -. -92 2;??./.< 34@C 6.4<./4.22 34 /18-6=.=3/C/.81343421<./1486-.496;/.3?6-.14>;/C 9=3?6-.35141346-969::;2.<3:3;@<7.2.46.4:.< 63 59C 9 ?14. 3? 2%%%% " 1426.9< 3? 1=532148 - 9 - 2;72694610.2.46.4:.63;4<./831=5/1234=.46-./.92 6-.2.46.4:.1=532.<?3/6-.3??.4:.2;4<./.:61342 94< % 3? :3;@< 7. :34?1/=.< 92 16 12 >;26 94< /.923497@.::3/<148@C942E./6-.9730.5314659/6@C 146-.9??1/=9610.94<5/3:..<6359226-.?3@@3E148 1) -./.0121345.616134129@@3E.<1459/6 11) -. 1=5;84.< >;<8=.46 3? :3401:6134 94< 3/<./3?2.46.4:.5922.<7C6-./19@3;/6 94<:34?1/=.<7C6-.*1/2655.@@96.3;/6 12-./.7C=3<1?1.<92;4<./ 9) -.:3401:61343?9::;2.<3?3/6-. 3??.4:.2 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:61342 94< % 3? 12 -./.7C :34?1/=.< 7) -.:3401:61343?9::;2.<3?3/6-. 3??.4:.5;412-97@.;4<./.:6134 3? 12 -./.7C 2.6 921<. E-1@. - 10 - :34?1/=148 -12 :3401:6134 ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:.2 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:61342 94<%3? :) -.3/<./3?2.46.4:.?3/6-.3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:61342 94< % 3? 9891426 9::;2.< 3 12 -./.7C:34?1/=.< <) -.3/<./3?2.46.4:.?3/6-.3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./ .:6134 3? 9891426 9::;2.< 3 12 =3<1?1.< 92 ;4<./ '1) . 12 2.46.4:.< 63 59C ?14. 3? 2%%%% "94<146-.<.?9;@66359C 6-. ?14. 9=3;46 -. 2-9@@ ;4<./83 21=5@.1=5/1234=.46?3/34.C.9/ .) ?9::;2.<3-9<<.53216.<6-.?14. 9=3;46 ?3/ 6-. 3??.4:. 5;412-97@. ;4<./.:61343?6-.29=.12 - 11 - 3/<./.<637./.6;/4.<63-1=34<;. 1<.461?1:96134 .8126/C632.4<79:F/19@3;/6.:3/<29@348E16- 6-. :35C 3? 6-12 >;<8=.46 ?3/ 14?3/=96134 94< 4..<?;@ 9:6134 -% &""+ # 1263@3#