Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 64760 (KAR)
JAGADEVI W/O SHAMRAO SUGUR v. N.E.K.R.T.C.
MFA/200982/2021 · 2025-12-04
P Sree Sudha
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64760 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 64760 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#!$!%!! !!%%
&'( )* !!%%
+&'(
)
*
!! !! !! ! "#$#%&'
! ( ( %)'% ( ! (
*+&%*&*&
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! %#&&&&
"
! !! #& *&%+
(
! ( ( , +,
(
)
+
*
!! +
!! !! !! ! "#$#%&*
! ( ( %)'% ( !( *+&%*&*& ! %#&&&&
"
! !! + *&%+
(
!! ( (,+, (
- 3 -
!!(
-! $ ./01.2.3455346748369723:;/84:<9779/=>92.2.3 ?/=73=2 /; 6348=3: ?/0=736 ;/8 2.3 5482937 92 97 24@3= 05 ;/8;9=46:975/746 * ?/<</=A0:1<3=2>4754773:/=*+&%*&*& 9= /7+ *&%+ 4=: #& *&%+ BC 2.3 ::929/=46 3=9/8 9D96 0:13 4=: 464B08419 ;/8 7./82 E2.3 89B0=46F(/*&&+$* *&*%97;963:BC2.3?649<4=29= /#& *&%+ 4=: ( /*&*$*) *&*' 97 ;963: BC 2.3?649<4=29=/+ *&%+ '
)
&' ) ( .3 ?649<4=2 413: # C3487 :/9=1 2496/89=1 <32 >92. 4= 4??9:3=2 /= %%&*&%$ 4=: 707249=3: 1893D/07 9=A0837 .383;/83 7.3 ;963: 4 ?649< 532929/= B3;/83 2.3
- 4 -
89B0=46 ?649<9=1 ?/<53=7429/= /; 7%#&&&&
" .3 89B0=46 ?/=79:389=1 2.3 3=2983 3D9:3=?3 /= 83?/8: 184=23: ?/<53=7429/= /; 7'%'+&&
" >92. 9=238372 42 , 54 ;8/< 2.3 :423 /; 532929/= 2966 834697429/= 4=: :983?23:2.38375/=:3=2"/85/8429/=2/:35/7922.374<3
11893D3:BC2.3749:A0:1<3=24=:4>48:2.3 9=A083: ?649<4=2 .47 583;3883: 2.97 455346 9= >.9?. 92 97 ?/=23=:3: 2.42 7.3 >47 :/9=1 2496/89=1 4=: 348=9=1 7*&&&&
" 538 </=2. 4=: ;963: G!*&"496/8 849=9=1 3829;9?423B022.389B0=46.47=/2?/=79:383:2.374<3 7 538 G!% ;02083 <3:9?46 3G53=737 483 =/2 184=23: .3>47413:#C3487B022.3<062956938.47=/2891.26C 24@3=.33G4<9=3:2.3:/?2/847! '4=:.34773773: 2.3:974B9692C42'#,2/2.3>./63B/:CB022.389B0=46 .47 24@3= /=6C %*, .383;/83 83H03723: ;/8 3=.4=?3<3=2/;?/<53=7429/= # 348:2.34810<3=27/;B/2.79:37
- 5 -
./01. 2.3 4553664=2 58/:0?3: G!*& 4=: 72423: 2.42 7.3 >47 348=9=1 7*&&&&
" 538 </=2. 7.3 .47=/2;963:4=C9=?/<358//;.383;/832.389B0=46.47 24@3= .38 9=?/<3 42 7+&&&
" 538 </=2. 02 47 2.3 4??9:3=297/;2.3C348*&%$475382.3109:369=37/;2.3 48=424@4 2423 3146 38D9?37 02./892C .38 =/29/=46 9=?/<3 97 2/ B3 24@3= 42 7%%)#&
" 538 </=2. 2 >47 /B738D3: BC 2.3 89B0=46 2.42 9= 2.3 532929/= .38 413 97 7./>= 47 # C3487 B02 9= 2.3 ( 4=: ?.4813 7.332 .38 413 97 7./>= 47 #& C3487 4=: 2.383;/83 2.3 89B0=46 ?/=79:383:.3841347#&C34874=:24@3=2.3<06295693847 E%'F >.9?. =33:7 =/ 9=238;383=?3 7 538 2.3 :97?.4813 ?48:IG!%'2.34553664=2>474:<9223:9=2.3./759246 ;8/< %%&*&%$ 2/ %)&*&%$ 93 ;/8 &) :4C7 .3 4553664=2 3G4<9=3: 2.3 :/?2/8 47 !
