- 1 - !! !"#$ % $&$$ !'' (!)&* + ! ! " # $ # % # Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " & ' (( ' " # )( () ( " '# )*(( ++ ((, - ' ' ' # # ' ''" ' ' # " # &!$ # .!/01/223!45$5264517/36841$5/09!994/5:5;$<175 =8;9>501 !0; 64;54 ;!15; )(()( ?!335; /0 6, (( 60 175 2/.5 62 175 /:/. #8;95 40 !1 - 3 - 764!?84 @7545/0!2154 4525445; 16 !3 A175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841B 264 $45:/1<C $< D7/%7 175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 D7/.5!..6D/091753!/;!??5!.351!3/;5175=8;9>501!0; ;5%455 ;!15; )(*(( ?!335; /0 6++ ((, 60 175 2/.5 62 175 /:/. #8;95 #40 764!?84 @7545/0!2154 4525445;16!3A1754/!.6841B264$45:/1<C 75 !$6:5 38/1 /0 6++ ((, /3 2/.5; $< 175 ?.!/01/223 355E/09 45./52 62 ?54>!0501 /0=80%1/60 45314!/0/09 175 ;5250;!013 246> %!83/09 !0< ;!>!95 64 ;5>6./37/09 !0< ?641/60 62 175 $80; 5F/31/09 /0 $51D550 175 .!0; $5!4/09 <63)*& !0; )*G !0; .!0; /0 <6)** + 3/18!15; !1 !90664 :/..!95 764!?84 1!.8E !3 376D0 /0 175 45; ./053 /0 $51D550 ?6/01 AB !0; AB /0 175?.!/013E51%775?.!/013E51%7/35F14!%15;754580;54 264/>>5;/!15?5483!. - 4 - ) 75 %!35 62 175 ?.!/01/223 /3 17!1 175< !45 175 6D0543 !0; ?633533643 62 .!0; 376D0 /0 175 !26453!/; 3E51%7 $5!4/09 <6)*& !0; )*G "7/.5 175 ;5250;!013 !45 175 6D0543 !0; ?633533643 62 .!0; /0 <6)** + >5!384/09 !%453 G 9801!3 $617 3/18!15; !1 !90664 :/..!95 764!?84 1!.8E 7!1 175 !26453!/; ?46?541/5362175?.!/01/223!0;175;5250;!013!45!;=!%501 165!%7617547!117545/3!$/95!41750$80;/0$51D550 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223 !0; 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013 - 5 - D7/%7 D!3 %603148%15; .609 !96 $< 175 !0%531643 62 175 ?.!/01/223 7!1 175 3!/; $80; /3 >645 17!0 ,( <5!43 6.; 753!/;$80;D!3%603148%15;16316?36/.5463/6062175 .!0; $5.609/09 16 175 ?.!/01/223 D7/%7 /3 3/18!15; !1 ! 7/9754 .5:5. !0; 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013 D7/%7 /3 3/18!15; !1 .6D54 .5:5. 75 3.6?5 62 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223/316D!4;3175.!0;62175;5250;!01375$80; /3+16,2551/075/971!0;17545!451D6H ./9!11/I/0175 3!/; $80; 16 !..6D 2.6D 62 D!154 246> 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223 /016 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013 /0 ! ?!41/%8.!4 ;/45%1/60 D/17681 %!83/09 ;!>!95 16 175 38/1 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!0137!1175$80;376D0D/17175.511543AB!0; 175 ./9!11/376D0/01753E51%7!45D/17/0175./>/1362175 38/1.!0;3!0;17545/30650%46!%7>501/0175.!0;62175 ;5250;!013 !0; 175 5F/3150%5 62 175 $80; !0; ./9!11/ /0 06D!<%!83/09!0<;!