Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 64773 (KAR)

SMT MALLAMMA v. K BUDEPPA

MFA.CROB/200018/2025 · 2025-08-06

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ " #$ "" %&' () $ * %&' "" %&' ) !" # $% # & '( ( #) (# * +% + Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ,+ # + -% #. (# * +! + + ( ( ,+ # + -% ! (# * +! +( +!%! # ,+ # + -% * (# * + + + ( ,+# + +# ,. + -% % ( (# * + " + # ( !$$. !$$ + ,+ + -% $ # (# * +* - 3 - + !$$. !$$ + ,+ + -% & '((( # / % $ # ) "!') # ( * ! # ( #* * * , $ * %&' ) (# * +% + # ,+ # + -% # (# * +!! + + ( ( ,+ # + -% ! - 4 - (# * +! +( +!%! # ,+ # + -% * (# * + + + ( ,+# + # ,. + -% & (* '((( #) ( (# * + + # ( !$$ !$$ + ,+ # + -% # (# * +* + ( !$$ !$$ # ,+ # + -% - 5 - ! -% !" # $% & '( ( # !/ # $% . ) ( * ! ( # * * # 0 * (* * # + + 1( * 1( * - 6 - $ ' +1( * ) 0$ 234256789:3;<=:>60?@=:9 =:7 <080% 23 42567 89 >5=2?=:A3 >B=556:C2:CD;7C?6:A=:7=E=<77=A67!2:# :0 @=3367 89 <5 6:20< 2F25 *;7C6 =:7 * =2>B;< B6<6 23 :0 723@;A6 E2AB <6C=<7 A0 52=8252A9 =:7 =@@6=523@;<6590:G;=:A;? ! 6=<7 <2 B=<=:=8=3=@@= =A25 56=<:67 >0;:365 40< :3;<=:>6 0?@=:9 =:7 ?A=A25 B=:A=8=2 ;8B=3B 56=<:67 >0;:365 40< >5=2?=:A3 =:7 @6<;367 =@@6=5@=@6<3 <2 B=<=:=8=3=@@= =A25 56=<:67 >0;:365 F6B6?6:A59 >0:A6:767 AB=A <28;:=5 B=3 A=H6: 2:>0?6 04 76>6=367 =A 3 "% 2: A6<?3 04 AB6 2:>0?6 >B=<A @<6@=<67890E6F6< 2A36<20;3596<<672:=772:C %IA0E=<734;A;<6@<03@6>A3=376>6=367E=3%96=<3 - 7 - 057=AAB6A2?604=>>276:A=3@6<<6@0<A=:730=530 <28;:=5>0??2AA6736<20;36<<0<2:767;>2:C AB2:3A6=7 04%IA0E=<73@6<30:=56J@6:363 32:>6 >5=2?=:A3:0 A0 =<6 ?=<<267 7=;CBA6<3 =:7 ?=D0< 30: : 3=27 C<0;:73 B630;CBA40<<67;>2:CAB6>0?@6:3=A20: % 64;A2:C 3;8?23320: 04 56=<:67 >0;:365 40< :3;<=:>6 0?@=:9 ?A=A25 B=:A=8=2 ;8B=3B F6B6?6:A59 >0:A6:767 AB=A <28;:=5 B=3 =@@<0@<2=A659 >0:3276<67 2:>0?6 04 76>6=367 =A 3 "% =:7 @<0@6<59=7767%IA0E=<74;A;<6@<03@6>A3=:7767;>A67 AB A0E=<73 @6<30:=5 6J@6:363 0E6F6< A<28;:=5 >0??2AA67 36<20;3 6<<0< 2: :0A =E=<72:C 4252=5 >0:30<A2;? =3 @6<76>2320:04 0:K856@6J 0;<A 2: >=36 04 !!"# F3 $ "%2:>6 AB6<6=<640;<>5=2?=:A3 AB69=<66:A2A567 40< 3 6=>BA0E=<733@0;3=5>0:30<A2;?