Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 64764 (KAR)

MD. WASEEM SHAIK AND ORS v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANR

CRL.P/201306/2024 · 2025-08-30

M G Uma

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $ ## # %& %'() &% (( * !" #$ %% !" ! #$ %% !" #$ " & !" ' $ %! ( """ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ! %! """ & $ %! """ ! )( %&% """ % #$ ! !" " ( %% !" %% !" ' % %% !" - 3 - %&% """ *# + $ $ , ( # # ## ( !" ) !" + "", +# !"!" # # (# , * # +# $ #(, # ( ! ( # +, ! ( " + , # # - (# # ( # && " ( # # - 4 - # ( ($ (( (( # %! " " "& %(# # ( . +# . , /012/3/4 5436360768 96834:;0< =:>688607 ?63/ 3/4 @0784730;94=<74:@017849;0<A03/3/45=<364863683=B47 15;0<;67=9:68508=9 /4 543636074<8 A4672 =@@184: 08 30 67 <6>4 0"! " 0; 0>47 #096@4 3=3607 =9=A1=<26 <426834<4: ;0< 3/4 0;;47@48 51768/=A94 17:4< 4@36078 %! " " "& <4=: ?63/ 4@3607 %0;3/47:6=7#47=90:4! "+;0<8/0<3C#D,70? 547:672 67 0&& " 07 3/4 ;694 0; 3/4 94=<74: ::63607=96E691:24=7:(=9=A1<=26=<4844B672 30F1=8/3/4@<6>67=95<0@44:672867636=34:=2=67833/4> - 5 - 4=<:<6/6E=8/=<=7=4::G94=<74:@017849 ;0<3/4543636074<8=7:<605=9<68/7==:=E94=<74: 62/ 01<3 0E4<7>473 #94=:4< ;0< <48507:473 0H 3=34#4<184:3/4>=34<6=9807<4@0<: 7 E64? 0; 3/4 <6E=9 @0734736078 1<24: AG 3/4 94=<74:@017849;0<A03/3/45=<36483/4506733/=3?019: =<684;0<>G@0786:4<=360768 !"#$% G=78?4<303/4=A0E45067368673/4 ;0<3/4;0990?672 48507:473 0 ;694: 3/4 ;6<83 67;0<>=3607 =2=6783=@@184:0830=99426723/=3=@@184:068 /4< /18A=7: =@@184: 0 68 = I01<7=9683 =7: =@@184: 0830=<43/4<49=36E480;=@@184:0/4>=<<64: - 6 - =@@184:0=7:63?=8=90E4>=<<6=24;34<>=<<6=24 3/4<4?=8=F1=<<49A43?4473/4/18A=7:=7:?6;467@4 3/4/18A=7:=7:/68;=>69G>4>A4<8/=E4=88=1934:=7: 01834: /4< ;<0> 3/4 >=3<6>076=9 /0184 <6>4 0& "0;0>47#096@43=3607=9=A1<=26@=>430 A4<426834<4:67@43/478/4?=8<486:672845=<=349G67= <4734:/0184/4=@@184:?4<43<4=3672/4<?63/@<1493G =7:3/<4=3474:30:4;=>4/4<AG51A968/672;=B474?87 3/=3 <42=<: 8/4 ;694: =703/4< @0>596=73 <426834<4: 67 <6>4 0" " 0; 0>47 #096@4 3=3607 =9=A1<=26 =2=6783 /4< /18A=7: =7: ;=>69G >4>A4<8 =34< /4< /18A=7: =7: 03/4< ;=>69G >4>A4<8 ?473 30 G:4<=A=: =7: 83=<34: <486:672 3/4<4 7 """ <48507:473 0 @=>4 A=@B 30 /4< >=3<6>076=9 /0184 =7: 83=<34: <486:6723/4<47" ""=3"5>3/4/18A=7: 0;<48507:4730=7:03/4<=@@184:@=>4=7:56@B4:15 F1=<<49?63//4<@@184:0A46723/4/18A=7:3<64:30 83=A /4< ?63/ = B76;4 =7: @=184: A944:672 67I1<G 07 /4< /4=: 3/4< =@@184: /=E4 =A184: =7: =88=1934: /4< - 7 - @@184: 08& 30 % 3<64: 30 83<=7219=34 /4< 74@B /4 =@@184:/=E4=980@<6>67=99G6736>6:=34:303=B4=?