>!9516175.!0;62175;5250;!013 7!1 45%501.< ;5250;!013 7!; 31!415; %!83/09 ;!>!95 16 175$80;376D0!1AB/01753E51%7!..59/0917!1/17!; $550 %603148%15; 50%46!%7/09 ! ?641/60 62 175/4 .!0; !0; - 6 - 7!;!.45!;<%!835;;!>!9516!?641/60621753!/;$80; 16D!4;3175/4.!0;7!1/2;5250;!013D545061?45:5015; 175 501/45 $80; D/.. $5 D!375; !D!< %!83/09 ;!>!95 16 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223 %!83/09 36/. 5463/60 50%5 175 38/126445./52!3368971264 + 5250;!01 6 2/.5; D4/1150 31!15>501 !;>/11/09 175 !:54>5013 >!;5 /0 ?!4!J+ 62 175 ?.!/01 16 1755F150162?.!/01/223$5/096D0543/0?633533/6062.!0; /0<6)*&!0;)*G !0;)*G !0;;5250;!013$5/09 1756D0543!0;?63353364362175.!0;/0<6)** +D!3 1485 F/3150%5 62 5!41750 $80; D/17 ! 31605 /0 $51D550 175 .!0;3 3/0%5 1/>5 />>5>64/!. /3 !.36 !;>/115; 6D5:54 /1 /3 %.!/>5; 17!1 3!>5 /3 3/18!15; D/17/0 175 !45!62175.!0;62175;5250;!013$5!4/09<6)** +1 /3 ;50/5; 17!1 175 3!/; $80; D!3 %603148%15; $< 175 !0%531643 62 175 ?.!/01/223 !0; !.36 ;50/5; 17!1 175 3!/; .!0;/3D/17/0175.!0;62175?.!/01/2237575/97162175 $80; !0; 175 5F/3150%5 62 ./9!11/ /3 061 ;/3?815; 75 !..59!1/6062;5250;!013%!83/09;!>!95161753!/;$80; - 7 - 60175?45>/35621753!>5$5/0950%46!%75;8?60175/4 .!0; /3 ;50/5; 1 /3 %6015015; 17!1 /2 ! 384:5<64 D!3 !??6/015;175;/3?81531!0;3%.5!4.<?46:5;161755225%1 17!1 175 3!/; $80; !0; 175 ./9!11/ /3 5F/31/09 D/17/0 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013 !0; 061 D/17/0 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/22350%5368971264;/3>/33!.6217538/1 , 75 4/!. 6841 24!>5; 26..6D/09 /33853 !0; !;;/1/60!./33853 ! " # $%&&'( ( ) ! " # $%&&'(* G .!/01/22 6 5F!>/05; 7/>35.2 !3 "J !0; !061754 D/10533 !/$!00! !3 "J !0; 5F7/$/15; 3/F - 8 - ;6%8>5013 >!4E5; !3 F3J 16 JG 5250;!01 6 5F!>/05;7/>35.2!3"J!0;5F7/$/15;605;6%8>501!3 FJ 0 !??45%/!1/60 62 5:/;50%5 175 4/!. 6841 !03D545; /3385 63 16 ) /0 175 !22/4>!1/:5 !0; %6035K8501.<;5%455;17538/1!380;54 $ " $%&&'( + $%&&'( % +,$ - # " - . % * & 5/09!994/5:5;;5250;!013?4525445;!4598.!4 !??5!. /0 6, (( 16 175 5F1501 94!01/09 ?54>!0501 /0=80%1/60 !3 368971 264 $< 175 ?.!/01/223 .!/01/2237545/0?4525445;%46336$=5%1/60161755F150162 175 2/0;/093 62 175 4/!. 6841 17!1 175 3!/; $80; D!3 5F/31/09/0175.!0;62175;5250;!013 - 9 - * 603/;54/09 175 94680;3 8495; 175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 24!>5; 26..6D/09 ?6/01 264 /13 %603/;54!1/60 . / . / / . ( ' 0 1 * L 75 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 60 45J!??45%/!1/60 !03D545; ?6/01 63 16 ) /0 175 !22/4>!1/:5 !0; ?6/01 6+/0175059!1/:5!0;%6035K8501.<!..6D5;175!??5!. 351 !3/;5 175 =8;9>501 !0; ;5%455 ?!335; $< 175 4/!. 