- 1 - ! "#$## # % &%'() *&%(( + ! " # $ $ ! " # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ %&' $ "#%(& $ " # )&(*+ $ $$ )( )( &)("%# $ *& $ $ " # $ ,-./ $ 0 "0 # 12 32/4/4,52. 62457 899-:2; ,% 45 .4<2 ,)&(*+ ,= 85>4 ,?492 /8/4,5 .274:/2.2; =,. /12 ,==2592: 3-54:186?2 -5;2. 29/4,5: )( )( &)("%# ,= 18.8/4@8@8@88514/8*&"=,.:1,./AB#325;457 ,5 /12 =4?2 ,= /12 ?28.52; ;;? 4>4? -;72 " .5# 85; $ 85>4 4:/.49/ 8491-. 4: 62=,.2 /14: ,-./ :22C457 7.85/ ,= 684? -5;2. 29/4,5 %(& ,= 18.8/4@8 878.4C-.8C:188514/8*& - 3 - 28.; .4 14>8C-<8. 8??,,. ?28.52; 9,-5:2? =,./1232/4/4,52.85;</ .8/48/4??28.52;471,-./ ,>2.5<25/ ?28;2. =,. /12 .2:3,5;25/ D/8/2 2.-:2; /12<8/2.48?:,5.29,.; & 5 >42E ,= /12 .4>8? 9,5/25/4,5: -.72; 6@ /12 ?28.52;9,-5:2?:=,.6,/1/1238./42:/123,45//18/E,-?; 8.4:2=,.<@9,5:4;2.8/4,54: @85:E2./,/1286,>23,45/4:45/12 =,./12=,??,E457 % 12 $ 45 .4<2 ,)&(*+ ,= 85>4 ,?492 /8/4,598<2/,62.274:/2.2;=,./128=,.2:84;,==2592:,5 /1268:4:,=/12=4.:/45=,.<8/4,5?,;72;6@/1285872.,= 85C 85>4 .8591 87845:/ 899-:2; ,) -.457 45>2:/478/4,5 /12 3.2:25/ 32/4/4,52. E8: 833.2125;2; ,5 - 4 - **F*+ / 4: /12 9,5/25/4,5 ,= /12 45=,.<85/ /18/ 899-:2;,);23,:4/2;:,<29-..259@5,/2:45 E1491 E8:=,-5;/,62=8C29-..259@5,/2:5/1268:4:,=/12 >,?-5/8.@ :/8/2<25/ ,= 899-:2; ,) /14: 32/4/4,52. E8: 833.2125;2; + / 4: /12 :3294=49 9,5/25/4,5 ,= /12 ?28.52; 9,-5:2? =,. /12 32/4/4,52. /18/ /12.2 E8: 5, .29,>2.@ ,= 85@459.4<458/457<8/2.48?:8//1245:/8592,=/123.2:25/ 32/4/4,52. 5?@ ,5 /12 68:4: ,= /12 >,?-5/8.@ :/8/2<25/ :84; /, 18>2 6225 74>25 6@ 899-:2; ,) /14: 32/4/4,52. E8:833.2125;2;85;18:6225;2/8452;459-:/,;@ F ?28.52; 471 ,-./ ,>2.5<25/ ?28;2. 9,5/25;: /18/ 2>25 /1,-71 $ E8: .274:/2.2; ,5?@ 87845:/ 899-:2; ,) ;-.457 45>2:/478/4,5 /12 32/4/4,52. E8: 8..2:/2; 12 .2=2.: /, /12 ,.;2. ,= /12 .48?,-./45.?4:9,&'F*+/,9,5/25;/18//12.2 E8:.29,>2.@,=9-..259@5,/2: - 5 - , <8/2.48?: 8.2 3?892; 62=,.2 /12 ,-./ /, :-6:/85/48/2 /12 9,5/25/4,5: /18/ 85@ 459.4<458/457 <8/2.48?:E2.2.29,>2.2;8//1245:/8592,=/1232/4/4,52. 12?28.52;471,-./,>2.5<25/?28;2.4:5,/8E8.2 8:/,E12/12./12.29,>2.2;9-..259@5,/2:E2.2=8C2,. 725-452 125 /12.2 8.2 86:,?-/2?@ 5, <8/2.48?: 3?892; 62=,.2 /12 ,-./ ! /, 9,5529/ /12 32/4/4,52. /, /12 ,==2592 45 G-2:/4,5 ;2/25/4,5 ,= /12 32/4/4,52. 45 9-:/,;@ E,-?;8<,-5//,45=.4572<25//, 14: .471/ /, ?4=2 85;?462./@25928<,=/12,3454,5/18//1232/4/4,52. 4: 25/4/?2; /, 62 25?8.72; ,5 684? :-6H29/ /, 9,5;4/4,5: E1491E4??/8C298.2,=/12833.2125:4,52I3.2::2;6@/12 ?28.52;471,-./,>2.5<25/?28;2./18//1232/4/4,52. <8@ 86:9,5; ,.<8@ /8<32. ,. /1.28/25/123.,:29-/4,5 E4/52::2: ( 99,.;457?@ 85:E2. /12 86,>2 3,45/ 45 /12 85;3.,922;/,38::/12=,??,E457 - 6 - 1232/4/4,54: 12 32/4/4,52. 4: ,.;2.2; /, 62 25?8.72; ,5 684? 45 .4<2 ,)&(*+ ,= 85>4 ,?492 /8/4,5 ,5 ,6/845457 /12 6,5; 45 8 :-< ,= :*****D "-322: E, 8C1: ,5?@#E4/1/E,:-.2/42:=,./12?4C2:-</,/12:8/4:=89/4,5 ,= /12 H-.4:;49/4,58? ,-./ :-6H29/ /, /12 =,??,E457 9,5;4/4,5: 8# 12 32/4/4,52. :18?? 5,/ 9,<<4/ :4<4?8. ,==2592: 6# 12 32/4/4,52. :18?? 5,/ /1.28/25 ,. /8<32.E4/1/123.,:29-/4,5E4/52::2: 9# 12 32/4/4,52. :18?? 83328. 62=,.2 /12 ,-./8:85;E125.2G-4.2; = 45 98:2 /12 32/4/4,52. >4,?8/2: 85@ ,= /12 9,5;4/4,5: 8: :/8/2; 86,>2 /12 3.,:29-/4,5 E4?? 62 8/ ?462./@/,<,>2/12.48?,-./:22C45798592??8/4,5,=684? 5=-.54:1457/12:-.2/42:6@/1232/4/4,52./12.48? ,-./ 4: 8/ ?462./@ /, ;4.29/ /12 5>2:/478/457 ==492. /, - 7 - >2.4=@ /12 9,..29/52:: ,= /12 8;;.2:: 85; 8-/125/494/@ ,= /12;,9-<25/:=-.54:12;6@/1232/4/4,52.85;/12:-.2/42: 85;8.23,./<8@6298??2;=,.45/18/.278.;E14914:/, 62 :-6<4//2; 6@ /12 5>2:/478/457 ==492. E4/145 + ;8@: 12.48?,-./,5:8/4:=89/4,5<8@3.,922;/,89923//12 :-.2/42:=,./123-.3,:2,=.2?28:457/1232/4/4,52.,5684? ,) %##( $ 4:/,)?,