' 4=: .3 4773773: 2.3:974B9692C0=:38G!%#42'#,2/2.3>./63B/:C.3 89B0=46 .47 24@3= %*, 93 % '8: /; '#, 348=3: ?/0=736;/82.34553664=2?/=23=:3:2.4292972/B324@3= 4263472*&,>.383476348=3:?/0=736;/82.38375/=:3=2
- 6 -
/BA3?23:2.374<34=:72423:2.422.389B0=46.47891.26C ?/=79:383:2.3:974B9692C75382.3:974B9692C?3829;9?423" G!%# 2.3 4553664=2 .47 707249=3: ;84?2083 /; 63;2 29B94 4=: ;84?2083 <3:946 ?/=:C63 4=: 75692 ;84?2083 6423846 ?/=:C63 /; 63;2 29B94 >47 /538423: >92. !! 0228377 564929=1 ;/8 <3:946 ?/=:C63 4=: 7?83> ;/8 6423846 ?/=:C63 /; 29B94 4=: 7.3 83H09837 4=/2.38 708138C ;/8 83</D46/;9<564=24=:2.33729<423:?/72977#&&&
" 7 2.383 97 <9=9<46 <460=923: ;84?2083 /; <3:946 ?/=:C63 63;229B94>92.9<564=29=7920>92.729;;=377/;63;2@=332.3 :974B9692C 97 4773773: 42 '#, 2/ 2.3 >./63 B/:C .3 89B0=46.47891.26C?/=79:383:% '8:/;2.374<347%*, >.9?. =33:7 =/ 9=238;383=?3 .07 2.3 6/77 /; ;02083 348=9=17>/06:B3 7%%)#&G%*G%'G%*,J7*%++&
" ) .3 89B0=46 .47 4>48:3: 4= 4</0=2 /; 7%&*+&&
" 2/>48:7 <3:9?46 3G53=737 4=: 92 =33:7 =/ 9=238;383=?3
- 7 -
$ .3 4553664=2 >47 4:<9223: 9= 2.3 ./759246 ;/8 &) :4C7 /=79:389=12.3=42083 /;9=A089374=:5389/:/;
./75924697429/= 2.97 /082 ;9=:7 92 8347/=4B63 2/ 184=2 4= 4</0=2/;7&&&&
";/8549=4=:70;;389=17'&&&&
" ;/8 6/77 /; 4<3=92937 4=: 7'&&&&
" ;/8 284=75/82429/= 3G284=/0897.<3=24=:4223=:4=2?.48137 + .3 4553664=2 <91.2 =/2 .4D3 4223=:3: 4=C >/8@ 42 63472 ;/8 4 5389/: /; ;/08 </=2.7 :03 2/ 2.3 9=A08937707249=3:.383;/832.97/082;9=:7928347/=4B63 2/184=24=4</0=2/;7)&&&
"7%%)#&G;/86/77 /;9=?/<3:089=1649:055389/: %& ! ' 72423: 2.42 2.3 4553664=2 83H09837 4=/2.38708138C;/883</D46/;9<564=24=:2.33729<423: ?/72 97 7#&&&
" .383;/83 2.97 /082 ;9=:7 92 8347/=4B63 2/ 184=2 4= 4</0=2 /; 7'&&&&
" ;/8 ;02083 <3:9?463G53=73793;/883</D46/;9<564=2 %%
3=?32.34553664=2973=29263:;/82.3</:9;93: ?/<53=7429/=0=:38:9;;383=2.34:747B36/>
- 8 -
!49=4=:70;;389=1 7&&&&
" 3:9?463G53=737 7%&*+&&
" (02083<3:9?463G53=737 7'&&&&
" /77/;;02083348=9=17 7*%++&
" /77/;9=?/<3:089=1649:055389/: 7)&&&
" 84=75/82429/= 3G284 =/0897.<3=2 4=:4223=:4=2?.48137 7'&&&&
" /77/;4<3=92937 7'&&&&
" /246 3774>48:3:BC89B0=46 ,-.,/010,2 7#%+$&
" 7'%'+&&
" 3 4
"
.3 =7084=?3 /<54=C .47 46834:C :35/7923: 2.3 4</0=2 4>48:3: BC 2.3 89B0=46 .07 2.3 4553664=2 97 3=29263:;/83=.4=?3:?/<53=7429/=/;7*&#+&
">92. 9=23837242,5384==0< %*
)
+ &' ) ( .3 ?649<4=2 413: # C3487 :/9=1 2496/89=1 <32 >92. 4= 4??9:3=2 /= %%&*&%$ 4=: 707249=3: 1893D/07 9=A0837 .383;/83 7.3 ;963: 4 ?649< 532929/= B3;/83 2.3 89B0=46 ?649<9=1 ?/<53=7429/= /; 7%#&&&&
" .3 89B0=46 ?/=79:389=1 2.3 3=2983 3D9:3=?3 /= 83?/8: 184=23: ?/<53=7429/= /; 7%#*#&&
" >92.