6841 ( 5/09 !994/5:5; 175 ?.!/01/223 !45 $52645 17/3 6841 7/36841$<64;54;!15;&()(24!>5; 17526..6D/0938$31!01/!.K8531/6062.!D - 10 - . 0 0 + . + $%&&'( * 5!405; %68035. 264 175 ?.!/01/223 1!E/09 17/3 6841 1746897 175 45%64;3 38$>/13 17!1 17545 /3 06 ;/3?815 D/17 459!4; 16 5F/3150%5 62 $80; !0; 17!1 ;5250;!013B D/10533 /0 175 %4633J5F!>/0!1/60 7!3 %!15964/%!..< ;5?635; 17!1 175 3!/; $80; /3 /0 5F/3150%5 3/0%5 1/>5 />>5>64/!. 7!1 5:50 !%%64;/09 16 175 ;5250;!0131753!/;$80;D!3%603148%15;264175$5052/1 62 $617 175 ?.!/01/223 !0; 175 ;5250;!013 !0; 17!1 ;5250;!013 7!:5 061 >!;5 !0< !115>?1 16 ;5>6./37 64 %!835 !0< ;!>!95 16 175 3!/; $80; !0; 175 .!9!11/ 52544/09 16 175 3!>5 75 38$>/13 17!1 D750 175 ;5250;!013 175>35.:53 7!:5 %!15964/%!..< !;>/115; 175 5F/3150%562$80;!0;7!;;5%.!45;175/4/01501/6062061 %!83/09 !0< ;!>!95 64 ;5>6./1/60 62 175 $80; 94!01 62 45./5262;5%45562?54>!0501/0=80%1/60$<1754/!.6841 - 11 - 68971 061 16 7!:5 $550 45:5435; $< 175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 ) 3 459!4;3 175 2/0;/093 62 175 4/!. 6841 !0; 75 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 459!4;/09 5F/3150%5 62 $80; D/17/0175.!0;62175;5250;!013/3%60%5405;452544/0916 175 45!3603 !33/905; $< 175 4/!. 6841 16 /3385 6) .5!405; %68035. 38$>/13 17!1 38%7 %60%.83/60 !44/:5; !1 D/17681!0<5:/;50%5!0;60175$!3/362>5456?/0/6062 175 4/!. 6841 16 !:6/; >8.1/?./%/1< 62 ?46%55;/093 5 38$>/13 38%7 ! 2/0;/09 $!35; 60 175 6?/0/60 /0 175 !$350%5 62 !0< !%%5?1!$.5 >!154/!. 5:/;50%5 /3 803831!/0!$.5!0;1753!>5!>6801316?54:543/1<50%5 355E3264!03D54/0917538$31!01/!.K8531/60362.!D/0175 !22/4>!1/:5 + 5!405; %68035. !??5!4/09 264 175 ;5250;!013 60 175 61754 7!0; 38$>/13 17!1 /1 /3 175 3?5%/2/%%!35 62 175?.!/01/22317!1175$80;D!35F/31/09/0175/4.!0;7!1 0617/09 ?45:5015; 175 ?.!/01/223 16 7!:5 368971 264 - 12 - !??6/01>50162!6>>/33/605416/;501/2<1755F/3150%562 175$80;!3%.!/>5;$<175>7!11754/!.6841!0;175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 7!:5 2680; 175 $!3/3 62 175 38/1 $< 175 ?.!/01/22 D/17 459!4; 16 5F/3150%5 62 175 $80; !3 544605683 7!1 3/0%5 175 ?.!/01/223 2!/.5; 16 ?46:5 175 5F/3150%562$80;/0175/4.!0;17560.<61754%60%.83/60 D7/%7 175 68413 80;54 175 %/4%8>31!0%53 %68.; 7!:5 !44/:5; D!3 17!1 $80; 5F/315; /0 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013754526457538$>/1317!117545/3065446464 /..59!./1< /0 175 2/0;/093 62 4/!. 6841 !0; 175 '/431 ??5..!156841538$>/1317!13/0%51752/0;/0962175 4/!.6841D/17459!4;165F/3150%562175$80;/0175.!0; 62 175 ;5250;!013 7!3 $550 %602/4>5; $< 175 '/431 ??5..!156841?.!