=G/4< 96;4 /4<4;0<4 8/4 <4F14834: 3/4 5096@4 30 <426834< 3/4 @=84 =7: 30 67636=34 @<6>67=9 =@3607 =2=6783 3/4> @@0<:6729G 3/4 5096@4 <426834<4: 3/4 @=84 =7: 300B 15 67E48362=3607 ;34< 67E48362=3607 ;67=9 <450<3 @=>4 30 A4 ;694: 0? 3/4 >=334< 68 547:672 67 0&& " A4;0<4 3/4 <6=9 01<3 7 3/4 >4=736>4 3/4 543636074<8 /=E4=55<0=@/4:3/6801<3844B67230F1=8/3/4@<6>67=9 5<0@44:6728 368A<012/3303/47036@40;3/401<33/=33/68 68 3/4 3/6<: @0>596=73 3/=3 ?=8;694:AG<48507:4730 3/4?6;40;=@@184:0368=98083=34:3/=3<48507:473 0 :64: 07 "" 7 3/4 >4=736>4 3/4 ;6<83 @0>59=673 ;694: AG <48507:473 0 =2=6783 /4< /18A=7: =7: 03/4< ;=>69G >4>A4<8 ?=8 F1=8/4: AG 3/68 01<3 67 <6>67=9 #4363607 0""&& " E6:4 0<:4< :=34: "%" /4 84@07: @0>59=673 @=>4 30 A4 ;694: 07 !"&" /4 8=6: @<6>67=9 5<0@44:6728 68 =980 - 8 - @/=994724: AG 3/4 =@@184: AG ;69672 <6>67=9 #4363607 0""& "=7:=76734<6>0<:4<83=G6723/4;1<3/4< 67E48362=3607688=6:30/=E4A4475=884:673/48=6:@=84 7 3/4 >4=736>4 07 " "" 3/4 5<48473 @0>59=673 @=>430A4;694: & /4 >=34<6=98 07 <4@0<: :68@9084 3/=3 3/4 543636074<8 =<4 3/4 <486:4738 0; G:4<=A=: :>6334:9G <48507:4730?=8<486:672845=<=349G/4<49=36078/65 A43?4473/4<48507:4730/4</18A=7:=@@184:0 =7: /68 ;=>69G >4>A4<8 ?=8 83<=674: 867@4 "% 4E47 3/012/3/46<>=<<6=24/=:3=B4759=@407" "!=7: 63?=8=90E4>=<<6=2436854<3674733070343/=3=@@184: 0/=8703=55<0=@/4:3/6801<3844B67230F1=8/3/4 @<6>67=95<0@44:672854@6;6@=9942=36078=<4>=:4=2=6783 /6>3/=3/43<64:3083=A<48507:4730?63/B76;4=7: @=184:67I1<648/4=9942=3607=2=67833/484543636074<868 3/=3 3/4G /=E4 =A184: =7: =88=1934: <48507:473 0 ?63/ /=7:8 =7: @<6>67=99G 6736>6:=34: /4< /4 ?017: @4<36;6@=34 :68@90848 3/=3 <48507:473 0 /=: 8183=674: - 9 - 079G86>59467I1<6488=6:30/=E4A447@=184:AG=@@184: 0 & 63 =554=<8 3/=3 <48507:473 0 /=8 ;694:3/68@<6>67=9@=84<0567267=993/484543636074<8079G 305<4881<6J4=@@184:030=2<44;0<34<>8 ! 0786:4<672 =99 3/484 ;=@38 =7: @6<@1>83=7@48 =>0;3/405676073/=33/4@073671=36070;3/4@<6>67=9 5<0@44:6728 =2=6783 3/4 543636074<8 /4<467 ?019: A4 67 =A184 0; 5<0@488 0; 9=? 47@4 3/4 8=>4 68 96=A94 30 A4 F1=8/4: @@0<:6729G =78?4< 3/4 =A0E4 50673 67 3/4 =7:5<0@44:305=883/4;0990?672 6, /45436360768 66, <6>67=9 5<0@44:6728 67636=34: =2=6783 3/4 543636074<8 =@@184: 08 30 67 <6>4 0"! " 0; 0>47 #096@4 3=3607 =9=A1<=26 547:672 67 0&& " 07 3/4 ;694 0; ::63607=9 6E69 1:24 =7: ( =9=A1=<26 ;0< 3/4 0;;47@48 51768/=A94 17:4< - 10 - 4@36078%!"" "& <4=:?63/4@3607%0;#68/4<4AGF1=8/4: +) %##( $ 683090!