9=238372 42
- 9 -
, 54 ;8/< 2.3 :423 /; 532929/= 2966 834697429/= 4=: :983?23:2.38375/=:3=2"/85/8429/=2/:35/7922.374<3 %' 11893D3:BC2.3749:A0:1<3=24=:4>48:2.3 9=A083: ?649<4=2 .47 583;3883: 2.97 455346 9= >.9?. 92 97 ?/=23=:3:2.427.33G4<9=3:2.3:/?2/847! 4=:.3 4773773:2.3:974B9692C42**+$,47538G!*%":974B9692C ?3829;9?423 B02 2.3 89B0=46 .47 24@3= /=6C ), 7 538 G!*% 2.3 :/?2/8 3729<423: 2.3 ?/72 ;/8 ;02083 70819?46 3G53=737 47 7*#&&&&
" .383;/83 83H03723: ;/8 3=.4=?3<3=2/;?/<53=7429/= %
348:2.34810<3=27/;B/2.79:37 %# ! 974:3=24670813/=
372423:2.422.383 97:3D9429/=9=/53=9=14=:?6/79=1/;<4=:9B6323=:38=377 9= % 4=: % 4=: ;4?946 4372.329? 97 4;;3?23: 7.3 ?4==/2 58/=/0=?3 2.3 >/8:7 58/5386C 4=: ?4==/2 <4729?423 4=C @9=: /; ;//: 4=: 2.07 .3 4773773: 2.3 :974B9692C42**+$,0=:38G!*%":974B9692C?3829;9?423
3 467/ 72423: 2.42 2.3 4553664=2 6/72 $ 2332. 4=: 7.3
- 10 -
83H09837 708138C ;/8 9<564=29=1 2.3 749: 2332. 4=: 2.3 3729<423: ?/72 97 7*&&&&
" 4=: 92 <4C 9=?83473 2/ 7*#&*&&
"% '8:/;*',?/<372/$,.383;/832.97 /082;9=:7928347/=4B632/24@32.3:974B9692C42$,.3 89B0=46.47?/=79:383:2.3413/;2.34553664=247)&4=:
2.3 <062956938 >47 891.26C 24@3= 47 E#F ./01. 2.3 4553664=2 72423: 2.42 7.3 >47 348=9=1 7*&&&&
" 538 </=2. 7.3 .47 =/2 58/:0?3: 4=C 9=?/<3 58//; 3G?352 2496/8 2849=9=1 ?3829;9?423 42 G!*& .383;/83 47 538 2.3 109:369=37/;2.348=424@42423314638D9?3702./892C 472.34??9:3=297/;2.3C348*&%$.38=/29/=469=?/<397 2/ B3 24@3= 42 7%%)#&
" 538 </=2. .07 2.3 6/77 /; ;02083348=9=17>/06:B3 7%%)#&G%*G#G$,J7#&&
" % .34553664=2.4758/:0?3:<3:9?46B96670=:38 G!%& 4=: 2.3 89B0=46 .47 4>48:3: 4= 4</0=2 /; 7**&&
" 2/>48:7 <3:9?46 3G53=737 4=: 92 =33:7 =/ 9=238;383=?3
- 11 -
%) .3 4553664=2 >47 4:<9223: 9= 2.3 ./759246 ;/8 &' :4C7 /=79:389=12.3 =42083/;9=A089374=:5389/:/;
./75924697429/= 2.97 /082 ;9=:7 92 8347/=4B63 2/ 184=2 4= 4</0=2/;7#&&&&
";/8549=4=:70;;389=17*#&&&
" ;/8 6/77 /; 4<3=92937 4=: 7'&&&&
" ;/8 284=75/82429/= 3G284=/0897.<3=24=:4223=:4=2?.48137 %$ .3 4553664=2 <91.2 =/2 .4D3 4223=:3: 4=C >/8@ 42 63472 ;/8 4 5389/: /; 2.833 </=2.7 :03 2/ 2.3 9=A08937707249=3:.383;/832.97/082;9=:7928347/=4B63 2/184=24=4</0=2/;7'**#&
"7%%)#&G';/86/77 /;9=?/<3:089=1649:055389/: %+ ! ":/?2/872423:2.422.34553664=2.476/72 $ 2332.