/01/223D68.;061$5501/1.5;26445./5262 /0=80%1/60 45314!/0/09 175 ;5250;!013 246> 50=6</09 175/4 $80;5F/31/09/0175/4.!0; , 5284175438$>/1317!1176897175;5250;!013 7!; >!;5 !0 !??./%!1/60 264 !??6/01>501 62 ! 6>>/33/60541753!>5D!36$=5%15;16$<175?.!/01/223 - 13 - 7!1/1/3!.D!<36?5016175?.!/01/223164!/35175$80;/0 175/46D0.!0;16?45:50136/.5463/6050%57538$>/13 17!1 06 38$31!01/!. K8531/60 62 .!D D68.; !4/35 264 %603/;54!1/60/0175!??5!.!0;355E3264;/3>/33!.62175 !??5!. G 5!4;54835;17545%64;3 & 7545/306;/3?815621752!%117!1175$80;!3 %.!/>5; $< 175 ?.!/01/223 376D0 /0 175 3E51%7 5F14!%15; 7545/0!$6:5/3/05F/3150%53/0%51/>5/>>5>64/!.7545 /3 !.36 06 ;/3?815 62 175 2!%1 17!1 175 3!/; $80; D!3 %603148%15;264175$5052/162$617175?.!/01/223!3D5..!3 175;5250;!01316!:6/;36/.5463/60/0!3>8%7!3175.!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223 /3 3/18!15; !1 ! 7/9754 .5:5. 17!0 17!1 62 175.!0;62175;5250;!0137545/3!.3606;/3?81562175 2!%1 17!1 175 D!154 D7/%7 2.6D3 246> 175 .!0; 62 175 ?.!/01/223 /3 %7!005./M5; 16 2.6D 1746897 175 .!0; 62 175 ;5250;!0131746897175 ..!9!1/62175$80; - 14 - * 5?63/1/60 62 "J 16 175 !26453!/; !3?5%1 62 175 >!1154 /3 5F14!%15; 754580;54 264 />>5;/!15 4525450%5 ! "!# $% &'( )*+ , $- ")#./ , ! 01+0 $- "!# 01+ 2-% 34./ $- "!# 01+$% &5*60 7 01+8 - 9 %%:7 *+$;<=$; ,>7?70"!# 01+ @+?A >&(*6%$B$-"!# 01+ 2-% ./ 1+$?A $- "!# 01+ 3%)C7$-"!# 01+ DE*+$;<=$ = F %% A)CG / = F"!# 01+ ! ; 9 7-% $./3 > )C HIG HI./ $- "!# 01+ $7-C , $./3C7 $- "!# 01+ %%:7 -7GJ ! HI% %) / KLMN ./ % $6 %!?AO$-$6 %>%./ H)3 / C7PH6A $- % > %./ H)3 / $-% /$-"!# 01+ ! HI%G$GC7 $-% /Q L 75 4/!. 6841 1!E/09 /016 %603/;54!1/60 17/3 !3?5%162175>!11547!;%60%.8;5;17!1175?.!/01/2237!; >!;5 681 ! %!35 264 94!01 62 ?54>!0501 /0=80%1/60 !0; - 15 - !%%64;/09.< ?46%55;5; 16 94!01 175 ;5%455 62 ?54>!0501 /0=80%1/606D5:54!3459!4;175%601501/683/3385D/17 459!4;16.6%!1/60621753!/;$80;1754/!.6841D7/.5 !03D54/09?6/016)7!3%6>516175%60%.83/6017!1175 3!/; $80; /3 /0 5F/3150%5 D/17/0 175 ./>/13 62 .!0; /0 <6)** + 62 175 ;5250;!013 ??46?4/!15 !1 17/3 =80%1845165F14!%11753!/;45!360/09!33/905;$<1754/!. 6841D7/.5!03D54/09/33856)D7/%745!;3!380;54 ) ! 2 % $ %&3' 43 4& $%&3' 43 15$%&6 6 % +, $ 7 $%&3' &3'&6# $%&&'( 7 + + !" $%&&'( 8 " 7 7 0 " + - 16 - " $%&3 &6 7 $%&3 &6 " 7 ! # ! + 0 0 " $%&&'( 0 $%&&'(8 2 " $%&&'(! 9 0 " 0 " $%&&'( + $%&&'( # # + - 17 - 0 14 , # 2 2 # 0 7 9 2 * ( .5!4.< 17545 /3 05/1754 !0< 5:/;50%5 064 !0< $!3/3 60 D7/%7 175 4/!. 6841 7!3 %6>5 16 175 ;52/0/15 %60%.83/60 62 1753!/; $80; $5/09 /0 5F/3150%5 D/17/0 175 ./>/13 62 .!0; $5!4/09 <6)** + $5.609/09 16 ;5250;!013 75 45!360 !33/905; $< 175 4/!. 