=:74252=5 >0:30<A2;? EB2>B>0?63A0 3 $ 2 *" - 8 - $ B6 =530 >0:A6:7 AB=A <28;:=5 B=3 4=2567 A0 =E=<7 63>=5=A20: 04 I 0: >0:F6:A20:=5 B6=73 40< 6=>B AB<6696=<34<0?AB67=A604=>>276:A 2:A6<?3040<76<04 0:K856 @6J 0;<A 2: >=363 04 "! "# F3 &' ("%! =:7 !" !) $ "% *+!,!! -"! .' !!"## "%/ " :304=<=3767;>A20:A0E=<73@6<30:=56J@6:363 23 >0:>6<:67 >0;:365 40< >5=2?=:A3<65267 ;@0:D;7C?6:A 040:K856@6J0;<A2:AB6>=3604"! .' !!"# , !# # 0 @=<A2>;5=<59 @=<=C<=@B :0 EB6<62: 0:K856 @6J 0;<A B=3 B657 AB=A 6F6: ?=D0< ?=<<267 =:7 6=<:2:C 30:3 04 76>6=367 =<6 6:A2A567 A0 86 >0;:A67 =3 76@6:7=:A3 B6 5=A63A D;7C?6:A040:K856@6J0;<A2:( !# * !" .' # 2: 2F25 @@6=5 :0!!% 723@0367 0: % 2: '")$$ !')"$" ')!%$ - 9 - @=<=C<=@B :0 =530 <646<<2:C A0 D;7C?6:A 04 (2<6:7<= '3;@<=)B=34;<AB6<B657AB=AAB6<623:0<6=30:A06J>5;76 ?=<<267 7=;CBA6<4<0?>0?@6:3=A20::F26E04 5=E5=27 70E:890:K856@6J0;<A <28;:=5@<0@6<59>0?@;A67 50330476@6:76:>9=:7?=76767;>A20:A0E=<73@6<30:=5 6J@6:363 : =80F6 C<0;:73 30;CBA 40< 6:B=:>6?6:A 04 >0?@6:3=A20: =F2:C B6=<7 56=<:67 >0;:365 @6<;367 6:A2<6 =@@6=5 @=@6<3 @02:A3 AB=A E0;57 =<236 40< 0;< >0:3276<=A20:=<6+ L2) B6AB6< <28;:=5 23 D;3A24267 2: =772:C %I A0E=<734;A;<6@<03@6>A3 EB6:=7?2AA675976>6=367 E=3=C67%96=<32:A6<?304<6@0<AM 22)B6AB6<<28;:=523D;3A242672::0A=E=<72:C4252=5 >0:30<A2;? A0E=<73 >5=2?=:A3 :0 A0 2: F26E 04 5=E 5=27 70E: 89 0:K856 @6J 0;<A 2: >=36 04 '3;@<=)MN 222) B6AB6<<28;:=523D;3A242672:767;>A2:C AB A0E=<73@6<30:=56J@6:3630476>6=367M - 10 - ;< =:3E6< A0 AB6 =80F6 @02:A3 40< >0:3276<=A20:=<62::6C=A2F6 40<AB640550E2:C+ "+,-. 3 @6< 5=E 5=27 70E: 89 AB60:K856@6J0;<A2:&'("%!3A=A673;@<= AB6 4;A;<6@<03@6>A;3A086=77672:<63@6>A0436546?@50967 @6<30: =C6 ;@A0 96=<3 23 I =C6 86AE66: % 96=<3 23 %I =:7 % A0 $ 96=<3 23 I B6 0:K856 @6J 0;<A 2: AB6 D;7C?6:A ?=76 2A >56=< AB=A AB6 35=8 42J6723 A0E=<73 AB6 @6<30:8650EAB6=C604 96=<323 I 8650EAB6=C604%96=<323%I=:78650EAB6=C6 04$96=<323I:AB6>=360:B=:7 =7?2AA6759AB6 76>6=367 E=3 % 96=<3 2: A6<?3 04 AB6 @03A ?0<A6? <6@0<A B6 <28;:=5 B=3 >0??2AA67 =: 6<<0< 2: =772:C %I 2:3A6=7 04 I >>0<72:C59 AB6 3=?6 <6G;2<63 ?07242>=A20:>0:3276<2:CAB6=C60476>6=367=3%96=<3 =:7 I 23 =7767 A0E=<73 4;A;<6 @<03@6>A;3 A0 AB6 ?0:AB59 2:>0?6 0 4=< =3 AB6 :0: C<=:A 04 4252=5 >0:30<A2;? 