- 1 - ! " # $$ %&'% (( ) ! " # $ %&'&#( & %&'&)( ! #* " Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #+% !" ! " ##%(,%(& - +((& %+ ! " $ #+'(& #',!" #,#!" #,#!)" ##'!#" ##'!" .#!" && #() )& )+!+" )&#!" $ #,( () )!#"!/"!0" )!"!1" ! "$ - +((& $ 2 # ! 2 " 340 566758 40 9487: ;< 5==>07: ?+ >@:7/ 7=A4?@ #+%!" ?9 A37 =37:>87: 50A70 5@: =37:>87: /4;70 ! /717@A4?@ ?9 A/?=4A470" =A #,', !9?/ 03?/A B ! "=A-"077C4@D/7D>85/;5484@ 68507?+((& 14:7 ?/:7/ :5A7: ##(,(& 65007: ;< A37 875/@7: ::4A4?@5840A/4=A5@: 7004?@0>:D7585;>/5D49?/A37 ?997@=70 6>@4035;87 >@:7/ 7=A4?@0 #',!" #,#!" - 3 - #,#!)" ##'!#" ##'!" .#!" && #() )& )+!+" )&#!"/75:E4A3 7=A4?@#,(?935/5A4<5<5<5 5@34A5 () 5@: 7=A4?@ ) !#"!/" !0" )!"!1" ?9 ! " =A 37D40A?9A376/?07=>A4?@=50740A35A5==>07: ?0# A? ) 5887D7:8< 5005>8A7: A37 :7=7507: E4A3 5 065@@7/ /70>8A4@D 4@ 340 :75A3 37 5667885@A5==>07: ?+405887D7:A?3517C4=C7:5@:5;>07:$%#+A37/7;< 5AA/5=A4@D A37 6/?1404?@0 ?9 A37 ! /717@A4?@ ?9 A/?=4A470"=A507:?@A374@9?/F5A4?@9>/@4037:;<A37 95A37/%4@%85E?9A37:7=7507:5=/4F7E50/7D40A7/7:5@: 59A7/ =?F687A4?@ ?9 A37 4@170A4D5A4?@ A37 @170A4D5A4@D 994=7/3509487:A37=35/D70377A ) 75/@7: =?>@078 9?/ A37 5667885@A /797//4@D A? A37 ;548 ?/:7/0 65007: ;< A340 ?>/A 4@ /4F4@58 66758 ?0((.#(& 5@: ((+((& 0>;F4AA7: A35A 5==>07:?0.A?#(351758/75:<;77@7@85/D7:?@;548 /5E4@D 5AA7@A4?@ A? A37 =35/D7 0377A F5A7/4580 65/A4=>85/8< A37 0A5A7F7@A ?9 $%#+ 875/@7: =?>@078 - 4 - =?@A7@:7:A35AA37/75/7@?067=494=?17/A5=A05AA/4;>A7: A? A37 6/707@A 5667885@A 4@ /785A4?@ A? A37 5005>8A ?@ A37 :7=7507:37 5887D5A4?@0 ?95005>8A 875:4@D A?:75A3 5/7 067=494=588< :4/7=A7: ?@8< 5D54@0A 5==>07: ?0# A? ) 7@=74AE500>;F4AA7:A35AA375667885@A0A5@:0?@A37 05F7 9??A4@D 50 A37 ?A37/ =?%5==>07: E3? 3517 ;77@ D/5@A7:;5485@:?@A37D/?>@:?965/4A<A375667885@A40 580? 7@A4A87: A?;77@85/D7: ?@;548A E50 9>/A37/>/D7: A35AA375667885@A350;77@4@=>0A?:<04@=7#(.(& 5@: 5@< 9>/A37/ 4@=5/=7/5A4?@ E?>8: 07/17 @? 9/>4A9>8 6>/6?07 7067=4588< E37@ A37 4@170A4D5A4?@ 350 ;77@ =?F687A7:5@:A37=35/D70377A9487: + 7/=?@A/5A37875/@7:4D3?>/A?17/@F7@A 875:7/ 350 9487: 5 0A5A7F7@A ?9 ?;G7=A4?@0 5@: 1737F7@A8< ?66?07: A37 6/5<7/ 9?/ D/5@A ?9 ;548 =?@A7@:4@D A35A A37 5887D5A4?@0 5D54@0A A37 5667885@A 5/7 D/5175@:A37=507:?70@?AE5//5@A5@<4@:>8D7@=7 & @ 67/>058 ?9 =?8>F@ ?# ?9 A37 =35/D7 0377AE37@/75:=?@G?4@A8<E4A3A370A5A7F7@A?9$%#+ - 5 - 4A40714:7@AA35AA375667885@A5==>07:?+350@?A;77@ 5AA/4;>A7:E4A35@<?17/A5=AA35A=5>07:A37:75A3?9A37 :7=7507:37?@8<5887D5A4?@5D54@0A34F40A35A37C4=C7: $%#+ 5@: >07: 5;>0417 85@D>5D7 @ 147E ?9 A37 F5A7/4580685=7:?@/7=?/:A340?>/A94@:0@?6/4F595=47 F5A7/458 4@:4=5A4@D A35A A37 5667885@A E50 :4/7=A8< /706?@04;87 9?/ A37 :75A3 ?9 A37 :7=7507: ==?/:4@D8< A340?>/A40?9A37=?@04:7/7:?64@4?@A35AA375667885@A40 7@A4A87: A? ;7 7@85/D7: ?@ ;548 ;< 4F6?04@D 0A/4@D7@A =?@:4A4?@0 . ?/A379?/7D?4@D/750?@06500A379?88?E4@D 437=/4F4@5856675840588?E7: 44 37 4F6>D@7: ?/:7/ :5A7: ##(,(& 65007: ;< A37875/@7:::4A4?@5840A/4=A5@: 7004?@0>:D7 585;>/5D4 4@ 68 507 ?+((& 40 37/7;< 07A 504:7 444 37 5667885@A5==>07: ?+ 03588 ;7 /787507: ?@ ;5484@=?@@7=A4?@E4A3 68507?+((&5/404@D - 6 - ?>A ?9 /4F7 ?#+'(& ?9 85@: ?84=7 A5A4?@ 0>;G7=AA?A379?88?E4@D=?@:4A4?@0 5375667885@A035887H7=>A7567/0?@58;?@:4@ 50>F?90#(((((%!>6770@75C3?@8<" E4A3 AE? 0>/7A470 9?/ A37 84C7 5F?>@A A? A37 05A4095=A4?@?9A37G>/40:4=A4?@58?>/A* ; 37 5667885@A 03588 @?A A5F67/ E4A3 A37 6/?07=>A4?@E4A@70070?/714:7@=774A37/:4/7=A8< ?/4@:4/7=A8<* =375667885@A03588/7D>85/8<56675/;79?/7A37 /458 ?>/A :>/4@D A37 =?>/07 ?9 6/?=77:4@D0 >@87007H7F6A7:9?/1584:/750?@0* :375667885@A03588@?A4@1?81734F07894@5@< =/4F4@58 5=A414A< 04F485/?/?A37/E407 4@ 9>A>/7* 5@: 7375667885@A03588@?A87517A37G>/40:4=A4?@?9 A37 /458 ?>/A E4A3?>A 6/4?/ 67/F4004?@ ?9 A37 054:?>/A>@A48:406?058?9A3767@:4@D=507 *& % ( # 40A?# 8?'