6841 17!1 1753!/;$80; /3 264175 $5052/162$617 175?.!/01/223 !0; 175;5250;!013!0;17!1/2175$80;/3;!>!95;$617175 ?.!/01/223 !0; 175 ;5250;!013 D/.. 7!:5 16 382254 175 .633 !0;16!:6/;>8.1/?./%/1<62./1/9!1/605F/3150%562$80;$5 ;5%.!45;16 $5 D/17/0 175 .!0;3 62;5250;!013 %!0061 $5 - 18 - 17545!36016%6>516175%60%.83/606017/32!%18!.!3?5%1 62175>!1154 75 '/431 ??5..!15 6841 D/17681 !;:541/09 16 17/3!3?5%162175>!1154!1?!4!94!?7J*62/13=8;9>501 7!36$354:5;!380;54 : ;:- + " 2 . 2 % <2 % /= 0 + . * 75 !22/4>!1/60 9/:50 $< 175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841!35F14!%15;7545/0!$6:5/3!.36605D/17681$!3/362 !0<5:/;50%5 ) 0175!$350%562!0<5:/;50%5$5/09.5;5/1754 $<175?.!/01/22364$<175;5250;!013D/17459!4;16175/4 %.!/>3 62 5F/3150%5 62$80; /0 175/4 453?5%1/:5 .!0;3 175 4/!.68411768977!3168%75;8?60175453?603/$/./1<62 >!/01!/0/09175$80;$5/0917!162$617175?.!/01/223!0; - 19 - 175 ;5250;!01 /0 175 %603/;545; :/5D 62 17/3 6841 25.. 37641 62 175 5:/;50%5 16 76.; 17!1 175 $80; /3 .6%!15; D/17/0175.!0;362175;5250;!01353/;53/0!38/1264 $!45 /0=80%1/60 D/17681 17545 $5/09 !0< %680154 %.!/> >!;5 $< 175 ;5250;!013 ! 45./52 62 ;5%.!4!1/60 264 >545 !3E/09%68.;0617!:5$55094!015; + 75'/431??5..!1568415K8!..<061=831/2/5;/0 45:543/09 175 =8;9>501 !0; ;5%455 62 175 4/!. 6841 264 /0=80%1/60 !0; %68.; 061 7!:5 !22/4>5; 175 2/0;/09 62 175 4/!.684160.6%!1/6062$80;/0175.!0;62;5250;!013 , 0 175 2!%13 3/18!1/60 62 175 >!1154 !0; /0 175 ./9716280;/3?815;2!%1625F/3150%562175$80;3/0%51/>5 />>5>64/!. 264 175 $5052/1 62 $617 175 ?.!/01/223 !0; ;5250;!013 /1 %!0 60.< $5 /025445; 17!1 175 3!/; $80; /3 3/18!15; /0 $51D550 175 ?46?541/53 62 $617 175 ?.!/01/223 !0;175;5250;!013338%7161755F150162?45354:/09 175 3!/; $80; 45314!/0/09 175 ?!41/53 246> %!83/09 !0< - 20 - ;!>!95!0;;/45%1/09175>16>!/01!/0:,D68.; >55117550;362=831/%5 G '64 175 !26453!/; 45!3603 !0; ;/3%833/603 175 38$31!01/!. K8531/603 62 .!D 4!/35; !$6:5 !45 !03D545; !%%64;/09.<50%517526..6D/09 ! / 75!??5!./3!..6D5; // 75=8;9>501!0;;5%455;!15;)(*(( ?!335; /0 6++ ((, $< 175 /:/. #8;95 #40 764!?84 16 175 5F1501 62 94!01/09 ;5%455 62 ?54>!0501 /0=80%1/60 /3 %602/4>5; /// 75 2/0;/093 !0; 175 %60%.83/60 !44/:5; !1 $< 175 4/!. 6841 !0; 175 '/431 ??5..!15 6841459!4;/09175$80;$5/09/05F/3150%5 62175.!0;62175;5250;!013/3351!3/;5 /: 1/36?50264175?!41/53167!:5!3?5%/2/% ;5154>/0!1/60D/17459!4;161756D05437/? 62175$80;/0!?46?54.<%6031/1815;38/1/2 - 21 - 36!;:/35;/..38%71/>5175?!41/5337!.. >!/01!/0 :, D/17 459!4; 16 175 5F/3150%5 62 175 3!/; $80; D/17 ?54/6;/%!. >!/0150!0%5!3>!<$545K8/45; ,) ($$* &! " /316.6,