":/?2/872423:2.422.34553664=2.476/72 $ 2332. 4=: 7.3 83H09837 708138C 4=: 2.383BC 3729<423: 2.3?/72/;9<564=29=12.3749:2332.477*&&&&
".3 89B0=46 .47 4>48:3: 4= 4</0=2 /; 7#&&&&
" 2/>48:7 ;02083<3:9?463G53=737.97/082;9=:7928347/=4B632/ 3=.4=?32.374<32/7%&&&&&
"
- 12 -
*&
3=?32.34553664=2973=29263:;/82.3</:9;93: ?/<53=7429/=0=:38:9;;383=2.34:747B36/> !49=4=:70;;389=1 7#&&&&
" 3:9?463G53=737 7**&&
" (02083<3:9?463G53=737 7%&&&&&
" /77/;;02083348=9=17 7#&&
" /77/;9=?/<3:089=1649:055389/: 7'#*#&
" 84=75/82429/= 3G284 =/0897.<3=2 4=:4223=:4=2?.48137 7'&&&&
" /77/;4<3=92937 7*#&&&
" /246 3774>48:3:BC89B0=46 ,-.,/010,2 7'*&$#&
" 7%#*#&&
" 34+
"
.3 =7084=?3 /<54=C .47 46834:C :35/7923: 2.3 4</0=2 4>48:3: BC 2.3 89B0=46 .07 2.3 4553664=2 97 3=29263:;/83=.4=?3:?/<53=7429/=/;7%$'#&
">92. 9=23837242,5384==0< *% =2.38370622.3;/66/>9=1/8:389754773: 9 /2.2.34553467483466/>3:9=5482 99 .3 4553664=2 9= ( /*&&+$* *&*% 97 3=29263: ;/8 2.3 3=.4=?3: ?/<53=7429/= /; 7*&#+&
" >92.9=23837242,5384==0<;8/<2.3:423/;532929/=2966 2.3:423/;834697429/=
- 13 -
999 .3 4553664=2 9= ( /*&*$*) *&*' 97 3=29263: ;/8 2.3 3=.4=?3: ?/<53=7429/= /; 7%$'#&
" >92.9=23837242,5384==0<;8/<2.3:423/;532929/=2966 2.3:423/;834697429/= 9D .3 8375/=:3=2"/85/8429/= 97 :983?23: 2/ :35/792 2.3 4;/83749: ?/<53=7429/= 4</0=2 9= B/2. 2.3 4553467>92.9=/=3</=2.;8/<2.3:423/;2.97A0:1<3=2 D = 70?. :35/792 2.3 4553664=27 9= B/2. 2.3 4553467 483 538<9223: 2/ >92.:84> 2.3 3=2983 4</0=2 46/=1>92.9=2383724??803:/=92 D9 2 97 <4:3 ?6348 2.42 47 538 2.3 /8:38 :423: %&$*&*' 2.3 4553664=2 9= ( /*&*$*) *&*' 97=/2 3=29263:;/89=238372;/82.3:364C3:5389/:/;*:4C79= ;969=12.3455346
35) &%!! ( $
972/%6/*