23>0:>6<:67 2:4=F0;<04 >5=2?=:A 03 A0 - 11 - AB6<6 23 :0 723>;3320: 89 AB6 <28;:=5 2: 2A3 D;7C?6:A =3 @6< 5=E 5=27 70E: 89 AB6 0:K856 @6J 0;<A 2: =C?= '3;@<=) B6 >5=2?=:A3 =<6 6:A2A567 3 6=>B 2: F26E 04 AB6 3=?6 AB6 >0?@6:3=A20: =E=<767 ;:76< AB6 B6=7 4252=5 >0:30<A2;? <6G;2<63 <6>0:3276<=A20: >>0<72:C59@02:A023=:3E6<672:4=F0;<04=@@655=:A 2:3;<=:>6 >0?@=:9 =:7 @02:A 0 2: 4=F0;< 04 AB6 >5=2?=:A "+,-/ :304=< =3 767;>A20: 23 >0:>6<:67 2: F26E 04 5=E5=27 70E: 89 AB60:K856@6J 0;<A3A=A67'3;@<=) 6F6:?=<<267?=D0<=:76=<:2:C30: =3 E655 =3 ?=<<267 7=;CBA6< =<6 6:A2A567 A0 86 >=5>;5=A67 =:7A=H6:2:A0=>>0;:AEB256767;>A2:C@6<30:=56J@6:363 :AB6>=360:B=:7 2:>5;72:CE246AB6<6=<6AE0?=<<267 7=;CBA6<3 =:7 0:6 ?=D0< 30: 862:C 40;< AB6 <28;:=5 @<0@6<59767;>A67 AB33;>B AB6<623:040<>62:AB6 3;8?23320: 04 AB6 56=<:67 >0;:365 =@@6=<2:C 40< AB6 =@@655=:A=:7E642:740<>62:AB6=<C;?6:A=7F=:>6789 56=<:67>0;:36540<AB6>5=2?=:A3 - 12 - 0< AB6 40<6C02:C <6=30:3 AB6 >0?@6:3=A20: <6G;2<63 <676A6<?2:=A20: : <676A6<?2:=A20: AB6 >0?@6:3=A20:E0;5786=340550E3+ ! B;3 2:=55AB6=@@655=:A3>5=2?=:A3=<66:A2A567 40<6:B=:>67>0?@6:3=A20:=340550E3+ 03304 6@6:76:>9 ' "%OIJJ!JPQ !%) 3 !% 033043@0;3=5>0:30<A2;?O4252=5 >0:30<A2;? 3 $ 033043A=A6 3 % ;:6<=56J@6:363 3 % I3>=5=A20: 3 0 / ( >>0<72:C59 AB6 >5=2?=:A3 =<6 6:A2A567 40< = 3;?04 3 " !%=3=C=2:3A 3 " $=E=<767 89AB6<28;:=5>>0<72:C59 E6@=33AB640550E2:C+ 2) B6 @@6=5 =3 E655 =3 <033 08D6>A20: =<6550E672:@=<A 22) B6D;7C?6:A=:7=E=<7@=336789AB6 <28;:=52:=E=<77=A67! 2: # 0 @=3367 89 AB6 <5 6:20<2F25*;7C6.*23?0724267/ - 13 - 222) B6 >0?@6:3=A20: 23 <67;>67 4<0? 3 " $ A0 3 " !% A 3B=55 >=<<9 2:A6<63A =A AB6 <=A6 04 $I @6<=::;?4<0?AB67=A604@6A2A20:A255 <6=52R=A20:6J>5;72:C! 7=93 765=967 @6<2072:4252:C=@@6=5 2F) B6 =?0;:A 2: 76@032A 86 A<=:3?2AA67 A0 AB6 >0:>6<:67 <28;:=5 40< 7238;<36?6:A F) B68=5=:>6=?0;:A3B=558676@032A67 =50:C E2AB 2:A6<63A =A AB6 <=A6 04 $I @6<=::;?4<0?AB67=A604@6A2A20:A255 <6=52R=A20: 89 AB6 =@@655=:A2:3;<=:>6 >0?@=:98640<6AB6>0:>6<:67<28;:=5 E2AB2: = @6<207 04 32J E66H3 4<0? AB23 0<76< F2) 00<76<=3A0>03A 1( %" ' $ 1( %' $ * 23A0+50+ +